BAKERY PROFILE

Bagels & Co

★ 4.0923 recorded reviewsUS$10–20

391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address: 391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
Phone: (212) 496-9400
Website: Visit official site
Rating signal: 4.0 from 923 recorded reviews

HOURS

Listed operating hours

Monday6:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Tuesday6:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Wednesday6:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Thursday6:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Friday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
SaturdayClosed
Sunday6:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Open turn-by-turn directions →

About and visit notes

For many New Yorkers, the day simply isn't complete without a perfectly crafted bagel. It's more than just breakfast; it's a cornerstone of the city's culinary identity. On the Upper West Side, a neighborhood synonymous with classic New York charm, Bagels & Co has emerged as a beloved institution, consistently delivering an authentic and delightful bagel experience. This isn't just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a vibrant hub where locals find comfort, quality, and a truly satisfying start to their day. Patrons rave about the bagels being "always fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy — exactly how real bagels should be," a testament to their dedication to traditional methods and high standards. Beyond the bagels themselves, the friendly atmosphere and extensive menu solidify Bagels & Co as a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine taste of New York. This article will explore what makes Bagels & Co an indispensable part of the Upper West Side community, from its convenient location and diverse offerings to the features that make it feel "like home" to its loyal customers.

Bagels & Co is ideally situated at 391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, placing it right in the heart of the bustling and residential Upper West Side of Manhattan. This prime location contributes significantly to its popularity and accessibility. For those relying on New York City's extensive public transportation system, reaching Bagels & Co is remarkably convenient. The shop is a short walk from the 79th Street subway station, served by the 1 local train, which provides direct access from various parts of Manhattan. Additionally, commuters from other boroughs can easily connect to this line. Several MTA bus routes also traverse Amsterdam Avenue and nearby major streets like Broadway, offering even more options for reaching the location by public transit. The surrounding neighborhood is highly walkable, making it a natural stop for residents out for a morning stroll, running errands, or heading to work. While street parking can be a common challenge in Manhattan, the abundance of public transport options mitigates this, ensuring that whether you're a long-time local or just passing through, getting your hands on a fresh bagel from Bagels & Co is a hassle-free experience. Its presence on a lively avenue further enhances its appeal as a central and welcoming community spot.

Services Offered:

Freshly Baked Bagels: A wide variety of traditional New York-style bagels, consistently described as fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy.
Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: Offers a great variety of delicious cream cheese spreads, including popular options like the favored veggie cream cheese, as well as classic and specialty flavors.
Bagel Sandwiches: Crafting a comprehensive menu of breakfast and lunch bagel sandwiches, from classic egg and cheese combinations to more elaborate deli options including smoked salmon.
Coffee and Beverages: A full selection of hot and cold beverages, including coffee, iced lattes, and juices, to complement your meal.
Other Baked Goods and Desserts: Beyond bagels, the menu extends to a diverse range of baked goods, including croissants, challah, danishes, muffins, cheesecakes, and various cookies.
Hot Food & Deli Items: Offers an array of hot breakfast options like Belgian waffles, French toast, and pancakes, as well as a wider deli menu including salads, paninis, sandwiches, soups, and even pizza by the slice.
Catering Services: Provides comprehensive catering solutions for various occasions, from corporate events to private gatherings, with platters of bagels, spreads, smoked fish, and other deli delights.
Online Ordering and Delivery: Conveniently offers online ordering for pickup or delivery across various New York boroughs, making it easy to enjoy their food from home or office.
Dine-in Option: Features a cozy and welcoming vibe with seating available for quick bites, making it suitable for both on-the-go and brief sit-down meals.
Kosher Certified: Proudly offers high-quality kosher food, serving the needs of the Jewish community and others seeking kosher options.

Features / Highlights:

Authentic New York Bagels: The bagels are consistently praised for being "perfectly chewy" and "exactly how real bagels should be," fulfilling the expectation of an authentic New York bagel experience.
Exceptional Freshness and Warmth: A key highlight is that bagels are "always fresh, warm," indicating frequent baking and a commitment to serving the best quality product immediately.
Delicious and Varied Cream Cheeses: The "delicious cream cheese spreads," especially the popular "veggie one," demonstrate a strong command of bagel accompaniments, offering both classic and appealing specialty flavors.
Friendly and Quick Staff: The staff are noted for being "friendly and quick, even during busy mornings," which significantly enhances the customer experience, making visits efficient and pleasant.
Cozy and Welcoming Atmosphere: The "cozy, welcoming vibe" contributes to the feeling of being "like home," creating a comfortable and inviting environment for customers. The cleanliness of the place is also highlighted, adding to its appeal.
"Rainbow Bagel" Attraction: The availability and positive reception of unique items like the "rainbow bagel" demonstrate their willingness to offer fun and visually appealing options alongside classics.
Comprehensive Menu: Beyond bagels, the extensive menu including deli items, breakfast plates, and kosher options, showcases their versatility and ability to cater to diverse tastes and meal times.
High Customer Satisfaction: Consistently receives high recommendations from both locals and tourists, indicating a broad appeal and success in delivering a satisfying experience.
Value for Price: Reviews suggest good value for the quality and portion sizes, especially for a Manhattan establishment.

Contact Information:

Address: 391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Phone: (212) 496-9400

For any New Yorker, Bagels & Co on the Upper West Side is truly an essential stop for an authentic and highly satisfying bagel experience. What makes this establishment particularly suitable for locals is its unwavering commitment to quality – consistently delivering bagels that are "always fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy." This dedication, combined with a "great variety of flavors and toppings" and notably "delicious cream cheese spreads," ensures that every visit meets the high standards New Yorkers have for their bagels. Beyond the food, the "friendly and quick" staff, even during the busiest hours, contribute to a seamless experience, while the "cozy, welcoming vibe" and impressive cleanliness make it feel genuinely "like home." Whether you're rushing to work and need "breakfast on the go," or seeking a moment to sit down for a "quick bite," Bagels & Co caters to diverse needs. Its prime Amsterdam Avenue location, easily accessible by subway and bus, integrates perfectly into the daily rhythm of Upper West Side life. For those seeking not just a bagel, but a warm, authentic, and delicious piece of New York’s culinary soul, Bagels & Co comes "Highly recommend to any bagel lover!"

MENU SNAPSHOT

Coffee
Freshly brewed coffee, available in small, medium, or large.
US$3.00
Tea
Sizes available in small, medium, large. Flavors include chamomile, earl grey, english breakfast, green tea.
US$2.50
Flavored Coffee
Flavored coffee, available in sm, medium, large. Choose from amaretto, butterscotch, caramel, cookie dough, sugar-free hazelnut, marshmallow, raspberry, or sugar-free vanilla.
US$3.00
Herbal Tea
Herbal tea selections available in sm, medium, large sizes.
US$2.50
Hot Chocolate
Rich, creamy cocoa served in sm, medium, or large sizes.
US$3.50
Espresso
Choice of single or double shot.
US$3.75
Latte
Coffee latte, available in small, medium, or large sizes.
US$4.00
Flavored Latte
Espresso and steamed milk latte with choice of flavors including amaretto, butterscotch, caramel, and more. Options for sugar-free. Available in small, medium, or large.
US$4.50
Iced Coffee
Chilled, freshly brewed coffee; available in medium or large.
US$5.00
Iced Tea
Iced tea, available in medium or large sizes.
US$4.00
Iced Flavored Coffee
Iced coffee in medium or large; choose from amaretto, butterscotch, caramel, cookie dough, sugar-free hazelnut, marshmallow, raspberry, or sugar-free vanilla flavors.
US$5.50
Iced Latte
Iced coffee latte, available in medium or large sizes.
US$6.00
Iced Flavored Latte
Iced flavored latte with choice of medium or large. Options include amaretto, butterscotch, caramel, cookie dough, hazelnut (sugar-free), marshmallow, raspberry, vanilla (sugar-free).
US$5.50
Poland Spring Water
Poland Spring water, options in medium or large.
US$2.00
Canned Soda
US$2.00
Bottled Soda
Bottled soda available in various flavors including seltzer, ginger ale, Sprite varieties, orange Fanta, diet Coke, and Hals New York lemon seltzer.
US$2.50
Snapple
Snapple tea, available in raspberry, diet raspberry, lemonade, peach flavors.
US$3.00
Tropicana Juice
Tropicana juices available in lemonade, orange (with or without pulp), cranberry, apple, and ruby red grapefruit flavors.
US$3.75
Smoothie
Smoothie options in small, medium, or large.
US$5.75

All Day - Breakfast 13 items

Spinach And Feta Omelet Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$14.95
Mushroom Omelet Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$13.95
2 Eggs Any Style Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$12.95
Greek Omelet Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$14.00
Spanish Omelet Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$13.00
Lox, Eggs And Onions Omelet Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$16.75
Eggs With Grilled Veggies Breakfast
Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$13.25
Muscle Man Breakfast
Egg whites, peppers, tomato and onion. Served with home fries and Israeli or Greek salad.
US$12.75
Eggs On Bagel Breakfast
Egg sandwich on choice of bagel or bread, including bialy, cinnamon raisin, everything, garlic, multigrain, sesame, whole wheat options, and more.
US$8.00
Eggs And Cheese On Bagel Breakfast
US$8.50
Egg Whites On Bagel Breakfast
Egg whites, choice of bagels including savory, sweet, and whole grain options, or opt for a challah roll or croissant.
US$8.00
Egg Whites And Cheese On Bagel Breakfast
Egg whites and melted cheese served on your choice of bagel or bread: variety includes plain, whole wheat, blueberry, and more. Selection of American, Swiss, cheddar, or fresh mozzarella cheese.
US$9.00
Grilled Cheese Breakfast
Grilled cheese with options of American, mozzarella, Muenster, Swiss, cheddar, or fresh mozzarella cheese. Served as a breakfast dish.
US$5.50

All Day - Salads 5 items

Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, crunchy croutons, shaved Parmesan, and a tangy Caesar dressing.
US$8.95
Greek Salad
Fresh mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese. Available in small or large. Choose from a wide range of dressings, including Italian, Caesar, and honey mustard.
US$7.75
Fruit Salad
Fresh fruit mix. Options: small or large.
US$7.75
Israeli Salad
Diced tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and bell peppers. Options include small or large sizes; choice of twelve dressings, including Italian, Caesar, and honey mustard variants.
US$7.75
Salad Bar
Bowl of greens, cucumbers, carrots and onions.
US$8.75

All Day - Bagels 6 items

Bagel
Hand-rolled and kettle boiled.
US$1.90
1 Dozen Bagels
Hand-rolled and kettle boiled. Get 1 free bagel with this choice.
US$22.80
Flat Bagel
Hand-rolled and kettle boiled. Everything, plain or sesame.
US$2.50
1 Dozen Flat Bagels
Hand-rolled and kettle boiled. Everything, plain or sesame. Get 1 free bagel with this choice.
US$24.00
Mini Bagel
Hand-rolled and kettle boiled. Everything, plain or sesame.
US$1.25
1 Dozen Mini Bagels
Hand-rolled and kettle boiled. Everything, plain or sesame. Get 1 free bagel with this choice.
US$15.00

All Day - Belgian Waffles, French Toast and Pancakes 11 items

Belgian Waffles
Golden and airy Belgian waffle, typically served with powdered sugar, butter, and syrup.
US$9.00
Nutty Swirl Belgian Waffles
Banana, walnuts and whipped cream.
US$12.00
Cookies And Cream Belgian Waffles
Oreos and whipped cream.
US$12.00
Romeo And Juliet Belgian Waffles
Strawberry, banana nad nutella.
US$12.50
Double Decker
Waffles and egg omelet.
US$14.00
3 Large Plain Pancakes
Three large pancakes, made from our classic batter, typically accompanied by whipped butter and maple syrup.
US$9.50
2 Pancakes With 2 Eggs Any Style
Two pancakes paired with eggs prepared your way: scrambled, sunny-side-up, over-easy, or fried.
US$11.50
3 Pancakes With Banana
Three buttermilk pancakes, accompanied by fresh banana slices.
US$9.95
2 Pancakes With Fruit Salad
Two fluffy pancakes served with a side of mixed fruit salad.
US$9.50
2 Pancakes With 2 Eggs And Home Fries
Two pancakes paired with choice of scrambled, sunny side up, over easy, or fried eggs. Served with home fries.
US$10.50
French Toast With Fruit Salad
French toast served with a side of mixed fresh fruit salad, typically includes a dusting of powdered sugar.
US$9.50

All Day - Cream Cheese Spreads 21 items

Butter On A Bagel
Creamy spread on choice of bagel: bialy, cinnamon raisin, egg, everything, garlic, and more. Satisfies all tastes.
US$3.75
Jelly On A Bagel
Choose strawberry, grape, orange or apricot.
US$3.75
Peanut Butter On A Bagel
Choice of bagel topped with creamy peanut butter spread. Selections include everything from plain to rainbow, and flat options.
US$4.00
Plain Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Rich cream cheese spread over your choice of bagel, including bialy, multigrain, whole wheat, and various flavored options like cinnamon raisin and blueberry.
US$5.25
Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Scallion cream cheese spread on choice of bagel including plain, whole grain varieties, flavored, and flat options.
US$6.50
Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Cream cheese blended with fresh vegetables on your choice of bagel, including classic, whole grain, and flavored varieties.
US$6.50
Blueberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Blueberry cream cheese spread atop your choice of bagels including bialy, cinnamon raisin, everything, and more.
US$6.50
Strawberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Bagel topped with strawberry cream cheese spread. Choice of bagel includes bialy, plain, cinnamon raisin, and more. Flat and specialty options available.
US$6.50
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Chocolate chip cream cheese spread over choice of bagel: bialy to french toast varieties, including whole grain and flat options.
US$6.50
Walnut And Raisin Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Walnut and raisin cream cheese served on a choice of over 15 bagels, including bialy, cinnamon raisin, everything, and flat varieties.
US$6.50
Jalapeno Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Jalapeno cream cheese spread over your choice of bagel: bialy, plain, cinnamon raisin, egg, everything, and more varieties including flat options.
US$6.50
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Kalamata olive cream cheese spread over your choice of bagel: includes classic, sweet, savory, and whole grain options.
US$6.50
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Sun-dried tomato cream cheese atop your choice of bagel, including plain, everything, cinnamon raisin, garlic, onion, multigrain, and more unique options like rainbow and french toast.
US$6.50
Nova Lox Spread On A Bagel
Nova lox spread on choice of bagel: bialy, plain, cinnamon raisin, egg, everything, garlic, onion, multigrain, poppy seed, pumpernickel, salt, sesame, whole wheat variants, rainbow, blueberry, french toast, flat options.
US$9.50
Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Low fat cream cheese atop choice of bagels: bialy, cinnamon raisin, everything, garlic, multigrain, pumpernickel, rainbow, blueberry, French toast, or flat varieties.
US$5.25
Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Low fat scallion cream cheese spread over a choice of bagels including bialy, plain, everything, flat variants, and more.
US$6.50
Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Low fat vegetable cream cheese spread over your choice of bagel, including options like plain, everything, multigrain, and more exotic varieties like rainbow and French toast.
US$6.50
Tofu Plain Spread On A Bagel
Tofu plain spread, selection of bagels including bialy, cinnamon-raisin, everything, and more. Variety of flavors and textures.
US$6.00
Tofu Vegetable Spread On A Bagel
Tofu and vegetable cream cheese spread. Choice of bagel includes bialy, plain, assorted flavors, and flat options.
US$6.50
Tofu Scallion Spread On A Bagel
Tofu and scallion cream cheese spread, choose from over 15 bagel options including whole grain, flavored, and flat varieties.
US$6.50
Rainbow Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Vibrantly colored cream cheese spread over your choice of bagel, including classic favorites to unique varieties like rainbow and French toast bagels.
US$6.50

All Day - By The Pound Menu 43 items

Butter
American by the pound: Butter available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$4.00
Jelly
Choose strawberry, grape, orange or apricot.
US$4.00
Peanut Butter
Peanut butter available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
US$3.50
Plain Cream Cheese
American cream cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb sizes.
US$3.50
Scallion Cream Cheese
Scallion cream cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb options.
US$4.00
Vegetable Cream Cheese
American blend of cream cheese with mixed vegetables. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
US$4.00
Blueberry Cream Cheese
Blueberry cream cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb selections.
US$4.00
Strawberry Cream Cheese
American-style strawberry cream cheese. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb sizes.
US$4.00
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
Cream cheese infused with chocolate chips. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb portions.
US$4.00
Walnut And Raisin Cream Cheese
Cream cheese blended with walnuts and raisins. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$4.00
Jalapeno Cream Cheese
Jalapeno Cream Cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$4.00
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese
Kalamata olive cream cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
US$4.00
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese
US$4.00
Nova Lox Spread
Creamy nova lox spread, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or full lb sizes.
US$4.50
Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese
American cuisine - By the Pound Menu: Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
US$3.50
Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese
Low fat scallion cream cheese. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb sizes.
US$4.00
Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese
Low fat vegetable cream cheese. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$4.00
Tofu Plain Spread
Smooth tofu spread, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb sizes.
US$4.00
Tofu Vegetable Spread
Tofu vegetable spread available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$4.00
Tofu Scallion Spread
Tofu scallion spread available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$4.00
Avocado Salad
Fresh avocado salad available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$4.50
Babaganoush
Smoky eggplant dip, tahini, lemon juice, garlic, olive oil. Sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$3.25
Baked Salmon Salad
Baked salmon over greens, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb portions.
US$38.00
Chopped Herring
Chopped herring, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$4.50
Egg Salad
Egg salad available in multiple sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 1 lb.
US$6.50
Egg White Spinach
Egg white and spinach. Available sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 1 lb.
US$5.50
Garlic Cream Cheese
Smooth garlic-infused cream cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
US$3.50
Hummus
Smooth chickpea blend, served by choice of 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$3.25
Jelly
Choose strawberry, grape, orange or apricot.
US$3.25
Kippered Salmon
Kippered salmon served by weight. Options include 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb servings.
US$15.75
Low Fat Tuna Salad
Low fat tuna salad available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb sizes.
US$4.50
Lox Cream Cheese
Silky lox blended with creamy cheese. Choices: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$3.50
Lox Cream Cheese
Lox cream cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 1 lb sizes.
US$6.00
Nova Lox 1lb
Nova lox, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$52.00
Pickled Herring
Pickled herring, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$4.50
Plain Cream Cheese
Smooth plain cream cheese. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$4.50
Sable
Sable fish available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes, prepared and served with water label.
US$14.75
Scallion Egg Salad
Scallion egg salad available in three sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 1 lb.
US$6.50
Spicy Tuna Salad
Spicy tuna salad, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
US$5.50
Tuna Salad
Tuna salad available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
US$5.50
Veggie Tuna Salad
Tuna salad mixed with fresh vegetables. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb portions.
US$5.50
White Fish Salad
White fish salad - choose from 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
US$8.00
1 Lb. Rainbow Cream Cheese
Our 1 lb. rainbow cream cheese is a vibrant and creamy spread, blending traditional cream cheese with a mix of flavors and colors for a unique twist on a classic favorite.
US$14.00

All Day - Sandwiches and Platters 40 items

Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich
Nova Scotia salmon, choice of bagel including everything, plain, sesame, and more.
US$15.75
Nova Scotia Salmon Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$18.25
1 Lb. Nova Scotia Salmon
Nova Scotia salmon, typically prepared and served as a generous platter, often accompanied by bagels, cream cheese, and a selection of garnishes such as capers, onions, and tomatoes.
US$52.00
Smoked Kippered Salmon Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$18.25
1 Lb. Smoked Kippered Salmon
Smoked kippered salmon, typically accompanied by a selection of cream cheeses, capers, and onions, served with bagels.
US$52.00
Gravlax Salmon Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$18.25
1 Lb. Gravlax Salmon
Cured gravlax salmon, typically served with cream cheese, capers, and lemon on a bagel or toast.
US$52.00
Pastrami Style Smoked Salmon Sandwich
Pastrami-style smoked salmon on choice of bagel, including everything, plain, sesame, whole wheat, and more. Option for open-faced.
US$13.25
Pastrami Style Smoked Salmon Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$18.25
1 Lb. Pastrami Style Smoked Salmon
Pastrami-style smoked salmon, typically includes a generous serving of salmon seasoned with a blend of spices reminiscent of traditional pastrami, often served as a hearty platter.
US$52.00
Sable Sandwich
Sable fish, choice of bagel including flavored, whole wheat, and mini options, option for open faced.
US$12.75
Sable Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$18.25
1 Lb. Sable
1 lb. sable typically includes smoked sablefish, often accompanied by cream cheese, onions, and capers, served on a bagel or bread.
US$55.00
White Fish Salad Sandwich
White fish salad nestled between your choice of mini or full-sized bagel, varying from everything to blueberry. Option to enjoy open-faced.
US$11.75
White Fish Salad Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$14.50
1 Lb. White Fish Salad
Our 1 lb. white fish salad is a creamy blend of smoked whitefish, mayonnaise, and delicate seasonings, typically served as a hearty spread or topping.
US$36.00
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Tuna salad on choice of mini or regular bagels, including everything, plain, sesame, bialy, cinnamon raisin to blueberry, or flat options. Open-faced available.
US$9.75
Tuna Salad Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$13.25
1 Lb. Tuna Salad
Creamy tuna salad with fresh lettuce and tomato, served on a sesame seed bagel.
US$20.00
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich
Tuna mix, choice of mini or regular bagel among 21 varieties, option for open-faced style.
US$8.75
Tuna A La Chef Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$13.25
1 Lb. Tuna A La Chef
Succulent tuna prepared a la chef, typically includes a blend of seasonings and herbs, served as a hearty 1 lb. portion.
US$20.00
Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich
Veggie tuna salad on choice of mini or full-size bagels, including everything, sesame, plain, and more. Option for open-faced style.
US$8.75
Veggie Tuna Salad Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$13.25
1 Lb. Veggie Tuna Salad
A blend of tuna and assorted vegetables, mixed with mayonnaise and seasonings, served as a hearty salad.
US$18.00
Herring Sandwich
Herring sandwich on your choice of mini or regular bagel, including everything, sesame, plain, bialy, cinnamon raisin, garlic, and more. Option for open-faced style.
US$9.75
Herring Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$13.25
1 Lb. Herring
1 lb. herring is typically served as a generous portion of cured or pickled herring, often accompanied by garnishes like onions or a side of cream sauce.
US$18.00
Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg salad on choice of mini or full-sized bagel, including everything, garlic, or blueberry. Option for open-faced. Multiple grains and styles available.
US$9.25
Egg Salad Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$12.25
1 Lb. Egg Salad
Egg salad typically includes chopped hard-boiled eggs mixed with mayonnaise, seasoned to taste.
US$19.00
Hummus Sandwich
Creamy hummus spread on choice of mini or full-size bagel, including options from everything to blueberry. Open-faced option available.
US$6.25
Hummus Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$11.75
1 Lb. Hummus
Creamy chickpea spread traditionally made with tahini, lemon juice, and garlic, served as a generous portion suitable for dipping.
US$15.00
Baba Ganoush Sandwich
Baba ghanoush spread on choice of mini or regular bagels, including everything, sesame, and more. Opt for open-faced style.
US$5.25
Baba Ganoush Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$11.75
1 Lb. Baba Ganoush
Roasted eggplant pureed with tahini, garlic, lemon juice, and olive oil, typically includes a garnish of parsley.
US$15.00
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich
Spanish eggplant, choice of mini or regular-sized bagels including everything, plain, sesame, and others. Optional open-faced style.
US$6.25
Spanish Eggplant Platter
Served with Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
US$11.75
1 Lb. Spanish Eggplant
Sliced Spanish eggplant, typically includes a blend of traditional spices, served on bread with a savory sauce.
US$15.00

All Day - Fresh Wraps 11 items

Falafel Wrap
Crunchy falafel in a soft wrap with fresh veggies and tahini sauce.
US$8.00
Grilled Vegetable Wrap
Seasonal grilled vegetables wrapped in a soft tortilla, often accompanied by a blend of cheeses and a light drizzle of balsamic glaze.
US$8.50
Tuna Wrap
Served with lettuce and tomatoes.
US$10.75
Fresh Mozzarella Wrap
Served with lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
US$8.50
Egg Salad Wrap
Served with lettuce and tomatoes.
US$9.25
Avocado Wrap
Served with lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
US$9.75
Greek Salad Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese, and olives, dressed with Greek vinaigrette and wrapped in a soft tortilla.
US$8.50
Caesar Salad Wrap
Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and croutons, lightly tossed in caesar dressing, wrapped in a soft tortilla.
US$7.95
Grilled Salmon Wrap
Grilled salmon wrapped with crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, and a hint of dill, encased in a soft tortilla.
US$14.75
Quesadilla Wrap
American and mozzarella cheese with vegetable melted together.
US$9.50
Breakfast Wrap
Home fries, eggs, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
US$7.50

All Day - Panini 6 items

Eggplant Parmesan Panini
Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, parmesan and fresh mozzarella.
US$9.50
Triple Cheese Deluxe Panini
Mozzarella, feta and american cheese with tomatoes and sauteed red onions.
US$9.50
Greek Supreme Panini
Feta, tomatoes, mixed olives and roasted peppers.
US$9.50
French Connection Panini
Grilled vegetables, zucchini, onions, mushrooms, peppers and tomatoes with melted cheese.
US$9.50
Napolitano Panini
Mozzarella, pesto, romaine fresh tomatoes and balsamic vinegar.
US$9.50
Tuna Melt Open Faced Panini
Tuna, mozzarella, lettuce and tomatoes.
US$13.75

All Day - Pizza 18 items

Slice Of Pizza
Variety of slices available including marinara, Hawaiian, margarita, and more with options like tonno, wild mushrooms, or whole wheat.
US$3.25
20" Marinara Pizza
Mozzarella and tomato sauce.
US$22.00
20" Caponata Pizza
Roasted eggplant, garlic and fresh herbs.
US$29.00
20" Caesar Salad Pizza
Romaine lettuce, croutons and caesar dressing.
US$29.00
20" Hawaiian Pizza
Grilled fresh pineapple.
US$29.00
20" Margarita Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato and fresh basil.
US$29.00
20" Onion And Peppers Pizza
Caramelized red onions and roasted peppers.
US$29.00
20" Olimato Pizza
Kalamata olives, plum tomato and fresh basil.
US$29.00
20" Pesto And Tomato Pizza
Ricotta pesto and plum tomato.
US$29.00
20" Pomodoro Pizza
Penne pasta, tomato sauce and mixed fresh herbs.
US$29.00
20" Savory Tomato Pizza
Caramelized onions, plum tomato and mixed fresh herbs.
US$29.00
20" Spinach And Ricotta Pizza
Fresh spinach, ricotta cheese and plum tomato.
US$29.00
20" Tonno Pizza
Tuna, peppers, scallions, fresh basil and cilantro.
US$29.00
20" Wild Mushrooms Pizza
Portobello, shiitake and cremini mushrooms.
US$29.00
20" White Pizza
Mozzarella and ricotta cheese
US$29.00
20" Whole Wheat Pizza
Mozzarella and tomato sauce.
US$28.00
10" Personal Pie Pizza
A 10" personal pie pizza typically starts with a classic tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese base, allowing for customization with a variety of toppings.
US$12.00
10" Gluten Free Pizza
A 10" pizza featuring a gluten-free crust, typically includes a blend of cheeses and a rich tomato sauce.
US$12.00

All Day - Calzones 3 items

Pizza Bagel
Marinara sauce, shaved parmesan, provolone, and Italian seasonings on a toasted bagel.
US$8.00
Cheese Calzone
Golden-brown calzone stuffed with melted cheese, accompanied by a side of steamed broccoli and sliced red onions.
US$7.25
Cheese Calzone With Topping
Stuffed with mozzarella and ricotta, choose from veggies like broccoli, eggplant, or mushrooms; herbs; or pineapple. Options for every palate, including caramelized onions and fresh basil.
US$8.50

All Day - Israeli Menu 9 items

Falafel In Pita
Falafel in pita typically includes deep-fried chickpea balls, served in a pita with tahini, Israeli salad, and hummus.
US$7.50
Falafel Plate
Served with hummus, tahini, Israeli salad, pickles and pita.
US$11.50
Tuna In Pita
Albacore tuna combined with lettuce and tomato, nestled in a pita.
US$10.00
Egg Salad In Pita
Egg salad gently nestled in a pita, typically includes a blend of chopped eggs, mayonnaise, and a hint of mustard.
US$6.50
Hummus Plate
Hummus, tahini & pita.
US$7.00
Shakshuka
2 eggs sunny side up in special tomato sauce with bread and Israeli salad.
US$13.95
Israeli Panini
Mozzarella, plain cream cheese and 3 veggie toppings.
US$7.95
Malawach
Israeli filo dough filled with hard boiled egg, tomato sauce and veggies.
US$8.00
Sabih
Fried eggplant, boiled egg, hummus Israeli salad, pickles, tahini and parsley.
US$9.95

All Day - Chef's Daily Special 18 items

Soup Of The Day
Rotating selection paired with choice of bagel: traditional to unique, including bialy, multigrain, whole wheat, and rainbow options.
US$7.00
Eggplant Parmesan
Elegant and savory dish made with breaded eggplant, tomato sauce, and melted cheese.
US$10.75
Plain Lasagna
Layers of pasta intertwined with a simple yet classic blend of cheeses and a savory tomato sauce.
US$10.75
Vegetable Lasagna
Layers of lasagna noodles with a variety of garden vegetables, typically includes a blend of cheeses and a rich tomato sauce.
US$10.75
Plain Baked Ziti
Oven-baked pasta with a blend of ricotta cheese and a special marinara sauce, typically featuring ziti noodles.
US$10.75
Baked Ziti With Vegetables
Baked ziti pasta combined with a medley of vegetables, typically includes ricotta and special marinara sauce, finished in the oven.
US$10.75
Pasta Salad
Zesty medley of pasta and fresh vegetables make this satisfying pasta salad.
US$9.75
Hot Pasta Dish
Pasta tossed with a selection of meats or vegetables, typically served with a unique sauce crafted daily by the chef.
US$9.75
Fish And Chips
Crispy beer-battered fish with golden fries
US$12.50
Fish Of The Day
Seasoned and fried fish fillets topped with sautéed mushrooms, bell peppers, carrots, black olives, and green olives.
US$15.00
Fish Of The Day Platter
Served with 2 side dishes.
US$19.50
Filet Of Fish
Crispy fried fish filet
US$8.75
Filet Of Fish Platter
Served with 2 side dishes.
US$13.50
Veggie Burger
Veggie burger typically includes a house-made patty with a blend of vegetables and grains, served with lettuce, tomato, and a savory sauce on a bun.
US$8.75
Veggie Burger Platter
Served with 2 side dishes.
US$11.50
Home Fries
Crispy home fries, available in small or large sizes.
US$4.75
Rice
Steamed rice available in small or large servings.
US$4.75
Coleslaw
Crisp cabbage and carrot salad, available in small or large sizes.
US$5.75

All Day - Side Dishes and Appetizers 13 items

French Fries
Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
US$5.75
Spicy Fries
Spicy.
US$6.00
Cheese Fries
Golden fries topped with melted cheese, perfect for snacking or sharing.
US$7.00
Sweet Potato Fries
Crispy and flavorful fries made from sweet potatoes, a delightful twist on a classic favorite.
US$6.00
6 Potato Cigars
Potato cigars wrapped in fillo dough, typically filled with a seasoned potato mixture, then fried until golden brown.
US$6.75
6 Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded mozzarella cheese sticks, deep-fried and typically served with marinara sauce.
US$6.50
10 Onion Rings
Ten slices of onion coated in batter and deep-fried.
US$6.00
4 Garlic Knots
Knotted pizza dough brushed with garlic butter, typically includes a sprinkling of herbs and parmesan cheese.
US$2.00
Cheese Garlic Knots
10 knots with cheese and sauce.
US$8.00
Nachos With Melted Cheese
Crispy tortilla chips topped with a generous layer of melted cheese.
US$6.00
9" Quiche
Broccoli, spinach, mushroom and cheese.
US$20.00
Mini Borekas
Cheese, spinach cheese, potato or mushroom potato.
US$2.00
Large Turkish Style Borekas
Cheese, spinach cheese and potato.
US$5.25

All Day - Baked Goods and Desserts 25 items

Raisin Challah
Raisin challah is a braided bread that typically includes eggs, honey, and raisins, offering a slightly sweet flavor.
US$7.50
Plain Challah
Traditional Jewish bread, plain challah is a braided loaf known for its soft, pillowy texture and slightly sweet taste.
US$7.00
Whole Wheat Challah
Whole wheat challah is a braided bread made with whole wheat flour, often incorporating honey and eggs, resulting in a slightly sweet and hearty loaf.
US$7.00
Challah Roll
A challah roll is a small, soft bread made with eggs, often featuring a slightly sweet flavor and a tender, golden crust.
US$2.25
Cheesecake
Plain, strawberry, caramel, chocolate, marble.
US$6.00
Pecan Pie
Classic Southern dessert made with a rich filling of pecans in a flaky pastry crust.
US$6.00
Chocolate Zebra Cake
Alternating layers of vanilla and chocolate cake, creating a visually striking zebra pattern, typically frosted with a smooth chocolate icing.
US$6.00
Tiramisu Cake
Classic Italian dessert with layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cheese, dusted with cocoa.
US$6.00
Knishes
Knish - traditional pastry filled with choice of kasha, potato, or spinach.
US$6.00
Sweet Knishes
Cheese, cherry or blueberry.
US$7.00
Butter Croissant
Flaky Butter Croissant, Light and Airy with a Rich Butter Flavor
US$4.50
Cheese Croissant
Freshly baked croissant filled with a rich and creamy cheese, offering a delightful balance between the buttery pastry and the savory cheese filling.
US$4.75
Chocolate Croissant
Buttery croissant filled with rich, melted chocolate.
US$4.50
Strawberry Croissant
Butter croissant filled with soft bavarian cream and fresh strawberries.
US$4.00
Apple Turnovers
Flaky puff pastry filled with a sweet blend of apples and spices, creating a classic and comforting treat.
US$4.25
Cheese Danish
Delicate, Flaky Pastry Filled with Rich, Creamy Cheese
US$4.75
Black And White Cookie
A classic treat featuring a decadent mix of dark and white chocolate - the perfect cookie indulgence!"
US$4.50
1 Lb. Variety Of Cookies
A one-pound assortment of cookies, typically including a variety of flavors such as chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and peanut butter, among others.
US$16.00
Muffin
Chocolate chip, corn, blueberry, raisin bran, banana walnut, cranberry, apple cinnamon and double chocolate.
US$4.75
Cinnamon Twist Danish
A cinnamon twist danish is a buttery, flaky pastry intertwined with layers of sweet cinnamon, often finished with a light glaze or sugar dusting.
US$4.25
Apple Strudel
Cinnamon and sugar spiced apples, typically includes raisins, wrapped in a flaky pastry dough. Often served with vanilla ice cream.
US$4.25
Rugalah
Crescent-shaped pastries filled with ingredients such as nuts, fruit preserves, and cinnamon.
US$6.95
Vanilla Yogurt, Fruit And Granola Cup
Vanilla yogurt layered with a mix of fresh fruits and crunchy granola, offering a balanced blend of sweetness and texture.
US$5.50
Donuts
Green donuts with a unique color and classic ring shape, offering a visually striking twist on a traditional treat.
US$4.25
Spinach Knish
A savory pastry filled with a seasoned mixture of spinach, typically encased in a soft yet crisp dough.
US$6.00

All Day - Hal's Sea Salt Chips 1 items

Hal's Sea Salt Chips
Orininal,barbeque,sweet onion,salt sea anf cracked pepper ,jalapeno,sweet chili.
US$2.00

All Day - Vegan 1 items

Sausage
Vegan.
US$9.00

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

Service options

Delivery
In-store pick-up
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings

Coffee

Dining options

Breakfast

Planning

Quick visit

Payments

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

PHOTOS

See the bakery

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

pizza 45kosher 35new york bagels 12quick service 9croissants 8delivery 7attention 6whitefish salad 5baked goods 5scallion cream cheese 5

★ 5.0

I absolutely love this bagel shop! The bagels are always fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy — exactly how real bagels should be. They have a great variety of flavors and toppings, and their cream cheese spreads are delicious (the veggie one is my favorite!).The staff is friendly and quick, even during busy mornings, and the place has a cozy, welcoming vibe. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go or sitting down for a quick bite, it’s always a treat. Highly recommend to any bagel lover! 🥯✨ Also the place SO CLEAN IT FEELS LIKE HOME

Jun 30 · Adel Djouraev

★ 5.0

I spent a few days in NYC and wanted to eat as many bagels as I could. Bagels & Co did not disappoint. I had the rainbow bagel and loved it! Cream cheese was good, as was the iced latte.

May 17 · Misty K

★ 5.0

Great breakfast sandwiches. Bagel was outstanding and the Kaiser roll was perfect. Looking forward to returning for breakfast again.

Apr 3 · Albert Gerrity

★ 5.0

First time visiting here. Picked up half a dozen late in the morning. Still fresh. Just enough crisp on the outside and nothing but warm soft goodness within. Staff amazingly friendly despite it being busy. The wife claimed she's "not into bagels"and still took down 2 of the 6. I'd call that a win. I'd be here regularly if I lived in the UWS. Worth a stop if visiting town to hit up the museums. Double park and jump in for some round love to bring back to the car!

Feb 6 · AT M

★ 5.0

This is my favorite bagel place in nyc. It holds so many special memories I can’t even begin with.. the coffe and the toasted bagel feel like home♥️

Jun 22 · Chiara Schenardi

NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

★ 3.0 · 441 reviews · 0.1 mi

Bagel Talk

368 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 324 reviews · 0.1 mi

Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods

212 W 80th St, New York, NY 10024, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 305 reviews · 0.1 mi

Barachou Upper West Side

449 Amsterdam Avenue Between 81st &, W 82 St, New York, NY 10024, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 370 reviews · 0.2 mi

PopUp Bagels

338 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 6,792 reviews · 0.2 mi

Levain Bakery

167 W 74th St, New York, NY 10023, USA

Details

★ 3.0 · 1,107 reviews · 0.3 mi

Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish

273 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 147 reviews · 0.5 mi

u00c9pices Bakery

104 W 70th St, New York, NY 10023, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 322 reviews · 0.6 mi

By the Way Bakery

2440 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, USA

Details

★ 3.0 · 220 reviews · 0.9 mi

Pick a Bagel

37 W End Ave, New York, NY 10023, USA

Details

★ 3.0 · 278 reviews · 1 mi

William Greenberg Desserts

1100 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 8 reviews · 1.1 mi

Bear Mountain Bakery and Cafe

1000 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA

Details

★ 3.0 · 444 reviews · 1.1 mi

Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South

1794 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, USA

Details

About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.