BAKERY PROFILE

Cookie Plug

★ 4.054 recorded reviews

1110 Del Prado Blvd S E, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address: 1110 Del Prado Blvd S E, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA
Phone: (239) 471-7165
Website: Visit official site
Rating signal: 4.0 from 54 recorded reviews

HOURS

Listed operating hours

Monday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Thursday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Friday12:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday12:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday1:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Open turn-by-turn directions →

About and visit notes

Welcome, Florida residents, to a dessert experience that truly breaks the mold. Cookie Plug, situated right in the heart of Cape Coral, is more than just a cookie shop—it's a full-fledged dessert destination, a vibrant restaurant, and a reliable wholesale bakery all rolled into one. For those in Southwest Florida searching for the ultimate sweet treat, a unique catering solution, or just a fun, happy vibe, Cookie Plug offers a distinctly memorable experience that stands out in the Florida culinary scene. This establishment is recognized not only for its quality baked goods but also for its completely unique atmosphere and diverse menu offerings, making it a local favorite for indulging that sweet tooth.

Operating as a multi-faceted business—a Cookie shop, Catering food and drink supplier, Dessert restaurant, Dessert shop, Restaurant, and Wholesale bakery—Cookie Plug serves a broad spectrum of needs, from a simple afternoon snack to corporate event catering. The focus is on bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and a commitment to delivering a product that consistently earns high praise from the local Florida community. As a local establishment based at 1110 Del Prado Blvd S E, Cape Coral, FL 33990, it’s strategically positioned to serve the greater Cape Coral and surrounding areas, including those who already loved their Fort Myers location.

***

Location and Accessibility

Cookie Plug is conveniently located at 1110 Del Prado Blvd S E, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA. This location on Del Prado Boulevard is a major thoroughfare in Cape Coral, ensuring excellent visibility and accessibility for local Florida patrons. The specific address places it within the 33990 zip code, a central area for shopping and dining, making it easy for residents from all parts of the city and beyond to reach.

Accessibility is a key feature of its location. Being on a prominent boulevard means easy navigation for drivers coming from Fort Myers, Punta Gorda, or other parts of the Southwest Florida region. While specific parking information is always subject to change, the nature of its commercial setting suggests ample parking is available for customers making a quick stop for takeout or those looking to stay and enjoy the "VIP lounge" seating. For Florida users, the proximity to other retail and dining establishments also makes it a perfect stop to cap off an evening out or a shopping trip. Its prime placement ensures that a truly unique dessert is never far away for the Cape Coral community.

***

Services Offered

Cookie Plug is highly versatile, offering a wide array of products and services that cater to individuals, families, and large events across the Florida region. Their services are well-defined by the unique categories of goods they produce and the ways they can be acquired:

Daily Fresh Cookie Sales ("Phatties"): Offering a robust selection of their signature, generously sized cookies, including classic flavors like Chocolate Chip Cookie and Cookies & Cream Cookie, alongside unique options such as Purple Velvet Cake Cookie and Snickerdoodle Cookie.
Specialty and Gourmet Stuffed Cookies: Providing an elevated dessert experience with options like the Dubai Chocolate Stuffed Cookie, Biggie Stuffed Cookie, and the unique Windmill Razz (Biscoff Cookie Butter Topped with Raspberry Cheesecake).
Health-Conscious Offerings: Catering to specialized dietary needs with a selection of Keto Cookies, including Keto Chocolate Chip Cookie, Keto Triple Chocolate Cookie, and Keto Snickerdoodle Cookie, providing guilt-free indulgence for the Florida market.
Cookie Packs and Samplers ("Kick Back Sacks"): Offering bundled options for sharing or stocking up, with sizes ranging from the Bump Sack (4 Cookies) to the Fat Sack (12 Cookies) and the large Crew Sack (8 Cookies + 12 Fun-sized Cookies).
Catering and Wholesale Supply: Serving as a Catering food and drink supplier and Wholesale bakery, providing large-volume orders and custom arrangements for events, businesses, and parties across Cape Coral and Southwest Florida.
In-House Dessert Dining and Takeout: Offering a Dessert restaurant experience with dedicated dining options and onsite services, along with convenient Takeout for customers on the go. They also offer a selection of "Dranks" to accompany the sweets.

***

Features / Highlights

Cookie Plug differentiates itself through several unique features that make it a favorite among Florida locals, blending high-quality products with a distinctive, fun atmosphere:

Unique Atmosphere and Decor: The store features a fun, unique, and happy vibe, with a specific "VIP lounge" area complete with seating and neon signs, creating a memorable and engaging environment for customers—a key factor highlighted in customer reviews.
Innovative Flavor Profile: The menu boasts a range of creative and appealing flavors that go far beyond the standard cookie shop, such as Fruity Pebbles Cookie, Azucar Blanca (Mexican Sugar Cookie), and the Secret Stash Cookies like Black Ops (Brownie Cookie), giving Florida dessert lovers something truly new to try.
Product Variety and Specialization: The ability to offer traditional cookies, gourmet stuffed cookies, and specialized Keto options ensures they can satisfy virtually any customer preference or dietary requirement. They also feature ice cream sandwiches, a delicious treat mentioned by patrons.
Focus on Large-Volume Orders: The dual role as a Catering food and drink supplier and Wholesale bakery makes them an excellent resource for parties, events, and businesses in the Cape Coral area needing reliable, high-quality sweet treats in bulk.
Local Approval and Standing: Customer feedback confirms the high quality, with patrons stating the cookies are "hands down better than Crumbl" and expressing excitement over the opening of the Cape Coral location, indicating strong local brand loyalty and preference.

***

Contact Information

For Florida residents interested in visiting, placing a catering order, or simply inquiring about the daily flavors, here is the essential contact information for the Cape Coral location:

Address:

1110 Del Prado Blvd S E, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA

Phone:

(239) 471-7165 or +1 239-471-7165 (Mobile Phone)

Customers are encouraged to contact the store directly, especially when planning a large order, requesting custom catering, or confirming the availability of specific menu items like the Secret Stash Cookie of the day.

***

What is Worth Choosing Cookie Plug

Choosing Cookie Plug for your dessert needs, whether you are a Cape Coral resident or just passing through Southwest Florida, is choosing an experience defined by quality, novelty, and community focus. What makes this establishment particularly worth choosing is its successful combination of a dedicated Dessert restaurant setting with the quality of a specialized Cookie shop. You are not just buying a cookie; you are entering a space designed to give off a "happy vibe," complete with unique decor and seating, making the consumption of dessert a true occasion.

The menu selection is unparalleled in its diversity, ranging from the indulgent "Phatties" and decadent stuffed cookies like the Dubai Chocolate Stuffed Cookie, to the health-conscious Keto options. This breadth of choice ensures that every member of a group or family, regardless of preference, can find a satisfying treat. Furthermore, the commitment to large-scale services—as a Catering food and drink supplier and Wholesale bakery—makes them a superior partner for local Florida businesses, event planners, and private parties seeking a guaranteed crowd-pleasing dessert that offers both taste and visual appeal. The enthusiastic, unsolicited testimonials from real customers, who find the flavors and atmosphere superior to competitors, solidify Cookie Plug’s position as a top-tier, locally-loved dessert destination in the Florida region. When you want more than just a sweet treat—you want a dessert experience—Cookie Plug delivers.

***

Deep Dive into the Culinary Offerings for Florida Patrons

The specific and creative menu at Cookie Plug is designed to excite the palate of the local Florida customer base. Beyond the standard offerings, the inclusion of items like the Choc Rock (Caramel Walnut Chocolate Turtle Cookie) and the Azucar Blanca (Mexican Sugar Cookie) demonstrates a commitment to unique and globally inspired flavors. For those looking for a savory-sweet combination, the Wheat Roller (Oatmeal Raisin Cookie) offers a classic, comforting option. The rotating "Secret Stash" cookies—like Rough Ave (Rocky Road Inspired Cookie) or Left Side (Blue Raspberry) Cookie—ensure that there is always something new and exciting to try, encouraging repeat visits from loyal Cape Coral customers. The option for "Mini Cookies" and even "Doggie Style" treats under the "Plugs n Puppers" section further illustrates the bakery’s commitment to providing a dessert for everyone in the Florida household. This depth of menu, coupled with the convenient Del Prado Boulevard location, cements Cookie Plug as an essential part of the Southwest Florida dessert landscape.

MENU SNAPSHOT

Food & drink

Menu items and prices may change. Confirm availability with the bakery.

Phatties 20 items

Chocolate Chip Cookie
If you’re wanting a straight classic then the O.G. Chocolate Chip Cookie is for you. Think thick, rich chunks of ooey gooey chocolate. Perfect for milk and cookies. Our cookies are part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one thick, fat warm cookie stack. Our O.G. Chocolate Chip Cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Cookies & Cream Cookie
Cookies n cream? Yes, please! Our infamous cookies and cream cookie stacks are thick, fat, and have a unique twist. They’re part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie with white chocolate chips and crushed Oreos! As you can see, Cookie Plug’s cookies and cream recipe is not the norm, but you can find them at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Smores Cookie
Get lit without the campfire with our Firecracker Smores cookie recipe. Ooey gooey marshmallow paired with a graham cracker crunch and rich chocolate chips all packed together in a warm cookie fat stack. Our smores cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie
Think strawberry cheesecake but in a cookie. You can’t go wrong with our strawberry cheesecake cookies recipe because we offer something new and very yummy that the streets have never seen before. They are part cake, part brownie, and part cookie, all formed into a thick, fat delicious stack. Our Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie
This Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie has crunchy peanut butter, chocolate, and chocolate peanut butter cups. What more could you really want? Two of your favorite desserts together with peanut butter in one thick cookie which is part brownie and part cake! Our chocolate peanut butter cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie
Nutty OG is going on Semi Retirement. Think thick, rich chunks of ooey gooey chocolate but with a nutty crunch. The nutty O.G. is another Cookie Plug classic. Perfect for milk and cookies. Our cookies are part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one thick fat warm cookie stack. Our Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Sugar Cookie
Butter, sugar, and loads of sprinkles make for the perfect warm cookie. This is not your grandma’s sugar cookie recipe. Meet Pixie Junkie, a highly addictive sugar cookie that’s available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery. Our cookies are part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one thick fat warm cookie stack.
Fruity Pebbles Cookie
Fruity Pebbles cookies aren’t just for kids but for all ages. Try our fat stacked Bam Bam cookie cereal recipe. Our cookies are truly unique. Part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie. Why have cereal in a bowl if you can have it in a cookie?
Purple Velvet Cake Cookie
Think red velvet cake but purple and in a cookie with white chocolate chips. We came up with the best deep purple velvet white chocolate chip cookie recipe. It’s part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one warm cookie stack. Our Purple Velvet Cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Snickerdoodle Cookie
Picture this: a perfectly thick and fat golden-brown canvas, crackling with the dopest cinnamon charm. Each bite, a journey through the mean streets of flavor town, where the snickerdoodle meets its streetwise cousin, the Snooperdoodle. It's a cookie with moxie, pal, and it ain't afraid to show it. Made to be part cake, part brownie, and part cookie. Our snickerdoodle cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Red Velvet Cake Cookie
At Cookie Plug bakery, we're dishing out a red velvet cake cookie that'll make your taste buds sing. Picture this: a cookie so smooth, it's like walking on velvet streets. Good Luv ain't just a cookie; it's a flavor heist, a thick, red velvet stack that’s part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie, that'll have you hooked from the first bite. We're talkin' cocoa dreams, buttery schemes – a symphony of indulgence that'll leave you wonderin' if you stumbled into dessert paradise. Good Luv rules the streets at Cookie Plug bakery – where the game's sweet and the cookies are even sweeter.
Choc Rock (Caramel Walnut Chocolate Turtle Cookie)
Looking for the ultimate indulgence? Choc Rock is a fan favorite that’s all about chocolate decadence. Think rich, fudgy brownie goodness loaded with gooey caramel and crunchy walnuts, wrapped up in a thick, fat cookie that’s pure dessert perfection. Warm it up to unlock the full, melty magic of this Caramel Walnut Brownie Turtle cookie. Part cake, part brownie, all cookie—Choc Rock will satisfy every chocoholic’s dream.
$5.00
Azucar Blanca (Mexican Sugar Cookie)
Meet Azúcar—our Mexican sugar cookie that’s straight fire from the first bite. This ain’t your abuelita’s cookie (no shade, abuelita)—it’s the Cookie Plug remix. We took that soft, buttery OG sugar cookie, hit it with a cinnamon-sugar coat, and turned it into a full-on flavor fiesta. It’s sweet, it’s smooth, and it melts in your mouth like it’s too cool to chew. One bite and you’ll be hooked on that cinnamon hustle. This cookie don’t play—it’s sugar, spice, and everything dope.
$5.00
Secret Stash Cookie
Try our hush-hush limited edition flavor of the month cookie. Every month, we're cookin' up somethin' that'll blow your taste buds away. From the shadows emerges a cookie so mysterious, even the dough dons a disguise. One month it might be a sultry salted caramel surprise, and the next, a zesty citrus chocolate sensation that'll leave you beggin' for the recipe. Our Secret Stash Cookie is available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
$5.00
Keto Chocolate Chip Cookie
Word on the street is we have the best keto chocolate chip cookie recipe. Kitt is not like any other keto cookie recipe that you have had before. It’s thick and fat. Pair our best chocolate chip cookie recipe with some of our other bomb AF keto items that’s available at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Keto Triple Chocolate Cookie
Tired of looking for the perfect chocolate Almond Flour Cookies? You’re in luck! We’ve perfected ours so you don’t have to. We modified our best seller Triple Chocolate XTC Cookie and made it keto. It’s still fat and thick like our original, but it’s made with almond flour. The result was a bomb keto almond flour cookie that we know you’ll enjoy! Our Keto Chocolate Cookie can be found at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Keto Snickerdoodle Cookie
Cinnamon-spiced perfection, wrapped in a guilt-free cookie package. It’s like a flavor heist in your mouth, and the only thing missin’ is the guilt. So, slide through, grab a batch, and let your taste buds join the keto revolution. We’re here to keep it real, keep it gangsta, and keep it keto, baby! Our Keto Snickerdoodle Cookie is sold at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Keto Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cravin’ Keto Peanut Butter Cookies? Skip the hustle and grab ‘em!” You’re in luck! We took our best chocolate chip cookies mixed in peanut butter, and then made them keto with almond flour. The result was a bomb keto cookie recipe. Find our Keto Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Oh Snap (Apple Pie Cookie)
If you’re craving fall flavors, Oh Snap is where it’s at. This thick cookie combines cozy oatmeal with sweet apple pie vibes—no crust needed. It’s part cake, part cookie, melting in your mouth with every bite. Find Oh Snap for a limited time at your nearest Cookie Plug bakery.
$5.00
Wheat Roller (Oatmeal Raisin Cookie)
Say hello to nostalgia with Wheatroller, the cookie that’s as wholesome as it is delicious. Packed with chewy oats, plump raisins, and crunchy walnuts, this classic treat brings comfort to a whole new level. Whether you’re craving a snack that reminds you of home or simply love a perfectly balanced cookie, Wheatroller has you covered. One bite, and you’ll be rolling in happiness!

Stuffed Cookies - 411 Inside Scoop 4 items

Dubai Chocolate Stuffed Cookie
Introducing the Dubai Filled Cookie—a flavor-packed creation that’s anything but ordinary. This thicc cookie is filled with creamy pistachio and finished with a crunch of golden kataifi. It’s rich, nutty, and straight-up unforgettable. Available only at Cookie Plug and only while it’s in stock… so don’t sleep on it.
$8.00
Biggie Stuffed Cookie
Say hello to the heavyweight champ—Biggie. This peanut butter cookie ain’t playin’ around, stuffed with smooth banana filling that brings the creaminess in every bite. We hit it with a Nutella drizzle for that chocolate-hazelnut flex, then crown it with a strawberry on top, because this cookie deserves the spotlight. It’s rich, it’s layered, and it’s built like a track full of bangers. One bite and you’ll know—Biggie’s not just a cookie, it’s a whole vibe.
$8.00
Windmill Razz (Biscoff Cookie Butter Topped with Raspberry Cheesecake)
Say hello to the Windmill Razz, our limited-edition stuffed cookie that’s here to blow your mind. Each cookie is topped with raspberry cheesecake filling and Biscoff cookie butter, bringing you a crave-worthy combo of sweet, creamy, and cookie-spiced goodness. Crafted with our signature thick dough, this flavor delivers the perfect balance of rich cheesecake, fruity raspberry, and that famous Biscoff cookie spread you know and love. This one’s part of our Secret Stash—which means it won’t be around forever. Grab it while it lasts!
Apple Pie Stuffed Cookie - Hood Crisp Cookies
Dive into Cookie Plug’s Hood Crisp, the ultimate apple pie stuffed cookie that’s redefining fall vibes. Our signature Oh Snap dough—chewy, golden, and straight-up perfect—wraps around a luscious, smooth apple pie filling packed with warm, autumnal spice. Topped with a velvety dollop of apple butter and a decadent butterscotch drizzle, these fall inspired stuffed cookies deliver a burst of sweet, tangy, and rich flavors in every bite. Crafted to capture the cozy heart of the season, Hood Crisp is a limited-time treat at select locations. Whether you’re a dessert lover or chasing a fresh spin on a classic, this apple pie stuffed cookie is your fall must-have. Grab yours now and taste the magic!

Kick Back Packs 5 items

Bump ‘n Bottles
Get any 4 cookies at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery with 2 Baby Bottles with Purple Drank. Choose any of our 12 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
Stack ‘em Fat
Get any 12 cookies at our Cookie Plug bakery with 2 Baby Bottles with Purple Drank- Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
Half ‘em Hooch
Get the ultimate snack fix with Half 'em Hooch, featuring 7 of your favorite cookies from Cookie Plug, paired with 2 Baby Bottles filled with Purple Drank. Choose from over 20 bold and banging cookie flavors like Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), S’mores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), and more! Whether you're chilling solo or sharing with a homie, this sweet combo brings the plug straight to your taste buds. Available now for pickup or delivery—don’t miss your cookie craving fix!
Smash ‘n Sip
Craving something extra fun? Smash 'n Sip brings you 12 of our signature fun-size cookies, served with 2 Baby Bottles of Purple Drank for the perfect pairing. Build your sack from a lineup of bold flavors, including Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), S’mores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), and more! Perfect for parties, road trips, or anytime snacking—this combo delivers on flavor and fun. Order online or visit your nearest Cookie Plug today to smash your cravings!
2 Dippers
Take your cookie game to the next level with our legendary Dippers! Choose from rich chocolate, creamy white chocolate, or indulgent caramel for the ultimate dunking experience. Whether you’re pairing them with our iconic Phatty cookies or Smash Sacks, these Dippers add a flavor boost to every bite. Perfect for sharing or keeping all to yourself—because why not? Grab a Dip, and let the snack attack begin!

Kick Back Sacks 6 items

Bump Sack | 4 Cookies
Get any 4 cookies at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery. Choose any of our 12 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
Half Sack | 7 Cookies
Get any 7 cookies at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery - Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
Fat Sack | 12 Cookies
Get any 12 cookies at our Cookie Plug bakery - Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
Dub Sack | 20 Cookies
Get any 20 cookies at Cookie Plug bakery - Choose any of our 17 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
Smash Sack | 12 Mini Cookies
Get 12 cookies in funsize, bite-size form at Cookie Plug! Choose from all 12 of our bold flavors, like Bam Bam (Fruity Pebbles), Cookie Cookie Cream (Cookies & Cream), Pixie Junkie (Sugar Cookie), Firecracker (Smores), Pink Elephant (Strawberry Cheesecake), and more flavors we’re slangin’! These bite-sized treats are perfect for sharing (or keeping all to yourself) and bring big flavor in every little bite.
Crew Sack (8 Cookies + 12 Fun-sized Cookies)
Rolling deep? The Crew Sack has you covered! Packed with 8 of our thick, signature Phatties—including fan favorites like Purple Haze (Purple Cookie with White Chocolate Chips), OG (Chocolate Chip), Pixie Junkie (sugar cookie with sprinkles), Firecracker (s’mores), Pink Elephant (strawberry cheesecake), and a rotating Secret Stash (Limited Edition)—plus 12 fun-size Smash Sack cookies, this bundle is built for sharing. Whether it’s family night, a squad hangout, or just a major cookie craving, the Crew Sack brings enough heat for everyone. Mix, match, and snack your way through the ultimate Cookie Plug experience—because sharing is caring (but no judgment if you keep a few for yourself). Grab yours today!

Plugs n Puppers 2 items

Mini Cookies
Mini Cookies: Don’t let the size fool ya. These little monsters pack a punch of flavor that’ll leave ya beggin’ for more. We’re talkin’ max taste in a mini package. The smallest cookie, the biggest whammy: Poppers prove that dynamite comes in small packages. When you need just a taste of heaven, these small chocolate chips and more cookies are your go-to hit. Find our Plug Poppers Mini Cookies at the Cookie Plug bakery.
Doggie Style
Human Grade, Real Ingredients, Cookie For Dogs!

Dranks 2 items

Purple Drank Baby Btl x2
Sippin’ Royalty in a Baby Bottle! Cookie Plug is droppin’ the illest concoction on the block: Purple Drank. This ain’t your grandma’s lemonade stand, nah, this is the real deal, the boss of all thirst-quenchers. Picture this: a smooth blend of zesty lemons, with a hit of that royal purple vibe, giving you a taste that’s straight outta the hood. It’s got that sweet kick that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance, and that swagger that’ll have you sippin’ like a true player. So step up and get your sip on, ’cause Purple Drank ain’t just a drink, it’s a statement. When you roll with our purple lemonade, you roll with the best. Find Purple Drank at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.
Purple Drank Baby Btl
Sippin’ Royalty in a Baby Bottle! Cookie Plug is droppin’ the illest concoction on the block: Purple Drank. This ain’t your grandma’s lemonade stand, nah, this is the real deal, the boss of all thirst-quenchers. Picture this: a smooth blend of zesty lemons, with a hit of that royal purple vibe, giving you a taste that’s straight outta the hood. It’s got that sweet kick that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance, and that swagger that’ll have you sippin’ like a true player. So step up and get your sip on, ’cause Purple Drank ain’t just a drink, it’s a statement. When you roll with our purple lemonade, you roll with the best. Find Purple Drank at our nationwide Cookie Plug bakery.

Secret Stash Cookies 4 items

Rough Ave (Rocky Road Inspired Cookie)
Welcome to Rough Ave, where the flavor stays bold and the streets run rich. This Secret Stash cookie is laced with deep coffee vibes, roasted almonds for that crunch, and chunks of chocolate that melt into every bite. But we didn’t stop there—we crowned it with a soft, gooey marshmallow that brings the heat and balance. It’s dark, it’s smooth, it’s a little wild—just like the block it’s named after. Only real ones ride down Rough Ave. Get it before it is gone.
Black Ops (Brownie Cookie)
Black Ops is going full stealth mode—with a patriotic twist. This thicc brownie cookie is loaded with deep, rich chocolate that hits like a flavor explosion. We laced it with red, white, and blue sprinkles to celebrate the drip and rep the squad. It’s bold, it's fudgy, and it rolls deep. Perfect for cookouts, late-night missions, or whenever you’re ready to drop something legendary on your tastebuds. Dark. Dangerous. Delicious. Get it before it is gone.
Sweet in the Middle (Mixed Berry Pop-Tart) Cookie
Sweet in the Middle is a straight-up throwback to your favorite toaster treat—but thicc. This Secret Stash cookie brings those mixed berry Pop-Tart vibes with sweet, fruity flavor baked into a soft, chewy cookie that hits just right. But the real flex? It’s soft on the outside, sweet in the middle, and built to satisfy every kind of craving. This drop won’t last forever
Left Side (Blue Raspberry) Cookie
Left Side is here to blow up the flavor game. This cookie is loaded with bold blue raspberry flavor that hits sweet, fruity, and straight-up addictive. It’s soft, thicc, and chewy—just like every Cookie Plug classic. One bite, and you’ll know this ain’t no basic bakery cookie.

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout

Offerings

Coffee

Dining options

Dessert

PHOTOS

See the bakery

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

price 5to choose 4chocolate chip 2dubai chocolate 2apple 2s'mores cookie 2call 2flavor 2

★ 5.0

Such a fun cookie store! I love how unique everything is—from the flavors to the decor. It definitely gives off a happy vibe. A sweet little spot that totally stands out! Hands down better than Crumbl

Aug 7 · Amber Fuoco (Amber Kristina Fuoco)

★ 5.0

This place is amazing! I’m so happy they opened a location in Cape Coral, we love the Fort Myers one too. They have so many different options, firecracker and good love are my favorite. They also have ice cream sandwiches which were delicious. They have a super cool “vip lounge” with seating to eat your cookies with neon signs. Deff will be back here!

Jun 17 · Ashleigh Scott

★ 2.0

We came in the young girl working came out and talked with us. To be honest she mumbled a lot and it was difficult to follow what she was saying especially with the music competing with her explaining cookies or box sizes. I order the 5 large cookies and 1 chocolate milk. This came to 31 dollars which means the cookies should taste $5.50 each good. Short story is they did not. The smores was the best one. They should have heated them up for us but we went home and figured we'd try room temp and microwave. The smores was good and even better warm. The Dubai was good but we heated it up and it became not good. Not sure how 20 seconds in the microwave does that to a cookie but it did. The strawberry cheesecake was ok at best. The biscoff Cookie butter was ok. The apple oatmeal cookie had zero apple. It was an oatmeal cookie. I was deceived and to top it off it was a bad oatmeal cookie. These cookies were greasy and something about them made me stop eating after 2 bites of each. The milk was just that, milk. The rep behind the counter was hard to understand, the cookies were ok at best except for the smores, the cookies were Overpriced and greasy. Cool place, cool concept but failed in execution. Id tell y'all to focus on making good cookies more than cool insta spots.

Sep 9 · Goku Gregory

★ 5.0

Best cookies ever!! Walked in and couldn’t resist!!!! Come all they won’t disappoint

Sep 23 · Sandra Craig

★ 5.0

Delicious cookies and such a great selection! We grabbed a mix of 7, also the Dubai cookie, and honestly there wasn’t a single one we didn’t love!

Sep 10 · Erica Ayoub

NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

★ 1.0 · 2 reviews · 0.8 mi

Walmart Bakery

1619 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 86 reviews · 1 mi

Tamu Cupcakery

311 Del Prado Blvd S #6, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA

Details

★ 5.0 · 90 reviews · 1.4 mi

Juanca's Bakery

1524 Hancock Bridge Pkwy, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 319 reviews · 1.6 mi

J&J Paradise Bakery

111 Del Prado Blvd N #9, Cape Coral, FL 33909, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 61 reviews · 1.7 mi

BB's Unique Cupcake Boutique and Custom Cakes

247 SE 8th Terrace, Cape Coral, FL 33990, USA

Details

★ 5.0 · 22 reviews · 2.3 mi

Sweet Empire

2709 SE 8th Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33904, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 58 reviews · 2.3 mi

Maddie's Artisanal Bakery

2924 Del Prado Blvd S Suites 7 and 8, Cape Coral, FL 33904, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 241 reviews · 2.4 mi

Jiggly Tasty Japanese cheesecake, Bubble Tea, Coffee

140 Santa Barbara Blvd Unit 119, Cape Coral, FL 33991, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 202 reviews · 2.5 mi

Yonutz Donuts and Ice Cream - Cape Coral

106 Hancock Bridge Pkwy #c11, Cape Coral, FL 33991, USA

Details

★ 5.0 · 3 reviews · 2.8 mi

Sam's Club Bakery

301 SW Pine Island Rd, Cape Coral, FL 33991, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 3 reviews · 2.9 mi

Walmart Bakery

2020 NE Pine Island Rd, Cape Coral, FL 33909, USA

Details

★ 5.0 · 2 reviews · 3 mi

Walmart Bakery

505 SW Pine Island Rd, Cape Coral, FL 33991, USA

Details

About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.