Forest superette and bagels

Welcome to Forest Superette and Bagels, a beloved local institution nestled right on Forest Avenue in Staten Island, NY. More than just a typical bagel shop, this location serves as a community superette offering a wide-ranging menu that caters to every craving from sun-up to sundown. For New Yorkers who appreciate a quality, fresh start to their day or a satisfying, generously portioned lunch, this spot is a true gem. Combining the freshness of a classic bagel bakery with the extensive offerings of a premium deli, Forest Superette and Bagels stands out as a convenient and high-quality food destination in the borough.

Whether you're grabbing a quick breakfast sandwich on your commute, picking up a dozen bagels for the office, or looking for a hearty hero for lunch, the friendly staff and excellent selection ensure a pleasant and efficient experience. The quality is a constant, with a commitment to fresh ingredients, including a fantastic selection of Boar's Head premium deli meats and cheeses.

Location and Accessibility: A Staple on Forest Ave

Forest Superette and Bagels is conveniently situated at 350 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10301, USA, making it a central and easy-to-reach spot for West Brighton locals and anyone passing through the area. As a staple on the busy Forest Avenue corridor, the shop is easy to find. The vibe of the establishment, as noted by some, is that of a superette that hosts a high-quality bagel and deli counter, which is a major plus for New Yorkers who value variety and efficiency in one stop. Its accessibility is enhanced by the options for both quick takeout and convenient delivery, ensuring that a quality meal is never far away. The operation supports modern payment methods including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making your quick visit even faster. For those participating in assistance programs, SNAP/EBT payments are also accepted.

Services Offered: A Complete Menu for Any Time of Day

Forest Superette and Bagels prides itself on an extensive menu that covers all the bases for breakfast and lunch. Their services and offerings go far beyond the standard cream cheese bagel, providing great variety and quality.

UL

• Fresh Bagels & Cream Cheese: Serving single bagels, mini bagels, and bagels by the dozen (including popular specials like "Buy 12 Bagels and get 2 FREE"). Cream cheese options include Plain and a variety of Flavored Cream Cheeses, available as a spread or by the pound. A classic, must-try New York option is the Fresh Lox with Cream Cheese Bagel.
• Signature Breakfast: Start your day with two eggs on a roll or a bagel, grilled cheese breakfast options, or a variety of specialty breakfast sandwiches featuring Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Turkey, Turkey Bacon, and Pastrami.
• Breakfast Specials and Omelets: For a more substantial morning meal, they offer the 'Healthy Man' wrap (egg whites, turkey, Alpine Lacey Swiss), the 'Hungry Man on a Roll' (multiple meats, eggs, and cheese), Croissant Omelets, Western Omelets, Veggie Omelets, and French Toast.
• Premium Deli & Sandwiches: The lunch menu is built on high-quality ingredients, featuring an array of Boar's Head Premium Deli Meats and Cheeses available by the pound and in their generously sized sandwiches. Signature lunch options include the Philly Cheese Steak, Spicy Italian, Turkey Crazy, and classic Chicken Cutlet Sandwiches.
• Deli Combos: Conveniently priced cold cut combinations, such as Combo 4 (1/2 lb of Deluxe Ham, Bologna, Gold Label Swiss, Ovengold Turkey, and American cheese), making it easy to stock your fridge with high-quality cold cuts.
• Burger and Hot Food Bar: Serving up hot lunch items like the fan-favorite Chopped Cheese, Cheese Burgers, and the Sunrise Burger, alongside sides like Crinkle Cut Fries and Tator Tots.
• Fresh Salads and Sides: A wide selection from the salad bar, including Caesar Salad, Garden Salad, and deli sides like Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, Chicken Salad, Tri-Color Pasta Salad, and Fresh Fruit Salad.
• Beverages and Drinks: A full selection of hot beverages, including freshly brewed Coffee, along with a wide range of cold drinks like Iced Coffee, Snapple, Gatorade, Red Bull, various juices, and even a selection of alcoholic beverages (Corona, Heineken, Modelo, White Claw) for purchase.

Features / Highlights: Quality and Variety

Forest Superette and Bagels differentiates itself in the busy Staten Island food landscape by focusing on a few key qualities that New Yorkers value most: quality ingredients, menu diversity, and quick service.

UL

• Boar's Head Deli Selection: A major highlight is the use of Boar's Head brand meats and cheeses for their deli counter and sandwiches. This premium commitment elevates the quality of all cold cuts, including options like London Broil Roast Beef, Ovengold Turkey, Gold Label Imported Swiss Cheese, and Spicy Sopressata.
• All-Day Service: The location offers dining options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with service options that include delivery, takeout, and quick counter service, ideal for people on the go.
• Signature Sandwiches: The lunch menu boasts several standout signature sandwiches, including the Philly Cheese Steak Lunch (Hot Deluxe Roast Beef w/ Onions, Peppers & Melted Mozzarella) and the Spicy Italian Lunch (Hot Sopressata, Hot Capicola, Deluxe Ham, Fresh Mozzarella, Hot Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Oil and Vinegar). The menu also features a fan-favorite Chopped Cheese sandwich.
• The "Healthy Man" Option: Catering to health-conscious diners, the 'Healthy Man Breakfast' provides a delicious and responsible option with three egg whites, turkey, and Alpine Lacey Swiss cheese on a whole wheat wrap.
• Customer-Approved Service: Testimonials from patrons consistently highlight the friendly staff and very good food, reinforcing the shop's role as a positive part of the local community.

Contact Information

For orders, inquiries, or catering requests, you can reach Forest Superette and Bagels at the following contact points:

Address: 350 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10301, USA

Phone: (718) 273-6928

Mobile Phone: +1 718-273-6928

What is Worth Choosing: The Local New Yorker's Verdict

For anyone in Staten Island or the wider New York area, Forest Superette and Bagels is worth choosing for its exceptional value and extensive menu. The core offerings, the fresh bagels, are the perfect New York standard—chewy, large, and satisfying. But what truly sets it apart is the high-end deli counter. The use of premium Boar's Head products ensures that every custom-made sandwich or cold cut platter is a step above the competition. If you’re visiting for the first time, start with an egg and cheese on a freshly toasted bagel to appreciate the basics done right. For lunch, the hot sandwiches like the Philly Cheese Steak or the classic Italian Lunch are excellent choices, offering generous portions that customer reviews confirm are "very good" and "a decent size." Beyond the food, the experience is also defined by the positive and "very nice" people who work there, making it a welcoming stop for your daily meal. Despite being "a bit pricey" according to some, the consistent customer feedback suggests the superior quality and generous portions make it absolutely "worth it."