Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse

In the charming town of Hawley, Pennsylvania, there’s a truly special bakery that feels less like a business and more like a cherished secret. Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse, nestled in a turn-of-the-century family home, offers a unique and intimate baking experience that is a world away from a typical storefront. This isn't your average bakery; it's a home-based operation run by Chef Marcia Dunsmore and her family, who have a deep passion for creating delicious, high-quality baked goods. The atmosphere is steeped in history and warmth, with the oven that bakes their creations having "roasted countless family feasts" over the years. This personal touch and a commitment to tradition are what make every item from Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse so memorable.

The core philosophy of Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse is a dedication to using the finest ingredients and a fresh, seasonal approach. All of their ingredients are "organic and carefully sourced," a detail that shines through in the flavor of their products. Chef Marcia is a "culinary artist inspired by the seasons and a bounty of local produce," which means the menu is always changing. This ensures that customers get to experience new and exciting creations on a regular basis, keeping the offerings fresh and engaging. Their breads, for instance, are not just a daily staple but a rotating selection that has included fan favorites like Hawley Sourdough, Spent Grains, and even unique options like Witches Brew Bread. This creative flair is part of what makes the bakery a true local gem.

Beyond their impressive range of breads, Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse also excels at creating delectable sweets. Their past offerings have included treats like Chocolate Babka, Carrot Raisin Bread, and classic Afghan & Choc Chip Cookies. They also craft a variety of fruit spreads to pair perfectly with their fresh-baked loaves, adding another layer of deliciousness to their products. This attention to detail and a broad range of items, all made with the same high standards, show a comprehensive and dedicated approach to baking. The team, including Marcia's husband, David, and a crew of "hard-working family friends," are known for their warm greetings and friendly atmosphere, making every interaction feel personal and welcoming.

The bakery’s unique structure as a home-based business adds to its charm. It allows for a more focused and personal baking process, where every batch is given the full attention it deserves. This isn't a high-volume factory; it's a place where food is "baked with love," and you can taste the difference. The fact that they operate by appointment and at local farmers' markets creates a sense of exclusivity and makes each purchase feel like a special treat. This model also allows them to maintain a close connection with their community, whether it’s through a personal interaction at the counter or a friendly chat at a market booth.

Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse is a testament to the power of a small, local business that is driven by passion and quality. The use of fresh, local, and organic ingredients not only makes their products taste better but also reflects a commitment to the community and the environment. In a world of mass-produced goods, this bakery offers a refreshing return to artisanal craftsmanship. The rotating menu, inspired by the seasons, ensures that there’s always a reason to come back and see what new creations Chef Marcia has come up with. It is a true culinary highlight for the Hawley area, a place where "Classical Breads & Rock 'n Roll Sweets" are made with care.

The bakery’s appeal is also rooted in its story. The idea of a bakehouse in a historic family home, with a legacy of love and food, resonates deeply with people. It’s not just about buying a loaf of bread; it's about buying a piece of that history and passion. This emotional connection is something that larger commercial bakeries simply can't replicate. It makes Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse a truly special part of the community and a must-visit for anyone who values authenticity and quality.

Location and Accessibility

Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse is located at 500 Myrtle Ave, Hawley, PA 18428. As a home bakery, it operates on a different schedule than a traditional storefront. The business is open by appointment, which provides a personalized and focused experience for customers. Additionally, locals can find their products at the Hawley Farmers' Market and sometimes at the Narrowsburg Farmers' Market in New York. This dual presence allows them to reach a wide audience while maintaining the intimate feel of a home bakery. The peaceful, residential location on a hill overlooking the town adds to its charm and unique character, making a visit to the bakehouse itself a pleasant experience.

Services Offered

• Artisanal Breads: A rotating selection of breads like Hawley Sourdough and Spent Grains, all freshly baked with organic ingredients.
• Gourmet Sweets: A variety of pastries and cookies, including fan favorites like Chocolate Babka and Afghan cookies.
• Seasonal Specials: The menu changes with the seasons, inspired by local produce, offering new creations to try regularly.
• Handcrafted Spreads: Unique spreads and jams, crafted with whimsy, to pair perfectly with their breads.
• Farmers' Market Presence: Find their products at local farmers' markets in Hawley, PA, and Narrowsburg, NY.
• By-Appointment Service: The home bakery is open for customers to pick up orders by appointment.

Features / Highlights

• Organic and Carefully Sourced Ingredients: A strong commitment to using only the best, organic ingredients in all their products.
• Home Bakery Charm: Operates from a historic family home, providing a unique and intimate atmosphere.
• Seasonal and Rotating Menu: New creations are regularly added, inspired by local produce and the seasons.
• Community-Focused: A friendly, family-run business known for warm greetings and a welcoming feel.
• "Classical Breads & Rock 'n Roll Sweets": A unique philosophy that blends traditional baking with creative new ideas.

Contact Information

Address: 500 Myrtle Ave, Hawley, PA 18428, USA

Phone: (570) 226-3267

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse is the perfect fit for the Hawley, Pennsylvania, community because it represents the very best of local, artisanal food. Its unique model as a home bakery, combined with a presence at local farmers' markets, allows it to serve the community in a personal and meaningful way. Locals can enjoy a constantly evolving menu of delicious baked goods, all made with organic and carefully sourced ingredients, a commitment that is highly valued. The warm, friendly atmosphere and personal touch from Chef Marcia and her family make every interaction a pleasure. This bakery isn't just about food; it's about a passion for baking, a love for the community, and a dedication to quality that shines through in every loaf of bread and every sweet treat. For Hawley residents who appreciate authenticity and a true taste of home, Myrtle Avenue Bakehouse is an essential and cherished local institution.