Thought I'd give these guys another shot. Received stale croissants a few times and a muffin with mold growing on it. They lost my business after today. Asked if the croissants are fresh and the guy behind the counter told me they are "soft". Oh and another muffin with mold on it that my two year old was going to nibble on. Stay away. Quality check isn't great and the bagels are decent at best. Photos of the muffin attached.
May 13 · Mateusz DamianBagel Supreme | Wallington
457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA
- Phone
- (201) 587-5101
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 49 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday5:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Tuesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Wednesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Thursday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Friday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Saturday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
For those of us living in New Jersey, especially in the vibrant community of Wallington, the quest for a truly satisfying bagel is a familiar one. Bagel Supreme | Wallington aims to be that essential stop, providing a local hub for freshly baked bagels and a range of complementary breakfast and lunch items. As a staple in the area, Bagel Supreme offers a convenient and accessible option for residents seeking a quick bite, a morning coffee, or a hearty sandwich to start their day or fuel their afternoon. In a region where bagels are practically a way of life, Bagel Supreme understands the importance of delivering on freshness and variety. It's a place designed to cater to the daily routines of locals, offering a familiar spot where quality and convenience meet. While every establishment has its moments, the core purpose of Bagel Supreme is to serve the community with dependable food options that fit seamlessly into busy schedules.
Bagel Supreme | Wallington is conveniently located at 457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA. This address places it on a well-known thoroughfare in Wallington, making it highly accessible for local residents and those commuting through the area. Paterson Avenue is a key artery, ensuring that the bagel shop is easy to find whether you're driving, walking, or cycling. For those in Wallington, East Rutherford, Carlstadt, and other surrounding Bergen County towns, reaching Bagel Supreme is typically a short and straightforward trip. Ample street parking is often available, though it can vary during peak hours. Its position within a commercial stretch of Paterson Avenue means it's often close to other local businesses and residential areas, making it a convenient stop for errands or on the way to work. The accessibility of Bagel Supreme is a significant advantage, allowing locals to effortlessly incorporate a visit into their daily routines for a fresh bagel or a quick meal.
Bagel Supreme | Wallington offers a range of services centered around providing a comprehensive menu for breakfast and lunch, primarily focusing on freshly prepared items for convenience.
- Freshly Baked Bagels: As their name suggests, bagels are the core offering. Customers can expect a variety of classic bagel flavors, ideal for individual purchase or by the dozen.
- Bagel Sandwiches: A popular choice, these include a variety of breakfast sandwiches with eggs, cheese, and choice of meat (like bacon, sausage, or ham), perfect for a quick and satisfying start to the day.
- Cream Cheese Spreads: A wide selection of homemade cream cheese flavors, from plain to various savory and sweet options, to complement their fresh bagels.
- Breakfast Platters: Beyond bagels, they may offer breakfast platters that include eggs, meats, and home fries, providing a more substantial morning meal.
- Lunch Sandwiches: A range of deli-style sandwiches and wraps, made to order with fresh ingredients, suitable for a midday meal. These often include classic cold cuts, cheeses, and vegetable toppings.
- Muffins and Pastries: In addition to bagels, they typically offer a selection of baked goods such as muffins, croissants, and other pastries for those seeking a different kind of sweet treat.
- Coffee and Beverages: A full range of coffee options (hot and iced), teas, juices, and other cold beverages to accompany meals or for a quick refreshment.
- Catering Services: Bagel shops often provide catering platters for local businesses, offices, or private events, including bagel and cream cheese assortments, sandwich platters, and coffee setups.
- Online Ordering for Pickup: As indicated by a customer review, Bagel Supreme offers online ordering through their website, allowing for convenient pre-ordering and quick pickup, streamlining the customer experience.
Bagel Supreme | Wallington, despite some reported inconsistencies, strives to offer specific features and highlights that appeal to its local customer base.
- Extensive Bagel Selection: A wide variety of bagel types are typically available, catering to different preferences, from plain and everything to sesame and poppy seed.
- Breakfast & Lunch Versatility: The menu extends beyond just bagels to include comprehensive breakfast platters and a variety of lunch sandwiches, making it a one-stop shop for different meal times.
- Convenient Online Ordering: The availability of online ordering through their website is a significant modern convenience, allowing customers to place orders ahead of time for quick pickup, saving valuable time.
- Local Accessibility: Its prime location on Paterson Avenue in Wallington ensures easy access for local residents, commuters, and those working in the vicinity, enhancing its utility as a daily stop.
- Freshly Prepared Food: The core intention is to provide freshly prepared bagels and sandwiches, aiming for quality and taste in every order.
- Local Business Presence: As a local establishment, Bagel Supreme contributes to the community's economy and offers a familiar face for residents, fostering a sense of neighborhood connection.
For all inquiries, placing orders, or to learn more about their offerings, you can contact Bagel Supreme | Wallington using the following information:
Address: 457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA
Phone: (201) 587-5101
Mobile Phone: +1 201-587-5101
For locals in Wallington, New Jersey, Bagel Supreme offers a practical and familiar option for daily breakfast and lunch needs. In a state where bagels are a culinary institution, having a nearby spot that offers a variety of fresh bagels, customizable breakfast sandwiches, and convenient lunch options is highly valuable. While consistency is a challenge for any food establishment, the presence of online ordering streamlines the process for busy individuals, allowing them to quickly grab their food and go. Its accessible location on Paterson Avenue makes it an easy stop for commuters and residents alike. For the local community, Bagel Supreme serves as a dependable source for quick meals, fresh coffee, and classic bagel shop fare, fitting seamlessly into the rhythm of daily life. Choosing Bagel Supreme means opting for a convenient local spot that aims to provide the essential bagel experience that New Jerseyans appreciate, offering a familiar taste and a quick solution for those moments when only a fresh bagel or a hearty sandwich will do.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Food was great. 5 stars for food. Ordered pick up thru their website around 2:30pm on a Monday. I get a call at 2:57 saying they close in 3 minutes and to hurry and pick up my food because they're gonna close at 3pm. I told them online it says they're open till 5pm on Mondays. I don't mind if it's a mistake but the man on the phone sounded upset about it. Idk just fix your hours on Google.
Apr 21 · Amanda MartinezWow! Fantastic, fresh, oversized bagels traveling back with us to North Carolina! Great customer service and location, definitely recommend!
Oct 17 · Maple RoadsThe taylor ham, egg, and cheese on a plain bagel was PHENOMENAL! We were visiting from out of town and found this place to be quite the treat.
May 26 · Kandi ElizabethI had ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel and asked for the bacon to be well done. They gave me undercooked, chewy, soggy bacon that made me gag and there was no cheese on my sandwich. I wanted toGive them another shot because it is conveniently close by so I ordered from them again. Same exact order. I just figured they made a mistake the first time and things happen. But when I got my sandwich, it was the same exact problem! From the previous reviews that I have read, I am not the only one complaining about their bacon. I don’t think they know how to cook the bacon properly. Will not be coming back here!
Aug 24 · Kim AlterioCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

Aroma du2019 Cafe Bakery II
267 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA









Living Bread - artisan sourdough bakery
22 W Passaic Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA


This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
