Wow! As someone coming from Europe, this is what I’d truly call a deli. They offer an impressive variety of bagels, along with a fantastic selection of salads, cheeses, and cold meats to pair them with. I tried a bagel with egg salad, and it was absolutely delicious.The prices are surprisingly competitive for the New York area, which was a pleasant surprise. However, the service was noticeably slow, and it seems they have a reputation for being that way.If you’re not in a rush, this place is definitely worth a visit for its excellent food!
Nov 29 · Oliver HeldtBAKERY PROFILE
Bagel Boss East
★ 3.0718 recorded reviewsUS$10–20
555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA
- Phone
- (631) 665-9820
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 718 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- Monday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Tuesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Wednesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Thursday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Friday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Saturday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
For many New Yorkers, the allure of a truly authentic bagel shop combined with a classic deli experience is irresistible. It's where the day begins with a perfectly toasted bagel and cream cheese, or a hearty sandwich crafted with fresh ingredients. In Bay Shore, Long Island, one establishment that has long been part of this culinary landscape is Bagel Boss East. This local institution has made a name for itself by offering a vast selection of traditional New York bagels alongside a comprehensive deli menu, providing a taste of the quintessential New York deli experience right in the heart of Suffolk County.
Bagel Boss East is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a vibrant hub where the aroma of freshly baked bagels mingles with the scent of savory cold cuts and cheeses. It embodies the essence of a classic New York deli, known for its impressive variety and generous offerings. From an extensive range of bagel flavors to a fantastic selection of complementary fillings, the shop caters to diverse tastes and cravings, ensuring there's something for everyone. This dedication to providing a wide array of options is a key reason why it attracts both loyal locals and those new to the area.
The commitment to offering authentic New York-style bagels, celebrated for their distinct chew and flavor, positions Bagel Boss East as a go-to destination for those seeking a genuine taste of the region's culinary heritage. While individual experiences may vary, the core appeal lies in its impressive array of choices and its long-standing presence as a local purveyor of classic deli and bagel fare.
Bagel Boss East is conveniently situated at 555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA. This prominent location places it directly on Montauk Highway, one of Long Island's most significant and well-trafficked roadways. Its position on this major thoroughfare makes it highly accessible for residents of Bay Shore and surrounding communities, as well as for those traveling along the South Shore of Long Island.
The accessibility of Bagel Boss East is a considerable advantage for its clientele. Being located on Montauk Highway means it's straightforward to reach by car, and the area typically offers ample parking, which is a valuable convenience in a bustling commercial zone. This allows for easy stops, whether you're grabbing breakfast on your commute, picking up lunch for the family, or stocking up on deli essentials. For those utilizing public transportation, local bus routes often run along Montauk Highway, providing additional connectivity to the shop. Its central location also makes it a popular stop for various local patrons, from morning commuters to weekend shoppers, firmly establishing it as a reliable and convenient part of the Bay Shore community's daily rhythm.
Bagel Boss East offers an expansive menu that goes beyond just bagels, providing a full-service deli experience to its customers.
- Impressive Variety of Bagels: A wide selection of freshly baked, authentic New York-style bagels, including classic flavors like:
- Plain
- Sesame
- Poppy Seed
- Everything
- And many more specialty flavors.
- Extensive Deli Selection: A fantastic array of fresh ingredients for custom-made sandwiches and platters, featuring:
- Cold Meats: Including popular choices like turkey, ham, roast beef, and often premium deli meats.
- Cheeses: A variety of cheeses to complement any sandwich or bagel.
- Salads: A selection of homemade salads such as tuna salad, chicken salad, and notably, their delicious egg salad.
- Breakfast Sandwiches: Customizable sandwiches featuring eggs, cheese, and various breakfast meats, served on your choice of bagel, roll, or hero. The "Boss sandwich" is a signature item.
- Specialty Sandwiches: Beyond basic deli options, they likely offer signature sandwiches or combinations.
- Cream Cheese Spreads: A wide assortment of freshly made cream cheese flavors, from plain to vegetable, scallion, lox spread, and sweet options.
- Coffee and Beverages: Freshly brewed coffee, iced coffee, teas, juices, and other cold beverages to complete your meal.
- Catering Services: Given their deli offerings, they may provide catering for local events, corporate lunches, or private gatherings, offering platters of bagels, deli sandwiches, and salads.
Bagel Boss East is recognized for several key features and highlights that contribute to its distinctive profile in the Bay Shore area.
- Impressive Variety of Bagels and Deli Items: Customers consistently note the "impressive variety of bagels" and a "fantastic selection of salads, cheeses, and cold meats," highlighting the extensive menu choices available.
- Delicious Egg Salad Bagel: The egg salad bagel is specifically called out as "absolutely delicious," indicating a particular strength in their prepared salads.
- Competitive Pricing for the New York Area: Despite being in the New York area, the prices are "surprisingly competitive," offering good value for money, which is a significant draw for customers.
- Authentic Deli Experience: For those "coming from Europe" or simply seeking a traditional feel, the establishment delivers what one would "truly call a deli," providing a genuine New York deli atmosphere and offerings.
- Potential for Great Food (When Not Rushed): While service speed can be a point of concern, the underlying quality of the food is high, making it "definitely worth a visit for its excellent food" if time is not an issue.
For inquiries or to explore the extensive menu, here is the contact information for Bagel Boss East:
Address: 555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA
Phone: (631) 665-9820
Mobile Phone: +1 631-665-9820
The availability of both a landline and a mobile phone number provides convenient options for customers to reach Bagel Boss East. Whether you are looking to place a large order, inquire about specific deli items or bagel flavors, or simply confirm their operating hours, direct communication is readily accessible. This ease of contact allows patrons to plan their visits or orders efficiently, which is particularly beneficial given the potential for longer service times noted by some customers.
For locals in the New York region, specifically those in Bay Shore and surrounding Long Island communities, Bagel Boss East presents a compelling option for a classic deli and bagel experience. Its most significant advantage lies in the "impressive variety of bagels" and a "fantastic selection of salads, cheeses, and cold meats." This extensive menu ensures that residents have a wealth of choices, whether they're craving a simple toasted bagel with cream cheese or a hearty deli sandwich. The "delicious" egg salad bagel, in particular, highlights the quality of their prepared items, making it a tempting choice for any meal.
Furthermore, the "surprisingly competitive" prices for the New York area are a major draw. In a region where dining costs can add up, Bagel Boss East offers excellent value without compromising on the authentic deli experience. While some customer experiences highlight slow service, suggesting that patience may be required during busy periods, the consensus points to the food being "excellent" and "definitely worth a visit" if you're not in a rush. This implies that for those with a more leisurely schedule or who prioritize quality and variety over speed, the rewards are considerable. For New Yorkers who appreciate an authentic, varied, and well-priced deli experience, Bagel Boss East remains a solid choice, despite any minor operational hiccups. It’s a place where the breadth of options and the taste of classic New York deli fare shine through.
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- On-site services
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Toilet
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
egg sandwich 26deli 14money 12chicken salad 9roll 9home fries 8grill 7walked 7butter 7employee 5
I’m really disappointed with my recent order from Bagel Boss. I ordered the original Boss sandwich and specifically asked for no peppers, but they still left out other key ingredients. Then, the second sandwich I got barely had any meat or cheese – it was so skimpy! I spent $30 for two sandwiches, and after waiting 20 minutes, I expected a lot more. This place used to be good, but it’s clearly gone downhill. I feel totally ripped off and won’t be coming back.
Dec 26 · Tacorah CherniseThis place it's way over priced to food that they sale and it's not even fresh. Their bagel spreads are sitting in the fridge for days and has formed a dark dry crust on it. Also, the prices on items in the fridge area aren't marked. On 02/27/2025 I wanted to buy boiled eggs that are sold 3 in a plastic container for $2.99. When I wanted to pay the men who was at the register said that the eggs are $3.99 bc the price of the eggs went up. I said by law you need to charge me the exact price as on the item $2.99, not a fictional price bc you said so. At Bagel Boss every day they change their price depending on how they woke up on that day. Also, when paying with cash they never provide a receipt to the customer and by law they should.After I paid and while I was walking away I heard the Spanish girl with the long ponytail who works there, started talking badly and gossiping about me in Spanish to the guy who wanted to overcharge me.Actually the staff constantly badmouth customers when they don't like the customer or the customer makes an observation to their service/food.There is no respect and professional courtesy from the staff. The management is no different. One of the worst bagel places for food, service and environment. Spend your money in places that at least they show respect the customers and don't badmouth them.
Mar 11 · PoshEleganceGreat sandwich for 7.75. Lots of bacon. Busy on a weekday at 10am but fast service. Would definitely go back.
Jan 29 · James MahonUsed to love this place now every time I come in I am waiting for 10 plus minutes…had to walk out this time. Was only one gentleman ahead of me on the line for the grill and neither him or myself was approached. Place needs a better set up…will start ordering mine and my employees order through stuff a bagel off door dash. Worrying about hanging and taking down signs rather than helping customers.
May 21 · joshua factorNEARBY ALTERNATIVES
Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
★ 4.0 · 148 reviews · 0.7 mi
Sunrise Bagel
2054 A Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.