The Original Goodie Shop

For decades, when residents of Upper Arlington and the broader Columbus, Ohio, area think of a classic, dependable, and community-focused bake shop, The Original Goodie Shop instantly comes to mind. More than just a simple bakery, this institution is a full-line, scratch-made Bakery and Cake shop nestled in the heart of the Tremont Center. It holds a cherished place in local tradition, consistently delivering an impressive array of baked goods that blend nostalgia with fresh, daily quality.

The Original Goodie Shop is famed for its authentic, from-scratch approach to baking, offering everything from delicate pastries and hearty breads to custom-decorated cakes and its legendary Signature Cinnamon Sticks. This establishment thrives on tradition, making it the go-to spot for holiday treats, birthday celebrations, or simply a delicious start to the day. As a women-owned business, it contributes a strong, local flavor to the community, and its reputation for a wide selection means there is truly something for every craving and every occasion. Whether you're an Upper Arlington local or just passing through Central Ohio, stepping into The Original Goodie Shop is a delightful experience that promises a genuine taste of local baking excellence.

The bakery is conveniently situated at 2116 Tremont Ctr, Upper Arlington, OH 43221, USA. Its location within the popular Tremont Center in Upper Arlington makes it a central and easily recognizable spot for those in the Columbus metropolitan area. This setting is perfect for local patrons looking to grab a quick treat, coffee, or a special-order cake. The location is ideal for a Quick visit, easily integrating into daily errands or a morning routine.

Accessibility is a priority for the business. Customers arriving by car will appreciate the availability of a Free parking lot, which removes the hassle of finding street parking in a busy suburban center. For patrons requiring mobility assistance, the bakery also provides a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that everyone in the community can easily access their wide variety of baked goods.

The Original Goodie Shop offers a range of services designed for maximum convenience, whether you’re planning a large party or just craving a single donut:

• In-store Shopping: Customers are welcome to browse the full selection of freshly baked items in the store's cases, from donuts to decorated cutout cookies.
• Takeout: All items are available for quick and easy takeout, perfect for busy schedules.
• In-store Pickup: Ideal for pre-ordered items like custom cakes, special occasion cookies, or the various pre-arranged Packages designed for groups or specific needs (e.g., "Birthday Box," "Help Us Through This Meeting That Should Have Been An Email").
• Delivery: Providing service to the local area, allowing customers to have their favorite treats or catering orders brought directly to their home or office.
• Breakfast Dining Options: While primarily a to-go establishment, the shop offers classic Breakfast items, including their range of donuts, sweet rolls, danishes, and fresh coffee.
• Payment Versatility: Accepting multiple forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a fast and modern transaction process.

This beloved establishment stands out in the Columbus food scene due to its long history, comprehensive offerings, and commitment to the local community:

• Full-Line, Scratch-Made Bakery: The shop offers a remarkably broad product list, ensuring everything from Donuts and Breads to Cakes and Cupcakes is made fresh, in-house, daily.
• Signature Cinnamon Sticks: A top-selling, must-try item. These are described as the delicious center of a cinnamon roll, layered with Korintje cinnamon and a buttery brown sugar glaze, sold by the dozen ($10.50).
• Iconic Buckeye Candies: Offering the quintessential Ohio treat—hand-made Buckeyes (8) in a red gift box ($9.50), perfect for local gifting.
• Specialty Cookie Selection: Famous for its artistic cutout cookies, including Smiley Face Cookies (1/2 Dz, $13.50) and detailed Decorated Cookies Seasonal Design (1/2 Dz, $16.00), often featuring local themes.
• Ready-Made Packages: A unique feature providing convenient, pre-selected boxes for gifting or group consumption, such as the "Thank Goodness Karen’s Leaving" box ($43.50) or the "Tea Party For 4" ($36.95).
• Prepared Meals for On-the-Go: In addition to sweets, they offer savory items like Chicken Pot Pies ($16.25) and Quiches, providing a convenient take-and-bake dinner solution for local families.
• Community-Focused Atmosphere: Identified as an LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace, reflecting a welcoming and inclusive environment for everyone in the Central Ohio area.
• Women-Owned Business: Continuing a strong tradition of local, women-led entrepreneurship in Upper Arlington.

Here is a small sampling of the delicious items regularly found on the menu, showcasing the variety of treats available:

• Assorted Donuts (1/2 Dz): A selection of the day's freshest donuts, a local staple. ($12.00)
• 7" 2-Layer Round Decorated Cake: A scratch-made cake decorated for celebration, perfect for small gatherings. ($33.50)
• Cream Horn: Flaky pastry dough, handmade and filled with sweet cream filling. ($4.25)
• Sour Cream Chocolate Chip Cookie: A soft, cake-like chocolate chip cookie, a popular, time-tested recipe. ($2.75)
• Paradise Coffee Cake: Sweet roll dough layered with a sweet cream and topped with streusel. ($9.75)
• Buttercrust White Bread: A preservative-free, classic white bread, great for daily use. ($4.95)

Local residents are encouraged to reach out to the bakery for any inquiries, special orders, or catering needs:

• Address: 2116 Tremont Ctr, Upper Arlington, OH 43221, USA
• Phone: (614) 488-8777
• Mobile Phone: +1 614-488-8777

For any Ohio resident seeking an authentic, neighborhood bakery experience, The Original Goodie Shop is undoubtedly worth choosing. The primary draw is its decades-long reputation for scratch-made quality across an enormous selection of goods. Unlike many modern specialty shops, this is a full-service bakery where you can reliably purchase everything from your morning coffee and donut to a fully customized birthday cake. The legendary Signature Cinnamon Sticks are frequently lauded by patrons and are a mandatory first-time order—often described as getting to eat the best, gooey center of a cinnamon roll in every bite.

Beyond the taste, choosing The Original Goodie Shop supports a pillar of the Upper Arlington community. It's a women-owned establishment with a welcoming, inclusive policy (LGBTQ+ friendly, Transgender safespace), making it a truly neighborhood-focused business. The unique convenience of their packaged gift boxes and ready-to-bake savory options, like the Chicken Pot Pies, positions it as a genuine one-stop solution for both everyday cravings and party planning. For a taste of tradition and reliable, high-quality baking in the Columbus area, The Original Goodie Shop provides unmatched variety, convenience, and community spirit.