Manhattan Bagel

Manhattan Bagel on Route 37 in Toms River is more than just a quick stop—it’s a local institution for fresh, authentic New York-style bagels, hearty breakfast options, and satisfying lunch fare. For New Jersey residents who appreciate the classic bagel tradition, this location is a reliable, convenient, and flavorful choice for starting your day or grabbing a midday meal.

From the moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked bread and brewing coffee sets the scene for a true East Coast bagel experience. This bagel shop brings the renowned quality of a classic New York-style bagel right here to Ocean County. They are famous for boiling and then baking their bagels daily, a process that creates that perfect, slightly crisp exterior and a delightfully chewy interior that NJ locals know and love.

Beyond the bagels, Manhattan Bagel serves as a full-service bakery, breakfast restaurant, and cafe, making it an ideal spot for any time of the morning or afternoon. The commitment to fresh ingredients is evident in their made-to-order breakfast and lunch sandwiches, ensuring that whether you're craving a quick bite or a full meal, you'll find something delicious.

For families on a Sunday outing, commuters grabbing a quick coffee on the way to work, or local residents planning a group gathering, Manhattan Bagel provides the quality, variety, and convenience that is essential to the New Jersey lifestyle. The popular “Baker’s Dozen Value Pack” with two tubs of cream cheese is a testament to its role as a Sunday family must-have, a tradition beloved by local customers for sharing fresh bagels with everyone.

***

Location and Accessibility

The Manhattan Bagel location in Toms River is strategically situated to serve the local community and those traveling through the area. Finding a convenient and accessible spot is key in New Jersey, and this location delivers on both fronts.

The shop is located at: 14 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA.

Its position right on Route 37 makes it an easy stop for commuters and a highly visible destination for local patrons. The location is focused on ensuring every customer can easily access their delicious food and coffee, offering a hassle-free experience for a quick visit or a leisurely dine-in moment.

For customer convenience, the establishment provides multiple accessibility features and parking options:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Free parking lot
• Free street parking

These thoughtful amenities make it a welcoming spot for all members of the Toms River community and surrounding Ocean County areas.

***

Services Offered

Manhattan Bagel offers a comprehensive range of services designed to meet the demands of busy New Jersey residents, whether you’re rushing out the door or hosting a meeting.

• Delivery: Enjoy all your favorites brought right to your door for maximum convenience.
• In-store pickup: Place your order ahead of time and grab it quickly on your way.
• Takeout: Perfect for a quick meal to enjoy on the go.
• In-store shopping: Browse the wide array of fresh bagels and baked goods in a welcoming setting.
• Dine-in: A comfortable atmosphere for those who wish to sit and enjoy their meal and a cup of coffee.
• Catering: Specialized options like the “Broadway Breakfast Box” are available, featuring 13 assorted bagels, assorted pastries, and cream cheese, making it simple to feed a large group for any event or gathering.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for easy transactions.

***

Features and Highlights

What sets Manhattan Bagel apart for the New Jersey bagel enthusiast is their authentic approach to bagel making, combined with an expansive menu that covers both classic and creative options. Here are some of the standout features:

• Authentic New York-Style Bagels: The core of the business, where bagels are made fresh daily, boiled and baked to achieve the signature New York texture—chewy inside, crisp outside.
• All-Day Breakfast: Serving breakfast classics all day long, including hot sandwiches like the highly popular “Original Bagel Classic Sandwich,” “Croissant Classic Sandwich,” and specialized options like the “Nova Lox Sandwich.”
• New Jersey Local Favorites: Customers consistently praise the inclusion of local staples. While not explicitly listed on the menu with the name, the breakfast sandwiches with various meats satisfy the local craving for a hearty morning meal.
• Extensive Lunch Menu: Offering robust lunch choices beyond traditional bagel sandwiches, including “Signature Lunch Sandwiches” like the “Manhattan Cheesesteak Sandwich Lunch” and “Ellis Island Hot Pastrami Sandwich Lunch,” along with deli classics like “Turkey & Cheddar” and “Chicken Salad.”
• Gourmet Coffee and Espresso Bar: Serving 100% Arabica artisan-roasted coffee and a full selection of espresso drinks, including Mochas, Lattes, and a refreshing “Coffee To-Go” box for groups.
• Variety of Baked Goods: In addition to bagels, they offer a rotating selection of fresh muffins—including seasonal options like the “Pumpkin Muffin”—and other pastries.
• Fresh & Wholesome Options: The menu features lighter and healthier choices, such as the “Classic Egg White Sandwich,” “Fresh Fruit Salad,” and “Yogurt Parfait,” ensuring options for health-conscious diners.

***

Contact Information

For planning your next visit, placing an order, or inquiring about catering, you can reach Manhattan Bagel with the following information:

Address: 14 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA

Phone: (732) 240-0177

***

What Is Worth Choosing at Manhattan Bagel

While the entire menu is filled with quality options, certain items stand out as customer favorites and represent the best of what Manhattan Bagel has to offer. For a quintessential New Jersey bagel experience, look no further than the fresh-baked goods and the hearty sandwiches.

If you are feeding a group, the Baker’s Dozen Value Pack ($26.49) is the undeniable champion. It provides thirteen fresh bagels and two tubs of your preferred cream cheese spread, making it perfect for weekend brunches, office meetings, or family gatherings—a true community staple.

For a hot breakfast, the Original Bagel Classic Sandwich ($10.29)—featuring egg, cheese, and your choice of meat on a fresh bagel—is a beloved standard that consistently receives high praise. For those looking for a flavorful twist, the Ranchero Wrap ($9.99) offers a delicious combination of spicy and savory ingredients to kickstart your day.

When it comes to lunch, the New York influence shines brightest in the grilled sandwiches. The Ellis Island Hot Pastrami Sandwich Lunch ($10.99) and the Manhattan Cheesesteak Sandwich Lunch ($10.99) offer a savory, deli-style experience that travels well and satisfies a hefty appetite. The quality of the meat and the use of fresh bread or bagels for these creations make them a great choice over standard fast-food fare.

Manhattan Bagel is a proud part of the Toms River community, providing a daily dose of authentic New York-style flavor in the heart of New Jersey. Whether for a morning coffee and plain cream cheese, a full family breakfast order, or a satisfying lunch, this local bagel shop remains a top choice for fresh, quality meals.