Order cupcakes and custom cake pops for a baby shower a bit ago. Gave a reference image and whoever made them made it look identical to the image. The taste was amazing and everyone loved them at the party.I picked them up the DAY BEFORE and was told to keep the cupcakes and cake pops cool until they were ready to be served and even after a 2.5 hour car drive and then a night in the fridge they were perfect for the next day!I was absolutely obsessed with them and so was everyone else at the party 🥰🥰Need an excuse to do another custom order sometime soon ♥️
Sep 27 · Melanie Johnson.BAKERY PROFILE
Sugar Rush Columbus Bakery & Milkshake Bar
★ 4.0477 recorded reviews$$
8114 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 8114 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA
- Phone
- (614) 604-8947
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 477 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- Tuesday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Wednesday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Thursday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Friday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Saturday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For residents across Central Ohio, the search for truly creative, high-quality, and unforgettable sweet treats often leads to Sugar Rush Columbus Bakery & Milkshake Bar. Located conveniently in Reynoldsburg, this establishment has quickly established itself as a must-visit destination, operating as much more than a traditional bakery. It proudly serves as a dedicated Cake Shop, Cupcake Shop, and Dessert Shop, offering an incredible variety that caters to virtually every sweet tooth and special occasion across the greater Columbus area.
At its core, Sugar Rush Columbus is an institution built on innovation and flavor complexity. The extensive menu is a testament to the business’s commitment to moving beyond the basic offerings, featuring signature items like their creative 'Mashup Cookies,' decadent brownies, delicate macarons, and a massive selection of specialty cupcakes. This focus on variety and novelty ensures that whether a customer is seeking a quick personal indulgence or a breathtaking centerpiece cake for a major event, they will find an exciting and expertly crafted option here.
A significant highlight and point of pride for the local community is that Sugar Rush Columbus identifies as women-owned. This designation is often important to local patrons who prioritize supporting female entrepreneurship within the Ohio business landscape. Furthermore, the bakery's dedication to quality is evident not just in the breadth of its menu—which includes hyper-local options like the 'Buckeye Brownie' and 'OH My Buckeye Mashup Cookie'—but also in the overwhelmingly positive feedback it garners for custom orders, from detailed cake pops to thematic birthday cakes. Patrons from all corners of Ohio, planning events or simply stopping by, consistently praise the team for their commitment to perfection and customer collaboration.
The bakery’s operation is designed for customer convenience, offering comprehensive service options including Delivery, In-store pickup, and In-store shopping. This flexibility, combined with a commitment to Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking, ensures that every member of the Reynoldsburg and Columbus community can easily access their delicious creations. Whether you're planning a quick stop to satisfy an immediate craving or collaborating on a custom cake for a monumental event, Sugar Rush Columbus is structured to provide a high-quality, professional, and friendly experience.
Location and Accessibility
Sugar Rush Columbus Bakery & Milkshake Bar is strategically situated at 8114 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA. East Broad Street is a significant artery that connects Reynoldsburg directly to Downtown Columbus, making the bakery highly accessible to residents throughout Franklin and Fairfield counties, and even those traveling from farther afield in Central Ohio. This location is key to its ability to serve a wide customer base for both daily treats and large custom orders.
Accessibility is a clear priority for this establishment. They provide a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that all customers, regardless of mobility needs, can comfortably visit the store. The availability of a Free parking lot is a major benefit in a busy retail corridor, eliminating the stress and expense of searching for street parking. The business is geared toward a Quick visit, meaning the layout and service structure are optimized for efficiency, allowing patrons to quickly grab an afternoon treat, pick up a pre-ordered cake, or select from the counter displays. This convenience-focused approach makes it an ideal stop for those on a tight schedule or commuters passing through the Reynoldsburg area.
Services Offered
- Full-Service Takeout and In-Store Shopping: Customers are welcome to browse the full selection of desserts, cupcakes, and cookies in-store or place an order for quick Takeout.
- Custom Cake and Dessert Orders: The bakery excels in creating custom cakes, cake pops, and other specialty desserts for events such as birthdays and baby showers, as affirmed by excellent customer reviews praising the attention to detail and ability to match reference images.
- Local Delivery Services: For maximum convenience in the Columbus and Reynoldsburg areas, the bakery offers Delivery for orders, ensuring treats arrive fresh and ready for any event.
- In-Store Pickup: Customers can place online or phone orders for convenient In-store pickup, streamlining the process for pre-planned purchases.
- Onsite Services: The bakery offers Onsite services, suggesting flexibility for certain types of event or catering needs, which can be crucial for larger gatherings in the area.
- Extensive Menu Options: Services include daily offerings of Macarons, Brownies, Cupcakes in dozens of flavors, 'Mashup Cookies,' and 'Quick Cakes' for immediate purchase.
- Financial Convenience: Payments are accepted via Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a smooth, modern transaction process.
Features / Highlights
- Women-Owned Business: A key distinction and a point of pride, supporting diversity in local Ohio business ownership.
- Innovative 'Mashup Cookies': These unique, substantial cookies blend multiple flavors and textures into a single treat, with imaginative options like 'The Floor Is Lava,' 'Brickhouse,' and 'Peanut Butter Overload.' These are far from standard cookies and represent the bakery's creativity.
- Ohio-Themed Specialties: The inclusion of 'Buckeye Brownie,' 'Buckeye Quick Cake,' and 'OH My Buckeye Mashup Cookie' provides a fun, locally relevant focus that appeals directly to Ohio pride.
- Extensive Cupcake Variety: With over 40 listed flavors ranging from classics like 'Red Velvet Cupcake' and 'Birthday Cupcake' to inventive options such as 'Holy Cannoli,' 'Maple Bourbon Cupcake,' and 'Jason Samoa Cupcake,' there is a unique flavor for every preference and season.
- Customer-Endorsed Quality for Events: Reviews highlight the exceptional quality and stability of custom products, with items like cupcakes and cake pops remaining perfect even after extended travel and overnight refrigeration—a crucial factor for party planning in the Ohio humidity.
- Convenient Quick Cakes: Offering 'Quick Cakes' in popular flavors like 'Buckeye,' 'Red Velvet,' and 'Rainbow Vanilla' provides a solution for last-minute celebrations without sacrificing quality or visual appeal.
- Comprehensive Accessibility: The combination of Wheelchair accessible entrance and Free parking lot ensures ease of access for the entire community.
Contact Information
For orders, inquiries, or information on the daily selection of treats, please use the following contact details. Custom order consultations are highly recommended for large events to ensure the best possible result.
Address: 8114 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, USA
Phone: (614) 604-8947
Mobile Phone: +1 614-604-8947
What is Worth Choosing
For any Ohio local seeking a dessert experience that transcends the ordinary, Sugar Rush Columbus in Reynoldsburg is undeniably worth choosing for several compelling reasons. The primary draw is the bakery’s sheer variety and dedication to flavor innovation. Where other bakeries might offer a dozen standard flavors, Sugar Rush presents an astounding rotation of over 40 distinct cupcake options, ensuring repeat visits always yield a new discovery, from 'Butterbeer' to 'Pineapple Upside Down Cupcake'. This extensive and creative menu is a genuine feature that elevates it above competitors.
Furthermore, the value of Sugar Rush lies in its proven ability to handle special occasions flawlessly. The customer reviews serve as factual evidence of the team's professional, collaborative approach to custom orders. The feedback on cakes and custom cake pops being "identical to the image" and the proactive approach of asking for "additional decoration items for the party to ensure that everything matched perfectly" demonstrate a superior level of event support and customer care that is invaluable when planning an important celebration in the Columbus area. Knowing that your custom cake will not only be delicious but also perfectly executed and stable for transport provides immense peace of mind.
The unique menu categories like the 'Mashup Cookies' and the inclusion of local favorites such as 'Buckeyes' woven into their brownies and cakes offer a specific, delightful local flavor profile that celebrates Ohio. This blend of creative ingenuity, dedication to customer service in custom orders, and commitment to community accessibility—including a Free parking lot and Wheelchair accessible facilities—makes Sugar Rush Columbus a premier, must-try dessert destination for any resident of Central Ohio. It is the ideal place to satisfy an immediate sweet craving, order a memorable party centerpiece, or simply support a highly successful, women-owned local business.
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Onsite services
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
icing 19cake pops 16cupcakes and cookies 13macarons 11cake decorating 10cupcakes, cookies 9baby shower 8buttercream frosting 7creativity 6dozen 6
We had a phenomenal experience with Sugar Rush! We ordered a custom cake for my son’s Animal Kingdom birthday and they did a great job. They reached out and even asked for additional decoration items for the party to ensure that everything matched perfectly. The cake was delicious and all of our guests raved about it. Will definitely be back! :)
Sep 27 · Kimberly HopkinsWe just moved to Ohio and I needed a birthday cake for my daughter. This place was absolutely amazing! They made exactly what we wanted and it was the most delicious cake I have ever had. I’m a home baker and would normally make their cakes myself. I can honestly say I will not be doing that anymore. This cake was delicious and the buttercream was absolutely perfect! Their prices are great for what you get, and I will be using them again!
Sep 28 · Katelyn HassonBuyer beware —- these folks are not professionals and are frankly, unkind…. Very disappointed in not only the cake we received but the customer service. I ordered a $200+ two-tier cake for my daughter‘s birthday. While I was appreciative that they were able to give me a cake within a week notice the end product was disappointing. Not only was the cake nearly falling over after one hour out of the refrigerator, the icing was behind the writing of her name on the cake was a different dark color and looked botched. And frankly , the piping did not look professional. I could’ve overlooked the piping had everything else not been a disaster. When we took the top tier off, we found a support rod in the top tier and a support rod in the bottom tier but nothing that went through the entirety of the cake (see photos of the separate rods not connected and not going through both tiers) I emailed the business and they seemed apologetic and assured that they would call me to discuss and when they didn’t call me within a week I emailed again with no response. Today I called them to discuss it and they gave me a story that some child was in a hospital so that’s why they didn’t get back to me. That may have been the case, and of course, a very unfortunate situation, but it seemed as though they were trying to guilt me about their lack of communication instead of being accountable to anything. When I started discussing the issues what we had with the cake, they were very defensive. They told me that having dark splotches all over the icing was normal, even though it aesthetically ruined the cake, and as I was telling them about the lack of support in the cake to keep it from leaning, someone was in the background saying that oh I saw them put it through and the very rude gentleman on the phone told me “I don’t want call you a liar but…” I would never order a cake if I didn’t want pay the price for it so this wasn’t about getting money from them but a legitimate grievance to which they took no responsibility. In fact, they got defensive and extremely rude on the phone that I told them I could no longer engage in the conversation and ended the phone call because they were being nasty and I will not tolerate being spoken to like that and called a liar. As any mom would, I went to great lengths to organize a wonderful birthday party, and the cake was supposed to be the centerpiece, but this shop failed to deliver what they said they would with the cake, and also had a lack of politeness and customer service. Do yourself a favor and find a more reputable cake shop that does professional work and provides basic customer service.
Sep 27 · Rashay LaymanIt's my favorite time of year! Time for butter beer!!! These are my favorite cupcakes at Sugar Rush! Sugar Rush is amazing. I have ordered several birthday cakes here and have never been let down. My kids and I have attended several of the cake workshops and we are always made to feel like family.
Sep 27 · Hillary DavisNEARBY ALTERNATIVES
Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
★ 2.0 · 16 reviews · 290.8 mi
Auntie Anne's
Milepost 219, 1 Eastbound Suite 1, Plainfield, PA 17081, USA
★ 5.0 · 26 reviews · 295.7 mi
Desserts by Regine-by appointment only
By appointment only, 714 Appalachian Ave, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.