Big Apple Bagels

Introduction / Overview

For over twenty years, Big Apple Bagels in Ashwaubenon, WI, has been a beloved fixture for residents of the greater Green Bay area seeking the freshest bagels, hearty sandwiches, and quality coffee. Located conveniently on South Oneida Street, this local establishment is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a versatile spot operating as a full-service bakery, restaurant, and sandwich shop. Their core promise revolves around bagels made from scratch in-store, ensuring a quality and freshness that keeps Wisconsin customers coming back for their morning fuel or midday meal.

The menu is vast, offering far more than basic toasted bagels. Customers can choose from an impressive variety of approximately 25 bagel flavors and 13 cream cheese options daily, ranging from savory choices like Cheddar Bacon, Garlic, and Everything to sweet favorites like French Toast, Blueberry, and Cinnamon Sugar. This wide selection ensures that even if a few popular flavors run out later in the day, a delicious alternative is always available.

Beyond the bagels, Big Apple Bagels is famous for its comprehensive food and drink menu. They serve a full breakfast menu featuring options like the Lox & Cream Cheese and various omelet sandwiches, alongside a robust lunch offering of gourmet and specialty sandwiches. To complete the experience, they proudly brew Brewster's Coffee, with a full array of espresso drinks and Icespresso blends, making it a true destination for a satisfying and quick visit in Ashwaubenon.

Location and Accessibility

Big Apple Bagels is strategically located to serve the Ashwaubenon and Green Bay communities, making access simple and convenient for customers on the go. Its address is a known hub in the area, offering straightforward navigation for both locals and visitors.

Address: 2321 S Oneida St, Ashwaubenon, WI 54304, USA

The shop is designed with customer convenience in mind, providing multiple options for ease of access and dining:

• Parking Convenience: Customers benefit from both a Free parking lot and Free street parking readily available, which is ideal when picking up large orders or stopping in for a quick bite.
• Full Accessibility: The facility is fully accommodating, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a Wheelchair accessible restroom, ensuring comfort for all patrons.
• Dining Options: While popular for Takeout and In-store pickup, the shop also offers a Dine-in option in its small, comfortable space for those who prefer to enjoy their meal and specialty coffee immediately.
• Quick Visit Planning: The service model is geared toward a Quick visit, ensuring efficient service, particularly during busy morning rush hours.
• Restroom Availability: A clean Restroom is available on the premises as an essential amenity for dining-in customers.

Services Offered

As a versatile food establishment, Big Apple Bagels provides an extensive range of services and menu items that cater to both individual cravings and group needs across Wisconsin.

• Made-From-Scratch Bagels: Offering approximately 25 fresh bagel flavors daily, including popular selections like Everything, Garlic, French Toast, Cheddar Bacon, and Plain, available individually ($2.99), by the half dozen ($14.93), or by the dozen ($22.19).
• Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: Providing around 13 specialty cream cheese flavors, available with a bagel ($6.59) or in an 8oz container for home use ($8.49).
• Comprehensive Breakfast Menu (Dining option: Breakfast): Serving a variety of hot breakfast sandwiches all day, such as:
  • Morning Classic ($6.83) and Southern Tradition ($7.79) options.
  • Specialty items like Lox & Cream Cheese ($13.79) and Just Veggies! Omelet ($6.83).
• Full Deli and Specialty Lunch Sandwiches: Offering a range of fresh, savory options served on your choice of bagel (or bread/wrap) along with a pickle spear:
  • Gourmet Sandwiches (e.g., Classic Turkey, Tuna Salad, B.L.T) all priced at $10.55.
  • Specialty Sandwiches (e.g., Big Apple Club, Turkey & Havarti, Holey Guacamole) all priced at $11.39.
• Gourmet Coffee and Specialty Drinks (Offering: Coffee): Featuring Brewster's Coffee with options ranging from simple Brewed Coffee ($3.35) and Cold Brew ($4.19) to premium beverages like:
  • Specialty Lattes and Mochas (e.g., Turtle Mocha, Vanilla Creme Latte, Cinnamon Toast Latte) at $7.43.
  • Blended Icespresso options (e.g., Caramel Decadence, Java Chip) also at $7.43.
• Group Deals and Catering Platters: Providing convenient and cost-effective solutions for groups:
  • Bagel Deals (Mini Deal, Dozen Deal, Mega Deal).
  • Platters like the Small Bit -O-Bagel ($35.99) and Large Bit- O- Bagel ($58.99) with bite-size pieces and cream cheese.
  • Coffee Box catering for up to eight people ($26.40).

Features / Highlights

The competitive advantage of Big Apple Bagels for the Wisconsin market lies in its commitment to fresh, in-house production and its extensive, quality menu that goes far beyond a typical breakfast shop.

• Fresh, Scratch-Made Bagels: The number one highlight is the commitment to baking bagels from scratch in store every day, providing a superior texture and taste compared to pre-made alternatives. This dedication to craft is highly valued by local customers.
• Brewster's Coffee Program: The exclusive offering of Brewster's Coffee alongside a full espresso bar (including the highly popular Icespresso blended coffees) makes the shop a dual destination for both premium baked goods and quality caffeinated beverages.
• All-Day Sandwich Menu: The extensive selection of both breakfast and lunch sandwiches—from the classic Breakfast B.L.T to the customer-praised Holey Guacamole pizza bagel sandwich—ensures it’s a reliable spot for a complete, satisfying meal any time of day.
• Variety and Customization: With over 20 bagel flavors and a dozen cream cheese options, the shop provides an unmatched level of choice, allowing patrons to perfectly customize their meal, whether they seek sweet, savory, or highly-specific flavor profiles (e.g., Garlic, Cheddar Bacon, or Cinnamon Toast).
• Convenient Group Catering: The selection of bagel and cream cheese deals and the organized catering platters (like the Bit-O-Bagel trays) makes it the ideal, easy solution for office meetings, tailgates, or family gatherings in the Green Bay area.

Contact Information

For fresh bagels, specialty sandwiches, or to place a catering order for your next Wisconsin event, please use the following contact details:

Address: 2321 S Oneida St, Ashwaubenon, WI 54304, USA

Phone: (920) 497-6039

What is Worth Choosing

For residents of Ashwaubenon and the wider Green Bay region, Big Apple Bagels is simply the best local choice when quality, variety, and convenience are priorities. You should choose this establishment not only for their fresh, made-from-scratch bagels—a genuine rarity in many fast-casual settings—but also for the extensive menu that covers breakfast, lunch, coffee, and catering. It’s the perfect place for the Wisconsin lifestyle, offering the speed of a Quick visit combined with the option to Dine-in comfortably.

Whether you’re grabbing a Dozen Deal for the office, indulging in a rich Turtle Mocha, or trying a flavorful gourmet sandwich like the Big Apple Club or the customer favorite Holey Guacamole on a fresh bagel, you can count on a consistently high-quality experience. Although a small fee may be applied to card transactions, the value, variety, and superior taste of their offerings—backed by decades of service to the Green Bay community—make Big Apple Bagels a worthwhile and reliable staple for every meal.