Good food here by hard working people. Lots of fresh bagels. NY bagel w/ lox was great. Fresh orange juice was good. Clean place. Not too busy on Tuesday 8am, but steady flow of people in and out. I imagine they get busy weekend mornings.
Jul 15 · Joey FLORIDABAKERY PROFILE
Silver Bay Bagels
★ 4.0501 recorded reviews$
1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA
- Phone
- (732) 255-8131
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 501 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- Monday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Tuesday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Wednesday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Thursday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Friday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Saturday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday5:00 AM – 2:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For anyone in New Jersey, especially those near the Jersey Shore, the search for an authentic, perfectly baked bagel is a lifelong pursuit. Fortunately for the residents and visitors of Toms River, there's a local gem that consistently delivers on the promise of an "old-fashioned" bagel: Silver Bay Bagels. More than just a simple bagel shop, this establishment has cemented its place in the community as a go-to spot for a wide range of delicious food options, covering everything from your essential morning coffee to full-scale catering for events.
Silver Bay Bagels proudly offers the true bagel experience—their bagels are meticulously boiled and baked the old-fashioned way, resulting in that signature chewy interior and crisp, glossy crust that New Jersey locals demand. But the menu extends far beyond the traditional dozen. They function as a comprehensive Breakfast Restaurant, a reliable Lunch Restaurant, and a quality Coffee Shop, making it an ideal stop any time of the day. Whether you're craving a classic Pork Roll, Egg, & Cheese (a true Jersey staple), a gourmet deli sandwich, or just need a satisfying coffee and crumb cake, Silver Bay Bagels has you covered. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and attention to detail—as noted by customers praising the quality and presentation—makes them a standout in the local food scene.
The shop maintains a friendly, professional atmosphere, ensuring a quick and pleasant experience even during rush hours, perfect for those needing a fast, high-quality meal on the go.
Location and Accessibility
Silver Bay Bagels is conveniently situated at a prime location in Toms River, making it easily accessible for locals and those passing through Ocean County.
The exact address is 1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA. Located on a main thoroughfare, the shop is a straightforward destination for your morning or midday cravings. Accessibility is clearly a priority at Silver Bay Bagels, ensuring that all community members can enjoy their offerings. The facility is equipped with a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, a Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot, a Wheelchair Accessible Restroom, and Wheelchair Accessible Seating. Parking is never an issue for dine-in or quick takeout, as the location provides a generous Free Parking Lot. This focus on ease of access, combined with its centralized Toms River location, solidifies its status as a convenient choice for any local user looking for a reliable and enjoyable dining experience.
Services Offered
Silver Bay Bagels goes above and beyond the typical counter service, offering a full suite of services designed for maximum customer convenience.
- Dine-in: Enjoy your fresh bagels and coffee in a comfortable, clean setting with access to amenities like a restroom and Wi-Fi.
- Takeout / In-store Shopping: For a quick grab-and-go order, the takeout service is fast and efficient, perfect for morning commuters or busy families.
- Curbside Pickup & In-store Pickup: These options offer maximum convenience, allowing customers who have placed orders ahead of time to get their food with minimal fuss.
- Delivery: Partnering with delivery services (as noted by customer reviews) ensures that their fresh, high-quality food can be enjoyed without even leaving your home or office.
- Catering: They operate as a dedicated Caterer, providing extensive platter packages for any event. Options range from the Dozen Bagel Platter to larger, comprehensive spreads like the Dozen Bagel, Muffin & Beverage Platter, and various trays of breakfast essentials (Scrambled Eggs, Bacon & Sausage, French Toast, Pancakes). They also offer deli sandwich assortments and large fruit/yogurt bowls, making them a one-stop catering solution for office meetings, parties, or family gatherings in the New Jersey area.
Features / Highlights
What truly sets Silver Bay Bagels apart is their commitment to quality ingredients, diverse menu, and customer-focused approach.
- Authentic Bagel Preparation: The number one highlight is their dedication to the traditional method: "All bagels are boiled and baked the old fashioned way!!" This is the secret to a genuinely great bagel.
- Extensive Menu Variety: Their menu covers every craving. Beyond the dozens of bagel flavors (from Plain and Everything to Cheddar Habanero and French Toast Bagel), they offer full Breakfast Platters (Omelettes, Pancakes, French Toast), numerous specialty Cream Cheese spreads (like Nova Lox Spread and Honey Walnut Cranberry), and a complete Deli Sandwich menu (including the local favorite Sloppy Joe and White Fish Salad Sandwich).
- Signature Breakfast Sandwiches: They offer a spectacular array of breakfast sandwiches, including all the essential meats (Pork Roll, Bacon, Sausage, Steak) and even health-conscious options like various Egg White Breakfast Sandwiches and Turkey Bacon. Customers consistently rave about the quality, noting the crispy bacon, perfectly cooked eggs, and fresh bagels, all served hot and double-wrapped with care.
- Quality Coffee and Beverages: As a dedicated coffee shop, they provide hot coffee, iced coffee, and even a "Jug Of Joe" for catering or large groups. They also stock a great selection of cold drinks, including fresh-squeezed Orange Juice, Naked Juice, and various sodas and teas.
- Flexible Payment Options: For a quick visit, they accept all modern forms of payment, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.
- Delicious Bakery and Sides: Beyond the main menu, their sweet treats are a major draw. They feature classic New Jersey Crumb Cake (including Raspberry and Pumpkin varieties), fresh muffins, black & white cookies, and other sweets, perfect for dessert or a sweet side with coffee.
Contact Information
Planning your next visit or need to place a large catering order? Here is the essential contact information for Silver Bay Bagels.
Address: 1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA
Phone: (732) 255-8131
Mobile Phone (for convenience): +1 732-255-8131
What is Worth Choosing
When deciding what to order at Silver Bay Bagels, the real question isn't if you should go, but what you should try first. The establishment stands out in the competitive New Jersey food landscape for several compelling reasons that make it worth your choice every time.
First and foremost, you choose Silver Bay Bagels for the authentic quality. In a state saturated with bagel shops, they adhere to the fundamental, time-tested process of boiling and then baking. This ensures a bagel with the perfect texture—a rare find that truly honors the traditional New York/New Jersey style. You can taste the difference in every one of their $1.40 Plain, Everything, or Poppy Bagels. If you're hosting, their Dozen Bagels ($16.00) is an easy win.
Secondly, you choose them for the unparalleled Breakfast Sandwiches. This is where Silver Bay Bagels truly shines for the local New Jersey clientele. The combination of a freshly baked bagel with a perfectly cooked egg, melted cheese, and your choice of meat—particularly the classic Pork Roll Egg & Cheese ($7.40)—is an essential morning ritual here. The customer reviews confirm that these sandwiches are consistently "10/10," arriving fresh, hot, and impeccably prepared. The care they put into wrapping and presenting a simple breakfast sandwich speaks volumes about their quality control.
Finally, choose Silver Bay Bagels for their versatility and convenience. This isn't just a morning stop; it’s also a quality Lunch Restaurant with excellent Deli Sandwiches like the Turkey Breast ($10.50) or the substantial Roast Beef ($11.95), all served with a side and a pickle. Their expansive menu, which includes robust Platter Packages for catering, means they can service a single quick visit or an entire office party with the same level of quality. The ease of service, from free parking to a variety of quick pickup options and full accessibility, ensures that getting a great meal is always a stress-free experience.
Whether you're after a bagel with their generous Nova Lox Spread ($5.50), a decadent slice of Crumb Cake ($3.25), or a full hot breakfast platter, Silver Bay Bagels offers a reliable, high-quality, and distinctly Jersey experience that keeps locals coming back.
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
area 18breakfast sandwich 15everything bagel 14pork roll 11iced coffee 8french toast 8bacon egg and cheese 7owner 6lox 6salt 5
tried these guys via uber eats because of their really high rating on there. the high rating is well deserved. breakfast sandwiches are 10/10. bacon is tasty and crispy, eggs tasty and cooked right, cheese melty, bagel fresh. comes nice and hot, double wrapped in foil. they obviously care about their product and how it is presented and how it tastes. will ALWAYS order from these guys because you never know what low quality garbage you’re going to get from a food place these days. thank you Silver Bay Bagels.
May 18 · Dan HoffmanWhat an excellent experience with silver bay bagels! I needed to order for a large catered breakfast for a work event. I was easily able to order the night before, the order was on time waiting for me when I arrived the next morning. The staff even helped me carry it to my car. Great food, great service!
May 14 · Samantha ShinnGood bagels are not hard to find in NJ. My buddy goes here pretty frequently either for a breakfast or lunch. I had food here a few times. Today we all got together and picked this place to eat. Food is good, service is good, fast paced and prices are just where they need to be. Not cheap not expensive. No issues, I’d go back and I’d recommend it to others as well . No complaints from here.
Jul 5 · Andrew PalankerThere are a lot of bagel shops in this area but Silver Bay is best especially if you DON'T prefer fat bagels, which I do not. Their bagels look and taste like they should. Like everywhere prices are not what they used to be and a bit pricey for simply a dozen bagels.
Aug 9 · Joe BaudiNEARBY ALTERNATIVES
Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
★ 4.0 · 570 reviews · 3.8 mi
La Scala Italian Pastry Shop and Bakery
1231-8 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.