Atlantic Bagel Co.

## Atlantic Bagel Co.: A Long-Standing Atlantic Highlands Tradition

For many loyal New Jersey residents in and around Monmouth County, Atlantic Bagel Co. is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a nostalgic hometown staple. Located in the picturesque town of Atlantic Highlands, this establishment successfully combines the functions of a Bagel shop, Breakfast restaurant, Coffee shop, and Deli, making it a versatile go-to spot for fueling up any time of day. Known for its extensive menu of freshly baked bagels and robust sandwiches, Atlantic Bagel Co. has maintained a reputation for providing quality food to its customers for years.

While the atmosphere may be characterized by the fast-paced, sometimes chaotic energy common in popular local deli settings, the core draw remains the food itself. From classic P.E.C. (Pork Roll, Egg, and Cheese) sandwiches to signature deli creations, the kitchen continues to churn out menu items that keep locals coming back. The variety on offer ensures that whether you're seeking a quick caffeine fix, a hearty meal, or ingredients for a feast at home, this local spot can meet your needs.

---

## Location and Accessibility in Atlantic Highlands

Atlantic Bagel Co. is conveniently situated at 74 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA. Located on First Avenue, the shop is easy to access for both residents and those traveling through the area near the Jersey Shore.

Accessibility is facilitated by multiple parking options, a huge plus in any busy shore town. Customers can utilize the Free parking lot as well as Free street parking nearby. The business is set up to accommodate a Quick visit, making it efficient for commuters or those running errands. Furthermore, the establishment features a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring comfortable access for all members of the community. Inside, the shop provides a Restroom and options for both Dine-in and Takeout service.

---

## Comprehensive Services Offered

As a full-fledged Bagel shop and Deli, Atlantic Bagel Co. offers a broad menu that covers breakfast, lunch, and catering components, designed to satisfy the diverse appetites of New Jersey customers.

UL

Bagel Sales and Options: Offering bagels individually or in bulk, including Half Dozen ($9.36) and a Bagel Dozen ($19.47). Also selling essentials like Whipped Butter ($6.23), 8 OZ Philly CC ($6.76), and Dozen Eggs ($5.72) from the refrigerator case.

Breakfast Sandwiches: Features all the Jersey classics like B.E.C (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese), P.E.C. (Pork Roll, Egg, and Cheese), and S.E.C (Sausage, Egg, and Cheese), along with a simple Egg Sandwiches option.

Signature Breakfast Creations: Includes robust specialty plates such as the Atlantic Bomber, Atlantic Burrito, The Tradition ($11.43), and the protein-packed Popeye ($11.89). They also offer breakfast Omelets like the Western Omelet ($11.36) and Veggie Omelet ($11.36).

Signature Deli Sandwiches: A full deli case and sandwich menu featuring complex specialty items like The Atlantic, Beefy Blue, Classic Reuben, Empire State, and the Triple Threat, alongside the standard Make Your Own option.

Hot Grill/Deli Items: Serving hot lunch options including Philly Cheesesteak ($9.10), Chicken Cheesesteak ($9.73), Tommy Big Burger ($8.84), and classics like Grilled Cheese and BLT.

Sides and Snacks: A variety of satisfying sides like French Fries ($4.68), Cheese Fry ($6.24), Mozz Sticks 5 Pc ($7.27), and breakfast sides such as Home Fries ($3.95) and PORK ROLL 2 Pc ($3.90).

Bakery and Coffee: Providing baked treats like Coffee Cake ($3.38), Muffin ($3.38), and Croissant ($3.12). They offer a full range of hot Coffee/Tea and Cold Brew in both small ($5.19) and large ($6.75).

UL

---

## Key Features and Highlights

Despite challenges noted in customer service and appearance, Atlantic Bagel Co. remains a local fixture due to the quality and breadth of its food offerings and its convenient operations.

UL

Classic Jersey Deli: The combination of a high-volume bagel shop with a full-service deli and grill sets it apart, offering everything from Pork Roll on a bagel to a hearty Philly Cheesesteak or a Tommy Big Burger.

Extensive Signature Sandwich Menu: The array of specialty hot and cold sandwiches, identified by names like The #1, Empire State, and Rousing Roast Beef, provides local patrons with numerous tried-and-true, high-quality meal options.

Full Breakfast Destination: Beyond simple bagels, the menu caters to a complete breakfast experience with Signature Breakfast platters and burritos, ensuring a filling start to the day.

Convenient Payment and Parking: Facilitating quick transactions with acceptance of Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, and providing both Free parking lot and Free street parking.

Long-Standing Community Staple: Despite acknowledged issues with service consistency and facility appearance in recent years, the business has successfully retained a base of loyal customers who enjoy the food and the nostalgia of their "hometown bagel spot."

UL

---

## Contact Information

For placing an order for In-store pickup or Takeout, or for any inquiries regarding the menu, please use the contact information below:

Address: 74 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA

Phone (Primary): (732) 872-7727

Mobile Phone: +1 732-872-7727

---

## What is Worth Choosing Atlantic Bagel Co.

Choosing Atlantic Bagel Co. is a choice for authentic, well-established local flavor and an extensive, diverse menu. While some loyal New Jersey customers have expressed concern about recent drops in service speed and order accuracy, the core reason for its longevity remains the quality of the food. The bagels themselves are consistently praised, and the sandwiches—both the classic breakfast builds and the signature lunch combinations—are known for being substantial and delicious.

If you're a local who values a wide selection of deli and grill options alongside your morning coffee, and you appreciate the heartiness of a true Jersey breakfast spot, Atlantic Bagel Co. delivers on that promise. It's especially worth choosing for its robust Signature Breakfast items and the comprehensive Signature Sandwiches, which provide a complete meal. New customers planning a visit should be prepared for potential wait times and are wisely advised by loyal patrons to dine in or double-check orders to ensure everything is correct. Ultimately, for the taste of a classic Atlantic Highlands bagel and deli sandwich, this local institution is still the place to go.