I love her cupcakes that she made for me for Christmas and early new years . They are really delicious and they have very beautiful flavors colors toppings/ fondant on the cupcakes the chocolate coffee truffles. Amy’s cupcakes bit of heaven, she is very hardworking and she is very talented. I am definitely going to order again.
Dec 21 · Ashley DanielsAmy’s Custom Cupcakes ( NOT A STORE FRONT)
25 Rockledge Ave, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 25 Rockledge Ave, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
- Phone
- (914) 258-9814
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 5.0 from 38 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Tuesday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Wednesday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Thursday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
About and visit notes
In the vibrant landscape of White Plains, New York, a truly special bakery experience awaits those with a penchant for beautifully crafted and undeniably delicious sweet treats: Amy's Custom Cupcakes. Unlike a traditional storefront, Amy's Custom Cupcakes operates as a dedicated online bakery, specializing in bespoke creations for corporate and special events throughout Westchester County. This unique model allows Amy, the passionate owner and operator, to focus entirely on the artistry and quality of each cupcake, bringing a personalized touch that sets her apart in the bustling New York baking scene.
Amy's Custom Cupcakes isn't just about baking; it's about transforming ideas into edible works of art. Customers consistently rave about the "most amazing cupcakes than what we could ever have imagined," highlighting the moist and fluffy texture, the beautiful buttercream swirls, and the striking aesthetic appeal. Amy's commitment to "integrating her artistic flair into each custom cupcake" ensures that every order is not just a dessert but a highlight of any celebration. This article will delve into what makes Amy's Custom Cupcakes an exceptional choice for locals in the New York region, exploring her operational approach, the exquisite range of services and products offered, and the standout features that make her a go-to for memorable and delicious custom treats.
Amy's Custom Cupcakes operates primarily as an online-based bakery, with its core operations located at 25 Rockledge Ave, White Plains, NY 10601, USA. This address places it within the heart of White Plains, a dynamic urban center and the county seat of Westchester County. While it does not function as a traditional walk-in storefront, this strategic White Plains location is crucial for efficiently serving customers across the region.
White Plains is known for its excellent connectivity and accessibility, making it an ideal base for an online bakery that specializes in custom orders and deliveries. The city is well-served by major highways such as I-287, the Bronx River Parkway, and the Hutchinson River Parkway, facilitating smooth delivery services to various parts of Westchester. The area around Rockledge Avenue itself is part of a residential and professional district, providing easy access for those who opt for direct pick-up, should that service be offered by appointment. For locals in White Plains, Scarsdale, Harrison, and other surrounding towns, accessing Amy's Custom Cupcakes means the convenience of ordering exquisite baked goods from the comfort of their home or office, with the assurance that the production is handled locally. This seamless integration into the local infrastructure allows Amy's Custom Cupcakes to effectively cater to the demanding needs of New Yorkers seeking high-quality, customized treats for their special occasions.
Services Offered:
- Custom Cupcakes: Specializes in highly customized cupcakes for various themes and occasions, including floral, polar bear, rainbow, princess, Spider-Man, butterfly, Frozen, Paw Patrol, Super Hero, Minnie Mouse, and space themes.
- Flavor Variety: Offers a range of delicious cupcake flavors, including Red Velvet, Vanilla, Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, Apple Crumble Cider, and Pumpkin Biscoff. Gluten-free options for basic vanilla & chocolate cupcakes are available.
- Artistic Toppings and Fondant: Known for beautiful buttercream swirls and intricate fondant decorations that transform cupcakes into edible art.
- Chocolate Coffee Truffles: Provides other sweet treats, such as "delicious" chocolate coffee truffles.
- Corporate and Special Event Orders: Focuses on catering to larger orders for corporate functions, birthdays, holidays, and other significant gatherings.
- Personal Delivery: Offers personal delivery services to customers, demonstrating a commitment to convenience and customer service.
- Online Ordering: Streamlined process for placing orders through an online form, making it easy to request custom designs and flavors.
- Single Cupcake Orders: Occasionally sells single cupcakes for specific monthly flavors, allowing customers to try individual treats.
Features / Highlights:
- Exceptional Baking Quality: Customers consistently praise the "superb baking quality," noting the cupcakes are "moist and fluffy" and the flavors "hitting the right notes."
- High Level of Customization and Artistry: Amy's "custom artistic touch" is a major highlight, with the ability to create unique and visually stunning designs "unlike any other we have seen before."
- Responsive and Accommodating Service: Amy is described as "very responsive," providing "great service" and "advice," and going above and beyond to deliver on customer visions.
- Delicious Flavors: Beyond aesthetics, the flavors are highlighted as "really delicious," with particular mention of chocolate coffee truffles.
- Reasonable Cost: Provides high-quality custom products at a "very reasonable cost," offering excellent value.
- Personalized Delivery: The option for personal delivery adds a convenient and thoughtful touch to the service.
- Passion-Driven Business: Operated by Amy Schwartz, who has a long-standing passion for baking and integrating her artistic flair, contributing to the high quality and care in her products.
- Community Minded: Donates unsold cupcakes from farmers' markets to local communities and charitable causes.
Contact Information:
Address: 25 Rockledge Ave, White Plains, NY 10601, USA
Phone: (914) 258-9814
Mobile Phone: +1 914-258-9814
Amy's Custom Cupcakes is exceptionally well-suited for locals in the New York region, particularly in White Plains and throughout Westchester County, due to its specialized focus on high-quality, custom-designed treats and its convenient, direct-to-customer service model. For New Yorkers planning special events, from corporate gatherings to intimate family celebrations, the ability to procure bespoke cupcakes that are not only delicious but also visually stunning is a significant advantage. The consistent praise for "superb baking quality," "moist and fluffy cupcakes," and flavors "hitting the right notes" ensures that the product itself meets the high culinary standards expected in this region.
What truly sets Amy's Custom Cupcakes apart and makes it ideal for locals is the unparalleled level of personalized service and artistic customization. Customers highlight Amy's responsiveness, valuable advice, and unique ability to translate mock designs into edible masterpieces "unlike any other." This dedicated, one-on-one approach is highly valued by New Yorkers who seek attention to detail and a seamless experience for their important events. The convenience of an online ordering system complemented by personal delivery directly to the customer's location eliminates the need for a physical storefront, streamlining the process for busy individuals and event planners.
Furthermore, the "very reasonable cost" for such high-quality, custom artistry provides excellent value, making premium bespoke cupcakes accessible to a wider local audience. Amy's evident passion for baking and her commitment to spreading joy through her creations resonate deeply within the community, fostering a sense of trust and appreciation. By focusing on niche excellence, personalized service, and convenient delivery from a central White Plains base, Amy's Custom Cupcakes has perfectly positioned itself as the go-to bakery for extraordinary and memorable sweet delights for all occasions in Westchester, embodying the essence of a modern, customer-centric local business.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Small Business
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- Delivery
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Appointment required
- Quick visit
Payments
- Cash only
- Cheques
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
From start to finish, Amy delivered great service, advice and all at a very reasonable cost. She is very responsive and she also was able to delivered them to us in person. The product we received from her, were the most amazing cupcakes than what we could ever have imagined. We gave her a mock design for inspiration and she delivered a product unlike any other we have seen before. Her baking quality is superb. Moist and fluffy cupcakes with a beatiful buttercream swirl on top. Her custom artistic touch made the cupcake sing aesthetically and the flavors were hitting the right notes with every bite, for all the kids and adults in attendance. From the bottom of our stomachs and our hearts,thank you Amy!
May 26 · Therese SeptimoOrdered cupcakes for baby shower and Amy was great to work with. She created a cupcake based on my daughter’s likes. I ordered a sampler to figure out what we wanted. Cupcakes are baked fresh and taste delicious. Absolutely no worrying when working with Amy because she’s easy to communicate with, will customize flavors and decorations and a huge plus kept in contact with me right up to delivery. Below are the pictures of what we chose - the restaurant did the plating for presentation. We ordered Black Forest, coffee truffle, vanilla w/custom butterfly deco and chocolate peanut butter cup (custom made for my daughter)
Sep 10 · Suzanne RibeiroAmy’s cupcakes were the hit at our party. My mother in law is a tough critic and she raved about the taste while everyone was amazed by both the small and large cupcake we used as a cake. Her pictures online are the same as in person. They cupcakes we requested were done perfectly and most important, the bday kid was thrilled. 10/10 would recco Amy for any needs. She’s a hidden gem!
Jul 13 · Kyle SharickWe had a wonderful birthday party for our 8 year old grandson. And to the delight of family and friends we presented Amy’s Cupcakes with amazing Minion fondant vanilla cake and everyone loved it. Thank you Amy Cupcakes for your tasty art work!!
Jul 6 · Charles ScheinbergCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.











Curly Tail Cakes | Dog Bakery
700 White Plains Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583, USA

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
