Matt's Bakery

For residents across Ohio, Matt's Bakery stands as a truly unique and essential culinary destination in Columbus. Far more than just a typical local bakery, this establishment operates as a full-service Glatt Kosher institution, providing a critical resource to the Central Ohio community. Its dedication to specialized dietary needs and high standards of preparation, overseen by the Kosher Supervision of the Vaad Hoir of Columbus, makes it a cornerstone for those seeking quality baked goods of a "more Hebrew bent," as one patron eloquently described.

Matt's Bakery is particularly celebrated for its specialization. All of its baked goods are Parve (dairy and milk-free), and the bakery operates with rigorous controls, even being nut-free for the vast majority of its products (with exceptions like the pecan pie made in isolation). This commitment makes it an invaluable option for individuals and families managing specific dietary needs or allergies within the Ohio area. The product range is simply astonishing, spanning from foundational breads and pastries to elaborate celebration cakes, alongside a growing selection of kosher grocery and deli items. This expansion into a broader service model, following its move to the current dedicated location, has transformed Matt's Bakery into a vital community hub.

The quality, according to customers, fully justifies the slightly higher price point compared to mass-produced alternatives. Patrons consistently find the taste "wonderful," even when trying ingredients they "might not normally try." This sentiment underscores the bakery's skill in crafting exceptional flavors across its entire menu, from the signature Challah to the intricate Mocha Cake and Black Forest Cake. The positive, helpful staff, including team members like Mindy, further enhance the experience, ensuring that every Ohio visitor is met with friendly service and expert assistance for their baking needs, whether routine or highly specialized.

Location and Accessibility

Matt's Bakery is conveniently located in the Columbus area at 39 S Yearling Rd, Columbus, OH 43213, USA. The bakery’s move to this larger, independent location in September 2022 allowed it to expand its offerings, turning it into a more comprehensive resource for the East Columbus and Whitehall communities.

The business is well-equipped to serve a broad range of the Ohio community, prioritizing both convenience and physical access:

• Accessibility Features: The bakery provides essential facilities, including a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that the space is welcoming and navigable for patrons with mobility challenges.
• Service Convenience: The business is strategically set up for a Quick visit, making it efficient for customers needing to pick up a morning pastry, a loaf of bread, or a pre-ordered cake. Furthermore, the availability of Delivery and Takeout services extends its reach, offering convenience to residents across the greater Columbus area, especially for custom orders or large grocery hauls.

Services Offered

Matt's Bakery operates as a hybrid establishment, seamlessly blending traditional bakery services with deli and small grocery offerings to provide comprehensive support to the Ohio community.

• Retail and Fulfillment: Key service options include Delivery for the ultimate convenience, and Takeout for fast pickup. Customers can also shop in-store for groceries, deli items, and freshly baked goods.
• Specialized Payments: In a commitment to community support, the bakery accepts various payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and importantly, SNAP/EBT, making high-quality kosher and specialized foods accessible to more Ohio families.
• Extensive Menu Categories: The offerings go far beyond simple baked goods, encompassing a wide range of Cakes, Pies, Breads (including a vast Challah selection), Cookies, and full Breakfast and Lunch items like Omelets, Pancakes, and Smoked Salmon Egg Sandwiches.

Features / Highlights

The defining features of Matt's Bakery are its deep product specialization and its exceptional role as a community-focused resource in Central Ohio.

• Specialized Kosher and Allergy Safety: As a Glatt Kosher, Parve bakery, all products are dairy-free, and the operation maintains near-nut-free status, making it a reliable choice for customers with milk or nut allergies. The Gluten Free items, such as Gluten Free Pumpkin Pie ($9.99) and Gluten Free Snickerdoodles ($7.99), though made in a facility that handles wheat, expand their options considerably.
• Signature Challah and Bread Selection: The bakery is renowned for its bread, especially its signature Challah ($7.50), which is available in various forms including Round Challah ($7.25), Raisin Challah ($7.50), and Ceremonial Challah ($12.00). Other breads like Marble Rye ($4.49) and Pita (6Pk) ($5.25) are also available.
• Extensive Dessert Menu: The cake menu is enormous, featuring over a dozen 8" cakes all priced around $22.49, including classics like Black Forest Cake, Chocolate Mousse Cake, and unique items like Iced Orange Bundt Cake ($12.50). They also feature seasonal favorites like Rugelach ($4.99/dozen) and various pies.
• Full-Service Deli and Prepared Foods: Beyond sweets, the bakery provides hearty Breakfast and Lunch options, multiple soups (Butternut Squash Soup, Onion Soup, Split Pea Soup), and deli staples like Potato Knishes (4Pk) ($7.50), reflecting its expanded grocery and deli capacity.
• Exceptional Customization and Service: Staff members like Mindy are highlighted for their expertise and "cheery" disposition, demonstrating an ability to deliver beautiful, custom-designed cakes, such as the lactose-free cake for a rehearsal dinner, on time and at a reasonable price.

Contact Information

For residents across Ohio looking to connect with Matt's Bakery for general inquiries, custom orders, or delivery service, please use the following contact information.

• Address: 39 S Yearling Rd, Columbus, OH 43213, USA
• Phone: (614) 237-4848
• Mobile Phone: +1 614-237-4848

What is Worth Choosing

Matt's Bakery is an absolutely essential choice for any Ohio resident seeking a highly specialized, full-service bakery experience. Choosing Matt's means prioritizing uncompromising quality and the peace of mind that comes with their Glatt Kosher, Parve certification—a critical, often hard-to-find resource in Central Ohio. This is the place to go for specialty needs, whether it's a lactose-free cake designed with a beautiful mid-Century motif, a nut-free option, or staple holiday items like Challah and Rugelach.

The value proposition is robust: the quality of the ingredients and the handmade nature of the goods "more than makes up for" the slightly higher cost than mass-produced alternatives. Beyond baked goods, the convenience of finding a wide range of kosher groceries, deli meats, and prepared foods—from Potato Kugel to full Grilled Salmon Sandwiches—in one location is a tremendous benefit to the local community. Furthermore, the acceptance of SNAP/EBT and the willingness of the friendly staff to help with custom and complex orders underscore its role as a supportive, community-focused small business. For Ohio patrons looking for tradition, variety, exceptional service, and certified quality, Matt's Bakery is the definitive choice.