EDIT: from 4 to 2 stars-Unfortunately, this place has really gone down hill. The bagels are always dry, and the challah has consistently been burnt every time. I tried door dashing from them for the first time and it came in a small brown bag with the baked goods sticking out of it- not stapled shut or anything. It didn’t even surprise me because there has been a lack of attention at The Bakery over the past few months, and it’s only gotten worse. The atmosphere is nice, but it doesn’t really outweigh the bad parts- I won’t be as frequent unfortunately, but I will definitely continue to give it a shot and support and update the review if it gets better.OLD REVIEW:A really great place to come in the morning before work. I’ve only had the baked goods, but they’re all great. The bagels, for me, are the perfect size and they taste really good! The only reason it’s lost one star is because it’s just a little expensive. $8 for a bagel with cream cheese and a latte (both delicious), and the croissants are like $3.50 each. *however* all the other cafes in NP are the same, so maybe there’s an external factor I’m just unaware of that makes it pricey. My main issue is that there is never any challah anymore… I would come every weekend to a boat load of loaves and pick the best and buy it and share with friends- now even in the mornings, there is MAYBE one loaf. I believe they make it on Fridays, but they used to on Saturday too if I’m not mistaken- regardless, I hardly see it anymore. As a Jewish man, I’m really hoping the new ownership cares for the Jewish community in the way the last owners did. Maybe I just happen to always come right before they put new loaves out, but just figured I’d note this. Final note- it’s not wheelchair accessible. Yes, you can get in the building on a wheelchair, but during cold months there is no where to sit downstairs- and no elevator. Similar with some other reviews I’ve seen, the bakery is amazing and has potential to be perfect, just with a few minor improvements :)
Feb 22 · Alexander MoonThe Bakery
13a N Front St, New Paltz, NY 12561, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 13a N Front St, New Paltz, NY 12561, USA
- Phone
- (845) 255-8840
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 442 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.
About and visit notes
For residents of the Hudson Valley and New Paltz, New York, finding a reliable and welcoming bakery is a key part of the local experience. The Bakery, situated at 13a N Front Street, has long been a part of this community, serving as a hub for morning coffee, freshly baked goods, and satisfying sandwiches. This establishment has a history of being a beloved local spot, known for its good food and inviting atmosphere. While it has recently gone through some changes that have been noted by patrons, it remains a place with significant potential and a loyal following. The Bakery offers a variety of products that cater to different tastes, from delicious bagels and croissants to big, tasty sandwiches. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of The Bakery, covering its central location, the range of services it offers, and the features that highlight its role in the New Paltz community. We will explore the positive aspects that have kept customers coming back, while also acknowledging the areas where the business has room to grow and improve, based on factual public feedback.
The Bakery holds a special place in the hearts of many New Paltz locals. For years, it has been a go-to spot for a quick bite before work or a casual weekend treat. The atmosphere is consistently described as a major positive, providing a cozy and welcoming environment that makes patrons feel at home. The quality of the food has also been a significant draw, with customers praising the taste and size of the bagels and the deliciousness of their lattes. Beyond the classic bakery fare, The Bakery has also gained a reputation for its hearty and satisfying sandwiches, which are noted for being a "most American sandwich place" in the Hudson Valley. This diversity of offerings ensures that there is something for everyone, whether they are in the mood for a sweet pastry or a filling meal. The staff is often described as friendly and helpful, adding to the overall positive experience. However, recent reviews have noted some inconsistencies in product quality, with baked goods occasionally being dry or burnt, and a perceived lack of attention to detail. This has led some long-time customers to express concern and hope for a return to the consistent quality they remember. Despite these recent challenges, the bakery’s core appeal—a great atmosphere and tasty food—remains, and its potential for excellence is a constant theme in customer feedback.
The Bakery is located at 13a N Front St, New Paltz, NY 12561. This address places it in a prime, central spot within the village of New Paltz. North Front Street is a key thoroughfare, and the location is easily accessible for both foot traffic and those driving through. New Paltz is a vibrant college town and a popular destination in the Hudson Valley, making this a high-visibility location. Its central position ensures that it is a convenient stop for students, locals, and tourists alike. The surrounding area is bustling with other shops and restaurants, making The Bakery a natural part of any outing in town.
However, a notable accessibility issue has been raised by a customer, which is an important point for potential visitors. While the building itself is wheelchair accessible on the ground floor, there is no elevator to access the upstairs seating area, particularly during colder months when outdoor seating is not an option. This is a crucial piece of information for individuals with mobility challenges. Despite this limitation, the ground floor is accessible, allowing everyone to at least enter and enjoy the products. The central location remains a significant advantage, ensuring that anyone in the New Paltz area can easily find and visit the bakery.
The Bakery offers a range of services designed to cater to various customer needs, from a quick morning bite to a full lunch.
Freshly Baked Goods: A core service is the daily offering of a wide variety of baked goods, including bagels, croissants, and other pastries. These items are a staple for many customers looking for a delicious start to their day.
Coffee and Beverages: The bakery serves coffee and other beverages, such as lattes, which are noted for being delicious. This makes it a great spot for a complete breakfast or a mid-day coffee break.
Sandwich Service: Beyond baked goods, The Bakery is known for its big, tasty, and filling sandwiches. This service makes it a popular lunch destination, offering a more substantial meal option for patrons.
The features and highlights of The Bakery are what contribute to its reputation and make it a valued part of the New Paltz community.
Cozy and Welcoming Atmosphere: The bakery's atmosphere is a major highlight, described as being a great place to come in the morning. This inviting environment is a key reason for its popularity and repeat business.
Quality Baked Goods and Sandwiches: While recent reviews note some inconsistencies, the overall quality of the baked goods and especially the sandwiches has been a significant feature. The bagels and sandwiches are consistently praised for being delicious and satisfying.
Friendly Staff: The helpful and friendly staff contribute significantly to the positive customer experience, making patrons feel welcomed and valued.
Historical Community Connection: The bakery has a strong history within the New Paltz community, particularly with its connection to the Jewish community through items like challah bread. While availability has changed, this historical role is a highlight that many hope to see continue.
Central New Paltz Location: Its prime location on N Front Street is a major feature, ensuring it is a convenient and easily accessible destination for anyone in the area.
For those looking to visit or contact The Bakery, here is the essential information.
Address: 13a N Front St, New Paltz, NY 12561, USA
Phone: (845) 255-8840
This information provides a direct way to find the bakery and get in touch with the staff for any inquiries.
In conclusion, The Bakery in New Paltz is a great fit for the local community for a number of reasons. Its central location on North Front Street makes it a convenient and practical choice for residents, students, and visitors. The cozy and welcoming atmosphere provides a perfect setting for a morning coffee or a casual lunch. The wide variety of offerings, from delicious baked goods like bagels and croissants to filling sandwiches, ensures that it can cater to a broad range of tastes and needs. While some recent feedback points to areas for improvement, the underlying potential and historical reputation of The Bakery as a quality, community-focused establishment remain strong. For locals, supporting this business means supporting a place with a storied history and a commitment to being a central part of New Paltz life. It is a place that many hope will continue to thrive and serve the community with the quality and care it is known for.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Payments
- Cheques
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Paid street parking
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Big tasty sandwiches made with a variety of bread. Most American sandwich place we found in 3 days in the Hudson Valley. Delicious and filling. Friendly, helpful staff.
Jul 25 · Niall MarshallBest service I ever had. The staff are kind, caring, and excellent customer service workers. The bagels, sandwiches, cakes, and pastries are all delicious. Can’t go wrong with anything here!
Jan 25 · Kristen AnnabiThis is one of my favorite places, ever. It's tucked away like a hidden gem for locals with outdoor seating and a loft over the bakery area with indoor seating and a play area for kids. It's one of the only places I can go to eat out with my child and actually relax!!!!! There's a wide variety of foods, not just baked goods but breakfast and lunch sandwiches as well as hot and cold coffees, teas, espresso drinks, and brand drinks for the picky ones (like bottled juice, seltzer, etc.) I appreciate they celebrate and bake for all different holidays. When I've ordered cakes the bakers have done amazing work. I FREAKING LOVE THIS PLACE
Sep 5 · Roberta FlahertyThe food is good, but the staff makes it so unwelcoming to enter and order. They’re extremely slow always making me late to wherever I need to go. The point of a take out bakery is the quick and effective process of getting food, not standing there for 15 minutes before someone even notices you. The workers lack the ability to multi task or greet customers. Horrible the way I was treated and disregarded, this place needs to focus more on kindness and an appropriate work ethic NOT decorating, walking around ignoring customers and talking with their coworkers/friends.
Nov 26 · Angela PistoiaCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.



Maxine's Catering/Bittersweet Bakers
1258 Rock Hill Rd, Accord, NY 12404, USA





Midnight Munchie Company
35 Main St Suite 205, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, USA




This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
