Everything Bagels and Cafe

Welcome to Everything Bagels and Cafe, a beloved local establishment right in the heart of Morganville, New Jersey. In a state renowned for having some of the absolute best bagels in the country—a distinction often attributed to the famous Jersey water and the traditional boil-then-bake preparation method—Everything Bagels and Cafe stands as a testament to that high-quality standard. This is not just another spot for a quick bite; it's a neighborhood staple where residents of Morganville, Marlboro, and the surrounding areas gather to start their day right or grab a satisfying lunch. Known for their consistently fresh, fluffy, and delicious bagels, paired with a remarkably friendly staff and an extensive menu, it's easy to see why customers often refer to this spot as having the best bagels around.

The core of Everything Bagels and Cafe's success lies in its commitment to the authentic New Jersey bagel experience. True Jersey bagels are characterized by a crispy, slightly chewy exterior and a dense, flavorful interior, and according to loyal patrons, this establishment delivers on all counts, no matter what time of day you visit. Beyond the iconic breakfast item, the cafe offers a full-service menu that spans hearty breakfast platters, specialty hot sandwiches, fresh salads, and a full array of deli favorites, ensuring there is something to satisfy every craving.

Location and Accessibility

Everything Bagels and Cafe is conveniently situated at a central location for Monmouth County residents, making it an accessible stop for your daily commute or weekend morning routine.

The shop is located at:

483 Hwy 79, Morganville, NJ 07751, USA

The location on Highway 79 offers ease of access for local driving traffic. For all patrons, the premises are designed to be accommodating:

The accessibility features include a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that a quick visit is convenient for all members of the community. Whether you're rushing in for a takeout order, enjoying a quick bite with dine-in service, or picking up a large order for an office meeting, the location is set up for a smooth experience.

Services Offered

Everything Bagels and Cafe provides a comprehensive range of dining and service options to meet the needs of the busy New Jersey consumer, from early morning breakfast to a late lunch.

Services include:

• Delivery and In-store Pickup options for convenient ordering from home or the office.
• In-store Shopping and Dine-in service for a traditional cafe experience.
• Takeout for those on the go who need to grab their order quickly.
• Breakfast dining options are available all day.
• A great spot for a Quick Visit, perfect for grabbing a coffee and a bagel before work.
• Various payment methods accepted, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments, to streamline the checkout process.

Features / Highlights

The menu at Everything Bagels and Cafe is a standout, offering far more than the standard bagel shop fare. It represents a full-service delicatessen experience built around the excellence of their freshly baked bagels.

Menu and Quality Highlights:

• Authentic New Jersey Bagels: Patrons consistently rave about the bagels being “delicious & fresh,” praising their fluffy texture and size. They are available individually, in a half dozen with a complimentary extra bagel, or a dozen with two free bagels.
• Creative Cream Cheese Options: The shop offers a wide array of cream cheeses by the pound, including Vegetable, Scallion, Bacon Cheddar, Jalapeño Cheddar, Blueberry, Strawberry, Walnut Raisin, and Lox Cream Cheese.
• Signature Breakfast Sandwiches: Beyond the classic Egg, Meat, and Cheese, they feature unique creations like the Everything Bagel Sandwich (with Lox Scallion, Cream Cheese, Red Onion, and Capers) and the indulgent French Toast Bagel Sandwich (with 2 Fried Eggs, Bacon, and White American Cheese).
• Hearty Breakfast Platters: All-day breakfast platters come with two eggs, home fries, and a bagel or toast, covering a full morning meal. Options include Egg Any Style, French Toast Platters (plain or with toppings like Nutella or Blueberries), and Pancake Platters (plain or with Chocolate Chips, Blueberries, or Strawberries).
• Extensive Omelet Selection: They serve five different types of 3-Egg Omelets, including Western, Mexican, Italian, Vegetable, Greek, and The Everything Omelet.
• Full Deli Lunch Menu: The cafe moves beyond breakfast with an impressive selection of hot and cold sandwiches, specialty wraps, and large, fresh salads such as the Chef Salad and The Everything Salad.
• Local Name Hot Sandwiches: A fun feature is the selection of hot sandwiches named after local Central New Jersey towns, such as The Morganville Sandwich (Chicken cutlet, marinara, fresh mozzarella), The Middletown Sandwich (Philly cheesesteak with peppers, onions, melted provolone), and The Colts Neck Sandwich (Fried or grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, pepper jack, and chipotle mayo).
• Specialty Comfort Food: The menu also includes classic diner/deli specialty items like the Pizza Bagel, Hamburger Deluxe, Chicken Fingers and French Fries, and The Everything Melt (Fried chicken, crisp bacon, melted American, honey mustard dressing).
• Friendly and Accommodating Staff: Numerous customer reviews highlight the staff’s kindness, pleasant attitude, and willingness to accommodate large, last-minute orders, which speaks volumes about the local, service-oriented focus of the business.

Contact Information

To place a quick order, inquire about catering, or find out more about the daily specials, you can contact Everything Bagels and Cafe directly.

Address: 483 Hwy 79, Morganville, NJ 07751, USA

Phone: (732) 696-2705

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Everything Bagels and Cafe, the obvious and essential choice is to experience their signature bagel, whether it’s plain, an Everything, or any other variety. For true bagel aficionados, getting a plain bagel with one of their unique, homemade cream cheese spreads—like the Jalapeño Cheddar or Walnut Raisin—is a must-try combination. The customer feedback consistently reinforces that the quality and freshness of the bagels themselves are truly what set this location apart from many others. New Jersey locals understand that a truly exceptional bagel should not require toasting, and at this Morganville establishment, they pride themselves on serving a bagel that is warm, fluffy, and delicious right out of the oven.

Beyond the bagel, the breakfast menu is where the shop truly shines. The Everything Breakfast Sandwich is a perfect representation of a true Jersey breakfast experience, combining two scrambled eggs, pork roll, mozzarella, and long hot peppers with a side of home fries—a hearty, local favorite that provides serious value and flavor. For lunch, diving into one of the locally-named hot sandwiches, such as The Matawan Sandwich with homemade meatballs and fresh mozzarella, provides a generous and flavorful option that is far beyond typical bagel shop standards. For larger gatherings, the option to buy cream cheese or specialty salads (like Tuna or White Fish Salad) by the pound, along with dozen bagel deals, makes this location the ideal catering choice for staff meetings or weekend family breakfasts in Monmouth County. In short, choose Everything Bagels and Cafe for the authentic Jersey bagel perfection and stay for the extensive, high-quality deli menu and warm, community-focused service. It’s a guaranteed fresh start to any day.