Highly dissapointed. Staff arrogant,poor customer skills, poor food quality, overpriced. Ordered taylor ham and cheese omelete platter they served it without homefries and toast even though it says on the menu it comes with that. After going back and forward who is right they put cold homefries in the box. Im huge supporter of Local Businesses but this i would not reccomend at all
Aug 4 · Misleshevo llcBagel Cafe 23
597 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 597 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009, USA
- Phone
- (973) 239-1364
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 103 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Tuesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Wednesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Thursday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Friday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Saturday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
For residents of New Jersey, particularly those in Cedar Grove, a local bagel shop is often a cornerstone of the community. It's a place where mornings begin, and quick, satisfying meals are a daily expectation. Bagel Cafe 23, located at 597 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009, USA, is one such establishment aiming to serve the local demand for bagels and breakfast items. As a local business, it strives to be a convenient option for those seeking a quick bite or a traditional bagel experience in the heart of Cedar Grove. Understanding what to expect when visiting a local establishment is key for New Jersey residents, and this overview aims to provide factual information about Bagel Cafe 23.
Local bagel shops are integral to the daily routines of many New Jerseyans, offering a familiar spot for breakfast, lunch, or a coffee break. Bagel Cafe 23 positions itself as a neighborhood option for these needs, providing a range of common bagel shop offerings. While the convenience of a nearby location is a significant factor for many patrons, understanding the various aspects of the customer experience, from service to food quality, can help locals make informed decisions about where to spend their dining dollars. This article will delve into the publicly available details about Bagel Cafe 23, offering a factual account of its services and highlighting relevant customer feedback.
Bagel Cafe 23 is conveniently located at 597 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009, USA. Situated on Pompton Avenue, a key thoroughfare in Cedar Grove, the establishment is relatively easy to locate for residents and commuters passing through the area. As part of a commercial strip, the location typically offers parking accessibility, which is a practical consideration for customers in New Jersey who often rely on their vehicles. This prominent address aims to make Bagel Cafe 23 a readily available option for those seeking breakfast or lunch items within the Cedar Grove community. Its position on a main road ensures visibility and straightforward access for local patrons looking for a quick and convenient stop.
Based on typical bagel shop operations and customer feedback, Bagel Cafe 23 generally offers a range of standard breakfast and lunch items.
Services Offered (based on common bagel shop menus and customer mentions):
- Bagels: A variety of freshly baked bagels, typically including plain and other common flavors.
- Bagel Sandwiches: Breakfast sandwiches often featuring combinations like Taylor ham and cheese.
- Omelettes: Platter options that typically include eggs cooked as an omelette, with side dishes.
- Coffee and Beverages: Standard coffee and other drink options commonly found in bagel cafes.
Features / Highlights (derived from customer experiences, both positive and negative):
- Local Presence: Bagel Cafe 23 operates as a local business in Cedar Grove, providing a neighborhood option for bagels and breakfast items.
- Common Bagel Shop Offerings: The menu includes staples like bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and omelette platters, which are standard for this type of establishment.
- Customer Service Variability: Public feedback indicates varying experiences with customer service, with some reporting issues related to staff demeanor and responsiveness.
- Order Accuracy Challenges: There have been instances where orders, even simple ones, were reportedly incorrect or incomplete, requiring customer follow-up.
- Food Quality Concerns: Some customer reviews have mentioned dissatisfaction with food quality, including issues like burnt bagels or cold side dishes.
- Pricing and Value Considerations: Customer feedback has occasionally raised concerns regarding pricing in relation to the quality and completeness of orders.
Contact Information:
Address: 597 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009, USA
Phone: (973) 239-1364
Mobile Phone: +1 973-239-1364
For New Jersey locals, especially those in the Cedar Grove area, choosing a reliable and satisfying bagel shop is an important part of their daily routine. Bagel Cafe 23 offers a convenient local option, but potential customers should be aware of varying experiences reported in public feedback. While supporting local businesses is highly valued in New Jersey, the provided customer reviews offer insights into specific aspects of service and product quality at Bagel Cafe 23.
One customer expressed being "highly disappointed," citing "arrogant staff, poor customer skills, poor food quality, overpriced." They detailed an issue where an "omelette platter" was served "without homefries and toast even though it says on the menu it comes with that," and after discussion, received "cold homefries." Another reviewer stated, "Sadly, this place has gone downhill," mentioning a "huge language barrier" and issues with order incompetence, even for a "very simple order." This customer also reported being "charged double if they mess up on one bagel and have to make another one," and a distressing incident of "a hair baked into the bagel," leading to a decision to "never go there again."
These direct accounts from local users provide important context for anyone considering Bagel Cafe 23. While convenience of location is a clear advantage, locals in New Jersey prioritize consistent quality, accurate orders, fair pricing, and respectful customer service. Therefore, while Bagel Cafe 23 exists as a local bagel shop option on Pompton Avenue, locals are advised to consider these past customer experiences when deciding if it's the right fit for their bagel and breakfast needs. Many New Jersey residents are willing to "drive to other towns for better bagels and customer service," suggesting that these factors weigh heavily in their choice of local establishments.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Sadly, this place has gone downhill. Besides a huge language barrier, they’re incompetent. I get a very simple order, plain bagel (not a burnt one) cut in half, on one side you put butter and on the other side you put cream cheese. Then cut it down the middle as normal. They’ve messed it up nearly every single time. But will charge you double if they mess up on one bagel and have to make another one. Latest debacle, there was a hair baked into the bagel. Threw it out and I’ll never go there again. I can only imagine how filthy it is back there in the kitchen area 🤮🤮. Will drive to other towns for better bagels and customer service.
May 24 · Alexis CallieI love this place. It's the only bagel place I go to and there are alot of them around. The staff is excellent! Never once had a bad sandwich!
Aug 23 · Christopher MattheisVery rude server. I ordered 2 pancakes and 1 bagel . Paid 27.00 dollars. The male server who took my order gave me 1 order of pancakes and 1 bagel . When I went to confront him he said that I confused him. How is that possible if they charged me that much ! The women at the register wanted to give me my money back for the 1 order of pancakes that I didn’t get but at that moment I was so upset to what he said I just left . So if the woman at the register understood my order why didn’t he ? I spoke to them at the same time . I think he’s the one that is confused and has issues ! He was so rude from the beginning that when I walked into the shop I asked for more time to order and he rolled his eyes at me and there wasn’t even a line .
Dec 31 · Rosanna PannulloThe ladies at the front were friendly when I went yesterday, and it was busy for the holiday. The breakfast sandwiches were better than some other places in the area. However, as a former business owner, I have a pet peeve for prices that are higher than what's posted on the menu boards. Otherwise, a good experience.
Dec 26 · Mike VigilCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.












This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
