First time trying the cakes from Susie’s and she did not disappoint. My order consisted of the key lime pie, the chocolate cake, and the lemon cake.Key Lime Pie: slice was a little small but its packs a punch. Not to tart not to sweet with a crust that completes the mission.Lemon Cake: I usually don’t like lemon and i ordered it for that reason. This lemon cake to me was better than the chocolate. Not to sweet and a hefty slice. The cake is moist and the filling is creamy. Very good!Chocolate Cake: can’t go wrong with this choice. I ended up eating it two days later and it tasted fresh still lol. Moist cake with creamy filling and not too sweet! This cake is definitely a classic and should be tried by all but don’t miss out on the rest they have to offer.
Jul 17 · Keena MiddletonSusieCakes - Chestnut
2109 Chestnut St, San Francisco, CA 94123, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
Essential details
- Address
- 2109 Chestnut St, San Francisco, CA 94123, USA
- Phone
- (415) 474-2253
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 241 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Tuesday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Wednesday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Thursday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Friday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Saturday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
About and visit notes
For Californians with a discerning sweet tooth, particularly those in the Bay Area, SusieCakes - Chestnut stands out as a beloved destination dedicated to the timeless art of American baking. Situated in the desirable Marina District, this establishment functions as a comprehensive, all-in-one dessert hub, covering every need from a simple afternoon indulgence to elaborate party planning. It proudly identifies as a women-owned business, adding a layer of community pride to its reputation for classic recipes and charming presentation. Functioning officially as a Bakery, Cake shop, Cookie shop, Cupcake shop, Dessert shop, and Pie shop, SusieCakes is the ultimate one-stop spot for any celebratory sweet treat.
The core philosophy of SusieCakes is rooted in nostalgia, bringing back the simple, delicious flavors of grandmother’s kitchen, executed with modern-day finesse. This commitment to classic, comforting taste is evident across their vast menu. The shop excels at delivering exceptional layer cakes and pies that receive high praise for their perfect moisture, richness, and crucial balance of sweetness. This makes it a highly dependable choice for everything from a spontaneous dessert craving to a major milestone event. Furthermore, the convenience offered by its full suite of services, from immediate takeout to large-scale delivery and party supply additions, makes it an invaluable resource for the busy San Francisco resident seeking quality and reliability.
---The location of SusieCakes is as appealing as its menu, placing it in one of San Francisco’s most vibrant and affluent neighborhoods. The bakery is centrally located at
2109 Chestnut St, San Francisco, CA 94123, USA
. This puts it right on the main commercial corridor of Chestnut Street, nestled between the Marina and Cow Hollow districts, surrounded by high-end boutiques and residential areas. The address is convenient for local residents and easily accessible for those driving or taking transit into the area, making it a reliable destination for picking up a last-minute celebratory dessert.Accessibility and convenience are key components of the SusieCakes experience. The establishment ensures it can serve all members of the California community by featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance. For those needing to quickly pop in and out, the service model is tailored for a Quick visit, offering fast transactions without compromising quality. The location’s inherent accessibility, combined with the comprehensive payment options—accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments—means that securing your favorite dessert is always a seamless and swift process, regardless of your mode of transit or payment preference.
---SusieCakes offers an exceptionally broad and convenient range of services, making it the preferred choice for both daily sweet cravings and elaborate event planning in the Bay Area.
Full-Service Shopping Options: Customers can choose between In-store shopping for immediate selection, Takeout for a fast grab-and-go experience, or utilizing the full suite of Onsite services for dedicated assistance with larger orders and party planning.
Seamless Fulfillment and Logistics: Recognizing the demands of modern California life, the bakery offers convenient solutions including In-store pickup for pre-ordered items and local Delivery services, ensuring high-quality desserts can reach events or homes across the city with ease.
Specialized Catering and Party Supplies: The menu extends beyond baked goods, incorporating essential PARTY FAVORS and Party Supplies like candles, cake plates, and toppers (e.g., Happy Birthday Acrylic Topper and Gold Plates). This unique offering simplifies the planning process by consolidating dessert and decor needs.
Modern Payment Convenience: Transactions are handled with speed and flexibility, accommodating all major Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, catering to the fast-paced, tech-savvy consumer in the Marina District.
Customization and Themed Options: The ability to order highly specialized and themed items, such as Gender Reveal Cupcake Boxes, Kids Cakes (like the Unicorn Cake or Baseball Cake), and seasonal pre-orders for holidays like Halloween, is a core service feature, simplifying celebration planning.
The key features and highlights of SusieCakes are defined by its expansive menu, its commitment to classic American flavors, and its role as a premier women-owned dessert caterer in San Francisco.
Excellence in Layer Cakes and Pies: The bakery’s strength lies in its classic CAKES and pies. Customer reviews highlight that the Lemon Cake is remarkably moist with a creamy, not-too-sweet filling, often noted as superior even to their excellent chocolate offerings. The Key Lime Pie is also a standout, praised for its perfect balance—not too tart, not too sweet—with a crust that "completes the mission." The Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake is celebrated as a reliable classic that remains moist and fresh even days later.
Unmatched Variety for Celebrations: SusieCakes is renowned for its selection of large cakes, ideal for any California celebration. The Signature Decorated Cakes include elegant options like the SusiePink Vintage Cake ($86.99), the colorful Rainbow Sprinkle Cake ($61.99), and themed options like the Floral Heart Cake ($76.99). They also offer large format options like the 2 Tier Cake ($280.00) and 1/4 Sheet Cake ($155.00).
Convenient Tasting and DIY Kits: For customers planning large orders, the availability of a Tasting Kit ($36.46) and the Cake Flight ($58.75) is a major feature, allowing for confident pre-selection. For home entertainment, the SusiePink Cupcake DIY Kit ($59.88) provides a fun, engaging, high-quality activity.
Diverse Small Treats and Cookies: Beyond cakes, the selection includes easy-to-grab items like Banana Chocolate Chip Cake Slice ($8.75), and cookie boxes featuring classics like the Chocolate Chip Cookies and the Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies. These small treats cater perfectly to individual indulgence or small group settings.
Factual Caution on Cupcakes: While the cakes and pies are highly praised for moisture and balance, customer feedback indicates some differing opinions on the cupcakes, with specific notes about dryness and overly sugary toppings on certain flavors like Red Velvet and Coconut. Professional advice is to utilize the excellent, highly-rated layer cakes and pies for a reliably superior experience.
For ordering, inquiries, or party planning needs, please use the following contact information for the SusieCakes - Chestnut location.
Physical Location Address:
2109 Chestnut St, San Francisco, CA 94123, USA
Primary Phone Number:
(415) 474-2253
Mobile Contact:
+1 415-474-2253
---The decision to choose SusieCakes - Chestnut is a decision to embrace reliable quality, exceptional variety, and streamlined convenience for all your California celebrations. What makes this women-owned establishment truly worth choosing is its proven track record with large, complex orders and, critically, the unmatched quality of its layer cakes and pies. The cakes, particularly the Luscious Lemon Cake and the Southern Red Velvet Cake, are noted for their perfect moisture and balanced creaminess, ensuring that your event dessert is guaranteed to be a hit.
For the busy individual or party planner in the Marina District, the comprehensive service model—offering everything from a Cake Flight for tasting to Delivery and all the necessary Party Supplies—saves invaluable time and effort. While customers should exercise caution or seek clarification when ordering the cupcakes based on varied reviews, the consistent excellence of the whole cakes, pies (like the spectacular Key Lime Pie), and party options makes SusieCakes the definitive, high-value choice. It is the premier destination for classic American sweets, ensuring every special occasion in the Bay Area is celebrated with a dessert that is moist, delicious, and perfectly suited to the moment.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Onsite services
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Overrated cupcakes.Went to check it out due to the hype and cute little shop. Cupcakes' base are dry and toppings are sugary.Tried 4 flavours: chocolate, strawberry lemonade (least worst because it had strawberry in its base so it wasn't so dry), coconut (taste like sugar) and red velvet (missing that 'bitter' topping and smooth base, it was just dry, felt like it was made 2 days before)Not worth it - if prices were half of it, I'd say they'd compete with Safeway cupcakes and get 4 stars.
Jul 21 · Edu GiansanteThe shop looks nice and they have a lot of options. There are no seating options unfortunately so it’s a take away shop. I ordered a piece of carrot cake, it was not the best unfortunately! I won’t be having it again here, but I will try some of their other stuff. A piece of carrot cake was $8.25. The service was ok, not the most friendly.
Oct 26 · Jo VI recently purchased a slice of the Tropical Cake.According to the website, it is described as: Vanilla cake layered with pineapple-accented coconut filling, topped with fluffy coconut buttercream and shredded coconut.Unfortunately, the slice I received did not contain any trace of pineapple, and it was overwhelmingly sweet to the point that no other flavors were distinguishable.I was very disappointed with the quality. For a lower price, Whole Foods offers cakes that are significantly more flavorful and balanced.I would not recommend this company based on my experience.
May 19 · Carnela LeeMaybe my expectations were too high, but this was truly disappointing. The cake tasted awful — dry, and nothing like what was promised. I’m honestly shocked. You can do much better than this. I just wasted $60.
Jul 14 · Fernand EizagaCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
SusieCakes - Laurel Village
3509 California St, San Francisco, CA 94118, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.