BAKERY PROFILE

Bagelicious II

★ 3.0446 recorded reviews

91 Washington Ave, North Haven, CT 06473, USA

DirectionsCallWebsite

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Bagelicious II
PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address
91 Washington Ave, North Haven, CT 06473, USA
Phone
(203) 535-0632
Website
Visit official site
Rating signal
3.0 from 446 recorded reviews
HOURS

Listed operating hours

  • Monday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
  • Tuesday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
  • Wednesday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
  • Thursday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
  • Friday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
  • Saturday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
  • Sunday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
About and visit notes

Welcome, Connecticut residents, to your comprehensive guide to a local breakfast and lunch staple: Bagelicious II. Located in the vibrant community of North Haven, Bagelicious II has carved out a niche as a popular spot for those craving authentic, freshly baked bagels and delicious bagel sandwiches. This article will delve into what makes Bagelicious II a notable establishment in the Connecticut food scene, providing insights into its offerings, location, and tips to ensure you have the best possible experience. For anyone in the North Haven area and beyond, seeking a classic bagel fix, this is a place worth knowing.

Bagelicious II aims to be more than just a quick stop; it's a place where the aroma of freshly baked goods fills the air, promising a satisfying start to your day or a delightful midday meal. While popular spots often come with their own unique quirks, understanding the rhythm of a local favorite like Bagelicious II can greatly enhance your visit. We'll explore their renowned bagels, the variety of cream cheeses, and provide a balanced perspective to help you navigate your experience, ensuring you get to enjoy the best of what they offer.

---
Location and Accessibility

Bagelicious II is conveniently situated at 91 Washington Ave, North Haven, CT 06473, USA. Washington Avenue (Route 5) is a major thoroughfare in North Haven, making the bakery easily accessible for both local residents and those commuting through the area. Its location on a main road means it's straightforward to find, whether you're heading to work, running errands, or specifically making a trip for their bagels.

For Connecticut locals, particularly those in North Haven, Hamden, Wallingford, and surrounding towns, this address offers excellent accessibility. Being on Washington Avenue provides clear signage and easy ingress/egress for vehicles. Bagelicious II also features a drive-through option, which, while noted by some customers to have wait times due to fresh preparation, offers a convenient alternative for those on the go. However, for a potentially quicker experience or if you wish to browse the full selection, stepping inside the shop is also an option. Parking is generally available, though during peak hours, patience may be required. This prime location contributes significantly to its status as a community hub for bagel lovers.

---
Services Offered

Bagelicious II focuses primarily on delivering a classic bagel shop experience with a few key offerings:

  • Freshly Baked Bagels: This is their core product. Bagelicious II bakes bagels fresh daily, ensuring a warm and chewy experience. It's highly recommended to arrive early to ensure you have the widest selection of bagel types.
  • Bagel Sandwiches: Beyond plain bagels, they offer a variety of bagel sandwiches. These are made fresh to order, featuring different fillings and combinations perfect for breakfast or lunch.
  • Homemade Cream Cheeses: A standout feature, as highlighted by customer reviews, is their assortment of homemade cream cheeses. These spreads are noted for their quality and variety, complementing the fresh bagels perfectly.
  • Drive-Through Service: For ultimate convenience, Bagelicious II provides a drive-through. While it can experience longer wait times due to everything being made fresh, it's a valuable option for customers in a hurry.
  • Discounted Day-Old Bagels: For the budget-conscious or those looking to stock up, the shop offers yesterday's bagels at a deeply discounted price when purchased inside. This is a great way to enjoy their bagels without breaking the bank.
  • Coffee and Beverages: As a typical bakery/bagel shop, they likely offer a range of coffee and other beverages to accompany your bagel or sandwich.
---
Features / Highlights

Bagelicious II has several distinguishing features and highlights that make it a notable establishment in North Haven's culinary landscape:

  • Authentically Fresh Bagels: The primary highlight is the commitment to baking fresh bagels daily. Customers consistently praise the quality, taste, and freshness of the bagels, noting they often disappear quickly due to demand. This freshness is a cornerstone of their appeal.
  • Exceptional Homemade Cream Cheeses: Their array of homemade cream cheeses receives high marks from customers. The variety and quality of these spreads significantly enhance the bagel experience, making them a must-try alongside your chosen bagel.
  • Made-to-Order Freshness: The fact that bagel sandwiches and other items are made fresh contributes to the quality of the food, even if it sometimes leads to longer wait times. This dedication to fresh preparation is a significant draw for many.
  • Value in Day-Old Bagels: The offering of deeply discounted day-old bagels inside the shop is a clever and customer-friendly feature, providing an economical option for those who don't mind a slightly less fresh product or who want to buy in bulk for later.
  • High Demand & Popularity: The quick disappearance of bagel selections and the noted long lines, particularly at the drive-through, are indicators of its high popularity and strong local demand. This buzz, while sometimes leading to waits, also signals a sought-after product.
  • Convenient Drive-Through Option: Despite potential wait times, the availability of a drive-through is a major convenience for commuters and busy individuals, offering a quick grab-and-go solution.
---
Contact Information

For inquiries, placing orders, or simply to confirm hours before your visit, here’s how you can get in touch with Bagelicious II:

  • Address: 91 Washington Ave, North Haven, CT 06473, USA
  • Phone: (203) 535-0632

It's always a good idea to call ahead, especially if you're looking for a specific bagel type or if you have a large order, as their popular selections can sell out quickly, particularly by midday. This will help ensure you have the best possible experience when visiting.

---
Conclusion: Why This Place Is Suitable for Locals

Bagelicious II in North Haven is a quintessential local spot that perfectly caters to the needs and preferences of Connecticut residents. Its suitability stems from several key aspects that resonate deeply with the community.

Firstly, the unwavering commitment to freshness is paramount. For many, a good bagel means one that's baked that very day, and Bagelicious II delivers on this promise. The emphasis on "everything made fresh" ensures a superior taste and texture that pre-packaged alternatives simply cannot match. This dedication to quality makes it a preferred choice for daily commuters, weekend brunchers, and anyone who appreciates a truly authentic bagel experience right here in Connecticut.

Secondly, the diverse array of homemade cream cheeses elevates the humble bagel to a gourmet experience. This isn't just about spreading something on your bagel; it's about indulging in rich, flavorful combinations that are crafted in-house. This variety allows locals to customize their bagel to their exact liking, ensuring every visit offers a new taste adventure or a comforting favorite.

Despite the occasional queues or sell-outs mentioned in reviews, these are often indicators of high demand for a genuinely good product. Savvy locals quickly learn the rhythm of Bagelicious II – arriving early for the best selection or utilizing the convenient drive-through (with patience!). The option for deeply discounted day-old bagels also highlights a thoughtful approach to waste reduction and offers an economical option that appeals to budget-conscious families and individuals.

In essence, Bagelicious II provides a product that consistently meets a high standard of quality, is easily accessible, and caters to both convenience and the desire for fresh, homemade goodness. For anyone in North Haven and surrounding Connecticut towns looking for a reliable and delicious source for their bagel fix, Bagelicious II is a deserving local favorite that continues to serve up satisfaction, one fresh bagel at a time.

PHOTOS

See the bakery

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

★ 4.0

Get here early as the bagel selections quickly disappear. Bagels and bagel sandwiches are really good! Drive through takes a long time as everything is made fresh. If you go inside, they offer yesterday's bagels at a deeply discounted price. Their home made cream cheeses are all very good!

Mar 9 · Jana Ziolkowski
★ 1.0

This is a nice shop but the service from the employees which are fairly young is not good, the wait for a bagel is too long, and the shop RUNS OUT OF BAGELS BY mid day. The drive through is a nightmare and standing on line is even worst. To then find out that what you want to order is not even available anymore.My drive through service was so bad I won’t do that anymore.But I feel like they are very cheap with their serving I paid $6.01 for a plain bagel and avocado plus spread and I think they spread half a teaspoon on the bagels. If you’re going to charge $6 you need to give $6 worth.Get friendlier employees and clean the coffee station.

Nov 12 · Aixanai Sanchez
★ 5.0

The Bagelicious experience is similar to getting a good pie on Wooster Street, sometimes you have to wait in a long line, but the product is well worth it.I’ve been a steady walk-in customer twice-a-week since they opened their North Haven location a few years ago.IMO their bagels are the best in the Greater New Haven area only rivaled by their Cheshire location, Shef’s in Cheshire, and Olmo in New Haven, which is why they have so many repeat customers like me.Sometimes the lines move slowly which are often attributed to some very picky customers in front of me who place complex hard to fill sandwich and drink orders like they are in S***Bucks, and other customers that want to order 2 dozen bagels and pick them out 1 at a time like they are going to eat every single one of them. I consider it a very good day if I don’t get behind one of these picky customers.I’ve always found all of the staff, and the owner, to be extremely helpful and friendly.

Jun 15 · Rick Bassett
★ 4.0

Bagels are always fresh and love the cream cheese - the jalapeño cheddar with the jalapeño cream cheese is my go to order.However as others have said - the wait for both placing your order and the receiving it is just an insane amount of time - both at the drive thru and in the store. How it take so long really boggles the mind.

May 27 · Pooja Perepa
★ 1.0

Disappointed with the Price Hike & Portion CutI’ve been a loyal customer of Bagelicious for years, but after my last visit, I don’t think I’ll be returning anytime soon. They recently raised their prices, citing increased costs, which I can understand. But what I don’t understand is why they’ve also decided to cut corners by only using one egg per sandwich instead of the two they’ve always used.If I’m paying more, I at least expect the same quality and portion I’ve always gotten. Instead, I got a sad, thin sandwich that wasn’t worth the inflated price. It’s disappointing to see a place I used to love go this route. If they’re cutting back on ingredients while charging more, I can’t justify coming back.

Apr 6 · Pizza Gavone
NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

Mighty Donuts
★ 4.0 · 107 reviews · 4.3 mi

Mighty Donuts

1700 Dixwell Ave, Hamden, CT 06514, USA

Details
JCakes
★ 4.0 · 144 reviews · 5.1 mi

JCakes

5 Foxon Rd, North Branford, CT 06471, USA

Details
Krafty Kakes
★ 4.0 · 9 reviews · 6.7 mi

Krafty Kakes

39 N Plains Industrial Rd, Wallingford, CT 06492, USA

Details
Sweet Mary's
★ 4.0 · 67 reviews · 6.9 mi

Sweet Mary's

129 Court St, New Haven, CT 06511, USA

Details
About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.

SIDE-BY-SIDE

Bakery comparison

Expanded bakery photo