Maddie created a beautiful dye free mermaid themed cake for my little girl's first birthday. She communicated with me well. The cake was delicious! Prices were reasonable. This was the only place in town that was willing to make a dye free cake. We appreciate it!! Can't wait to have more goodies by Maddie!
Aug 12 · Gwen CarmenFrosted by Maddie
3315 S 7th St, Terre Haute, IN 47802, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 3315 S 7th St, Terre Haute, IN 47802, USA
- Phone
- (812) 298-4616
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 58 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Tuesday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Wednesday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Thursday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Friday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Saturday10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Sunday10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
About and visit notes
## Introduction / Overview
Frosted by Maddie stands out as a unique and dedicated Bakery in Terre Haute, Indiana, specializing in crafting inventive, oversized, and often custom-ordered baked goods. Located conveniently at 3315 S 7th St, this shop has built a reputation not just for delicious flavor, but for creative execution, particularly in the realm of specialty cookies, jumbo brownies, and personalized cakes.
The bakery's menu goes far beyond standard fare, offering an indulgent and playful array of treats designed to spark joy. Customers flock here for the signature Stuffed Cookies, decadent Deluxe Cookies, and hefty Jumbo Brownies and Cinnamon Rolls. This focus on bold, generous portions and unique flavor combinations—such as Pumpkin Cheesecake Stuffed Cookies and the Jumbo Cookie Dough Brownie—makes every visit a luxurious treat.
Frosted by Maddie also distinguishes itself by taking on challenging custom orders, such as dye-free cakes, showcasing a commitment to accommodating specific dietary needs that other local bakeries may not offer. Whether you are seeking a quick sweet fix via Takeout, picking up a Variety Treat Box for an event, or consulting on a custom cake for a major milestone, Frosted by Maddie aims to be the go-to destination for high-quality, creative baked goods in the Terre Haute and surrounding Indiana region.
---
## Location and Accessibility
Frosted by Maddie is conveniently situated to serve the Terre Haute community and those passing through the area:
3315 S 7th St, Terre Haute, IN 47802, USA
The location on South 7th Street makes it an easily accessible spot for local residents and a straightforward stop for those driving by. The bakery is well-suited for a Quick visit, offering streamlined services like In-store pickup and Takeout that minimize wait times.
Recognizing the needs of all patrons, the bakery offers key accessibility features, including a Wheelchair accessible parking lot. This ensures that customers with mobility needs can conveniently access the shop to pick up their orders. For payments, the process is efficient and modern, accepting both Credit cards and Debit cards, facilitating a smooth transaction experience.
---
## Services Offered
Frosted by Maddie offers a wide array of specialized baked goods and services, making them a top choice for everyday cravings and special occasions in Indiana:
- Specialty Cookie Categories: Offering three tiers of indulgent cookies—Regular Cookies (e.g., Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Blossom), Deluxe Cookies (e.g., Turtle, Red Velvet), and premium Stuffed Cookies (e.g., Oreo Truffle, S'mores).
- Jumbo Brownies: Crafting oversized, decadent brownies in classic and specialty flavors, including Jumbo Cosmic Brownie, Jumbo Reese's Cup Brownie, and Jumbo Oreo Brownie.
- Cakes and Slices: Providing custom cakes for birthdays and events, along with daily options like the Funfetti Cake Slice and specialty cheesecake cups.
- Custom Baking Requests: Specializing in unique custom orders, such as dye-free cakes, demonstrating flexibility and an ability to cater to specific health and aesthetic needs.
- Gourmet Breakfast Items: Offering oversized breakfast favorites like the Jumbo Cinnamon Roll and the deluxe Jumbo Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Roll.
- Unique Desserts: Selling distinctive items like Banana Pudding and the Caramel Heath Cheesecake Cup for single-serving indulgences.
- Variety Treat Boxes: Providing pre-selected assortments, such as the Variety Treat Box ($10.00), which offers a convenient way to sample multiple bakery items.
- Efficient Ordering Options: Supporting quick Takeout and In-store pickup for all orders, from a single cookie to large custom orders.
---
## Features / Highlights
The standout features of Frosted by Maddie center on innovation, indulgence, and customer accommodation, positioning them as a premier bakery in Terre Haute:
- Signature Stuffed Cookies: These are a major highlight, with gourmet creations like the Pumpkin Cheesecake Stuffed Cookie and Banana Pudding Stuffed Cookie offering a rich, layered dessert experience that is hard to find elsewhere.
- Jumbo Sizing: The generous portions on items like the Jumbo Cinnamon Roll and Jumbo Cookie Dough Brownie provide exceptional value and a truly indulgent treat, appealing to customers looking for an elevated experience.
- Expert Customization (Dye-Free): The bakery's willingness and ability to create specialized products, such as the praised dye-free mermaid themed cake, showcase a high level of expertise and dedication to meeting specific customer requests and health requirements.
- Broad Flavor Creativity: The extensive menu features unique and rotating flavors across all categories—from the Birthday Cake Cookie to the Caramel Pumpkin Crumb Deluxe Cookie—ensuring there is always something new and exciting for regulars.
- Reasonable Pricing: For the quality and size of the specialty products offered, customers often find the prices to be highly reasonable, making gourmet treats accessible for everyday enjoyment.
- Daily Dessert Convenience: The availability of single-serving items like cake slices and cheesecake cups makes it an ideal spot for a quick, delicious dessert without needing to purchase an entire cake.
---
## Contact Information
To place an order, inquire about custom cakes, or find out the day’s featured items, customers in the Indiana region can contact Frosted by Maddie at the following:
Address: 3315 S 7th St, Terre Haute, IN 47802, USA
Phone: (812) 298-4616
Mobile Phone: +1 812-298-4616
---
## What is Worth Choosing
For Indiana locals, Frosted by Maddie is worth choosing because it represents a premium, specialty experience that outshines mass-produced alternatives, especially for those in the Terre Haute area seeking inventive and generous treats. You choose this bakery for its Commitment to Specialty and Indulgence and its unique ability to handle complex custom orders.
The shop is a paradise for cookie and brownie enthusiasts, offering a depth of choice—from simple and perfect Regular Chocolate Chip Cookies to the ultimate decadence of a S'mores Stuffed Cookie or a giant Jumbo Reese's Cup Brownie—that few other places can match. Their products are designed to be showstoppers, whether it is a small treat for yourself or a spectacular centerpiece for a party.
Crucially, Frosted by Maddie goes the extra mile by accommodating specific needs. The ability to create a high-quality, delicious dye-free cake, an option often difficult to find, is a significant benefit for parents and those with sensitivities, showcasing a flexible and attentive service model. While it is important for customers to ensure communication is clear on custom requests, the dedication to unique design and delicious flavor makes this bakery an essential local resource. When you need a guaranteed crowd-pleaser or a custom treat that caters to unique needs, Frosted by Maddie delivers the creativity, size, and flavor that locals expect from a top-tier Indiana bakery.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
The wedding cake tasted good, but we didn’t get what we ordered. When I sent pics, response was just that yes, it was different. When I asked if that was the only response, I was told I was rude, that they didn’t do anything wrong, and that I don’t have to like their bakery. Long cry from “the customer is always right!” An apology, discount, or maybe complimentary item in the future? No mention of any of it. White icing cake is lovely, but don’t ask for anything unique, as we were told they assumed it should be white because it was a wedding cake.
Sep 26 · Dianna WhitlockI cannot believe I was late to this party! Just found out about this place on tiktok.1000/10! These treats are delicious!Thank you for your amazing customer service today Hope!
Aug 12 · Charrell WheatonMaddies baked goods are always so yummy. I originally went for the Dubai cups but unfortunately they were out. Maybe next time I can snag one.
Jul 21 · Ashlee PendletonBest Local place to get cookies or have a cake made! The cake is moist and wedding quality. Freshly baked cookies and on point with what they are supposed to taste like (cinnamon roll for example). Clean place and friendly staff! I do wish the deluxe cookie lineup varied more each week and had different ones as there’s so many that can be created but that’s probably good for my waistline!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!
Aug 21 · TiffanyCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

Sugar Studio by Tiers Of Elegance
2939 S 7th St, Terre Haute, IN 47802, USA




Sprinkles Cookie Co (SugarBell Sprinkles)
8 N Church St, West Terre Haute, IN 47885, USA







This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
