Very disappointing experience! I ordered avocado toast for breakfast TWICE within 1 week. First, they called me on Sunday morning claiming they don't have any salmon. The toast arrived with everything (pastrami)but salmon, but I was still charged for salmon. I gave them 2nd chance today, 07-06-24, the toast arrived with salmon but not much of anything else: 1 spoon of avocado with few capers in the middle, instead of herb salad I got 1 slice of lettuce w/ a slice of red onion. I don't understand why are they even in restaurant business, and I certainly can't recommend them!
Jul 6 · Romana RobisBAKERY PROFILE
Bagel Brothers of New York
★ 3.0832 recorded reviews$10–20
10802 SW Tradition Pkwy, Port St. Lucie, FL 34987, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 10802 SW Tradition Pkwy, Port St. Lucie, FL 34987, USA
- Phone
- (772) 345-1770
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 832 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- Monday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Tuesday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Wednesday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Thursday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Friday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Saturday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For residents of Port St. Lucie and the surrounding areas, finding an authentic, high-quality bagel shop that delivers on the promise of that true New York flavor can be a challenge. That's where Bagel Brothers of New York steps in. Located right on Tradition Parkway, this establishment has made a name for itself by bringing the tradition of the hand-rolled, water-boiled, and baked-to-perfection bagel straight to the Treasure Coast. More than just a bagel shop, this locally owned small business operates as a full-service deli, bakery, and sandwich shop, making it a versatile and essential stop for breakfast, lunch, or catering.
Bagel Brothers is committed to quality, preparing their award-winning bagels fresh all day long. This dedication ensures the ultimate texture that locals look for: a crisp, slightly chewy crust with a soft, dense interior. Beyond the staple bagels and housemade cream cheese spreads, the menu has expanded significantly to offer a truly impressive array of breakfast and lunch options. From classic Nova Scotia salmon sandwiches to hearty breakfast burritos, and even authentic Carnegie Deli Classics, this establishment offers a taste of the Northeast right here in Florida. They pride themselves on using top-tier ingredients, including Boar's Head meats and cheeses, guaranteeing a superior flavor profile for all their sandwiches and deli items.
Location and Accessibility
Bagel Brothers of New York is strategically located to serve the bustling Tradition area and the wider Port St. Lucie community. Their address is:
10802 SW Tradition Pkwy, Port St. Lucie, FL 34987, USA
This location offers superb convenience, featuring a dedicated Free parking lot as well as Free street parking for easy access. For the comfort of all patrons, the small business is highly committed to accessibility:
- Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensuring ease of entry and exit.
- Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated, convenient parking spots are available.
- Wheelchair Accessible Restroom: Clean and fully accessible facilities are provided for all guests.
- Wheelchair Accessible Seating: Designated areas are available for comfortable dining in.
The shop caters to a modern Florida lifestyle with multiple service options, including Curbside pickup, Delivery, In-store pickup, Takeout, and Dine-in. Whether you're planning a Quick visit or settling in for a satisfying meal, the location is set up for efficiency and comfort. They also offer Wi-Fi and provide a welcoming, inclusive atmosphere, noted as both LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace.
Services Offered
The menu at Bagel Brothers of New York goes far beyond simple bagels and cream cheese, offering a comprehensive suite of deli, bakery, and catering services.
- Freshly Baked Bagels & Spreads: Award-winning, hand-rolled bagels baked fresh all day in over two dozen varieties, from classic Plain and Everything to specialties like Asiago Parmesan and Rainbow. Served with over a dozen housemade, whipped cream cheeses, including Lox Spread and Honey Walnut.
- Classic Deli & Nova Sandwiches: Featuring Boar's Head cold cuts and Acme Smoked Center Cut Nova, offering traditional New York favorites like The Nova Sandwich, the Jersey Special (Taylor Pork Roll), and various egg and cheese bagel sandwiches (Long Island Originals).
- Carnegie Deli Classics: A unique offering of authentic, oversized New York deli sandwiches, including The Carnegie Hot Pastrami, The Carnegie Hot Corned Beef, and The Carnegie Reuben.
- Hearty Breakfast & Lunch Items: A robust selection of hot food including the NEW!!! Original Philly Cheesesteak (made with shaved seasoned ribeye and Cooper Sharp Cheddar), Crispy Chicken Sandwiches, and large Breakfast Burritos (like the Huevorito and PastramiRito).
- Bakery & Gourmet Desserts: Offering classic desserts like Homemade Crumb Cake, Jumbo Muffins, Fresh Baked Cinnamon Rolls, and Carnegie Black & Whites. They also feature NEW! Gourmet Donuts (available Sat & Sun ONLY) in a variety of decadent flavors.
- Full Catering Services: Operating as a caterer, the shop can supply bagels by the box (including the Box Of Bagels Combo), spreads by the pound, and platters for local events, meetings, or gatherings.
- Omelettes and Classic Breakfast Platters: All-day breakfast options including 3-egg Omelettes (Garden Veggie, Original Leo) and the Classic Platter, served with breakfast potatoes and a bagel.
Features / Highlights
Bagel Brothers of New York stands out in the Treasure Coast dining scene due to several unique features that elevate it beyond a standard local bagel shop.
- Authentic New York Preparation: Their bagels are genuinely hand-rolled, boiled, and baked, the traditional way, giving them the distinct, chewy crust and fluffy interior that New Yorkers and Florida transplants alike crave.
- Exclusive Carnegie Deli Partnership: This is a major highlight, allowing customers to access legendary deli meats and signature sandwiches—like the famous Hot Pastrami—without having to travel far outside of Port St. Lucie.
- Specialty Menu Expansion: The continuous innovation of the menu is a strong feature, with new items like the Philly Cheesesteak and the massive Breakfast Burritos (PastramiRito!) broadening their appeal well beyond breakfast to become a full-service lunch destination.
- High-Quality Ingredients Commitment: The exclusive use of Boar's Head products for their deli selection assures customers of premium quality, consistent flavor, and high standards in all their meats and cheeses.
- Weekend Gourmet Donuts: A highly sought-after, weekend-only treat, the Gourmet Donuts (available in flavors like Maple & Bacon, Nutella, and Boston Cream) provide a perfect, indulgent option for Saturday and Sunday mornings in Florida.
- Convenient Bulk Purchasing: The option to purchase bagels in quantities of a Bakers Dozen or even Twenty Eight Bagels for large groups, along with spreads by the pound, makes it the ideal spot for family brunches and local business meetings.
Contact Information
To place an order for delivery, catering, or pickup in Port St. Lucie, please use the following contact information:
Address: 10802 SW Tradition Pkwy, Port St. Lucie, FL 34987, USA
Phone: (772) 345-1770
What is Worth Choosing
What makes Bagel Brothers of New York truly worth choosing for Florida residents in Port St. Lucie is the unmatched commitment to authenticity and variety in one convenient location. While some local bagel places might offer a decent bagel, very few can match the commitment to the New York bagel process while simultaneously providing an entire New York-style deli counter featuring Carnegie Deli classics. You're not just buying a bagel; you're buying a culinary experience rooted in decades of tradition.
The convenience of having everything from a classic Nova Sandwich on a freshly baked bagel to a half-pound Hot Pastrami on a hero roll, plus specialty treats like Gourmet Donuts on the weekend, makes this place an indispensable part of the local dining landscape. It serves as your morning stop, your catering partner, and your weekend indulgence all in one. For anyone in the Port St. Lucie area seeking the genuine flavors of a traditional New York bagel and deli, this small business on Tradition Parkway is the premier and most complete choice.
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
order 30tradition 19walking 14delivery 13mask 11new york bagel 11number 930 minutes 9panini 6soup 6
14.90 for a bacon egg and cheese! With 2 strips of bacon! And almost no cheese and 2 eggs! Never going back. And don’t get me started with the blueberry muffin! Almost no blueberrys! And they claim to be a New York bagel place. With those prices maybe Long Island. And it took them almost 10 mins to make the sandwich. I know this is Florida and everything is slower . But don’t put NY in your name and don’t have the speed or flavors. 14.90 tasted terrible
Sep 18 · Not Urs at allThis is my second time coming to this store and I will say that I like the atmosphere. It’s clean. It’s friendly and a couple things. I did enjoy like the rainbow cookie cake but The bagels were OK. Putting New York bagel in your name you have to have really great bagels, treasure Coast, bakery bagels Are better in my opinion and I grew up in New York. But It’s good Don’t get me wrong. It’s not horrible or Gimmicky It’s a good Option for people who just want a bagel and aren’t picky. Today I had the Blueberry muffin and I honestly couldn’t finish it. It was packed with sugar. My husband had a tuna out and he really enjoyed it. I’ve had sandwiches for them before and I really enjoyed it. The last time I went, I had the rainbow bagel and it was Not great I wouldn’t even say good I will say it was cute to look at aesthetically pleasing. But you buy a bagel to eat not to look at. I asked for it to be toasted And it was warm, not toasted but warm and the cream cheese was not spread evenly. I will say they were ridiculously busy at the time and still very nice and helpful. The cashier said she was new and she said that after I told her what I wanted about three times And she still wasn’t getting it my husband said it once and all of a sudden she heard what he said, and it was kind of annoying because I said Danish and she kept saying you want a bagel.. I almost screamed danish lol. But The eggs and potatoes are good. This is a very honest and long review because I see great potential in them. I just wish that number one their cashiers were a little bit more present. And I understand at the time that I want they had just freshly opened up I think so that was another factor again super busy that day. I was probably in there for about 30 minutes and the entire time it was packed to the rim. The last thing I will say is Be careful when you’re buying danishes from them because gosh I bought three and I ate them on the car ride home. It was that good so the pastries are great. But the muffin was a little sweet again. I got blueberry crumb, I think it was.
Apr 21 · subrina RamdinI have not been to Bagel Brothers in years. I was in the mood for a bacon, egg and cheese on a bagel. I like that I was able to order on the app and go pick up. When I got there a lady who was changing out the coffee station was a bit rude when she was trying to go around me but hey I will excuse that. The young man at the counter asked if I had been helped. He only had one item in my order but as soon as I told him what I had ordered he went and got the rest of it. The bagel sandwich was very tasty. Much better than Brooklyn Water Bagels. I also ordered a black and white cookie as being from NY that is one of my most missed things from NY. I have to say that this was one of the BEST black and white cookies I have had in Florida.I will be back again to try a few of their other items and of course another black and white cookie.
Jul 20 · Nancy ItriVisually the place looks great however I was so disapointed with my lunch. When I walked in I waited 10 minutes just for someone to acknowledge I was there to take my order (with no one in front of me). Not one worker looked up so that I could even try to get there attention (there were also 3 other people waiting behind me). Eventually they got around to taking my order but then I ended up waiting another long while just for a grilled cheese and tomato soup. When I finally got the food, the grilled cheese was barely toasted and the cheese was not melted, basically it was a cheese sandwhich. The tomato soup was not good either, it literally tasted like jarred pasta sauce and was barely heated up. I really had high hopes for a delicious lunch but this wasn't it...
Feb 6 · E MNEARBY ALTERNATIVES
Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
★ 4.0 · 4 reviews · 909.5 mi
Amish Pie Stand #2
on 896 south, 1461 Georgetown rd, ft on the left before, Noble Rd #500, Bart Township, PA 17509, USA
★ 2.0 · 16 reviews · 912.1 mi
Auntie Anne's
Milepost 219, 1 Eastbound Suite 1, Plainfield, PA 17081, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.