Just Pies Inc

Introduction / Overview

For over two decades, Just Pies Inc has cemented its reputation in Central Ohio as the ultimate specialist in one beloved dessert: pie. Located in Westerville, this family-owned bakery is not just a local gem, but has been recognized nationally for creating some of the best pies in America. This establishment operates on a singular, unwavering focus, offering an extensive selection of over 35 different pie options to satisfy every possible craving, from classic fruit varieties to decadent cream creations and hearty, savory pot pies.

Just Pies Inc represents a cherished tradition in the Ohio community. They offer three distinct sizes—small, medium, and large—making it easy for customers to pick up a single-serving treat for a Quick visit or a large pie for a holiday gathering. Their dedication to quality is evident in the positive reviews, which praise the light, fluffy creams, the generous and ripe fruit fillings, and the signature flaky crusts. While their dessert pies are an undisputed highlight—with the Buckeye Pie and Peach Riot being frequently recommended—they are also well-known for their savory pot pies, including beef, turkey, and chicken varieties, which serve as perfect, comforting meals.

This Westerville location, which serves as a bustling baking facility and retail spot, is a testament to the bakery’s enduring success and commitment to the local Ohio area. Whether you are a long-time resident seeking a familiar favorite or a newcomer looking for an exceptional, award-winning baked good, Just Pies Inc is an essential stop for any pie lover.

Location and Accessibility

Just Pies Inc is easily found in the Columbus suburb of Westerville, offering convenience for customers throughout Central Ohio:

Address: 736 Northfield Rd # 1, Westerville, OH 43082, USA.

The location on Northfield Road is designed with customer convenience in mind. The bakery provides multiple access options for a seamless experience:

• Parking: Customers benefit from a dedicated Free parking lot, eliminating the stress of finding street parking.
• Accessibility: The business is equipped with a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring access for all patrons.
• Service Options: The availability of Curbside pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout caters to every customer's preference, from a quick grab-and-go to a leisurely browse inside.

The bakery operates during typical business hours, generally Tuesday through Saturday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, though it is advisable to check holiday hours, as they are known to open earlier during peak seasons due to high demand.

Services Offered

As a specialty bakery, Just Pies Inc focuses intently on providing a diverse and high-quality pie menu and convenient purchasing options:

• In-Store Retail: A vast selection of fresh pies available for immediate purchase in small, medium, and large sizes.
• Curbside and Takeout: Convenient options for customers to quickly pick up their orders without extended delays.
• Three Pie Categories: Offers pies in Fruit and Nut, Cream, and Specialty categories, with over 35 different flavors available seasonally and year-round.
• Savory Pot Pies: Sells hearty, savory pies, including Chicken, Beef, and Turkey pot pies, perfect for take-home meals (often sold frozen for the customer to bake).
• No Sugar Added Options: Provides a thoughtful selection of pies made with no added sugar for health-conscious customers, including Apple, Cherry, Peach, Blueberry, Banana, Chocolate, and Peanut Butter varieties (seasonal availability may apply).
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Custom and Bulk Orders: While the focus is on a rotating daily menu, the bakery caters to large volume orders, such as holiday and corporate needs, which often require advance ordering.

Features / Highlights

The primary appeal of Just Pies Inc lies in several standout features that distinguish it within the Ohio bakery landscape:

• Over 35 Varieties of Pie: The sheer breadth of the menu ensures that whether you crave a classic like Pecan or a unique flavor like Peach Riot or Buckeye Cream, Just Pies has it.
• The Famous Buckeye Pie: This signature Cream Pie, representing an Ohio favorite, is a major draw and a highly recommended specialty item.
• Savory Pot Pie Selection: Beyond sweets, they offer various savory pot pies, which are often cited by locals as a top choice for a comforting, home-style meal.
• Three Convenient Sizes: Offering small (perfect for one to two servings), medium, and large pies for easy shopping, fitting everything from a personal treat to a family gathering.
• Nationally Recognized Quality: The bakery has been acknowledged by respected sources like Yelp and even received a nod from Oprah, testifying to the high standard of their recipes and execution.
• Focus on Fresh, Quality Filling: Customer feedback frequently highlights the quality of the ingredients, such as thick slices of ripe banana in the cream pies and the non-soggy, flaky crusts.

Contact Information

For orders, hours, or any specific inquiries, Ohio residents can contact the Westerville location directly:

Address: 736 Northfield Rd # 1, Westerville, OH 43082, USA

Phone: (614) 818-9300 or +1 614-818-9300

What is Worth Choosing

Just Pies Inc is undeniably worth choosing for any Ohio resident seeking the best possible pie for any occasion. When you choose Just Pies, you are choosing decades of specialization and a product that has been celebrated beyond Central Ohio borders.

The extensive menu, particularly the ability to find specialty items like French Silk, Key Lime, and a wide array of seasonal No Sugar Added options, means that all palates and dietary considerations can be satisfied. For a party, a large Fruit Pie like the Bubleberry or Tripleberry makes a stunning centerpiece. For a weeknight meal, a hearty Chicken Pot Pie offers convenience and home-cooked flavor, although customers should be prepared to adjust the at-home bake time to achieve the perfectly crisp crust that is a hallmark of all their pies. The pleasant and friendly customer service, coupled with the ease of Curbside pickup and a Free parking lot, makes the entire experience efficient and enjoyable. Simply put, for pies—sweet or savory, large or small—Just Pies Inc in Westerville is the unrivaled choice in Central Ohio.