First time trying these cookies.On Uber Eats they’re Dubai is 9.69 and in store it’s 8.52! Definitely recommend just walking in to grab cookies instead of ordering online.Already made, really quick to grab and go! Also, the variety pack is 4 for $17. A little bit pricier of a cookie, but definitely large cookies.
Sep 6 · Myra JaimesCookie Plug
12377 S Cleveland Ave #16, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 12377 S Cleveland Ave #16, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA
- Phone
- (239) 362-1624
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 239 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Tuesday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Wednesday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Thursday1:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Friday12:00 AM – 11:00 PM
- Saturday12:00 AM – 11:00 PM
- Sunday1:00 PM – 9:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For Southwest Florida locals craving a dessert that is anything but ordinary, the Cookie Plug in Fort Myers has established itself as the premier spot for a unique, street-style baking experience. Positioned as a modern bakery, cake shop, and dessert restaurant, the Cookie Plug is famous for its signature, thick cookies—or "Phatties"—that are often described by fans as being part cake, part brownie, and part cookie, all rolled into one substantial treat.
This local Fort Myers dessert shop specializes in slinging a wide array of bold, creative, and generously sized cookies, moving well beyond the traditional chocolate chip. The menu is a vibrant mix of imaginative flavors, featuring everything from the popular Bam Bam Cookie (Fruity Pebbles) and Firecracker Cookie (S’mores) to luxurious Stuffed Cookies like the Dubai Chocolate. They also cater thoughtfully to specific dietary needs with an impressive selection of Keto Cookies.
What sets Cookie Plug apart is its focus on quick, convenient service combined with high-quality, freshly baked goods. Whether you're looking to grab a quick snack, order a bulk 'Kick Back Sack' for a party, or commission a massive cookie cake, this bakery offers a fun and reliable way to satisfy your sweet cravings in the Fort Myers area. Customer feedback frequently highlights the cookies' desirable texture—super chewy and moist, often likened to cookie dough but baked to perfection—making them an instant local favorite.
Location and Accessibility
The Cookie Plug in Fort Myers is conveniently located in a bustling, accessible shopping area, ensuring that a quick dessert run is always easy for residents and visitors of Southwest Florida. Its placement on a major roadway enhances its accessibility.
The full address is:
12377 S Cleveland Ave #16, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA
The location on South Cleveland Avenue places it in a high-traffic retail area, accessible from both Fort Myers and neighboring communities. As a modern dessert shop, accessibility is a priority:
- The facility includes a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, ensuring all members of the community can easily visit.
- The location offers Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot spaces for maximum convenience.
- For drivers, the parking situation is excellent, with both a Free Parking Lot and Free Street Parking available.
The shop is designed for a Quick Visit, meaning you can be in and out with your favorite cookies, perfect for a treat during a lunch break or on the way home.
Services Offered
Cookie Plug offers a comprehensive range of services designed to meet diverse needs, from individual cravings to large-scale event catering. The emphasis is on convenience and variety.
- In-Store Pickup & Takeout: Customers can easily stop by to grab a few cookies or pre-ordered 'Kick Back Sacks.'
- Delivery: The bakery provides a Delivery option, allowing Fort Myers users to enjoy their favorite cookies right at home or the office.
- Cookie Bundles ("Kick Back Sacks"): Offering various sizes of cookie packs, from the Bump Sack (4 cookies) to the Dub Sack (20 cookies), and the Fat Sack (12 cookies), perfect for sharing.
- Dessert Catering: Available for events from 25 to 1,000 people, featuring bulk Party Sacks (40 cookies) and custom orders for corporate events, parties, and graduations.
- Cookie Cakes: They specialize in Massive Cookie Cakes that can be customized with personalized messages and custom colors, providing a unique alternative to traditional birthday cakes.
- Specialty Beverages: Offering unique "Dranks," notably the Purple Lemonade (Purple Drank), available in single servings or two-packs.
- Reward Program: The “Plugged in Rewards” program lets customers Earn DRIP ($1 = 1 drip) toward free treats and access to exclusive birthday offers and promotions.
Features / Highlights: A Menu for Every Craving
The Cookie Plug's standout feature is its innovative and extensive menu, which ensures there is a cookie for virtually every taste, mood, and even specific dietary plan.
- The 'Phatties' Signature Cookies: These are the thick, substantial cookies described as a cake-brownie-cookie hybrid. Popular flavors include Pink Elephant (Strawberry Cheesecake), Chocolate XTC (Triple Chunk Chocolate), Purple Haze (Purple Velvet Cake), and the comforting Snooperdoodle (Snickerdoodle).
- Specialty Keto Options: A rare and highly valued feature, the bakery offers a full line of Keto-friendly cookies, including the Bart Keto Cookie (Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip) and Kitt Keto Cookie (Chocolate Chip), making dessert accessible for those on a low-carb diet.
- The 411 Stuffed Cookies: The menu elevates the cookie concept with filled options, such as the trendy Dubai Chocolate Stuffed Cookie (pistachio filling with crispy kataifi) and the Hood Crisp Cookie (Apple Pie Stuffed Cookie), providing an extra layer of richness and texture.
- Rotating Secret Stash: They keep things exciting with a Secret Stash Cookie that rotates frequently, featuring limited-time flavors like the Rough Ave (Rocky Road Inspired) and Sweet in the Middle (Mixed Berry Pop-Tart) Cookie.
- Late-Night Dessert Hours: The Fort Myers location is often open later than many local bakeries, typically until 10 PM on weekdays and 11 PM on Friday/Saturday, perfect for a late-night sweet fix.
Contact Information
You can easily connect with the Cookie Plug Fort Myers location via phone or by visiting their store during open hours.
Address:
12377 S Cleveland Ave #16, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA
Phone:
(239) 362-1624
What is Worth Choosing
For local users in Fort Myers, choosing the Cookie Plug is about selecting a high-energy, fun, and high-quality experience over a generic dessert option. It’s the perfect fit for anyone who prefers a cookie that is moist, doughy, and substantial—a truly "phat" treat.
Here’s why the Cookie Plug is a must-try bakery in Southwest Florida:
- Texture and Size: The most consistent praise from customers is for the cookies' signature doughy, moist center and large size, making each cookie a deeply satisfying indulgence. They deliver on the promise of a big, thick cookie that feels like a full dessert.
- Flavor Diversity: With flavors ranging from nostalgic (Bam Bam) to sophisticated (Dubai Chocolate) and specialized (Keto), there is an unparalleled selection that keeps customers coming back to try the next flavor drop.
- Keto-Friendly Treats: For those actively managing sugar or carb intake, the availability of a dedicated, highly-rated Keto Cookie line means no one has to miss out on the fun, a crucial offering in the modern dessert market.
- Event Readiness: The comprehensive catering options and massive Cookie Cakes make the Cookie Plug a superior choice for quickly and affordably handling dessert for any local party, gathering, or work function in the Fort Myers area.
- Convenience and Speed: The ready-to-grab nature of the cookies and available services like in-store pickup, delivery, and mobile pay (NFC) means a delicious dessert is never more than a few minutes away.
The Cookie Plug is more than just a cookie shop; it's a specialty dessert destination for Fort Myers, delivering on its promise of "the fattest and thiccest cookies on the block" every single day.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Onsite services
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Some of the best store cookies I’ve ever had. All excellent. Very cookie dough like without being too raw. If you like your cookies on the doughy side, you will love these. They also have keto cookies, although we haven’t tried those yet. We will be back.
Feb 1 · Aaron SlackI absolutely love this place. We went to the grand opening for the Cape Coral store and it did not disappoint. I love the atmosphere, outstanding customer service with delicious cookies. We are hooked.
Jul 5 · Hiedi WhiteOk so havent been to the cookie plug since I was in los Angeles, Ca. So I was excited to see what they had in store. Got the haze, sugar cookie, cookies and cream, and a brownie mix thing. They were pretty good like 6/10. I would definitely go back to get the haze it was delicious.
Oct 20 · ChristopherWe got a new cookie joint in the hood & they are pretty delicious! The Cookie Plug opened yesterday! The staff was friendly but little shy. They definitely got thiccc cookies. Warm them up and on you go. The place is cool with graffiti art all over the walls. They don't accept cash but have a cash tip jar. They are open late!
Jun 19 · Brandy DCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.




Empire Bagel Factory
9961 Interstate Commerce Dr #195, Fort Myers, FL 33913, USA



Crave Cookies Estero
19517 Highland Oaks Dr unit 502, Estero, FL 33928, USA





This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
