Kendra provided cupcakes and a cutting cake for our wedding. We had to reschedule with her 2 years in a row due to the pandemic and she was so accommodating. Everything was delicious and having all the different flavors was a huge hit. I love the flavor combos she offers and she perfectly matched my ombré color request. Highly recommend!
May 23 · Alyssa WillisSugar Mountain Bakery
3296 Reading Rd, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 3296 Reading Rd, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA
- Phone
- (607) 215-3861
- Rating signal
- 5.0 from 15 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.
About and visit notes
Welcome to Sugar Mountain Bakery, a beloved local establishment located right here in Watkins Glen, New York. If you're planning a special event, celebrating a milestone, or simply craving a beautifully crafted sweet treat, Sugar Mountain Bakery is your premier destination. Under the expert hands of Kendra, this bakery has earned a stellar reputation for creating not just desserts, but edible works of art that are both stunning to look at and incredibly delicious to eat. For residents across the Finger Lakes region and beyond, Sugar Mountain Bakery represents the pinnacle of personalized baking, transforming your sweet visions into reality with meticulous attention to detail and an undeniable passion for pastry.
At Sugar Mountain Bakery, we understand that every celebration is unique, and your desserts should be too. That's why we specialize in custom creations, from elaborate wedding cakes that serve as a beautiful centerpiece to an array of flavorful cupcakes that delight every guest. We pride ourselves on our ability to work closely with clients, ensuring that every detail, from flavor combinations to color matching, perfectly aligns with their vision. Our commitment to quality ingredients and innovative designs sets us apart, making us a go-to choice for anyone in the New York area seeking a truly memorable dessert experience. We believe that a great bakery isn't just about selling sweets; it's about crafting joy, one delicious bite at a time.
Sugar Mountain Bakery is conveniently located at 3296 Reading Rd, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA. This accessible location makes it an ideal choice for customers throughout Watkins Glen and the surrounding Finger Lakes region. Reading Road provides straightforward access, allowing for easy pick-ups or consultations without the hassle often associated with navigating congested town centers. Whether you're coming from Seneca Lake, enjoying the Watkins Glen State Park, or simply running errands in the area, our bakery is within easy reach.
The address places Sugar Mountain Bakery in a prime position to serve not only the immediate Watkins Glen community but also clients from nearby towns and villages who are seeking high-quality, custom-made baked goods. Its location away from the immediate hustle and bustle of downtown offers convenience and ease of access for customers, particularly those picking up larger orders like wedding cakes or numerous cupcakes. This strategic placement ensures that whether you're a local resident or planning an event in the beautiful Finger Lakes region, Sugar Mountain Bakery is a convenient and stress-free destination for all your dessert needs. We aim to be a welcoming and easily reachable spot for all our valued customers across New York.
Sugar Mountain Bakery specializes in custom-baked goods, primarily focusing on personalized creations for special events. Here's a look at the key services offered:
- Custom Wedding Cakes: Crafting beautiful and delicious cutting cakes that serve as a centerpiece for wedding receptions. These are tailored to the couple's specifications, including design, size, and flavor profiles.
- Event Cupcakes: Providing a wide variety of cupcakes, often in multiple flavors, to cater to larger gatherings such as weddings and parties. These can be customized in terms of flavor combinations and aesthetic to match event themes.
- Flavor Customization: Offering diverse and often unique flavor combinations for both cakes and cupcakes, allowing clients to create a truly personalized dessert experience for their guests.
- Color Matching and Design Services: Working closely with clients to perfectly match specific color schemes, such as ombré requests, and to execute intricate design elements on cakes and cupcakes.
- Accommodating Scheduling: Demonstrating flexibility and understanding, particularly for clients who may need to reschedule events due to unforeseen circumstances, ensuring a smooth and stress-free planning process.
- Consultation and Planning: Providing personalized consultations to discuss dessert needs, preferences, and design ideas for various events.
Sugar Mountain Bakery prides itself on delivering not just baked goods, but complete dessert solutions that are both visually stunning and incredibly tasty, tailored to each client's unique celebration.
Sugar Mountain Bakery is distinguished by several key features and highlights that make it a top choice for custom baked goods in the New York region.
- Exceptional Customer Service and Accommodation: A standout feature is Kendra's remarkable willingness to work with clients, even through challenging situations. For instance, the ability to reschedule orders two years in a row due to the pandemic showcases unparalleled flexibility and dedication to customer satisfaction. This level of accommodation significantly reduces stress for clients planning major events.
- Delicious and Diverse Flavor Offerings: Customers consistently rave about the taste and variety of flavors available. Sugar Mountain Bakery goes beyond standard options, offering unique and popular flavor combinations that are a huge hit with guests. This ensures that every bite is a delightful experience.
- Beautiful and Customizable Designs: The bakery excels at creating visually appealing desserts. Whether it's matching specific ombré color requests for a wedding cake or designing beautiful cupcakes, the aesthetic quality is highly praised, ensuring the desserts are as stunning as they are delicious.
- Excellent Value and Reasonable Pricing: Despite the high quality and custom nature of the products, Sugar Mountain Bakery is noted for being very reasonably priced. This makes high-end, personalized desserts accessible to a wider range of clients without compromising on quality or beauty.
- High Client Satisfaction and Recommendations: The overwhelming positive feedback from real customers, particularly for significant events like weddings, highlights a consistent track record of exceeding expectations. Strong recommendations from satisfied clients speak volumes about the quality of both the products and the service.
- Focus on Wedding and Event Desserts: While general bakery items may be available, the clear strength and highlight of Sugar Mountain Bakery lie in its specialization in providing custom cakes and cupcakes for weddings and other special events. This focused expertise ensures a high level of proficiency and attention to detail for these crucial celebratory items.
These features collectively position Sugar Mountain Bakery as a highly recommended and reliable choice for anyone in New York seeking custom, delicious, and beautifully presented baked goods for their most important occasions.
For all inquiries, orders, or to schedule a consultation with Kendra at Sugar Mountain Bakery, please use the following contact information:
Address: 3296 Reading Rd, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA
Phone: (607) 215-3861
Mobile Phone: +1 607-215-3861
We encourage you to reach out directly to discuss your specific dessert needs, whether for a grand wedding celebration or a more intimate gathering. Kendra is dedicated to providing personalized service and will work with you to create the perfect sweet treats for your event. Given the custom nature of our services, it's always best to contact us in advance, especially for larger orders, to ensure your vision can be brought to life beautifully and deliciously.
In conclusion, Sugar Mountain Bakery is an exceptionally suitable choice for locals in Watkins Glen, New York, and the wider Finger Lakes region, particularly for those planning significant life events. The overwhelming positive feedback from real customers, especially regarding wedding cakes and cupcakes, underscores the bakery's consistent ability to deliver both delicious and visually stunning products. For any New Yorker seeking personalized, high-quality desserts, Sugar Mountain Bakery truly stands out.
Kendra’s remarkable accommodating nature, as evidenced by her flexibility with rescheduling due to unforeseen circumstances like the pandemic, speaks volumes about her dedication to client satisfaction. This level of understanding and personalized service is invaluable when planning important celebrations. Furthermore, the bakery’s reputation for offering a wide array of delightful flavor combinations ensures that every palate can be pleased, making sure that your guests will be raving about the desserts. The ability to perfectly match specific color requests and create beautifully designed treats means that your vision for your event’s sweets will be brought to life flawlessly. Combined with reasonable pricing, Sugar Mountain Bakery offers exceptional value, providing luxurious custom desserts without an exorbitant cost. For these reasons, Sugar Mountain Bakery is not just a bakery; it's a trusted partner in making your special moments even sweeter and more memorable right here in our New York community.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Amenities
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Appointment required
Payments
- Cheques
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Kendra was amazing to work with! She recently did cupcakes and a cutting cake for our wedding in early October. We got a ton of compliments on the cupcakes from our guests. They were also beautiful! She is very reasonably priced and I highly recommend Sugar Mountain Bakery!
Oct 27 · Molly MonroeWe selected Sugar Mountain Bakery to prepare, deliver, and setup our wedding cutting cake and various other desserts. We were very impressed with the final result. Our cutting cake was beautiful and the guests attacked our various other desserts before dinner was even over. Kendra was very timely and did a wonderful job setting up the entire dessert table.
Jun 19 · Christopher GillWe used Sugar Mountain Bakery for our wedding desserts and (besides saying yes) it might have been the best choice we made for that day! the cookies were delicious, and the mini-filled cupcakes were everyone's favorite. The set up was prompt and looked perfect. We are looking for an excuse to order from here again, and we would highly recommend ordering desserts from here!
Jun 26 · Doug StansleyOrdered a cake and cookies and it was delicious.
Jun 12 · gabriela garciaCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

The Blackberry Inn Kitchen
309 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA











Great American Cookies
3300 Chambers Rd Space K-8, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
