Phenomenal service, and great food! Uber Eats messed up big time and I brought my order to the store myself. The owner was there and helped me immediately. She remade my order in minutes and even gave me extra fries because of the inconvenience that was not even her fault! I got the Hot Open Faced Roast Beef and it did not disappoint! Delicious! Highly suggest going to this place!
Aug 21 · Kenneth MBAKERY PROFILE
Not Just Bagels
★ 3.0619 recorded reviews$1–10
1910 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 1910 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA
- Phone
- (718) 351-8870
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 619 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- Monday5:30 AM – 3:00 PM
- Tuesday5:30 AM – 3:00 PM
- Wednesday5:30 AM – 3:00 PM
- Thursday5:30 AM – 3:00 PM
- Friday5:30 AM – 3:00 PM
- Saturday5:30 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview: Not Just Bagels – The Staten Island Name Says It All
In the competitive culinary world of New York City, a business must truly deliver on its name to stand out. Not Just Bagels, located right here on Staten Island, does exactly that. Categorized not merely as a Bagel shop, but also as an American restaurant, Bakery, Coffee shop, Deli, Takeout Restaurant, and Sandwich shop, this establishment at 1910 Hylan Blvd offers a massive, multifaceted menu that caters to every conceivable craving from dawn till dinner. For local New Yorkers, this means finding authentic, high-quality bagels alongside a dizzying array of breakfast, lunch, and specialty items.
The core appeal, of course, starts with the bagels, offered by the piece, the dozen, or as specialty Flagels and Mini Bagels. However, the experience expands dramatically into elaborate breakfast options like 3 Egg Omelette Platters, creative pancakes (like the Fruity Pebbles variety), and unique French Toast styles. For the midday meal, the deli selection is formidable, featuring extensive Lunch Wraps, Paninis, Burger Bar items, and classics from the Lunch Hot Spot like the highly praised Hot Open Faced Roast Beef.
Furthermore, Not Just Bagels elevates the standard neighborhood spot with specialty offerings like the Lox Specialties menu, a dedicated Fit Zone for health-conscious diners, and an impressive Smoothies and Protein Shakes list. This dedication to variety and quality firmly establishes Not Just Bagels as an essential, all-encompassing food destination on Staten Island.
Location and Accessibility: Your Convenient Stop on Hylan Boulevard
The strategic location of Not Just Bagels is 1910 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA. Hylan Boulevard is one of the island’s most heavily traveled thoroughfares, making the shop highly visible and incredibly accessible for residents across multiple Staten Island neighborhoods.
Accessibility is a major factor for New York customers, and Not Just Bagels addresses this with practical solutions. The location provides the significant convenience of a Free parking lot, a highly valued feature in the busy NYC metro area, supplementing the availability of Free street parking. For those relying on public transit, Hylan Boulevard is served by numerous local and express bus lines, ensuring that New Yorkers can easily reach the location whether they are starting their day or taking a lunch break. Adding to the convenience is a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring the space is welcoming to all members of the community.
This easy-to-reach spot, combined with the promise of high-quality food, makes Not Just Bagels a practical and attractive daily dining option for Staten Island residents and visitors alike.
Services Offered
Not Just Bagels provides a comprehensive range of services tailored to meet the diverse needs of the New York consumer:
- Full In-Store Dining: Offering Dine-in service, allowing customers to enjoy their meals in a setting described as having a "Great atmosphere."
- Takeout & In-store Pickup: Fast and efficient service for customers placing orders online or grabbing items for a Quick visit.
- Delivery Service: Providing Delivery through various platforms to bring their extensive menu right to customers' doors across Staten Island.
- Catering and Large Orders: While not explicitly listed as a category, the vast menu—including Dozen Bagels, Lox by the pound, and full Omelette Platters—suggests they are well-equipped to handle large group orders and office catering.
- Specialty Coffee and Beverage Service: Serving high-quality Kobrick Coffee drinks, including Drip, Espresso, Cappuccino, and specialty Smoothies and Protein Shakes.
- Retail Dairy and Deli Items: Selling essential items like Cream Cheese By The Pound, various milks (including Oat Milk and Almond Milk), and Butter By The Pound.
- Diverse Payment Methods: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for speed and convenience.
Features / Highlights
The features and highlights of Not Just Bagels emphasize its wide variety, specialty offerings, and dedication to the customer experience, making it a standout in the NYC market:
- Unmatched Cream Cheese Variety: The shop offers an extensive selection of Specialty Cream Cheese Flavors, including unique creations like Cookie Monster, Apple Pie, Birthday Cake, and Jalapeno Cheddar, alongside classic flavors.
- Signature Breakfast Creations: Features highly creative and hearty breakfast items like the "Heart Attack Sandwich," Breakfast Quesadillas, and fun pancakes such as Cookie Monster and Fruity Pebbles.
- Gourmet Lunch Sandwiches: Boasts nearly 20 different Lunch Wraps and Paninis (all priced consistently at $11.95 or $12.95), plus specialty burgers like The What Do You Think This Is A Joke Burger and The Stuffed Nacho Burger.
- Full-Service Diner Menu Items: Beyond typical deli fare, they offer full-plated meals including Waffles, French Toast (Churro, Coconut, Apple Pie A La Mode), and a comprehensive Omelette Platter selection.
- Focus on Health and Modern Trends: Catering to various dietary needs with a dedicated Fit Zone menu (Avocado Egg White Omelette, Whole Wheat Pancakes), Avocado Toast variations, and a large selection of fresh Smoothies.
- Exceptional Customer Service: Customer reviews highlight the "Phenomenal service" and the owner’s willingness to go "above and beyond" to correct issues, underscoring a commitment to customer satisfaction.
Contact Information
New York residents looking to place an order, inquire about the extensive menu, or find directions to the Staten Island location can use the following confirmed contact details:
- Address: 1910 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA
- Phone: (718) 351-8870 or +1 718-351-8870 (Mobile)
What is Worth Choosing Not Just Bagels
For New Yorkers on Staten Island, choosing Not Just Bagels means opting for a destination that perfectly blends traditional NYC bagel culture with the vast offerings of a full-service restaurant and gourmet deli. The value proposition here is simple: comprehensive variety without compromising quality.
What truly makes it worth choosing is the ability to satisfy any craving at any time of day. You can start with a traditional bagel and lox, select a gourmet spread from the nearly two dozen Specialty Cream Cheese Flavors, or skip the bread entirely for a healthy option from the Fit Zone. The seamless transition from a breakfast spot to a full-fledged lunch destination—with expertly prepared hot entrees like the delicious Hot Open Faced Roast Beef and creative, juicy burgers—is unmatched by most single-focus bagel shops.
Furthermore, the customer experience is top-notch. The combination of a comfortable atmosphere, efficient service, and the convenience of both a dedicated Free parking lot and all modern payment methods makes the logistics of dining here effortless. The establishment’s dedication to resolving issues quickly and professionally, as noted in customer reviews, underscores their commitment to the community. When you want the quintessential New York bagel experience backed by a massive menu and outstanding service, Not Just Bagels is the smart choice on Hylan Boulevard.
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
island 18delivery 18bacon egg and cheese 8smoothie 7phone 7dollar 7management 7review 7potatoes 5grilled 5
Great atmosphere and customer service. I will say this is a classy version of a bagel store with specialty drinks. However, the cost of a plain butter bagel was a bit too much. I can assume the ambience adds a few extra dollars to the bagels.
Jan 19 · Ebenezer A. AwolesiThey never disappoint! We have ordered over the years catering from them for our office and they have always come through. Everything is always fresh and delicious. Even yesterday, we had to place a last minute catering order that was fairly large, and they were more than accommodating towards us and came through last minute. Colleen who answers the phones is such a sweetheart and pleasure to speak to. We will always support our local businesses and look forward to many orders from them.
Jul 30 · Lenny Kipnis (Homes R Us)So last week I placed an order spur of the moment because I needed to have a meeting with my employees. I spoke to Christine in the morning and last minute placed a catering order. She was very patient and i literally drove her crazy changing my order a few times… I’ve never ordered from here but my mom ranted and raved about their bagels. Well she couldn’t be more spot on. My pancakes was delicious, the bagels were so soft and fresh. Thank you for being 💯 perfect for for Accommodating my last-minute order. I will be forever, lacing orders with you guys in the future!!
Jul 31 · Melissa LottieI've held off on leaving a review because this at one time was my go to spot (every single morning). And there was two workers there that were nice to me, but after getting screwed yet again and then seeing how so many people feel the same I just can't hold back anymore. The prices this thief charges is an absolute joke, a bacon egg and cheese that's 90% bread, 2 eggs (at best) and one piece of bacon (and this wasn't a one time thing, it's every time). Also, you can order the same thing 5 days in a row and get it completely different every single day and makes it a gamble to get food from them because you never know what version of the food you will receive. You can tell the owner is extremely cheap too, to his staff and customers. After being there on a really busy day my order came to $20.20, I had two $20 bills on me. Instead of taking the $20 because A. I come in every single morning for a couple of years and B. I tipped every single morning as well they ran around trying to find change so they can give me $19.80..... that was enraging. Also, depending on who rings you up, your price changes. It's just a mess and honestly I let it all slide but the owner in these reviews comes off as such a clown, he deserves the hate. If the owner wants to continue to act like customers are the problem then maybe he should get into something more recession proof, strip club perhaps? You're on Hylan Boulevard with 40 bagel spots surrounding you, I guess keep burying your head in the sand, I'll be excited to see what opens up at that location next.
Apr 26 · GCThis page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.