Fantastic bakery! One of the BEST. My family stops here for pastries, bread, and other delicious desserts whenever we’re in Staten Island.
Sep 9 · Anthony MBAKERY PROFILE
Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe
★ 4.0294 recorded reviews$$
4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA
- Phone
- (718) 984-8011
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 294 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- Tuesday7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Wednesday7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Thursday7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Friday7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Sunday7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
About and visit notes
For New York residents, a great bakery is more than just a place to buy sweets—it’s a community cornerstone, a repository of tradition, and the essential stop for every major life celebration. In Staten Island, one name has been synonymous with exceptional Italian craftsmanship and quality baked goods for over half a century: Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe. Since its founding in 1970, this establishment has woven itself into the fabric of the borough, carrying forward the rich culinary heritage of its founder, Alfonso Campitiello.
Alfonso’s journey began in Italy, where he honed his skills working alongside regional chefs. This dedication to perfection continued when he arrived in America, leading him to prestigious roles such as baking at the renowned Plaza Hotel and serving as the pastry chef for The Hampshire House. This high-level experience laid the foundation for the bakery's unwavering commitment to quality. The original shop opened on Manor Road in 1970, later moving to Victory Boulevard in 1978, and has since expanded to a second location on Amboy Road, ensuring that this cherished legacy is accessible to more Staten Islanders and visitors alike.
Today, Alfonso's is proudly run by the next generation, preserving the old-world techniques and traditions while embracing the latest cake trends. Stepping into Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe on Amboy Road is to immerse yourself in a world of sweet, authentic Italian flavors. Whether you're picking up a loaf of fresh bread for Sunday dinner, grabbing a quick, decadent treat, or commissioning a show-stopping custom cake, the shoppe offers a delightful experience built on tradition, warmth, and exceptional taste.
The bakery is famous throughout New York for its vast selection, covering everything from classic Italian biscuits to sophisticated layer cakes. Locals repeatedly turn to Alfonso's for their cannolis—often cited as some of the best in the area—their flaky sfogliatelle, and their vibrant rainbow cookies. The continuous stream of loyal customers is a testament to the quality and consistency that this family-owned business strives to maintain, making it a reliable choice for families celebrating milestones like graduations, confirmations, engagements, and birthdays.
This particular location, nestled on Amboy Road, serves the South Shore community of Staten Island with the same dedication to quality that has defined the brand since its inception. While the original Victory Boulevard location holds decades of history, the Amboy Road shop carries the torch forward, ensuring that more New Yorkers have access to their incredible array of fresh, daily-baked goods.
The immense selection is perhaps the most impressive aspect of Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe. The sheer variety ensures that every customer finds their perfect indulgence. From simple, yet perfect, Italian loaves to elaborate, multi-tiered cakes, the offerings reflect a mastery of both Italian and contemporary baking. The commitment to providing fresh products is a core value, driving the team to constantly bake and restock their shelves. While some long-time patrons have noted inconsistencies in product freshness during off-peak hours, the overall consensus remains that for specialty items and celebratory cakes, Alfonso’s delivers a quality product that New Yorkers expect.
It is important for local patrons to remember that a business with such a long history often evolves. Current owner, Anthony Campitiello, continues to honor his father Alfonso’s dream, ensuring that the essence of the Italian bakery tradition lives on. The shop is a place where you can find products specifically catering to various dietary needs, such as gluten-free and sugar-free options, illustrating their commitment to serving the entire community.
When planning your next family gathering, holiday meal, or simple Sunday treat, keep Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe in mind. Their classic Italian specialties are a taste of history, and their modern cake designs ensure they stay current with today’s demands. It’s a true New York staple, celebrating the sweetest moments of life, one fresh pastry at a time.
Location and Accessibility
The Amboy Road location of Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe makes it a convenient stop for residents in the southern part of Staten Island. Located in a commercial area, accessibility is a key focus for the establishment, making sure the experience is smooth for all customers.
Address: 4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA
Accessibility Features:
The location offers a Wheelchair accessible entrance.
Parking:
Customers can utilize the Free parking lot, which makes quick pick-ups or longer browsing a stress-free experience.
Services Offered
Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe caters to a wide variety of customer needs, focusing on convenience and a comprehensive selection of baked goods.
- Takeout and In-store shopping service options are available.
- The bakery offers a wide array of fresh bread, baked daily, including Italian, Peasant, Semolina, and specialty loaves like Meat Bread.
- A diverse selection of individual cookies and packaged Italian biscuits, including Pignoli, Rainbow, and Gluten-Free varieties.
- Large and Mini Pastries, featuring Italian classics such as Cannolis, Napoleon, Sfoghiatelli (clam shells), and Lobster Tails.
- Full-size cakes, including Layer Cakes (Red Velvet, Blackout, 7 Layer), Cheesecakes (Italian, Cream Cheese, Sugar Free, Strawberry), and Specialty Cakes (Tiramisu, Fruit Tarts).
- Custom Birthday Cakes, available in both buttercream and whipped cream finishes, with Cannoli Birthday Cakes also offered.
- Pies and Rings, such as Apple, Blueberry Crumb, Lemon Meringue, and specialty items like Grain Pie.
- A selection of Cupcakes, including Standard Vanilla, Chocolate, Oreo, and Red Velvet.
- Special deals are often available, such as the Tuesday-Saturday special on large pastries (buy 12 or more for a reduced price per piece).
Features / Highlights
Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe is distinguished by a number of key features that have made it a Staten Island institution.
- Decades of Tradition: The bakery has been a family-owned Staten Island staple since 1970, founded by Alfonso Campitiello, who brought high-level culinary experience from his time in Italy and at establishments like the Plaza Hotel.
- Signature Italian Pastries: Widely known for their famous Cannolis and Cannoli Cream, as well as other Italian favorites like Sfoghiatelli, Pasticiotti, and Lobster Tails.
- Extensive Cookie Selection: Features an expansive showcase of classic Italian butter cookies sold by the pound, including the highly popular Rainbow Cookies, Pignoli Cookies (gluten-free), and a selection of Italian biscuits.
- Accommodating Menu: The menu includes specialized items like Dietetic (sugar-free) Butter Cookies and Gluten-Free Cookies, demonstrating a commitment to serving a diverse customer base.
- Custom Cake Artistry: Known for creating specialty and custom cakes for all occasions, from simple birthday cakes to elaborate wedding cakes.
- High Variety of Fresh Bread: Daily-baked bread options range from basic Italian and French loaves to unique offerings such as Meat Bread and Roasted Artichoke and Asiago Cheese bread.
- Multiple Locations: The Amboy Road shop is one of two locations on Staten Island (the other being on Victory Boulevard), providing more access points for loyal New York customers.
What is Worth Choosing
For anyone in the New York area looking for an authentic and reliable bakery, Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe represents a fusion of old-world Italian baking passion and modern convenience. The primary reason for choosing Alfonso's is its deeply rooted history and the consistency of its core, traditional products. The Cannoli is a must-try item—it’s an iconic Italian pastry that the bakery is built upon, known for its rich, house-made cream, often containing chocolate chips and citron. Beyond the creamy classics, their cookie trays are an essential purchase for any New York gathering or holiday. The ability to order a tray of mixed Italian butter cookies, including the celebrated Rainbow Cookies and luxurious Pignoli Cookies, takes the stress out of planning for guests. Furthermore, for major life events, the expertise in custom-designed cakes, whether a classic Tiramisu or a customized multi-layer birthday cake, ensures a beautiful and delicious centerpiece for any celebration. The availability of fresh Italian bread, like the Round Semolina or the unique Meat Bread, also makes it a perfect stop for those looking to complement their savory meals. Alfonso's is more than just a bakery; it's a piece of Staten Island’s heart, ready to add sweetness to your day.
Contact Information
Address: 4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA
Phone: (718) 984-8011
Mobile Phone: +1 718-984-8011
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Amenities
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
cannoli 18prices 17cheesecake 9island 7italian 6pie 6donuts 4rainbow 3semolina 2lobster 2
The place is a neighborhood staple and I refrained from writing this review for a couple days because the kids that work in there are sweethearts, but I’ve been burned more then once now…for starters it seems like whoever is running the place whether it’s a manager or the owner I couldn’t tell you but regardless he’s a miserable person thankfully, he isn’t in there too often so you don’t have to see that depressed mug or hear him talk to the girls like crap too often & the bulldog walking around like she’s in the iron workers union, like she’s back there building a high rise, calm down you’re baking cookies… sometimes I go in & there’s either one of them walking around And talking like They are doing you a favor serving you there semi stale products at three times the amount they should be charging…. Listen, I have no problem spending good money on goods & services as long as you get what you’re paying for… But these guys definitely push the limits of “fresh” on some of their items & When you’re having guests it’s embarrassing if stuff is beyond a day or two old and lost it’s zest so to speak… anyway, I’ve been biting my tongue for month's. My wife keeps sending me there even though I tell her I hate spending money there but after this past weekend, I’m done, enough is enough. I’ll take the ride to a further bakery At least I know I’m getting fresh stuff from people that appreciate your business and not act like they just did you a solid slinging you some sour cheese cake and gravel topped crumb cake. Respectfully, Get your acts together and stop being complacent…
Sep 14 · Rece RockHas been a part of the neighborhood for years. The products they produce are well made and we never had an issue.The fresh breads are great. We particularly love the Meat Bread.Prices are extremely high (40 dollars for a 2 pound of cookie tray). A 5 pound tray had a price of 98 bucks!!!! INSANE Personally I think bakery prices are way too high recently,The staff are very friendly and helpful.Owner or manager seems very hands on and looking for improvements.
May 28 · Joseph IaconoBought an apple crumb cake here today (4-5-25). Brought it home, cut into it, MOLD.
Apr 6 · Michael MurphyDelicious Gluten Free cookie and rainbow cake. Please make more!!!
May 3 · Jason KrebsThis page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.