This spot near downtown Ft Lauderdale was a great place to satisfy my craving for a bagel sandwich! The setup is nice and the bagels are baked fresh. As busy as they were with to-go orders, our food was ready quickly. As was recommended, I ordered the bacon/egg/cheese on everything bagel and my husband ordered the pastrami/egg/cheese on plain bagel. Also got the French toast bites. All in all, the service was great, friendly and we really enjoyed our food. The only negative for us was the price point. Compared to other bagel shops, this is a bit more expensive. Now, don't let that keep you from checking them out! You can't put a price on service so maybe it's worth a few extra bucks. They have multiple locations and more going up, so put Mitch's on your breakfast list.
Aug 9 · Rhonda SoriMitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe
540 N Andrews Ave, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
Essential details
- Address
- 540 N Andrews Ave, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301, USA
- Phone
- (754) 779-7599
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 711 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- Tuesday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Wednesday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Thursday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Friday7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Saturday8:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday8:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
## Introduction / Overview
For Florida locals in the Fort Lauderdale area searching for a true New York-style bagel experience paired with an expansive, creative deli menu, Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe is the premier destination. Positioned as a dedicated Bagel shop, Mitch's has swiftly become a Flagler Village staple, successfully blending the tradition of an old-school New York deli with a trendy, elevated culinary twist. It’s an ideal spot for those who demand fresh, high-quality ingredients for both breakfast and lunch.
Mitch's is renowned for its freshly baked bagels and an impressive variety of homemade spreads, or 'schmears,' including savory options like BACON SCALLION CREAM CHEESE and FETA DILL CREAM CHEESE. The menu, however, extends far beyond the basics, offering a full range of inventive breakfast favorites and massive deli creations. Popular items include signature egg sandwiches like the highly-rated BACON, EGG AND CHEESE and adventurous brunch plates like The Hangover and FRENCH TOAST BITES, the latter of which have been praised by customers as the "best French toast I've ever had."
What truly sets Mitch's apart is its commitment to both product quality and exceptional hospitality. Customers frequently praise the friendly service and how well the team manages even busy periods, ensuring food is ready quickly despite a high volume of to-go orders. This blend of authentic New York flavors and warm South Florida service makes Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe a stand-out choice for locals.
---
## Location and Accessibility
Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe is centrally located in the vibrant Flagler Village neighborhood of Fort Lauderdale, making it easily accessible for downtown workers, residents, and visitors seeking a quality breakfast or lunch.
The shop’s exact location is:
540 N Andrews Ave, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301, USA
The establishment is designed to be highly accommodating, offering services that fit various dining preferences, from a quick solo visit to a full sit-down meal:
Access and Convenience:
- The facility is fully accessible, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, and Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating.
- Service options are diverse, including Delivery, In-store pickup, Takeout, and comfortable Dine-in arrangements.
- The atmosphere supports a Quick visit but also provides Amenities such as a clean Restroom and Wi-Fi.
Parking in the downtown area is primarily Paid street parking, so local customers should plan accordingly. For transaction ease, the shop accepts all modern forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
---
## Services Offered
Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe offers a surprisingly extensive menu that goes well beyond a basic bagel and schmear, covering both breakfast and lunch needs with a distinctly New York deli flair:
- Signature Bagels & Schmears:
- Freshly baked LOOSIE BAGELS and BAGEL DOZEN ($25.30).
- A variety of decadent Schmears including BACON SCALLION CREAM CHEESE ($7.45) and specialty NOVA CREAM CHEESE ($9.35).
- All-Day Breakfast & Brunch:
- Creative, high-demand breakfast sandwiches like THE BECTA ($17.05) and PASTRAMI BFAST ($18.15).
- Full plates like Egg Plates And Omelttes (e.g., THE BIG BOY OMELET $20.35) and indulgent Pancakes & French Toast options (e.g., NUTELLA FRENCH TOAST $15.95).
- Trendy options like WAKE THE F UP AVO ($15.40) and SALMON AVO ($19.80) from the Avocado Toasts section.
- New York Deli & Smoked Fish:
- Classic NY Deli Sandwiches such as LEAN CORNED BEEF ($22.00) and specialty combinations like THE NEW YORKER (a pile of corned beef and pastrami).
- House-made salads like MITCH'S FAMOUS TUNA SALAD ($18.70) and premium Nova Sandwiches like NOVA SUPREME ($20.90) and "THE CHOPPED BAGEL" ($20.90).
- Catering and Bulk Deli:
- Deli By The Pound for various meats and fresh salads (e.g., SLICED NOVA, BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD, WHITEFISH CHUNK) and a full catering program ideal for corporate meetings or Florida-based special events.
- Hot Soups And Noshes like POTATO KNISH ($7.70) and QUART OF MATZOH BALL SOUP ($14.85).
- Beverages & Desserts:
- A full Coffee And Espresso bar, featuring drinks like ICED LAVENDER MATCHA LATTE ($8.25) and COLD BREW ($7.15).
- A selection of Sweets And Desserts like RUGELACH ($11.00) and BLACK & WHITE COOKIE ($6.05).
- The inclusion of Craft Wine And Beer (e.g., MIMOSA PACKAGE $28.60) suggests a full brunch experience.
---
## Features / Highlights
Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe stands out in the competitive Fort Lauderdale dining scene with several key highlights focused on quality, convenience, and unique menu items:
- New York Deli Authenticity in FL: The cafe brings an authentic New York-style deli experience to South Florida, specializing in high-quality, generously portioned deli meats, smoked fish, and classic recipes like Matzoh Ball Soup and Potato Pancakes.
- Creative Bagel Sandwiches and Brunch: They are known for their innovative bagel sandwich creations, such as THE HANGOVER and the truffle oil-infused THE BECTA, which elevate the traditional egg sandwich into a gourmet meal.
- Fresh-Baked Quality: Customers consistently affirm that the bagels are baked fresh, ensuring the chewy-yet-crisp texture that defines a great bagel, which is critical for bagel aficionados.
- Highly Praised Customer Service: The staff is recognized for being friendly and patient, particularly in assisting with issues like loyalty program sign-ups and managing the high demand of in-store and catering orders, ensuring a positive experience despite the rush.
- Extensive Catering Program: Mitch's offers a robust catering menu, featuring platters of bagels, cream cheese, Nova, deli meats, and even hot breakfast bars. This makes them a reliable local partner for corporate meetings, client events, and large family gatherings across Fort Lauderdale.
- Full-Service Menu Depth: Beyond bagels, the menu offers full Pancakes & French Toast options, Wraps, and specialty coffees, positioning the cafe as an all-encompassing breakfast and lunch destination.
---
## Contact Information
For local Florida residents interested in visiting, ordering takeout, or arranging a catering order, here is the direct contact information for Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe:
Address: 540 N Andrews Ave, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301, USA
Phone: (754) 779-7599
Mobile Phone: +1 754-779-7599
For catering requests or to place a large order, customers are encouraged to call ahead or visit the official website for the full catering menu and advance booking details. The ability to manage large catering orders effectively is a major advantage for local businesses and residents.
---
## What is worth choosing
Choosing Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe is worthwhile for Fort Lauderdale residents because it offers a rare combination of authentic New York deli quality and a forward-thinking, creative menu tailored for a modern Florida clientele. If you are looking to satisfy a serious craving for a freshly baked bagel that is truly baked to a high standard, this is your local spot.
The value proposition lies in the breadth and quality of the menu. Customers can start their day with a simple, perfectly executed BAGEL WITH PLAIN CREAM CHEESE or dive into a substantial meal like the CORNED BEEF REUBEN or one of the specialty Nova Sandwiches. This versatility makes Mitch's the perfect single stop for a quick breakfast, a working lunch, or catering a client event with a high-quality food presentation.
While some patrons note the price point is slightly higher than competitors, they overwhelmingly conclude that the cost is justified by the excellent customer service and the superior quality of the ingredients and finished products. For the quality-conscious Florida consumer, the fresh bagels, premium deli meats, and dedicated service make Mitch's Downtown Bagel Cafe a clear winner in the local bagel shop category.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Paid street parking
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
I recently catered from Mitch’s Bagel Downtown for my client during Housekeeping Week, and they did not disappoint! The bagels were fresh, delicious, and a huge hit with everyone. Their quality and presentation truly elevated the breakfast, and I couldn’t have asked for a better experience.On top of that, I ran into a small issue creating a login to start earning points, and their team was super helpful and patient in getting everything set up for me. Excellent customer service paired with amazing food makes this place a standout. Highly recommend Mitch’s Bagel for both catering and everyday cravings!
Sep 17 · Hanan Alba✨Mitch Downtown Bagel Shop in Fort Lauderdale is a must. The food? Next level. The service? Spot-on every time. You can taste the love in everything they make. 🥯☕️But let me put you on…the French toast. 🤯 Golden, fluffy, and just the right amount of sweet—it’s honestly worth the trip all by itself. If you know, you know.This place isn’t just breakfast, it’s an experience. 🌟
Sep 18 · Keith KwanWe are in town for a short trip, and this was our first visit to Mitch’s. It did not disappoint! The bagels were fantastic and toasted perfectly. We also had an iced latte and a hot latte, both of which were great as well. The space is clean and bright with a friendly, welcoming vibe. It’s not a full-service restaurant as you order at the counter, but the young lady who helped us, Makayla, still came around and checked in with us and other tables to be sure everyone was good and had what they needed. Excellent service. 10/10 all around experience. We will definitely be back!
Apr 3 · Brienna GSo delish! Wonderful, attentive service & friendly atmosphere. Had these fried chicken & syrup sandwich bites too as a lovely surprise. So good. Thank you!
Aug 31 · Michaela PaladioCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
Amish Pie Stand #2
on 896 south, 1461 Georgetown rd, ft on the left before, Noble Rd #500, Bart Township, PA 17509, USA
Alfred & Sam's Italian Bakery
17 Fairview Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.