Casa Saratoga

Introduction / Overview

For residents who have long cherished the tradition of authentic, high-quality Italian baked goods in the Rochester, New York region, the return of a local legend has been a source of significant excitement. Casa Saratoga is not just another bakery; it is the highly anticipated successor to the iconic Martusciello Bakery. After a period of absence that left a distinct void in the local food scene, the original owner, Frank Martusciello, emerged from retirement to re-establish the tradition under a new name, a name that pays homage to the bakery's initial location on Saratoga Avenue. This new chapter, quietly opened in Gates, NY, carries forward a legacy of baking excellence that dates back to the late 1950s.

Casa Saratoga operates with a renewed focus and a smaller footprint than its predecessor, ensuring that every batch of their famous bread and every freshly prepared item meets the exacting standards that made the original bakery a beloved community staple. The current operation centers around the essentials that made them famous: world-class Italian breads, submarine rolls, delicious calzones, and a selection of classic desserts. This is the place locals have relied on for generations to provide the foundation—literally—for the area's best sandwiches, especially for other local establishments that depend on the quality of their rolls. The vibe is friendly, professional, and entirely focused on the product, making for a quick and rewarding visit for anyone craving that unmistakable taste of old-school Rochester baking. It's a testament to dedication and passion, proving that true quality is always worth waiting for.

Beyond the exceptional bread, Casa Saratoga has broadened its appeal by serving a selection of subs and pizza, embracing its role as a versatile food provider in the neighborhood. This expansion solidifies its position as a go-to spot for both an essential loaf of bread and a hearty, satisfying lunch. The bakery has been welcomed back with open arms, with local patrons frequently expressing their relief and delight at finally having their favorite bread back on the market.

Location and Accessibility

Strategically positioned to serve the greater Rochester area, Casa Saratoga is conveniently located in the town of Gates, New York. Its address places it on a major thoroughfare, making it simple for customers coming from various directions.

The bakery is situated at:

2280 Lyell Avenue, Gates, NY 14606

This location is highly accessible, featuring high traffic counts on Lyell Avenue (NY-31) and offering quick access to major interstate highways. Specifically, the bakery is just off I-390 and less than a mile from I-490, making it a straightforward stop for commuters or those running errands in the area. For local patrons, the facility provides free parking in its lot, in addition to free street parking, which removes the stress of finding a spot.

In terms of in-store accessibility, the premises are wheelchair-accessible, including the entrance and designated parking spots, ensuring that all community members can easily access their products.

The operating hours (as of May 2025) are structured to accommodate both morning shoppers and afternoon visitors:

Monday - Friday: 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM

Saturday: 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Please note that hours can change, and it's always wise to check ahead for holiday schedules, but these regular times make it easy to plan a visit to pick up a fresh loaf or a quick lunch.

Services Offered

Casa Saratoga has consolidated its operations to focus on the items that made it a local favorite, blending classic bakery services with quick-service dining options. Services offered include:

• Bakery Sales: Offering a selection of freshly baked Italian, French, and Wheat breads, available in sizes like the classic 15oz. and 30oz. loaves.
• Specialty Rolls and Buns: Producing high-demand items such as Subs rolls, Panini rolls, “T” Tops, Grenade rolls, and sliced rolls for hamburger and hot dog buns, which are essential for many local sub shops.
• Savory Takeaway Meals: Serving a variety of hot and ready-to-eat items, including Pizza and Subs made on their famous rolls.
• Calzones: Featuring freshly baked calzones with classic fillings like Meatball & Mozzarella, Sausage & Mozzarella, Mozzarella & Pepperoni, Mozzarella & Eggplant, and Broccoli & Cheese.
• Sweet Baked Goods and Desserts: A selection of delicious treats like Cookies, Pies, Turnovers, Strawberry Delights, and Baklava.
• Dining Options: Offering takeout, in-store shopping, and in-store pick-up, suitable for a quick visit or grabbing Breakfast or lunch on the go.
• Beverages: Serving fresh Coffee to complement any baked good or breakfast order.
• Catering and Wholesale Supply: Functioning as a Wholesale bakery to supply other food establishments in the region with their signature bread products, maintaining their deep connection to the local food industry.

Features / Highlights

Casa Saratoga stands out in the Gates/Rochester area due to its storied past and the high quality of its fundamental products. Key features and highlights include:

• Legacy of Quality: The bakery is the highly-regarded successor to the legendary Martusciello Bakery, carrying on decades of tradition and beloved family recipes, particularly for Italian bread.
• The Famous Bread and Rolls: Considered by many locals to have the best bread in Monroe County, the bakery specializes in bread products like the Torpedo loaves and sub rolls, which are crucial components for many of the region's best sandwiches and subs.
• Savory Specialties: Beyond traditional baked goods, the bakery offers outstanding calzones that are a favorite among local customers, available with a generous range of fillings.
• Convenient Location and Accessibility: Situated on Lyell Avenue near major interstates (I-390 and I-490), the location is easy to reach, supported by a dedicated free parking lot and full wheelchair accessibility.
• One-Man Operation (at its re-opening): The dedication of the owner, Frank Martusciello, who came out of retirement to ensure the community did not lose its favorite bakery, highlights a deeply personal commitment to the craft and local history.
• Quick and Easy Service: The emphasis on takeout, in-store pick-up, and providing a smooth process for a quick visit makes it ideal for busy customers seeking high-quality food efficiently.

Contact Information

For more information, to inquire about wholesale orders, or to confirm current hours before your visit, here is the essential contact information for Casa Saratoga:

Address:

2280 Lyell Avenue, Gates, NY 14606

Phone:

Information is currently needed/being updated as the business is newly reopened, but locals are encouraged to check online resources or local listings for the most current phone number.

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in the Rochester area, a visit to Casa Saratoga is about reconnecting with a beloved culinary tradition. What is truly worth choosing here is the legendary Italian bread and rolls. This is the core product that built the bakery's decades-long reputation, and its return is the main reason for the community's excitement. Patrons frequently claim there is no better bread in the county, making it a non-negotiable choice for your next family dinner, picnic, or sandwich creation. The 15oz. Italian or French loaves are perfect for slicing, while the specially crafted Subs rolls are a must-buy for creating an authentic Rochester-style submarine sandwich.

Beyond the bread, the Calzones are another standout feature. Offered with classic, savory fillings like mozzarella paired with meatballs, sausage, or eggplant, they make for an incredibly satisfying and inexpensive lunch or dinner option. Combining the famed dough with generous portions of filling and sauce, these calzones are an ideal reflection of the bakery's hearty, quality-first approach to food. Finally, don't overlook the simple pleasure of grabbing a cup of Coffee alongside a traditional Cookie or a unique Strawberry Delight dessert for a perfect quick morning or afternoon treat. Choosing Casa Saratoga means choosing quality, history, and the unmistakable taste of a true local favorite, back and better than ever.