Great local family business. I was greeted with a warm smile. Picked up some cookies for a Christmas get together (and for the ride home). The Christmas cake was yumm-o! I will most definitely be back.
Dec 13 · Matt EyerlyOccasional Cookie & More
1220 Hayes Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 1220 Hayes Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870, USA
- Phone
- (419) 621-7394
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 22 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For those of us in the Ohio area, particularly in the vibrant city of Sandusky, sometimes a craving hits for something sweet and comforting that only a local, dedicated shop can satisfy. Occasional Cookie & More is exactly that spot. Located conveniently on Hayes Ave, this specialized cookie shop is much more than just a place to grab a quick snack; it’s a great local family business that prides itself on delivering high-quality, delicious desserts with a warm, welcoming smile. It’s the perfect destination for both planning a centerpiece dessert for a special event, like a Christmas gathering, or simply treating yourself during a quick visit.
While their name highlights cookies, the "More" ensures that locals can count on them for a variety of treats, as evidenced by satisfied customers praising their Christmas cake as "yumm-o!" This versatility makes them a valuable resource in the Sandusky, OH, community for all things sweet. As a small, family-run operation, the service here is personal and friendly, creating the kind of experience that encourages repeat visits and builds strong neighborhood loyalty. Whether you're a local resident or just passing through Erie County, stopping by Occasional Cookie & More offers a taste of authentic local Ohio charm and quality baking.
It's important to note that, as a dedicated small business, their hours and stock can sometimes vary, reflecting a focus on quality and possibly custom orders or special deliveries. This means the freshest products are guaranteed, though a quick call ahead may be wise for late afternoon visits or large orders. This commitment to fresh, family-made quality is what makes them a treasured part of the Sandusky dessert scene.
Location and Accessibility
Occasional Cookie & More is easily found in a convenient location for all Sandusky, OH, residents and visitors. The shop is located at:
1220 Hayes Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870, USA
This address places them centrally for easy access, whether you're making a dedicated trip or swinging by on your way home. Accessibility is a key feature here, ensuring all members of the Ohio community can enjoy their treats. The location provides a wheelchair accessible parking lot, allowing for close and convenient parking. This is especially helpful when picking up a large order of cakes or cookies for a party, ensuring a hassle-free takeout experience from the car to your event. The convenience of their location and accessibility makes them a practical choice for a quick visit any time you need a sugar boost.
Services Offered
As a specialized cookie shop and bakery, Occasional Cookie & More offers a streamlined selection of services designed for quick, delightful dessert fulfillment:
Takeout Service: The primary service option is efficient takeout. Customers can quickly grab their chosen cookies, cakes, and desserts to enjoy elsewhere, perfect for parties or immediate cravings.
Dessert Sales: Offering a variety of freshly baked goods, the focus is on sweet treats, including their namesake cookies and other popular desserts like custom cakes.
Custom & Event Orders: They cater to special occasions, providing larger orders of cookies and specialized cakes for events like holiday gatherings and family parties, which are often discussed and arranged in advance.
Delivery Options: The business has been known to offer deliveries for specific arrangements, often communicated via social media platforms like Facebook, adding an extra layer of convenience for local customers.
Modern Payment Acceptance: Making transactions easy, they accept various modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
Features / Highlights
Occasional Cookie & More stands out in Sandusky, OH, not just for its sweet products but for the complete customer experience. Here are some key highlights that make them a favorite local spot in Ohio:
Great Local Family Business: Customers consistently praise the fact that it is a great local family business, often citing the warm, friendly service and personal touch that comes with a community-focused shop.
Warm and Welcoming Service: The owner or staff often greet customers with a warm smile, making the quick visit a genuinely pleasant experience.
Delicious Variety: While specializing in cookies, the "More" includes other high-quality desserts, such as cakes, with the Christmas cake being singled out as yumm-o! by satisfied patrons.
Convenient Payment Options: The acceptance of Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments makes transactions fast and hassle-free, streamlining the takeout process.
Easy Accessibility: The provision of a wheelchair accessible parking lot ensures convenient access for all customers, especially important when transporting large dessert orders.
Contact Information
To place a special order, confirm the day's availability, or inquire about their delivery options in Sandusky, OH, here is the essential contact information for Occasional Cookie & More:
Address: 1220 Hayes Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870, USA
Phone: (419) 621-7394
Using the dedicated local phone number is the best way to ensure your cookie or cake needs are met promptly, particularly for evening visits or large, custom orders.
What is Worth Choosing
For residents of Sandusky, OH, and surrounding areas, choosing Occasional Cookie & More is a decision to prioritize local quality and personalized service for your dessert needs. What makes them distinctly worth choosing is the combination of phenomenal desserts—like their highly praised cake and fresh cookies—with the genuine, warm atmosphere of a great local family business. When you walk through the door, you’re often greeted with a warm smile, making your quick visit feel personal and appreciated, which is a rare treat in today's retail environment.
You choose this cookie shop because you know the treats you pick up will be fresh, delicious, and made with care, whether they are cookies for the ride home or a special cake for a large gathering. The ability to cater to both immediate needs and pre-ordered party essentials (the "More") makes them incredibly versatile. While, as a small business, they might occasionally close early due to selling out or focusing on deliveries, this simply underscores their commitment to freshness and dedication to special orders, making it wise to call ahead for evening pickups. With the convenience of a wheelchair accessible parking lot and accepting all major modern Payments, Occasional Cookie & More at 1220 Hayes Ave is the perfect local Ohio choice for satisfying your sweet tooth with a side of authentic community charm.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Dessert
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
I went there today. I was there probably at about 5:20.They're open till 6:00. But today they were closed. They said they did deliveries on Facebook. So I left.
Aug 26 · Cheryl HaywardGreat little bakery! Has a large variety and the best white sheet cake with almond flavor!!😋
Dec 11 · Star BakerSmall little place, in a house, right in a neighborhood. We were expecting more of a selection, but overall it was a good experience. I think it was a little pricey. Wife was happy with the cookies, so would return.
Jul 17 · Brentle SgI stopped in and was greeted by a friendly female employee and the baker working in the back also enthusiastically said hello. We tried their pumpkin cream cheese muffins, their peanut butter truffle brownies, white and chocolate frosting brownies and two other varieties of muffins. All were very good and everyone in my family enjoyed them. I got about 20 items and spent 25 dollars. Moderately priced and although not mind blowing, will definitely please your palate. They wished me a Merry Christmas on the way out and I will definitely be back.
Dec 19 · Joseph JonesCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.












