Bloomington Bagel Company

Introduction / Overview

For Indiana locals, finding an authentic, scratch-made bagel can often feel like a treasure hunt. Thankfully, the search ends in Bloomington with the Bloomington Bagel Company (BBC). More than just a simple Bagel shop, BBC operates as a cherished local Bakery where the entire process—from mixing the dough to the final bake—is carried out by hand. This dedication to traditional methods ensures a superior texture and flavor that Indiana residents have come to love and rely on.

Bloomington Bagel Company is the community’s go-to destination for high-quality breakfast and lunch, specializing in their robust and inventive bagel sandwiches, affectionately known as 'bagelwiches.' The atmosphere is often described as invitingly simple and industrial, a perfect backdrop for the lively rush of patrons—from college students to local professionals—who frequent the spot during peak morning hours. As one reviewer noted, the service is "faithful and true," delivering direct and familiar breakfast offerings quickly, despite being frequently slammed.

The menu goes far beyond the basic bagel and cream cheese, featuring a creative range of signatures like the Lotsa Lox, the indulgent Hangover, and the over-the-top Super Nova. With a variety of handcrafted schmears, freshly made fillings, and a full espresso bar serving Coffee and Iced Latte, Bloomington Bagel Company provides a complete dining experience. It caters to the essential morning rush and provides a hearty, fulfilling start to the day for Hoosiers across the region.

Location and Accessibility

Bloomington Bagel Company is strategically located in the heart of downtown Bloomington, Indiana, making it a highly accessible spot for university students, downtown workers, and residents alike. The address is:

238 N Morton St, Bloomington, IN 47404, USA

This location on North Morton Street is particularly convenient as it is situated near City Hall, the B-Line Trail, and the Bloomington Community Farmers' Market. However, customers should plan for parking, as one review mentioned the "annoyingly expensive parking" in the area. The great news for drivers is that paid parking is readily available just steps away at the Morton Street Parking Garage (220 N. Morton St.), which offers affordable hourly rates (e.g., $0.50 per hour) and is free on Sundays.

The facility is committed to full accessibility, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible parking lot. Whether you choose to Dine-in and enjoy the vibrant, simple industrial atmosphere, grab Takeout for a meal on the go, or use the Delivery and In-store pickup options, the shop is designed for a convenient Quick visit.

Services Offered

Bloomington Bagel Company offers a broad spectrum of services centered around their core product—the hand-made bagel:

• Authentic Bagel Production: Bagels are made, boiled, and baked by hand daily on-site, a key differentiating factor that provides the authentic, chewy texture and flavor of a true artisan bagel.
• Gourmet Bagelwiches: A signature menu of loaded sandwiches, including the Hangover (Egg, cheese, all the meats—bacon, sausage, ham—and schmear, $12.81) and the iconic Lotsa Lox ($14.39) featuring Nova lox, capers, tomato, and onion.
• Breakfast and Brunch: A full Breakfast offering with essentials like Egg & Cheese ($6.93), the hash brown-stuffed Wake & Bake ($10.50), and simple Avocado Toast ($4.41) on a bagel.
• Customizable Schmears: An extensive range of house-made cream cheese spreads (schmears), available to complement any bagel choice for only $1.05 for a 2 oz serving, or as part of a classic Bagel & Schmear ($3.41).
• Deli and Vegetarian Options: A substantial menu of lunch-focused items like the Deli Bagelwich ($10.50), Reuben ($10.49), and satisfying vegetarian choices such as the Hummus-A-Tune ($9.19) and Veggie Burger ($10.49).
• Coffee and Beverages: A complete beverage selection, including locally roasted Coffee, Iced Mocha, Iced Latte, Smoothies, and various bottled drinks (Water, OJ, Chocolate Milk for $3.94 each).

Features / Highlights

Bloomington Bagel Company has earned its reputation among Indiana locals by focusing on quality and unique offerings:

• Authentic Hand-Crafted Bagels: The commitment to making bagels from scratch daily is the key highlight, ensuring freshness and the perfect chewy-on-the-inside, crusty-on-the-outside texture that defines a great bagel.
• The "Godzilla" Bagel: A must-try specialty for adventurous eaters, this bagelwich combines sushi-inspired flavors, featuring smoked salmon, avocado, a unique miso schmear, nori, and wasabi aioli. The name is often associated with the generously sized and loaded portions that customers adore.
• Exceptional Cream Cheese Selection: The variety of house-made schmears, which often include unique flavors like Jalapeño Sriracha, Smoked Nova Lox, and Honey Toasted Almond, allows for countless customized flavor combinations.
• Dedicated Breakfast Service: The shop is a dedicated Breakfast restaurant, with many of the menu’s favorites, like the Wake & Bake and the Hot Mess ($9.19), being hot, cooked-to-order options perfect for fueling the start of a busy Indiana day.
• Diverse Menu for All Tastes: Whether you are looking for a simple Naked Bagel ($2.52), a healthy Fruit Cup ($4.20), or a hearty meat-filled sandwich, the menu’s breadth ensures an option for every dietary need and craving.

Contact Information

For Indiana residents in the Bloomington area looking to contact the Bagel shop for orders, inquiries, or business details, use the information below:

Phone: (812) 349-4653

Mobile Phone: +1 812-349-4653

Address: 238 N Morton St, Bloomington, IN 47404, USA

The Bloomington Bagel Company accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a smooth checkout experience whether you are ordering in-store or online.

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Bloomington Bagel Company, the primary choice worth making is anything that showcases their truly unique and hearty approach to the classic bagel sandwich. Specifically, the Hangover bagelwich ($12.81) is a definitive choice for anyone seeking a maximum-impact breakfast—it perfectly bundles all the breakfast meats, egg, cheese, and a schmear into a single, satisfying meal on your favorite bagel.

For a lighter, yet equally flavorful choice, the Lotsa Lox ($14.39) on an Everything or Sesame bagel with their signature lox or Salmon schmear is highly recommended, delivering a fresh, classic deli flavor. Furthermore, customers are encouraged to experiment with the unique, handcrafted schmears—especially those with a spicy kick, such as the Jalapeño Sriracha spread, or any option featuring a mix of cheese and jalapeños, as per local recommendations. Finally, add an air-fried Hash Brown ($2.10) to any sandwich to transform it into the celebrated Wake & Bake style, adding a desirable crunch that many Indiana diners value for a truly "scrumptious" breakfast experience.