All in Favor, Say Pie

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Waukesha and the wider Wisconsin community, finding a dedicated artisan who focuses on one specific, perfect dessert is a true delight. All in Favor, Say Pie is precisely that establishment. Operating out of 502 Mandan Dr, this specialized small business and bakery dedicates itself entirely to crafting exceptional, homemade-style pies. This is not a grab-and-go storefront but a carefully managed, custom-order operation, ensuring that every pie receives meticulous attention before it reaches your family’s table.

As a proud women-owned, small business, All in Favor, Say Pie places immense pride in the quality of its fundamental components. The owner, Jennifer Danks, takes immense pride in her crust, which customers consistently describe as having a "great buttery crust"—the hallmark of a truly excellent pie. Whether it's a seasonal favorite like the Harvest Apple, a sweet and tart blend like the Apple Blueberry top seller, or a classic such as the Door County Cherry, the commitment to delicious filling and superior texture is unwavering.

The business runs on a model of careful planning and personalization, which necessitates an Appointment required for ordering and operates primarily through convenient Curbside pickup. This allows the owner to manage their schedule and capacity effectively, ensuring that every order is custom-baked with the freshest, often in-season, ingredients. It's the ideal local spot for the Wisconsin customer who values artisanal quality and a neighborly, personal touch.

Location and Accessibility

All in Favor, Say Pie is located at 502 Mandan Dr, Waukesha, WI 53188, USA. This address places the pie shop within a local, accessible area of Waukesha, making it a reliable and convenient source for custom dessert orders within Waukesha County.

The structure of the business is highly streamlined to ensure a smooth transaction for its local clientele, even with the requirement for advance planning:

• The facility includes Wheelchair accessible parking lot, which is an important consideration for customer convenience during the pickup process.
• The exclusive use of Curbside pickup eliminates the need for customers to enter the premises, making the entire process easy and convenient, as noted by satisfied patrons.
• The transaction process is streamlined but traditional; payment is Cash-only, though they also accept Venmo payments (often utilizing a QR code for quick scanning during pickup), and credit cards can be accepted for larger orders, catering to the local community's preference for simple, direct payments.

Services Offered

All in Favor, Say Pie is a dedicated specialty pie shop, offering focused services for custom dessert fulfillment:

• Custom Whole Pie Orders: Provides full-size, nine-inch custom-baked pies ($25 average), requiring orders to be placed at least 2-5 days in advance.
• Specialty Flavor Range: Offers a seasonal and specialized menu that includes favorites like Apple Blueberry, Dutch Apple Pie, Apple Cranberry, Chocolate Cherry Pie, and seasonal items like Pumpkin and Cherry Crumble.
• Variety of Pie Sizes: Available sizes include the standard 9-inch whole pies, smaller 5-inch mini pies ($8), and handpies ($4), the latter typically available at monthly pop-up sales.
• Dietary Accommodations: Provides a Gluten Friendly crust option for all pies, accommodating customers with dietary restrictions without compromising flavor.
• Curbside Pickup Service: Facilitates a safe and convenient pickup experience through an easy, pre-scheduled curbside model.
• Gift Certificates: Offers gift certificates in any denomination, perfect for gifting delicious, local, custom-made pies to friends and family in the Wisconsin area.

Features / Highlights

This Waukesha small business is highlighted by its deep focus on quality and customer service, making it a standout local choice:

• Exceptional Crust Quality: A core highlight is the "great buttery crust," which is central to the shop's reputation and pride, ensuring an authentic homemade taste.
• Customized Seasonal Ingredients: Focuses on baking with in-season ingredients, allowing for the freshest possible fillings, such as the noted use of Door County cherries.
• Personalized Customer Experience: Customers frequently mention the owner, Jennifer, being "very nice," reinforcing the friendly, personal, and neighborly feel of the small business.
• Convenient Curbside Payment: The streamlined pickup station often includes a Venmo QR code and listed prices at the door, maximizing efficiency for quick and easy payment.
• Women-Owned Local Business: Operating as a certified women-owned small business, it encourages the Wisconsin community to "shop local" and support small-scale entrepreneurship.

Contact Information

For Wisconsin residents wishing to order a custom, scratch-made pie, please use the following contact information. Remember that Appointment required for planning your order and pickup.

Address: 502 Mandan Dr, Waukesha, WI 53188, USA

Phone: (262) 290-3366

Mobile Phone: +1 262-290-3366

What is worth choosing

All in Favor, Say Pie is emphatically worth choosing for the discerning Wisconsin customer who wants a dessert that is truly homemade, high-quality, and completely customized. When you choose this Waukesha pie shop, you are choosing passion over mass production. You are guaranteed a pie where the "delicious filling and a great buttery crust" are not just claims but facts confirmed by satisfied patrons.

The appointment-only model, while requiring a bit of planning, is a huge benefit—it ensures that the pie you receive is baked specifically for you, not pulled from a freezer case. This focus on individual orders is what allows the owner to offer essential options like the Gluten Friendly crust, a commitment to inclusion that many larger bakeries often cannot manage with the same personal care.

Moreover, supporting All in Favor, Say Pie means actively engaging in the local economy by supporting a women-owned small business right in Waukesha. The ease of the pickup, described as quick and easy via convenient curbside service, combined with the personal touch of the owner, creates a unique, friendly, and trustworthy experience. For your next family dinner, holiday, or personal craving, casting your vote for this pie shop is a vote for quality, local flavor, and an outstanding dessert.