I will be back for every event I have that involves cake, and even events that don’t need cake but could benefit from one. The service was excellent and friendly. The personal touches on the cake are the best. The cakes are delicious every time and worth every cent.
May 12 · bri sTareBear’s Cakes
2150 W Arthur Ave, Chicago, IL 60645, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 2150 W Arthur Ave, Chicago, IL 60645, USA
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 5.0 from 15 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.
About and visit notes
## Introduction / Overview
Located in the vibrant Chicago, Illinois community, TareBear’s Cakes is not just another neighborhood bakery; it is a highly specialized destination for custom-crafted cakes, gourmet slices, and meticulously formulated sweet treats. Situated near the intersection of Arthur Avenue in the 60645 ZIP code, this establishment operates as an intimate and dedicated one-woman shop, with owner Taryn personally handling the entire process—from baking and decorating to boxing each order.
TareBear’s Cakes distinguishes itself in the competitive Illinois food landscape through a genuine passion for flavor and a focus on baking as a precise, almost scientific art. Taryn’s philosophy is that "flavor comes first," and she acknowledges that creating her irresistible goods involves "a little bit of chemistry." This meticulous approach has resulted in a unique product that inspires exceptionally loyal customer feedback. Patrons consistently rave that the cakes are "delicious every time and worth every cent," with one review highlighting the bakery’s greatest feature: the cake is "somehow dense and light at the same time," a challenging and highly desirable texture in the baking world.
While currently operating as a home bakery focused on pick-up orders, TareBear’s maintains a safe and inviting atmosphere, welcoming all Chicago locals. The primary offering is the custom cake, available for every event imaginable—or even for events that simply "could benefit from one." This specialization, combined with gourmet, layered flavor profiles like Spiced Caramel Vanilla and Chocolate Caramel Espresso, positions TareBear’s Cakes as the essential local expert for premium confectionery creations.
---
## Location and Accessibility
TareBear’s Cakes serves the Chicago, Illinois area from its base near Arthur Avenue, making it highly accessible to residents in the 60645 neighborhood and the North Side. While operating as a home-based business, the location is centralized for convenient pick-up of custom orders.
The specific location is near:
2150 W Arthur Ave, Chicago, IL 60645, USA
Patrons should note that the advertised pick-up address is specifically 2136 W Arthur Ave, which is immediately adjacent to the general address provided, ensuring a straightforward and easy-to-find location. As a dedicated custom bakery focused on fulfilling pre-orders, the accessibility is streamlined for quick, pre-arranged collection:
- Pick-Up Focused Model: The primary service is custom order and slice pick-up, ensuring efficiency for customers.
- Inviting Atmosphere: Despite its small-scale, home-based operation, the atmosphere is described as "safe and inviting," prioritizing customer comfort.
- Modern Payment Options: To facilitate easy transactions, the bakery accepts major payment methods, including Credit cards and Debit cards.
Due to the small, specialized nature of the shop, seating is limited—a fact noted by a customer who expressed hope for more seating in the future—reiterating that the current focus is on exceptional product quality and efficient service for the Illinois customer base.
---
## Services Offered
TareBear’s Cakes provides a targeted range of specialized bakery services, with a clear emphasis on high-quality cakes and corresponding confectionery items for the Chicago, IL market.
- Full Custom Cake Orders: Specializing in cakes for any occasion (birthdays, celebrations, or simple indulgence), with base prices provided for 6-inch, 9-inch, and 9x13-inch cakes. Custom orders can include flavors not regularly featured on the daily menu, with a possible surcharge for special ingredients.
- Custom Cupcake Orders: Available by the dozen (12 or 24 count) with base pricing that includes boxing and custom design.
- Gourmet Slices and Individual Treats: Offering a rotating selection of cakes by the slice for $6, providing an opportunity for customers to try various flavors before committing to a full custom cake. This includes unique flavor combinations like Strawberry Shortcake (with strawberry compote) and Cookies n' Cream (with OREO buttercream).
- Ready-to-Go Staples: Selling limited non-cake baked goods, including Chocolate Chip or Blueberry Muffins (2 for $5) and Banana Bread slices (2 for $5).
- Beverage Service: Offering a small menu of hot and cold drinks to accompany treats, including Drip Coffee, Hot or Iced Latte, Hot or Iced Matcha, and Hot Chocolate, with options for alternative milks and flavor additions.
- Expert Consultation: Owner Taryn is available for consultation; customers are advised to "Ask the owner, Taryn, what she suggests and you won’t be disappointed," ensuring personalized recommendations.
- Flexible Payment Acceptance: Accepting both Credit cards and Debit cards for all purchases.
---
## Features / Highlights
The standout features of TareBear’s Cakes revolve around the quality of its product, the uniqueness of its approach, and the personal nature of its service within the Chicago, Illinois area.
- Unique Cake Texture: The most highly praised feature by customers is the consistently excellent cake texture, described as "somehow dense and light at the same time." This difficult-to-achieve balance is a testament to the owner's expert baking techniques and "chemistry."
- Gourmet and Innovative Flavors: The standard slice menu showcases high-end, complex flavor profiles, such as Spiced Caramel Vanilla, Lemon Blueberry Bliss (featuring lemon curd and blueberry buttercream), and Chocolate Caramel Espresso (with a HEATH BAR topping), ensuring a sophisticated taste experience with every bite.
- Vegan and Gluten-Free Options: The inclusion of a specialized item, such as the Caramel Apple Cake, which is specifically listed as Vegan (V) and Gluten-Free (GF), demonstrates a commitment to accommodating diverse dietary needs in the Illinois community.
- Personalized Customer Experience: As a one-woman shop managed by Taryn, every cake benefits from genuine "personal touches" and dedicated service. Customers appreciate the friendly approach and the owner's willingness to offer expert suggestions.
- Artisanal and Meticulous Craftsmanship: The owner emphasizes that every recipe is "meticulously created to ensure flavor comes first," treating baking as a science. Each item is made from scratch, guaranteeing a truly homemade and premium quality product.
---
## Contact Information
For local patrons in Chicago, Illinois, specifically in the 60645 area, here is the essential contact information for placing custom orders, inquiring about the daily slice menu, or arranging a pickup at TareBear’s Cakes.
Address (General Area): 2150 W Arthur Ave, Chicago, IL 60645, USA
Note: All orders are currently for pick-up at the dedicated address, 2136 W Arthur Ave.
Phone: Not provided in the available public data.
For initial contact, custom order inquiries, and to verify the pick-up time, customers are encouraged to visit the bakery’s official website or use any available online contact forms or email, as direct phone information was not publicly listed. Given the nature of a home bakery, digital communication is often preferred for managing detailed custom orders.
---
## What is Worth Choosing
Choosing TareBear’s Cakes is an investment in unparalleled quality and dedicated, personal service, making it a standout choice for residents across Chicago, Illinois. It is especially worth choosing for a number of compelling, product-focused reasons:
Firstly, you are choosing The Best in Cake Chemistry and Texture. The primary reason customers return and recommend this business is the unique, highly sought-after cake texture—simultaneously "dense and light." This is a signature characteristic of Taryn’s expert baking, ensuring a superior mouthfeel and unforgettable taste in every bite. When a celebration demands a cake that truly impresses, TareBear's delivers on the promise of quality that is "worth every cent."
Secondly, this is the place for Gourmet, Customized Flavor and Personal Touches. Unlike generic bakeries, TareBear’s operates as a one-woman shop where the owner's passion and expertise are infused into every order. Customers are guaranteed a friendly experience and benefit from expert suggestions, ensuring a truly personalized creation. The gourmet flavor combinations (e.g., Chocolate Caramel Espresso, Lemon Blueberry Bliss) provide a level of sophistication that elevates any event.
Finally, the ability to find Dietary-Conscious Excellence, such as the specialized Vegan and Gluten-Free Caramel Apple Cake, combined with the convenience of buying single slices to sample the best flavors, makes TareBear’s Cakes a versatile and reliable specialty resource in the 60645 area. For any resident in Illinois seeking a custom cake where both the aesthetics and the flavor are guaranteed to be exceptional, choosing TareBear’s Cakes is the definitive, local premium option.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
All of her cake is somehow dense and light at the same time!! Ask the owner, Taryn, what she suggests and you won’t be disappointed! The atmosphere was safe and inviting, just wish there was more seating -but she’s new so hopefully there’s more to come!
Mar 26 · Grace VicarsThis cute new fresh baked goods in Roger’s Park is a hit! The butter crème frosting is amazing!
Apr 12 · Tara NourWould highly recommend the blueberry lemon cake. The cake is beautifully spiced, deliciously tart curd and lovely blueberry throughout. *chef’s kiss* 👌
Mar 28 · Keta BThe cake was amazing, I had the espresso chocolate cake and the taste was unforgettable. The prices are also very reasonable.
Mar 30 · Naijier KalyangoCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.









defloured: A Gluten Free Bakery
1477 W Balmoral Ave, Chicago, IL 60640, USA



This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
