Old School Bagel Cafe

Introduction / Overview: Old School Bagel Cafe – Authentic New York Style in Oklahoma City

For Oklahoma City residents seeking an authentic, satisfying bagel experience, Old School Bagel Cafe stands out as a genuine local gem. Located conveniently on North May Avenue, this establishment prides itself on bringing the time-honored tradition of water-boiled bagels—a method that creates the famous chewy-on-the-inside, crispy-on-the-outside texture of true New York-style bagels—right here to the heartland.

More than just a bagel shop, Old School Bagel Cafe functions as a versatile local cafe, breakfast restaurant, and lunch destination. It’s a place where you can quickly grab a morning classic or settle in for a relaxed lunch. Patrons consistently rank the shop as one of the best bagel options in the city, frequently praising the friendly, attentive staff who consistently greet them with a smile. The menu is robust, featuring a wide variety of freshly made bagels, savory breakfast sandwiches piled high with ingredients, satisfying lunch creations, and a full-service coffee bar. For many locals, the combination of a great bagel and their absolutely incredible, always fresh drip coffee makes starting the day here a non-negotiable routine.

Location and Accessibility: Quail Plaza Area Convenience

Old School Bagel Cafe’s North May Avenue location places it perfectly to serve the residents and professionals of Northwest Oklahoma City, including the Quail Plaza and surrounding shopping centers. Its address is:

10946 N May Ave #6202, Oklahoma City, OK 73120, USA

The area benefits from excellent transportation links and high visibility, making it easy to find for a quick visit or a morning meeting.

Accessibility is a key factor, ensuring all local community members can enjoy their offerings:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures smooth entry for all guests.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Available for convenient access from the moment you arrive.
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom: Prioritizing comfort and convenience inside the café.
• Parking Availability: Guests benefit from a free parking lot as well as the option for free street parking, easing the stress of a busy morning visit.

Services Offered: Catering, Coffee, and Customizable Meals

Old School Bagel Cafe offers a comprehensive range of services, cementing its role as a full-service café and caterer in the OKC metro:

• Full Breakfast and Lunch Dining: Offers a complete menu of breakfast and lunch options, available for dine-in, making it an excellent spot for a quick visit or a longer break.
• Artisan Coffee Bar: Serving a wide selection of coffee and espresso drinks, from Drip Coffee and Americanos to specialty items like Large Caramel Macchiatos and White Chocolate Mochas (available in 16 Oz and 20 Oz sizes).
• Bulk Bagel and Cream Cheese Sales: Offers Individual Bagels, Pre-Selected Bakers Dozens, and the option to Build Your Own Bakers Dozen, along with cream cheese in to-go sizes (2 Oz, 4 Oz, and 8 Oz).
• Multiple Service Options: Provides maximum customer convenience with Curbside pickup, Delivery, In-store pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout.
• Full-Service Catering: Specializes in catering for business meetings, office breakfasts, and events, offering everything from 'The Breakfast Box' and 'The Meats Tray' to 'The Mixed Sandwich Tray' and 'Coffee Totes.'
• Bagel Customization: Allows customers to customize their bagel, spread, and sandwich fillings extensively, ensuring every meal is exactly how they want it.

Features / Highlights: Quality and Variety that Locals Love

The distinguishing features of Old School Bagel Cafe are centered on the quality of their primary product and the breadth of their menu:

• Authentic Water-Boiled Bagels: The commitment to the traditional New York-style process results in a superior bagel texture that is a true standout in the Oklahoma market.
• Award-Worthy Drip Coffee: Customer reviews frequently and highly praise the quality of their drip coffee, noting it is "incredible" and always served fresh and warm, making it a powerful draw for coffee enthusiasts.
• Generously Loaded Sandwiches: The menu offers numerous well-regarded breakfast and lunch sandwiches that are "loaded," including favorites like the classic Sausage, Egg, & Cheese Bagel, the rich Lox & Cream Cheese, the spicy Firecracker, the hearty Meat Lovers Bagel, and lunch favorites like the Sooner Club and the 'Old Smokey' (smoked turkey with chive & onion cream cheese on an Everything Bagel).
• Comfortable and Spacious Vibe: The medium-sized café provides a welcoming atmosphere with ample seating, including a lounge area and outdoor patio seating, perfect for studying or catching up with friends.
• Diverse Cream Cheese Selection: Offers a variety of spreads beyond plain, including Flavored Cream Cheese, Bacon Chive & Onion, Lox Spread, and Nutella Cream Cheese, providing endless topping combinations.

Contact Information

For local residents looking to place a catering order, call ahead, or inquire about the day's fresh bagels, Old School Bagel Cafe on North May Avenue can be reached here:

Address: 10946 N May Ave #6202, Oklahoma City, OK 73120, USA

Phone: (405) 286-2233

Mobile Phone: +1 405-286-2233

What is Worth Choosing Old School Bagel Cafe

For local Oklahoma users, choosing Old School Bagel Cafe is an easy decision if you value true authenticity, variety, and a fantastic morning routine. It is simply one of, if not the best, bagel options available in the city, making it a must-try for any resident.

The Quality Commitment: The core reason to choose this spot is the superior product. Their commitment to the water-boiling process delivers a bagel texture and flavor profile that consistently delights those seeking genuine New York style. The quality extends beyond the bagel to the fillings and, notably, to their highly-praised coffee, which elevates the entire experience.

A One-Stop Shop for All Needs: Whether you need a quick, affordable, and loaded breakfast sandwich before heading to the office, a relaxed place with Wi-Fi to spend an afternoon, a satisfying lunch sandwich (like the 'Mile High Club' or the 'Cuban'), or a complete catering spread for a large group event, Old School Bagel Cafe has a comprehensive, reasonably priced menu to fit every need. The ability to customize your bagel and sandwich choices means you are never limited.

The combination of excellent, friendly customer service, great prices, and a product that stands toe-to-toe with the best in the country makes Old School Bagel Cafe a true North May Avenue staple and an excellent local business to support in the Oklahoma City metro area.