BAKERY PROFILE

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

★ 4.012 recorded reviews

W345 S8810, W345S8810 Eagle Terrace, Eagle, WI 53119, USA

DirectionsCall

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Photo unavailable
PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address
W345 S8810, W345S8810 Eagle Terrace, Eagle, WI 53119, USA
Phone
(262) 470-0672
Rating signal
4.0 from 12 recorded reviews
HOURS

Listed operating hours

Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.

About and visit notes

Introduction / Overview

For residents across the Waukesha County area, and particularly in Eagle, Wisconsin,

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

has established itself as a premier destination for high-quality, gourmet baked goods. Although listed generically as a

Cake shop

, this local establishment, spearheaded by owner Dawn, specializes in much more than just standard cakes. It is widely praised for its exceptional cupcakes, custom cakes, and an array of other delectable desserts.

The company's mission revolves around using real, fresh ingredients and taking immense pride in the detailed, sophisticated presentation of every single item. Customer reviews consistently highlight not only the phenomenal taste—with specialty flavors like Coconut Cream, Strawberry, and an outstanding Carrot Cake—but also the amazing talent and personalized service provided by the owner. This high level of dedication suggests a commitment to homemade quality that elevates their products above mass-produced alternatives.

Whether you are planning a large party, a special wedding, or simply need a dozen of the best cupcakes you've ever tasted,

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

offers a friendly, professional, and reliable option right here in southeastern Wisconsin.

Location and Accessibility

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

is located at W345 S8810 Eagle Terrace, Eagle, WI 53119, USA. This location places the specialty shop conveniently within the Eagle community, making it accessible to local patrons and those traveling from nearby towns like Mukwonago or Palmyra in Waukesha County. The address, featuring the W345 S8810 designation, helps pinpoint the location precisely on Eagle Terrace.

The shop is set up to ensure ease of access for customers, a critical component for those picking up large or delicate custom orders:

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated, accessible parking spaces are available, allowing all patrons to quickly and safely manage the pickup of their treats.

The business primarily offers

Takeout

service, meaning the physical location is optimized for efficient order collection. Customers are highly encouraged to place their orders ahead of time to ensure their specialized desserts are ready for a quick and seamless pickup.

Services Offered

  • Gourmet Cupcakes: Specializes in a wide variety of daily and custom cupcake flavors, including favorites like Strawberry, Coconut Cream, and Carrot Cake, often using real, fresh ingredients.
  • Custom Cake Design: Offers personalized cake creation for all special events, including birthdays, anniversaries, and weddings, with the capacity to bring unique design visions and themes to reality.
  • Mini-Cheesecakes: Provides individual-sized, gourmet mini-cheesecakes, perfect for occasions requiring a variety of small, intense flavor options.
  • Specialty Dessert Items: Offers other decadent items such as chocolate-covered strawberries, and likely other treats like fruit arrangements, depending on the current menu.
  • Takeout Service: All products are available for convenient

    Takeout

    pickup at the Eagle Terrace address, supporting the operation’s custom and made-to-order focus.
  • Flexible Payment Options: Accepts various payment methods including

    Checks

    ,

    Credit cards

    , and

    Debit cards

    .

Features / Highlights

  • Exceptional Quality and Flavor: Known for using high-quality, real ingredients like sweet butter, fresh fruit, and pure vanilla beans, resulting in moist, delicious, and intensely flavored products that customers consistently rave about.
  • Owner-Operated Personal Touch: The talent and dedication of owner Dawn are frequently highlighted in customer testimonials, promising a personalized approach and amazing attention to detail on every custom order.
  • Great Value: Customers often note that the prices for these professional, high-quality, handmade desserts are surprisingly low compared to other comparable specialty shops in the area.
  • Wide Range of Specialty Flavors: Offers unique and standout flavors beyond the standard fare, such as Coconut Cream, Strawberry, and a highly recommended Carrot Cake cupcake.
  • Custom Event Focus: Excels at handling large-scale custom orders for all event needs, including multi-year orders for loyal customers, demonstrating reliability and consistency.

Contact Information

To place a custom order for cupcakes, specialty desserts, or a celebration cake, or to discuss your event needs with the experienced team, please use the following contact details:

Address: W345 S8810 Eagle Terrace, Eagle, WI 53119, USA

Phone: (262) 470-0672

Mobile Phone: +1 262-470-0672

What is Worth Choosing

For any Wisconsin resident planning an event or seeking an exceptional everyday treat in Waukesha County,

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

is absolutely worth choosing. The primary value lies in the

unparalleled combination of gourmet flavor, personalized service, and great affordability

.

The testimonials speak volumes: customers repeatedly emphasize the superior quality and taste, claiming these are the "Best cupcakes I've ever had in my life," and noting that the prices are "very low" for such a professional, high-end product. For the cost-conscious yet quality-demanding consumer, this represents a unique market advantage.

Furthermore, the attention to detail and ability to execute complex custom orders, as mentioned by customers ordering specialty items for years, provides immense peace of mind for those planning important events like weddings or big parties. The clear advice from satisfied patrons to "just plan ahead of time" underscores the high demand for their quality work, confirming that a little foresight guarantees access to the area's finest cupcakes and cakes. For a truly professional, delicious, and locally-supported dessert experience,

Simply D'Lish Cupcakes

is the top-tier, must-try destination in Eagle, WI.

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

Service options

  • Takeout

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Payments

  • Checks
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
PHOTOS

See the bakery

No visitor photos are available in this record.

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

flavors 3eagle 2
★ 5.0

These cupcakes are amazing! Dawn goes above and beyond with her amazing talent! I have ordered my daughter cupcakes the past 3 years, plus I call her shop for all my event needs. She puts so much time into her work and the flavors are amazing !! Coconut cream and strawberry are my favorite, plus she makes an outstanding carrot cake cupcake. I would recommend this shop to anyone!!!

Jun 30 · Kristie Millikin
★ 5.0

Best cupcakes I've ever had in my life 😍 The owner goes above and beyond constantly. I always take a dozen or so back to school with me when I visit town. The prices are very low in comparison with other professional cupcake companies in the area, and taste better too! 10/10 would recommend.As for some of the poor reviews, there's only so many cupcakes a small shop can feasibly make in a given period of time. I honestly don't see why other reviewers are complaining - just plan ahead of time and there are no issues.

Sep 15 · J Ack
★ 5.0

Simple D'lish Cupcakes was one of our favorite vendors from our wedding! I met Dawn at another wedding and it was fate! We drove out to Eagle to try her cupcakes and it was an easy decision. Dawn from beginning to end was sweet, flexible, thoughtful and helpful. After our first tasting I asked if she could put together the flavors we liked so we could share with our parents. She did and even included a few extra AND dropped them off at my in-laws. Dawn went above and beyond what our expectations were. The display was beautiful, flavors were amazing and many of my guests said it was some of the best cupcakes they have ever had. We went with the minis so people could try a few different flavors and they loved that!! She accommodated for a wedding of 160 people and we had over 300 cupcakes that looked and tasted wonderful!! I look forward to another event so I can buy more cupcakes!

Aug 4 · Tarah Farruggia
★ 5.0

I LOVE this place !! I needed cupcakes for my dad's birthday which is on Halloween. Not only did Dawn go out of her way to accommodate me for my order, she patiently answered all of my questions and made recommendations on the flavors. I will continue to buy from here and I have told everyone I know about the wonderful shop in Eagle.

Jan 18 · Liz M
★ 5.0

The most amazing, beautiful, tasty cupcakes I have ever had! I now will never eat anyone else's cupcakes! So moist and delicious. They are definitely worth the drive!

May 3 · Cass Marie
NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

Meijer Bakery
★ 0.0 · 0 reviews · 12.9 mi

Meijer Bakery

801 E Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA

Details
Baker Meister
★ 4.0 · 279 reviews · 15.1 mi

Baker Meister

421 N Wisconsin St, Elkhorn, WI 53121, USA

Details
About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.

SIDE-BY-SIDE

Bakery comparison

Expanded bakery photo