Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too!

For New Yorkers, a truly exceptional bagel shop isn't just about the bagels; it's about the entire experience—the aroma, the friendly faces, and the comforting knowledge that you're getting a quality meal. On Long Island, in the welcoming community of Farmingville, Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! has emerged as a true standout, consistently earning rave reviews from locals who declare it "hands down one of the best local bagel shops I’ve ever been to." This beloved establishment prides itself on delivering not just delicious food, but also a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasure.

Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! shines brightly thanks to its unwavering commitment to freshness and customer satisfaction. From the moment you step through the door, you're greeted with a "cozy, welcoming atmosphere" and the irresistible scent of freshly baked goods. What truly sets this place apart, however, are the owners and staff, who are described as "genuinely friendly, welcoming, and clearly care about their customers and the quality of the food." This palpable pride in their business translates into "delicious and satisfying" bagels that are "crispy on the outside and perfectly soft and chewy inside," along with perfectly crafted sandwiches and surprisingly good coffee. For Long Islanders seeking that quintessential New York bagel experience, delivered with genuine care and at a reasonable price, Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! is undoubtedly the place to be.

Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! is conveniently situated at 1055 Portion Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738, USA. This prime location in Farmingville, a bustling hamlet in Suffolk County on Long Island, makes it highly accessible for residents across the central Long Island area. Portion Road is a well-known artery, ensuring easy navigation for those traveling by car, and the surrounding commercial area typically offers ample parking, contributing to a hassle-free visit. For New Yorkers in the surrounding towns, this spot is an ideal choice for a quick breakfast or lunch pick-up without venturing too far. Its easy access makes it a perfect stop for daily commuters, families grabbing a weekend treat, or anyone looking for a reliable and delicious meal in the area.

• Freshly Baked Bagels: At the heart of Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too!'s offerings are their delicious, fresh bagels, praised for their crispy exterior and soft, chewy interior. They offer a wide range of bagel types, including popular choices like plain, sesame, poppy, everything, and flagels (flattened bagels). Customers can purchase single bagels, mini bagels, half dozens, or full dozens.

• Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: To complement their bagels, they provide a variety of cream cheese options, including plain, flavored cream cheeses, and lox spread.

• Breakfast Bagel & Roll Sandwiches: A highly popular category, their breakfast sandwiches are available on bagels, rolls, or heroes. Options include classic combinations like Bacon, Egg, and Cheese (B/E/C), Sausage, Egg, and Cheese (S/E/C), Ham, Egg, and Cheese (H/E/C), and Turkey Bacon, Egg, and Cheese (TB/E/C). Customers can also "Create Your Own Egg Sandwich" with various choices of eggs (any style) and Boar's Head cheese.

• Signature & Deli Sandwiches: For lunch or a more substantial meal, they offer an impressive selection of signature sandwiches, wraps, and classic deli options. These include creations like "Italian Mobster," "Long Island Love," "Plymouth Rock" (Turkey, Bacon, Melted Swiss & Russian Dressing), "California Chicken," and various chicken cutlet sandwiches. They also feature traditional deli choices such as Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, and Boar's Head cold cuts.

• Coffee and Beverages: To complete any meal, they serve "surprisingly good" coffee, described as "rich and smooth," setting it apart from average diner coffee. They also offer a range of other hot and cold beverages.

• Side Dishes: Common side dishes often accompany sandwiches or are available à la carte, such as home fries. Other menu items may include options like French fries, onion rings, and a variety of salads (though a full salad bar is not explicitly mentioned, they offer specific salads like "Tuna Deluxe").

• Exceptional Bagel Quality: Consistently praised for their "delicious," "crispy on the outside and perfectly soft and chewy inside" bagels that are "freshly made," indicating a high standard of quality.

• Outstanding Customer Service: The owners and staff are frequently highlighted as "genuinely friendly, welcoming," "fast," and always getting the order right, even during busy rushes. This creates a highly positive and comfortable atmosphere.

• Clean and Inviting Environment: Customers consistently note that "the place is always clean and inviting" and "everything from the counter to the tables is always spotless," contributing to a pleasant dining experience.

• Reasonable Pricing & Value: Despite the high quality and generous portions, prices are described as "super reasonable," with customers often walking away "full and happy for under $10."

• Perfect Egg Sandwiches: The egg sandwiches, particularly on a toasted everything bagel, receive specific praise for being "absolutely perfect," with fluffy eggs and melted cheese.

• Quality Coffee: The coffee is noted for being "surprisingly good—rich and smooth," a refreshing contrast to typical diner coffee and a perfect complement to their bagels.

• Pride in Business: Reviewers feel the "pride they put into their business," which translates into consistent quality and a commitment to customer satisfaction.

Address: 1055 Portion Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738, USA

Phone: (631) 846-4468

Mobile Phone: +1 631-846-4468

For New Yorkers, especially those in Farmingville and the surrounding Long Island communities, Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended local business. It embodies everything a discerning local seeks in a neighborhood bagel spot: consistently delicious, fresh bagels with the ideal texture, a broad menu that caters to all cravings from breakfast to lunch, and an inviting atmosphere.

What truly cements its place as a local favorite is the remarkable dedication of the owners and staff. Their genuine friendliness, professionalism, and commitment to ensuring every order is perfect, even during the busiest times, create a welcoming experience that makes customers feel valued. The emphasis on cleanliness and the "super reasonable" prices further enhance its appeal, providing excellent value without compromising on quality or portion size. Whether it's a quick morning grab-and-go, a satisfying lunch, or simply a desire for a "classic New York bagel shop that does everything right," Mayfair Bagel Cafe Too! delivers time and again, making it an indispensable part of the Farmingville community for any Long Islander.