The Cake Lady

For residents of the greater Milwaukee area and all across Wisconsin looking for a specialty bakery experience, few names resonate with the promise of custom design and exquisite flavor quite like The Cake Lady. This professional bakery, led by owner and lead decorator Cecelia Baker Grade, has built a strong reputation for crafting desserts that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. What started as a beloved local business has flourished under Cecelia’s ownership, carrying on a tradition of quality and personalized service.

The Cake Lady doesn't operate as a traditional storefront with ready-to-buy pastries; instead, it is a custom-order specialty bakery dedicated to creating the perfect centerpiece for your biggest life moments. Everything produced here is made from scratch, using premium ingredients like Swiss chocolate, Swiss buttercream, and fresh fruits. This commitment to quality ensures that every wedding cake, birthday cake, or special occasion dessert is a memorable one. The business requires advance notice, typically one to two weeks minimum, on all orders, emphasizing their focus on custom work and detail rather than high-volume retail. For a truly unique dessert for your Wisconsin celebration, The Cake Lady offers a highly tailored experience from consultation to final delivery.

Conveniently situated to serve the greater Milwaukee metropolitan area, The Cake Lady is located in the charming community of St. Francis, Wisconsin. Its address is easily accessible for customers across the region, making consultations and pick-ups straightforward.

The physical address for The Cake Lady is:

3561 S Kinnickinnic Ave, St Francis, WI 53235, USA

The bakery understands the importance of accommodating all patrons, especially those planning large events who may visit for consultations or tastings. The location is equipped with Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that accessibility is considered for all visitors. This central St. Francis location places it within easy reach of South Milwaukee, Cudahy, Bay View, and the heart of Milwaukee itself.

As a highly specialized custom bakery, The Cake Lady focuses its services entirely on made-to-order, high-quality products for special events. The core offerings are built around customization in both flavor and design to meet the unique needs of each client.

• Custom Wedding Cakes: The primary focus, offering extensive customization in size, design, flavors, and fillings. Services include private consultations and tasting sessions.
• Special Occasion Cakes: Custom-designed cakes for all major life events, including birthdays, baby showers, anniversaries, and corporate events.
• A Wide Variety of Cake Flavors & Fillings: Options include popular choices like French Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, and unique selections such as Pink Champagne, S'mores, or Lavender cake, paired with over 20 rich fillings like Lemon Curd, Chocolate Mousse, Rich Raspberry, and more.
• Cupcakes: Custom cupcakes are available in all cake flavors and fillings, typically with a minimum order requirement (e.g., a dozen).
• Sheet Cakes: Available in all flavors, fillings, and frostings (excluding fondant) for large gatherings and events.
• Other Sweet Treats & Favors: The bakery offers other desserts, mini-desserts, and mints (such as Cream Cheese or Peppermint Chocolate mints) that can be used as wedding or party favors.
• Consultations & Tastings: Personalized meetings to discuss design concepts, flavor combinations, and overall vision for the event cake. Appointment is required for all services, including consultations.
• Delivery and Setup: Services are offered for event cakes, particularly for weddings, ensuring the cake is transported safely and set up at the venue.
• Custom Flavor Requests: The team is open to accommodating requests for custom flavors if a desired item or flavor is not listed in their standard menu.

What makes The Cake Lady a notable choice in the competitive Milwaukee bakery scene are its distinct features that prioritize quality, experience, and customer satisfaction.

• Customization is King: Every single order is a custom creation, unique in both design and flavor profile. The wide array of flavor options (over 10 cakes and 20 fillings) allows for truly personalized layered combinations, such as the highly praised lavender cake with lemon curd and custard filling.
• Made From Scratch with Premium Ingredients: A core commitment to using only the finest, freshest ingredients, including Swiss chocolate and Swiss buttercream, which elevates the quality and taste of the finished product. This dedication ensures the cakes are known for being both beautiful and equally delicious.
• Owner-Led Expertise and Experience: Cecelia Baker Grade holds a Baking and Pastry degree from Kendall College and interned under top chefs, bringing a high level of professional training and artistry to every cake design. She personally oversees the baking and decorating processes.
• A Focus on Wedding Cakes: The bakery is a recognized and popular choice for Milwaukee-area wedding cakes, with a portfolio showcasing everything from classic, elegant designs to whimsical novelty creations. They offer an in-depth process from initial inspiration photos to final design visualization.
• Variety of Payment Options: For convenience, The Cake Lady accepts Credit cards and Debit cards for payments.
• Commitment to Detail (When Time Allows): Past clients have frequently highlighted the bakery's ability to take inspiration photos and translate them into a cake that perfectly fits the overall venue and theme, though feedback suggests attention to detail can be a challenge on very tight-deadline orders.

To begin your custom cake order or to schedule a required consultation and tasting, you can reach The Cake Lady at the following contact points:

Address: 3561 S Kinnickinnic Ave, St Francis, WI 53235, USA

Phone: (414) 294-4220

Mobile Phone: +1 414-294-4220

Note: The Cake Lady operates on an Appointment required basis, so calling ahead is essential to discuss your needs and secure your date.

Choosing The Cake Lady is a decision to prioritize personalized artistry and superior flavor for your Wisconsin-based event. This bakery stands out because its business model is built entirely around the creation of custom, scratch-made masterpieces. You aren't simply picking a cake from a display case; you are collaborating with a skilled professional to bring a unique vision to life.

The commitment to high-quality ingredients, from Swiss chocolate to fresh fruits, ensures that the cake will taste just as incredible as it looks. The extensive flavor menu—which offers unique pairings like lavender cake with lemon curd—allows for a truly bespoke experience that standard bakeries often cannot match. This level of customization is particularly invaluable for wedding couples who want their dessert to be a perfect, unforgettable reflection of their style.

While the requirement for an appointment and lead time (typically two months for major events like weddings) is a necessary step, it underscores the care and individual attention that goes into every order. This is a choice for those who believe their special occasion deserves a unique, expertly crafted, and delicious work of art from a proven local Milwaukee-area expert.

To ensure the best experience, Wisconsin locals are encouraged to plan well in advance of their event date, allowing ample time for a consultation and for The Cake Lady team to perfect every detail of your custom dessert.