BAKERY PROFILE

Tottenville Bagels Staten Island

★ 4.0308 recorded reviews$1–10

6959 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

DirectionsCallWebsite

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Tottenville Bagels Staten Island
PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address
6959 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA
Phone
(718) 984-7052
Website
Visit official site
Rating signal
4.0 from 308 recorded reviews
HOURS

Listed operating hours

Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.

About and visit notes

## Introduction / Overview

For over 20 years, Tottenville Bagels Inc. has established itself as a cornerstone of the Staten Island food scene, offering locals and visitors alike a genuine taste of New York's bagel and deli culture. Located conveniently on Amboy Road, this establishment is more than just a bagel shop; it's a full-service deli and bakery that specializes in creating fresh, hand-rolled, and kettle-boiled bagels baked right on the premises. Their reputation is built on a commitment to quality ingredients, generous portions, and a wide-ranging menu that caters to every craving, from the earliest morning rush to late-night snacking.

Proudly serving the community, Tottenville Bagels is a local institution often praised for its friendly, quick staff and a classic, unpretentious deli atmosphere. While the interior has a classic New York deli "grit and character," as some reviewers describe, the food quality and consistency keep patrons returning. They offer everything from traditional breakfast favorites like their massive Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich to inventive signature creations and high-quality lunch items featuring premium Boar's Head meats. Whether you're grabbing a quick bagel with flavored cream cheese or ordering a full catered spread, this Staten Island spot aims to be your one-stop shop for fresh food, any time of day or night.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Tottenville Bagels is strategically located at 6959 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA. Situated in the Tottenville neighborhood of Staten Island, the shop is a familiar and convenient stop for daily commuters and local residents. The location on Amboy Road near Page Avenue is a major thoroughfare, making it easily reachable by car. While the interior is often described as small, it’s a high-traffic spot known for its consistent service.

Accessibility notes for planning your visit:

UL

  • The shop is noted to have parking available nearby. However, be aware that during peak hours, finding a spot may be challenging due to high customer traffic.
  • For those preferring to avoid the rush, the shop is highly accessible through various service options, including in-store pickup, takeout, and a robust delivery service via multiple third-party platforms.
  • The store is famous for being open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, on all holidays (though some online ordering platforms may show limited hours), providing unparalleled availability for New Yorkers seeking a fresh meal at any time.
  • Payment is convenient, accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
  • ---

    ## Services Offered

    Tottenville Bagels provides a comprehensive range of food and convenience services, extending far beyond the typical bagel shop. They truly operate as a full deli, bakery, and convenience store all rolled into one. Customers can expect a wide array of options for breakfast, lunch, and catering.

    UL

  • Breakfast and Morning Menu: Features classic options like Pancakes, French Toast, and a variety of Egg Sandwiches including the classic Bacon Egg & Cheese, and specialty wraps and omelets such as the Italian Omelet (Sausage, Roasted Peppers & Tomatoes) and The Jersey Classic (Taylor Ham, Eggs, Cheese, Hashbrown).
  • Bagels and Spreads: Offers fresh hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels in various quantities (single to a dozen), alongside a wide selection of flavored and plain cream cheeses, lox, and spreads like Nutella and peanut butter. Also available are Bialys and Mini Bagels.
  • Signature Sandwiches & Wraps: A huge menu of specialty lunch options, including cold-cut specials, hot items like the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana and Meatball Parm, as well as custom BYO Sandwiches and wraps like the Italian Wrap (Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella) and Cracked Up (Cracked Pepper Turkey, Pepperjack Cheese).
  • Premium Deli & Prepared Foods: Stocks a full line of Boar's Head Premium Meats (like Ovengold Turkey, Prosciutto, and Pastrami) and cheeses (Fresh Mozzarella, Swiss, Cheddar), available by the pound or in combination combos. They also prepare fresh items like homemade Potato Salad, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, and hot prepared foods such as Sausage & Peppers and Buffalo Chicken Strips.
  • Burger Bar: A selection of "Between the Buns" burgers, including a Bacon Cheeseburger, Jalapeño Cheddar Burger, and the Texas Burger.
  • Coffee and Beverages: A dedicated Coffee Station serving Hot Coffee, Iced Coffee, Flavored Hot Coffee, Cappuccino, and Herbal Hot Tea. The drink selection also includes a variety of sodas, juices (Tropicana, Naked Drink), and energy drinks (Red Bull, Celcius).
  • Baked Goods and Desserts: Beyond bagels, they offer a variety of Baked Goods like muffins and croissants, as well as desserts such as Italian Cookies, Cheesecake Factory Cheesecake, and Yogurt Parfait.
  • Catering: Provides catering packages for both business and personal events, featuring Continental Breakfast and Hot Breakfast options.
  • ---

    ## Features / Highlights

    Tottenville Bagels stands out in the competitive New York food landscape with several unique attributes and customer-favorite features:

    UL

  • Authentic New York Bagels: The shop is devoted to the traditional New York style, where bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked on premises, ensuring maximum freshness and a classic "grip-and-rip chew."
  • 24/7 Operating Hours: A significant convenience factor, the shop's commitment to being open 24 hours a day, seven days a week, ensures that a fresh bagel or deli sandwich is always available, a rarity even in New York City.
  • Signature Breakfast Innovations: The menu goes beyond the standard Bacon, Egg, and Cheese with unique creations like the THE CHIPOTLE SUNRISE (Bacon, eggs, spinach, avocado & Chipotle Mayo) and the HONEY I'M HOT (Bacon, eggs, cheese on French Toast with Hot Honey).
  • Full-Service Deli: The expansive menu and dedicated use of Boar's Head premium cold cuts elevate the establishment from a simple bagel shop to a high-quality neighborhood deli.
  • TikTok-Inspired Custom Orders: Staff have been praised by customers for being friendly and willing to accommodate custom or trending requests, even those "off TikTok," highlighting their commitment to modern customer service and satisfaction.
  • Commitment to Speed and Quality: The staff is often described as quick and efficient, working fast to process orders even when the shop is busy, while consistently serving food that customers rate as delicious and fresh.
  • Unique Menu Items: The shop is known for carrying some distinctive and fun items like Rainbow Bagels and specialized burgers served on a bagel, allowing for a unique dining experience.
  • ---

    ## Contact Information

    To place an order, inquire about catering, or for general questions, you can reach Tottenville Bagels using the following information:

    UL

  • Address: 6959 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA
  • Phone: (718) 984-7052
  • ---

    ## What is Worth Choosing

    When visiting or ordering from Tottenville Bagels, there are several standout menu items that consistently draw praise and represent the best of what this Staten Island spot has to offer. Focusing on their specialties and customer favorites is a great way to experience their decades of service and quality.

    If you are a first-time visitor, you should undoubtedly try the signature bagels themselves. The pride in their hand-rolled, kettle-boiled process is evident in the fresh taste and texture. Pairing a bagel with one of their unique flavored cream cheeses—or the classic Plain Cream Cheese & Fresh Lox—is the foundational experience. New York bagel enthusiasts looking for a bold flavor profile may appreciate the highly-praised, saltier profile of their everything bagels.

    For a hearty morning meal, one of the TOTTENVILLE BAGELS SIGNATURE BREAKFAST SANDWICHES is a must-try. The LEAN & GREEN (Turkey Bacon, Eggwhites, Swiss, Spinach, Avocado) is perfect for a health-conscious start, while the THE JERSEY CLASSIC (Taylor Ham, Eggs, Cheese, Hashbrown) offers a beloved regional twist on the breakfast staple. Customers frequently rave about the delicious, generous portions in their egg sandwiches, so you can expect to be satisfied.

    At lunchtime, move on to their extensive deli offerings. The use of premium Boar's Head meats for their cold cuts, like the Roast Beef or Ovengold Turkey, ensures a high-quality sandwich. For hot lunches, the various Lunch Specials and the massive Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana are popular choices. Don't forget their salads, like the Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad, which offer a fresh alternative. Finally, for a large gathering or office event, the Bagels Combo Specials or their comprehensive Catering packages provide a convenient and delicious solution, solidifying Tottenville Bagels' role as a dependable, all-hours favorite on Staten Island.

    VISIT FEATURES

    Services and accessibility

    These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

    Service options

    • Delivery
    • In-store pickup
    • In-store shopping
    • Takeout

    Accessibility

      Offerings

      • Coffee

      Dining options

      • Breakfast

      Planning

      • Quick visit

      Payments

      • Credit cards
      • Debit cards
      • NFC mobile payments
      • Credit cards
      PHOTOS

      See the bakery

      VISITOR FEEDBACK

      Reviews and recurring themes

      Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

      prices 10deli 6cold cuts 5breakfast sandwich 5cheese 5afternoon 3BLT 3macaroni salad 2buffalo chicken 2orange 2
      ★ 5.0

      Stopped by this morning to get a breakfast sandwich and something for lunch and I was very satisfied. The store was very well put together and very clean! Staff was very friendly. I had asked them if they can make me a sandwich I got off TikTok lol and it was AMAZING😻 definitely found my new favorite deli

      May 30 · Margarita Gil
      ★ 5.0

      my go to spot for sandwiches and bagels! they’re friendly and give good portions. if they for some reason mess up an order, they’re quick to fix it. definitely recommendit does get busy so keep that in mind!

      Jun 1 · Liz Alvarez
      ★ 5.0

      I've been to Tottenville Bagels many times during the past 6+ years, and I continue to return for a reason: The food is consistently great

      Aug 19 · Roger radio
      ★ 5.0

      absolutely love their sandwiches! usually go for a classic turkey sandwich or blt then add avocado (10/10)their bagels are always fresh and i love their variety of cream cheese flavorstheir staff is friendly and always make you feel welcomed.it does get busy so definitely recommend going with some patience and keep in mind that these people are human too. they do work fast and get you your food in a timely manner.

      Dec 8 · Elizabeth Alvarez
      ★ 1.0

      Absolutely horrible since the new owners took over. The cheapest portions and the most expensive bagels. 9.00 for a bec with pork roll and they gave me ham. Theres barely any egg on the sandwich and who puts the cheese on the cold side and not in the eggs. Why did I ask for scrambled eggs when they fried a single egg and put it in this sad excuse for a nyc breakfast. Their website offers 3 free bagels with every dozen but when you go inside they tell you no, a dozen is 12. Pork roll and Taylor ham are the same thing but Taylor ham and ham are not. Please don't put boars head on my sandwich and tell me it's pork roll, I'm fat I know the difference. This has been my favorite bagel spot on the island for 19 years. Unfortunately I have to find a new one as I will not be returning unless things change here. The food is not even good, if you're in the area you're better off going 2 stores down to the convenience store, Omar will take care of you, this place wont.

      Dec 7 · Al B
      NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

      Compare another bakery nearby

      Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

      Sal's Bakery
      ★ 4.0 · 165 reviews · 0.4 mi

      Sal's Bakery

      245 Richmond Valley Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA

      Details
      Kiddie Cakes
      ★ 4.0 · 164 reviews · 0.9 mi

      Kiddie Cakes

      6378 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

      Details
      Citi Bagels
      ★ 4.0 · 82 reviews · 1 mi

      Citi Bagels

      6372 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

      Details
      Bittersweet Bake Shoppe
      ★ 5.0 · 10 reviews · 1.5 mi

      Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

      Bittersweet Bake Shoppe, 4275 Arthur Kill Rd Store 3, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

      Details
      Cinnabon
      ★ 0.0 · 0 reviews · 1.8 mi

      Cinnabon

      25 Hank Pl, Prince's Bay, NY 10309, USA

      Details
      Pio Hot Bagels
      ★ 4.0 · 160 reviews · 2.3 mi

      Pio Hot Bagels

      655 Rossville Ave, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

      Details
      Country Donuts
      ★ 3.0 · 17 reviews · 2.4 mi

      Country Donuts

      877 Huguenot Ave, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA

      Details
      About this listing

      This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.

      SIDE-BY-SIDE

      Bakery comparison

      Expanded bakery photo