Be aware, this lady is a scam. I ordered 405.00 worth of cookies. She lied about sending them twice (only one shipping receipt to show for). Cookies came melted and broken. Looked like a toddler made them. She uses profanity when speaking to clients. If you still want to risk it, I will suggest ordering a sample first... I'm sure you'll change your mind after seeing the horrific work she does. Even after sending her a video of the condition of the cookies she blames the post office for her ugly work. She's a joke.
Jun 6 · Priscilla GarciaCafe Create a Cake LLC
179 Rocky Pond Rd, Plymouth, MA 02360, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
Essential details
- Address
- 179 Rocky Pond Rd, Plymouth, MA 02360, USA
- Phone
- (508) 524-3502
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 10 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- Tuesday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Wednesday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Thursday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Friday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Sunday11:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
When it comes to celebrating special occasions, a custom-made cake or dessert is often the centerpiece of the event. In Plymouth, Massachusetts, local residents seeking these personalized creations may come across Cafe Create a Cake LLC. This business, run by an individual named Lisa, specializes in custom cakes and baked goods for a variety of events, from children's birthdays to other celebrations. As a local operation, it aims to provide a personal touch and creative flair to its customers' dessert needs.
However, public feedback on the business presents a mixed picture. Some customers, like Maureen McLallen, have had very positive experiences. She praised Lisa's work, stating that she "created two beautiful cakes for my grandkids' birthdays" that "far exceeded my expectations." This type of feedback highlights the potential for the bakery to produce high-quality, beautiful cakes that can be the highlight of a family celebration. On the other hand, another customer reported a highly negative experience, citing issues with the condition of cookies upon arrival, communication, and overall quality. This review serves as a cautionary tale about the risks that can sometimes come with ordering custom products from a small business, especially when relying on shipping.
This dichotomy in customer reviews is not uncommon for small, local, and custom-order businesses. It indicates that the experience can vary widely. For locals in Massachusetts considering Cafe Create a Cake LLC, it is important to weigh both the positive and negative feedback and to take precautions, as one reviewer suggested, such as ordering a sample first. This due diligence can help ensure that the final product meets expectations and avoids potential disappointment.
Cafe Create a Cake LLC is located at 179 Rocky Pond Rd in Plymouth, MA 02360. This address suggests that the business operates out of a home-based studio or a small-scale, non-retail location. This business model is common for custom-order bakeries that do not rely on walk-in traffic. For local customers, this means that interactions are likely centered around pre-arranged appointments for consultations and pickups.
The accessibility of the business, therefore, is more about communication and scheduling than about physical storefront hours. Customers would typically place an order by phone, discuss their vision for the cake or cookies, and then coordinate a pickup time at the Plymouth location. This setup allows the baker to focus entirely on the custom orders without the distractions of a retail environment. It is important for locals to understand this model and plan accordingly, as a spontaneous visit would likely not be possible.
Based on the provided information, Cafe Create a Cake LLC's services are focused on custom baked goods for special events.
- Custom Cakes: The core service is creating personalized cakes for occasions such as birthdays and other celebrations. The cakes are custom-designed to the client's specifications.
- Custom Cookies: The bakery also offers custom-designed cookies, which can be tailored for various events and themes.
- Special Event Desserts: The business specializes in creating desserts that are the centerpiece of parties, ensuring they are unique and visually appealing.
- Personalized Service: The process involves direct communication with the baker to discuss design ideas, flavors, and other specifications for the custom order.
- Pickup Service: As a home-based operation, the primary method of delivery for local clients is pickup at the designated address.
The features and highlights of Cafe Create a Cake LLC are centered around its capacity for creative, custom work, as well as the experiences of its clientele.
- Customization: The main highlight is the ability to create unique, personalized cakes and cookies that are specific to a customer's event theme and vision.
- Positive Customer Experiences: In some cases, as with Maureen McLallen, the work has been praised for its beauty and for exceeding expectations. This highlights the potential for the baker to produce truly wonderful creations.
- Home-Based Operation: This model can allow for a high degree of focus on each individual order, which is often a feature of a true artisan business.
- Artistic Potential: The positive review for the beautiful cakes suggests that the business owner has significant artistic talent when the final product meets expectations.
- Direct Communication: The custom-order nature of the business means customers work directly with the baker, which can be a rewarding and collaborative experience.
Address: 179 Rocky Pond Rd, Plymouth, MA 02360, USA
Phone: (508) 524-3502
For local Massachusetts residents, Cafe Create a Cake LLC is a business that offers a unique service for custom-made desserts. It is particularly suitable for those who are seeking a highly personalized and creative cake for a special occasion and are comfortable with a custom-order, home-based business model. For anyone considering an order, it is wise to heed the advice of a past customer and take proactive steps, such as ordering a small sample, to ensure the quality and style align with your expectations. When the experience is positive, as it was for Maureen, the result is a beautiful, custom cake that far exceeds what a commercial bakery can offer. By engaging with this local business, customers have the opportunity to get a truly one-of-a-kind dessert for their event.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
No visitor photos are available in this record.
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
I do not know why there are negative comments here!! Lisa was terrific and created two beautiful cakes for my grandkids' birthdays this weekend. Her work far exceeded my expectations (and honestly, I am very picky). I would recommend Lisa's work to anyone! Thanks, a proud Grandma of three who loves her cakes. Thanks Lisa!! Maureen McLallen
Jan 21 · Maureen McLallenThe owner of this so called business is a horrid person. My husband picked up a cake from her today for my sons birthday it was supposed to be an iron man cake she sent me pictures of cakes she “made” and I picked one well when my husband brought the cake home it looked nothing like the cake she sent me a picture of it looked like a child made it. After further review of her page I noticed she had pictures off of other bakery websites she even left the logo in the picture. She was very nasty to me when I expressed that I thought the cake was awful she told me she would pick it up and fix it and refund me. I waited for her outside and she never shows up although she claims she did but she has lied to me from the beginning. I ended up going to her place of business which apparently is out of her home she told me over and over that she would not refund me my money and she called me a C U next Tuesday. I hope what happened to me never happens to anyone else please don’t get scammed like I did this business is a fraud and I will be calling the better business bureau on her.
Feb 4 · Melissa NogueiraAlways easy to deal with and the numerous cakes we have had over the years have all been knocked out of the park. Strongly recommend. Lisa is great.
Nov 5 · Gabriel WhiteAlways easy to deal with and the numerous cakes we have had over the years have all been knocked out of the park. Strongly recommend. Lisa is great.
Nov 5 · Gabriel WhiteBest Cake and pastries I've ever had. My wedding cake was amazing tha.nk you to Lisa. And all her staff!!!
May 26 · Gregg S.Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.












