We got 2 ice cream sandwiches. Which you can customize. Along with a smores & lemon blueberry cookies. They are served warm. And cookies shake which you can also customize. The owner and other employee were very friendly and handled our craziness with ease.
Jul 10 · Brandy FisherAlibi Cookies
5200 N Illinois St Suite 107, Fairview Heights, IL 62208, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 5200 N Illinois St Suite 107, Fairview Heights, IL 62208, USA
- Phone
- (618) 641-9298
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 23 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Tuesday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Wednesday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Thursday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
About and visit notes
For residents across Illinois, especially those seeking a decadent, specialized sweet experience in Fairview Heights, Alibi Cookies stands out as a premier Bakery. This is not your average cookie shop; it's a dedicated dessert hub focused on delivering warm, rich, and highly customizable cookies and inventive frozen treats. Located conveniently in St. Clair County, it has quickly become the go-to destination for satisfying serious sugar cravings.
The core appeal of Alibi Cookies lies in the quality and the temperature of their signature product: the cookies are consistently served warm, creating an indulgent experience that customers rave about. Reviewers highlight this immediate gratification, noting the cookies are "Absolutely delicious! Rich, warm," and often declaring them "way better than Crumbl Cookies."
Beyond the perfect cookie, the bakery offers a robust menu of specialty items, including customizable Ice Cream Sandwiches and signature Cookie Shakes. These options showcase their creativity, turning simple dessert ingredients into memorable, multi-layered treats. Whether you’re stopping in for a single S’mores or Lemon Blueberry cookie or picking up an Alibi Party Pack for a celebration, the owners and employees are known for their exceptional friendliness and ability to handle "craziness with ease."
## Location and Accessibility
Alibi Cookies is strategically located to serve the greater Fairview Heights, IL community and surrounding areas. You can find this sweet spot at:
5200 N Illinois St Suite 107, Fairview Heights, IL 62208, USA
Positioned conveniently on North Illinois Street, the location is easily accessible for drivers from anywhere in the 62208 zip code and beyond. The premises are highly user-friendly, offering excellent practical amenities for customers:
- Free parking lot: Plentiful and complimentary parking is available directly at the location, ensuring a quick and hassle-free stop for pick-ups or a short, indulgent visit.
- Highly Accessible: The setup is designed for customer ease, making it simple to get in, select your warm treats, and get back on the road.
## Services Offered
Alibi Cookies provides a specialized yet diverse menu of high-quality baked goods and frozen desserts, perfect for individual treats or large group events across Illinois:
- Warm Cookies and Specialty Flavors: Offers a wide range of cookies, from classics like Sugar and Oatmeal Raisin to signature items like Churro Cookie, S’mores, and deluxe options such as Deluxe Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and Deluxe Lemon Blueberry.
- Custom Cookie Cakes: Provides customizable large format desserts, including Cookie Cake ($25.00), Heart Shaped Cookie Cake ($25.00), and the impressive Double Layer Cookie Cake ($45.00), perfect for birthdays and celebrations.
- Gourmet Shakes and Drinks: Features unique Cookie Shakes ($8.75) with options like Cinnamon Crunch Cereal and Crunch Berry, in addition to coffee, Hot Chocolate, Chocolate Milk, and specialty sodas from Excel (Root Beer, Black Cherry, etc.).
- Ice Cream Creations: Customers can customize Ice Cream Sandwiches ($6.50), combine 1 Cookie + 1 Scoop Of Ice Cream ($5.50), or enjoy a Cookie Sundae ($6.75) with various ice cream flavors and toppings.
- Sampler and Party Packs: Offers ready-to-go assortments like the 12 Pack Sampler ($23.40), Super Sampler Pack ($34.00), and the Alibi Party Pack ($45.00) for convenient entertaining.
- Dietary Options: Caters to dietary needs with items like the Gluten Free Chocolate Chip cookie ($2.00).
## Features / Highlights
What sets Alibi Cookies apart in the highly competitive Illinois bakery landscape are its commitment to indulgence and personalization:
- The Warmth Factor: A defining feature is serving all cookies warm, enhancing the richness and overall flavor—a key reason for the positive customer reviews.
- Dessert Customization: Customers have the ability to customize virtually everything, from their Ice Cream Sandwiches to their Cookie Shakes and Cookie Cakes, allowing for a truly personal treat.
- Gourmet Fusion Desserts: The unique incorporation of cookies into other dessert categories, such as the elaborate Cookie Shakes and Cookie Cream Pies, creates memorable, specialty products unavailable at standard bakeries.
- Friendly, Efficient Service: The team, including the owner and employees, is consistently praised for being friendly, helpful, and highly efficient, ensuring large or complex orders are handled with "ease," leading to a pleasant customer experience.
- Late Hours (Implied): Reviews mentioning the shop is "Open pretty late too !!" suggest excellent convenience for evening and late-night dessert cravings, a significant benefit for local Fairview Heights patrons.
- Affordable Sampler Options: The availability of sampler and party packs at various price points makes it easy and affordable to try multiple flavors or cater a small event without breaking the bank.
## Contact Information
For Illinois residents ready to order a custom cookie cake, inquire about daily flavors, or simply stop by for a warm treat in Fairview Heights:
Address: 5200 N Illinois St Suite 107, Fairview Heights, IL 62208, USA
Phone: (618) 641-9298
## What is Worth Choosing
Alibi Cookies is the definitive choice for any Illinois local in the Fairview Heights area seeking a specialty bakery that focuses purely on indulgent, customizable, and high-quality sweet treats. If your primary goal is a dessert that is guaranteed to be rich, delicious, and served warm, this is where you need to go.
What makes it truly worth choosing is the combination of their signature products—especially the unique Cookie Shakes and the flexibility of their Cookie Cakes—with their noted exceptional customer service. For a simple evening treat, a last-minute party dessert, or accommodating a special request like the Gluten Free Chocolate Chip option, Alibi Cookies provides a level of dedication and excitement that elevates the entire experience. Skip the mass-produced options and choose this local gem for a perfectly warm, decadent dessert experience in St. Clair County.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Parking
- Free parking lot
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Absolutely delicious! Rich, warm, and the Smores cookie was sooo good!
Jul 10 · Addisyn FisherOn a Sunday I went to this place with my mom my husband and my daughter. crumbl and hotbox where closed so we went here but little did we know we were about to have the best cookies. they were soft and warm and the flavor was amazing. it was also very gooey these cookies could easily surpass crumbl , very clean and organized. recommend for a nice desert. definitely coming again
Aug 18 · markeisha carterI recently discovered this spot and was delighted by their deluxe lemon blueberry cookie, it was unexpectedly delicious. The owner is genuinely kind, professional, and truly values the support from the community. If you’re craving something tasty, I highly recommend giving them a try.
Jul 8 · Shay R.My boyfriend and I are doordashing as I'm writing this review, we went to pick up an order and had never been to this place, but the woman giving us the order let us try one of the cookies and it was delicious. The order also smells amazing, I hope the customer loves it, and the woman was so kind. I hope to come back as a customer soon and try more items.
Sep 5 · Lunar LexxCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.





De la Creme Creative Studio
1709 Washington Ave #402, St. Louis, MO 63103, USA

Dough Joe's Artisan Doughnuts, Bagels & Coffee
2720 N 14th St, St. Louis, MO 63106, USA

Union Station Cookies and Cupcakes
201 S 18th St, St. Louis, MO 63103, USA





This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
