The Bakehouse of Tarrytown

Introduction / Overview

For residents and commuters of New York's Hudson Valley, finding a truly exceptional, old-fashioned bakery-cafe that embraces the taste of homemade goodness is a daily delight. The Bakehouse of Tarrytown, situated in the heart of Tarrytown, New York, is exactly that rare gem. More than just a simple bakery, this beloved local establishment functions as a full-service restaurant and coffee bar, providing a welcoming haven right at the Tarrytown Metro-North Train Station. It’s an essential destination for anyone needing a quick, quality breakfast, a mid-day pastry indulgence, or a rich, perfectly crafted coffee.

The Bakehouse carries a notable history, tracing its lineage back to the revered Riviera Bakehouse in Ardsley, a local institution with over 70 years in business. While the Tarrytown location is a smaller bakery-cafe, it proudly carries forward the tradition of making everything on premises, from scratch, and with real, high-quality ingredients. Customers consistently rave about the phenomenal pastries and the high standard of all their offerings, from their butter-rich baked goods to their savory egg dishes. The setting itself adds to the charm—it is housed in what used to be part of the train station's waiting room, creating a nostalgic and unique atmosphere where locals can meet friends or simply enjoy a quiet moment with a cup of Coffee Labs-roasted coffee. With a diverse menu that includes everything from the essential Cinnamon Bun to specialty items like the Frittata Sandwich, The Bakehouse of Tarrytown is an indispensable part of the Westchester culinary landscape.

Location and Accessibility

The location of The Bakehouse of Tarrytown is a significant part of its appeal, offering ultimate convenience for a wide range of patrons in the New York region. It is perfectly positioned at 2 Depot Plaza, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA. This address places it directly at the Tarrytown Metro-North Train Station, making it a critical and popular stop for daily commuters heading into or out of New York City.

Its location within the train station setting provides a memorable backdrop, with one customer noting their love for how the place used to be part of the train station's waiting room—a charming nod to local history and community space.

Accessibility features are thoughtfully provided to ensure ease of visit for all members of the community:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring convenient access for patrons requiring mobility assistance.
• Paid parking lot is available on-site, which is standard for a commuter hub, but essential for those driving to the station.
• Direct proximity to Metro-North train services, making it a necessary, convenient stop for the thousands of daily commuters and travelers passing through the station.

The internal layout provides a group of tables where patrons can sit, and customers often note that finding a spot, even for a small party, has never been a problem, making it suitable for both a quick visit and a short, relaxing break.

Services Offered

The Bakehouse of Tarrytown offers a full complement of services as both a specialty bakery and a dynamic breakfast restaurant, ensuring all morning and midday dining needs are met for the busy Westchester community.

• Dining Options: Patrons have the flexibility of In-store shopping for a quick purchase, Takeout for meals on the go, or a relaxing Dine-in experience in the cafe's charming seating area.
• Full Artisan Coffee Bar: They feature a comprehensive beverage menu, including freshly brewed Coffee, Iced Coffee, Latte, Macchiato, Americano, and more unique offerings like the rich and flavorful Mocha (which one reviewer called the best they’ve ever had) and the robust Red Eye.
• Fresh Baked Breakfast Pastries: A wide variety of classic baked goods are available daily, such as Coffee Cakes ($4.95), the essential Cinnamon Bun ($3.95), various Muffins ($3.95), Danish ($4.95), and the highly recommended Scones ($3.95), along with the flaky Spinach Feta Boreka ($3.95) and Apple Turnover ($5.45).
• Savory and Hearty Egg Menu: The shop features a full breakfast menu with egg-based items, including the Ec-Egg & Cheese ($6.69) sandwich, the full-meal The Bakehouse Breakfast Burrito ($12.95), and customized options like The Cali Scramble ($11.00) and The Western Scramble ($11.00).
• Lunch and Other Items: Beyond breakfast, the menu includes items like the BLT (reviewed as good by customers) and specialty beverages such as the Matcha Latte and Arnold Palmer.
• Modern Payment Convenience: For a quick and seamless transaction, the bakery accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

The Bakehouse of Tarrytown distinguishes itself within the competitive Westchester market through a number of standout features that appeal directly to the local New York clientele.

• Quality Scratch Baking Tradition: The bakery maintains the high standards of its predecessor, committing to making everything on premises and from scratch with real ingredients, resulting in butter-rich pastries and consistently delicious baked goods.
• Premier Commuter Convenience: Situated directly at the Metro-North Train Station, it is the ideal spot for commuters to grab a quick, high-quality breakfast or coffee without adding an extra stop to their busy morning routine.
• Exceptional Coffee and Beverages: The coffee bar serves a fantastic selection, with the Iced Mocha being cited as "phenomenal," "super tasty and rich in flavor," making it a must-try for local coffee lovers.
• Unique and Nostalgic Atmosphere: The setting, which repurposed the historic train station waiting room, offers a charming, comfortable, and unique place to sit and enjoy a meal or pastry, enhancing the overall experience.
• Diverse and Hearty Menu: While a beloved bakery, it offers a robust breakfast and sandwich menu. Patrons can choose from delicious scones, flaky Danish, savory Spinach Feta Boreka, to filling meals like the Breakfast Burrito and various scramble plates.
• Customer-Approved Favorites: The pastries are a clear highlight, with customers having "not been disappointed" after trying several varieties, confirming the quality of the German chocolate cup cake and the perfectly sweet pecan topping.

Contact Information

For any inquiries about their daily baked goods, to check on stock, or to place a same-day order from their in-stock selection, please use the contact information provided below.

Address: 2 Depot Plaza, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone: (914) 366-7420

What is Worth Choosing

The Bakehouse of Tarrytown is absolutely worth choosing for anyone in the New York area who appreciates the combination of convenience, quality, and a touch of local history. What makes this establishment a standout choice, particularly in Westchester County, is its exceptional commitment to scratch baking coupled with its strategic location. For the daily commuter, the location at 2 Depot Plaza is a game-changer, offering a delicious, hearty breakfast or a stellar coffee beverage right where you catch your train. Unlike the many chain coffee shops nearby, The Bakehouse provides truly homemade goods—from their butter-rich pastries and perfectly sweet pecan-topped cupcakes to their famously rich Iced Mocha. You won't find traditional bagels here, but you will find "yummy" Scones and a variety of other baked goods that more than make up for it. The service options (Takeout, Dine-in, In-store shopping) and modern payment methods are geared toward the busy New York lifestyle, ensuring a quick and smooth visit. By choosing The Bakehouse of Tarrytown, you are not just getting a meal; you are supporting a local business that honors a decades-long baking tradition while enjoying phenomenal, scratch-made food in a truly unique and charming environment. It's an amazing place, highly recommended, and a must-try before or after your Tarrytown train ride.