Pie Fight

Introduction / Overview: Pie Fight—The Ultimate Hand Pie Destination

For those living in or visiting the Utah area, particularly Salt Lake City, Pie Fight is a truly unique culinary gem that has built a loyal following. It’s a specialty bakery that has taken the humble pie and elevated it into a portable, gourmet experience. Unlike traditional bakeries that offer large, sit-down cakes or full-sized pies, Pie Fight focuses on hand pies—a perfectly portioned, delicious item that’s ideal for people on the go.

Located in the charming and popular 9th and 9th neighborhood, Pie Fight is far more than just a dessert spot. The menu is intentionally split between highly creative sweet flavors and surprisingly complex savory options, ensuring there is a perfect pie for any craving, any time of day. This distinction is what makes Pie Fight stand out in the competitive Salt Lake food scene; they cater to a Quick visit need while delivering top-notch, scratch-made quality.

Local patrons consistently rave about the quality of the crust—often described as incredibly flaky and buttery—a sign of the high-quality ingredients and attention to detail used by the bakers. This commitment to the perfect foundation is paired with seasonal and inventive fillings, resulting in a product that is both comforting and exciting. Whether you are grabbing a Coconut Macaroon pie for a sweet treat or a Sloppy Joe pie for a quick lunch, Pie Fight is a dedicated artisan bakery that offers a fresh, local perspective on a classic baked good.

Location and Accessibility

Pie Fight is perfectly situated in one of Salt Lake City’s most pedestrian-friendly and vibrant areas, the 9th and 9th neighborhood. This location contributes to its local, neighborhood charm and high accessibility for Utah residents.

The primary address is:

937 E 900 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84105, USA

While the shop itself is small and primarily designed for grab-and-go service, its placement in this bustling district ensures ease of access. Key logistical information for visitors includes:

• Service Format: The shop operates as a small, highly efficient operation, focusing on quick Takeout and In-store pickup through a walk-up window. There are typically no tables inside, though some external bench seating may be available seasonally for those wishing to enjoy their pies right away.
• Parking: Customers can utilize Free street parking available in the surrounding 9th and 9th area, a significant convenience for a popular downtown location.
• Accessibility: The bakery is committed to ensuring all patrons can access their goods, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot nearby.

The combination of excellent pies and convenient neighborhood access makes Pie Fight a mandatory stop when exploring this beloved section of Salt Lake City.

Services Offered

As a highly focused specialty bakery, Pie Fight concentrates on delivering an exceptional range of hand pies, complemented by a few essential services.

• Signature Hand Pies (Sweet): A rotating menu of inventive and classic sweet pies, featuring creative combinations and seasonal favorites. Examples from the menu include:
  • Bourbon Caramel Apple
  • Red Velvet Cake Pie
  • Peanut Butter S'mores Brownie
  • Raspberry Brownie Oreo
  • Banana Chocolate Chip
  • Classic Cherry
• Savory Hand Pies (Meal Replacements): Gourmet, substantial pies designed as a quick, flavorful meal. These often feature hearty ingredients encased in their famous flaky crust:
  • Macaroni & Cheese Pie ($9.40)
  • Chicken Pot Pie ($8.00)
  • Sloppy Joe ($8.00)
  • Tomato Caprese ($7.80)
  • Mushroom, Bacon & Swiss ($8.40)
  • Savory Sweet Potato & Sage ($7.80)
• Cinnamon Sugar Crust Bites: A popular, affordable treat made from leftover pie dough scraps, tossed in cinnamon and sugar. Known locally as "Scrappies."
• Beverages: Offering essential drinks to pair with their baked goods, including Coffee and Bottled Water.
• Convenient Order Fulfillment: Providing Delivery, Takeout, In-store pickup, and In-store shopping (via the walk-up window) to meet the diverse needs of the Salt Lake community.

Features / Highlights

Pie Fight distinguishes itself from other Utah bakeries through its specialization and commitment to a high-quality, handheld product.

• The Famous Flaky Crust: This is consistently cited by customers as the bakery's most defining feature. The rich, buttery, and perfectly flaky crust is the secret to both their sweet and savory success, proving that a great pie starts with a flawless shell.
• Gourmet Hand Pies: By focusing on the hand pie format, Pie Fight offers a convenient and perfectly sized alternative to the full-size dessert, making it easy to enjoy a truly gourmet product while on the move in the city.
• Inventive and Rotating Menu: The bakery is known for its creativity, offering unique flavor combinations like German Chocolate Bread Pudding Pie and Raspberry Eggnog, alongside popular seasonal choices like Peach Cobbler and Pumpkin Cream Cheese Crumble.
• Savory Meal Options: The inclusion of meal-sized savory pies, such as the Chicken Pot Pie and the hearty Macaroni & Cheese Pie, establishes the bakery as a great option for a unique and comforting lunch or quick dinner.
• Local Presence: Pie Fight is a true local Salt Lake City business that often connects with the community through appearances at local events like the Farmers Market, a practice that builds trust and loyalty within the Utah consumer base.

Contact Information

For local patrons in Utah wishing to place a large order, inquire about the daily rotating menu, or arrange a delivery, here is the essential contact information for Pie Fight.

Address: 937 E 900 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84105, USA

Phone: (385) 528-1184

For the fastest service, especially given the "grab and go" nature of the shop, utilizing their phone or online ordering options for In-store pickup or Delivery is highly recommended.

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Pie Fight in Salt Lake City, the best approach is to sample from both their sweet and savory offerings to truly appreciate the breadth of their skill.

For the ultimate savory experience, the Macaroni & Cheese Pie is a must-try. It takes a classic comfort food and wraps it in that perfectly flaky crust, creating a uniquely satisfying and substantial meal. The Savory Sweet Potato & Sage is also a fantastic choice for those looking for a sophisticated, warming flavor.

On the sweet side, the choice often depends on your preference, but the Bourbon Caramel Apple is a year-round favorite that perfectly balances tart fruit with rich, gooey caramel and a hint of warmth from the bourbon. The Coconut Macaroon is another fan-favorite for its decadent, dessert-bar-like filling.

However, no visit is complete without a side of Cinnamon Sugar Crust Bites (Scrappies). This simple, yet irresistible, item allows you to taste the essence of what makes Pie Fight so popular: that incredibly delicious, buttery crust. Given that the shop is primarily Takeout and focused on a Quick visit, picking up a mix of 2-3 pies—one savory, one sweet, and the Scrappies—provides a perfect, mobile feast for enjoying the rest of your day in the 9th and 9th neighborhood or elsewhere in Utah.