Remarkable find. Some time ago, driving up from the city, I was asked to pick up a birthday cake at this bakery. While waiting I spotted the classic Kaiser rolls - which I know quite a bit about. I bought a half dozen and they were as wonderful as they looked. Most rolls labeled as "Kaiser rolls" in other stores are not authentic. Genuine Kaiser rolls have unique characteristics including an outer crust and a soft denser inside. They are rare to find (in New York City, generally only in the outer boroughs). These were the real deal – and baked right on premises - in a family owned bakery. I always stop by now when I'm in the area. I stock up on Kaiser rolls and generally pick up one or two other items. Everything freshly baked right there. A delightful family owned business. The lady who is generally there on weekends is just charming once you get to know her. A real treasure in Pompton Lakes New Jersey. Easy 5 stars!
Apr 30 · WTM WTMPompton Lakes Bakery
117 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
Essential details
- Address
- 117 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442, USA
- Phone
- (973) 835-2381
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 80 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- Tuesday6:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Wednesday6:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Thursday6:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Friday6:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Saturday6:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sunday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
For many New Jersey residents, especially those with a keen appreciation for authentic, high-quality baked goods, finding a local bakery that truly stands out is a remarkable discovery. In the charming borough of Pompton Lakes, NJ, there’s a local gem known simply as Pompton Lakes Bakery, a place that has clearly captivated its patrons with its commitment to traditional baking and exceptional flavors. This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Pompton Lakes Bakery, detailing what makes it a cherished and appealing choice for users in the New Jersey region. From their renowned Kaiser rolls to their delightful array of pastries and cakes, we'll explore what makes this family-owned establishment a true local treasure.
New Jersey's culinary landscape is rich with diverse offerings, and bakeries play a vital role in providing fresh, comforting, and often nostalgic treats. Pompton Lakes Bakery, nestled conveniently on Wanaque Avenue, embodies the spirit of a traditional neighborhood bakery that prioritizes quality and authenticity. We understand that for local patrons, the ability to find genuinely fresh-baked items, prepared with care and tradition, coupled with friendly service, is paramount. This overview is crafted with the perspective of a local New Jersey user in mind, highlighting the practical aspects and distinctive features that make Pompton Lakes Bakery a highly recommended stop for your daily bread, a sweet treat, or a special occasion cake.
Pompton Lakes Bakery is conveniently located at 117 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442, USA. This address places the bakery directly on Wanaque Avenue, a central and well-known thoroughfare in the heart of Pompton Lakes, a picturesque borough in Passaic County, New Jersey. Its position on this main avenue makes it highly accessible for residents of Pompton Lakes and the surrounding communities, ensuring that a craving for fresh baked goods is never too far away.
For customers traveling by car, the location on Wanaque Avenue typically offers straightforward access. As is common with businesses situated in town centers or along main local roads, there is usually ample on-street parking or nearby public parking options available, contributing to a hassle-free visit. This ease of parking is a significant convenience, whether you're making a quick stop to grab some Kaiser rolls or taking a moment to browse their wider selection. While specific public transportation routes might vary, for most New Jersey residents in this suburban area, driving remains the most practical and common method of access. The central and accessible location on Wanaque Avenue solidifies Pompton Lakes Bakery's role as a convenient and essential stop for delicious baked goods for the entire community.
Authentic Kaiser Rolls: A signature offering and a major highlight, Pompton Lakes Bakery is lauded for its "real deal" Kaiser rolls, characterized by their unique outer crust and soft, denser inside, a rarity to find genuinely fresh-baked outside of specific urban areas. These are baked right on premises.
Wide Array of Freshly Baked Pastries: Customers consistently praise the variety and deliciousness of their pastries. Offerings include items like "Melt Away," "French Croller donuts," "Apple turnover," and "Pecan danish," indicating a diverse selection of sweet treats.
Cakes for Special Occasions: While specifically mentioned for a birthday cake pick-up, the bakery likely offers a range of cakes for various celebrations, either ready-made or available for custom order, fulfilling the needs for local events.
Daily Baked Goods: The reviews emphasize that "Everything freshly baked right there," reinforcing their commitment to providing daily fresh products, from rolls to other items.
Other Baked Items: In addition to the highlighted items, a full-service local bakery typically offers a variety of breads, cookies, and seasonal specialties.
Authenticity of Kaiser Rolls: This is arguably their standout feature. Customers who understand and appreciate genuine Kaiser rolls recognize Pompton Lakes Bakery as a rare find for these "real deal" items, describing them as "wonderful as they looked" with the correct "unique characteristics."
Freshness and On-Premises Baking: The repeated emphasis that "Everything freshly baked right there" highlights their commitment to quality and traditional baking methods. This ensures customers receive the freshest possible products.
Family-Owned Business: Being a "family owned bakery" adds a layer of charm and community connection, suggesting a dedication to craftsmanship passed down through generations and a personalized approach to customer service.
Exceptional Taste and Variety of Pastries: Beyond Kaiser rolls, the bakery receives high praise for its "delicious" and "fantastic" pastries, with specific mentions of "Melt Away," "French Croller donuts," "Apple turnover," and "Pecan danish" being "delish!"
"Remarkable Find" and "Real Treasure": Customers consistently describe the bakery in glowing terms, calling it a "Remarkable find" and a "real treasure in Pompton Lakes New Jersey," indicating a high level of satisfaction and loyalty.
Charming and Friendly Staff: The lady "generally there on weekends is just charming once you get to know her," suggesting a welcoming and pleasant customer experience that contributes to the bakery's positive atmosphere.
Consistent Quality: The fact that customers "always stop by now when I'm in the area" and "stock up" indicates a high level of consistent quality that encourages repeat visits.
For direct inquiries, to place an order, or to learn more about their daily specials and offerings, Pompton Lakes Bakery can be reached via the following contact methods:
Address: 117 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442, USA
Phone: (973) 835-2381
Mobile Phone: +1 973-835-2381
It is always recommended to contact the bakery directly, especially if you are looking for specific items or placing a large order, to ensure availability and a smooth pick-up experience.
For the discerning residents of Pompton Lakes, New Jersey, and its surrounding areas, Pompton Lakes Bakery at 117 Wanaque Ave is undeniably a highly suitable and deeply cherished local establishment. Its convenient location on a main avenue ensures effortless accessibility, making it an easy and frequent stop for anyone in the community seeking fresh, authentic baked goods. This ease of access is a significant advantage for busy New Jerseyans looking to incorporate quality into their daily routines.
What truly sets Pompton Lakes Bakery apart, elevating it to a "remarkable find" and "real treasure," is its unwavering commitment to authentic craftsmanship, particularly highlighted by their "real deal" Kaiser rolls—a rare and highly praised specialty. Beyond this, the consistent freshness of "everything freshly baked right there," combined with a "delightful" array of "delicious" pastries like "Melt Away" and "French Croller donuts," guarantees a satisfying experience for every palate. The fact that it is a "family owned business" further enhances its appeal, fostering a sense of community and personal connection, especially with their charming staff. For New Jersey locals who prioritize genuine quality, traditional baking methods, and a welcoming, familiar atmosphere in their culinary choices, Pompton Lakes Bakery is an indispensable and beloved fixture, embodying the very best of a true neighborhood bakery.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- In-store shopping
- Takeaway
Offerings
- Coffee
Planning
- Quick visit
See the bakery
No visitor photos are available in this record.
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Wow everything was so delicious! Melt away was fantastic. French croller donuts so soft and really tasty. Apple turnover delicious…. Pecan danish delish! We will be going back. Thank you!
Jun 23 · Donna BeidemanDesserts were ok. Cake not finished at all. Lady at bakery was not amused with us whatsoever. Rather travel further for better tasting pastries and warmer service.
Mar 22 · Angela MirandaI picked up pastries for a party last minute and the owner threw together a nice platter for 50 guest so quickly! He was super busy but went out of his way to accommodate! This bakery is the best! And the pastries were a hit! The Neapolitan was especially good!
Jan 18 · Jen LI picked up pastries for a party last minute and the owner threw together a nice platter for 50 guest so quickly! He was super busy but went out of his way to accommodate! This bakery is the best! And the pastries were a hit! The Neapolitan was especially good!
Jan 18 · Jen LI am not really fond of this place but I was so excited to try for the first time. The cake taste stale and the frosting definitely had a weird taste. I am also very shocked that I spelled the name out for this woman and she still spelled “Gordon” instead of “Jordan” so I did try to fix it. She also did not care at all to spell birthday out so she didn’t even bother to put the “y”at the end. 👎 definitely will stick to Gencarelli’s in Wayne but I guess thanks for the cake anyway.
Mar 20 · Don’t need My nameI am not really fond of this place but I was so excited to try for the first time. The cake taste stale and the frosting definitely had a weird taste. I am also very shocked that I spelled the name out for this woman and she still spelled “Gordon” instead of “Jordan” so I did try to fix it. She also did not care at all to spell birthday out so she didn’t even bother to put the “y”at the end. 👎 definitely will stick to Gencarelli’s in Wayne but I guess thanks for the cake anyway.
Mar 20 · Don’t need My nameCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.












This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
