I had a Toy Story themed birthday party for my 1 year old and Stephanie and her team made the most amazing gourmet Toy Story themed cookies. Everyone at the party loved them and they looked like a work of art. In addition to the cookies I had asked Stephanie last minute to make me a cake smash cake and not only she delivered and did exactly what I had asked from the inspo picture but the cake also tasted AMAZING. I highly recommend this place for all your specialty bake goods, so worth it! Attached are the pics as words are not enough to describe the amazing work from this team!
May 25 · Zoe NissiriosTreat Me Sweet Cookies
26 Chestnut St, Ridgewood, NJ 07450, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 26 Chestnut St, Ridgewood, NJ 07450, USA
- Phone
- (201) 345-0606
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 3.0 from 42 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- Tuesday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Wednesday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Thursday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Friday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday12:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- SundayClosed
About and visit notes
Welcome, fellow New Jersey residents, to a delightful exploration of one of our region’s sweetest spots: Treat Me Sweet Cookies. Tucked away in the charming village of Ridgewood, this bakery has quickly become a local favorite for anyone seeking high-quality, beautifully crafted baked goods. Whether you're planning a special celebration or simply looking to satisfy a sweet craving, this establishment offers a unique and memorable experience. From its warm and inviting atmosphere to its impressive range of custom creations, Treat Me Sweet Cookies is more than just a bakery—it's a hub of creativity and flavor. This article is designed to give you an insider's look into what makes this spot a must-visit destination for locals and a true gem in the heart of Bergen County. We'll dive into everything from their location and accessibility to the incredible services and special features that set them apart. By the end, you'll understand why so many people in the area are singing their praises and why you should consider them for your next special occasion.
The foundation of a great local business is often its commitment to the community, and this bakery exemplifies that spirit. They have built a reputation not just on the quality of their products, but on their ability to bring joy to their customers. The team’s dedication to their craft is evident in every cookie and cake they produce, turning simple ingredients into edible works of art. As a local, you appreciate businesses that go the extra mile, and Treat Me Sweet Cookies consistently does just that. They understand the importance of making every customer feel valued and every order feel special. This is the kind of place where you feel like a regular on your very first visit, and that welcoming vibe is a significant part of their charm. It’s a place where childhood memories are made, and where adult celebrations are elevated with a touch of sweetness. The passion for baking and for their community shines through in every interaction, making it a truly special place for anyone living in or around the Ridgewood area.
Treat Me Sweet Cookies is conveniently located at 26 Chestnut St, Ridgewood, NJ 07450, USA. This prime address places it in the heart of Ridgewood's vibrant downtown area, making it an easy destination for residents and visitors alike. The location is highly accessible, situated within a bustling commercial district that offers a pleasant walk for those coming from nearby neighborhoods. For those traveling by car, there is often street parking available in the vicinity, though it's always wise to check for local parking regulations. The village of Ridgewood is well-connected by major roadways, making it a straightforward drive from various parts of Bergen County and beyond. Public transportation is also a viable option, with the Ridgewood train station and bus stops within walking distance, providing a hassle-free journey for those who prefer not to drive. This accessibility ensures that whether you're making a quick stop for a treat or picking up a large custom order, your visit will be as smooth as possible. The storefront itself is easy to spot and adds to the quaint, local feel of the street, inviting you in with its charming exterior. The location is not only convenient but also enhances the overall experience, as you get to enjoy the atmosphere of one of New Jersey's most beloved towns while you're there.
The services offered at this bakery are a testament to their versatility and commitment to meeting the diverse needs of their customers. They specialize in a variety of delicious and visually stunning baked goods that are perfect for any event.
Custom-Designed Cookies: One of their standout services is the creation of bespoke cookies. These aren't just any cookies; they are gourmet, hand-decorated masterpieces that can be tailored to any theme or occasion. As one customer review highlights, they can create incredible designs like gourmet Toy Story themed cookies that look like "a work of art." This service is ideal for birthday parties, baby showers, corporate events, and other special gatherings where a personalized touch is desired.
Specialty Cakes: Beyond their famous cookies, the bakery also excels in crafting specialty cakes. They can take an inspiration picture and deliver a cake that not only matches the requested design but also tastes "AMAZING," as noted in a review. This makes them a perfect choice for smash cakes for first birthdays, wedding cakes, or any celebration where a centerpiece dessert is needed.
Expanding Selection: The new ownership seems to be dedicated to continuously improving and expanding the product line. One review mentions that the new owner is "working on expanding the cookie selection," which suggests that customers can always look forward to new and exciting options on their visits. This commitment to growth is a great sign for locals who love variety.
Adorable Events: A unique and fun addition to their services is the offering of events. A customer noticed that the shop has been "offering some adorable events lately," which is a wonderful way for them to engage with the community and offer a new type of experience. These events could be anything from cookie decorating classes to themed parties, making the space a hub for creativity and fun for all ages.
The bakery is not only about delicious treats but also about creating a memorable experience for its patrons. Their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is what truly sets them apart.
Artistic and High-Quality Products: The craftsmanship is a major highlight. The custom cookies are described as "a work of art" and the cakes are said to taste "AMAZING." This emphasis on both aesthetics and flavor ensures that every product is a highlight of any event. The team, led by Stephanie, is praised for their ability to deliver exactly what customers envision, and often exceed expectations.
Fun and Cute Vibe: The physical space itself is a notable feature. A customer described the shop as "really cute and has a fun vibe." This inviting atmosphere makes a visit to the bakery a pleasant experience in itself, whether you're just popping in or spending time at one of their events. The decor and ambiance contribute to the overall brand identity, which is all about joy and sweetness.
Engaged New Ownership: The new owner is actively working to improve the business. The mention of expanding the cookie selection and adding events shows a proactive approach to business management. This is a reassuring sign for local patrons, as it indicates a commitment to listening to customer feedback and growing with the community.
Quick and Reliable Service: The ability to handle last-minute requests, such as the smash cake mentioned in a review, is a significant highlight. This demonstrates flexibility and a strong commitment to customer service, which can be a lifesaver for people planning events. The reliability of their delivery and service is a key factor in building trust with the local community.
For all inquiries and orders, you can reach out to Treat Me Sweet Cookies using the following contact information.
Address: 26 Chestnut St, Ridgewood, NJ 07450, USA
Phone: (201) 345-0606
Whether you're calling to place a large custom order or simply to ask about their daily offerings, the team is ready to assist you with their friendly and professional service.
In conclusion, Treat Me Sweet Cookies is an excellent choice for anyone in the New Jersey area, particularly those in and around Ridgewood. This local bakery is suitable for locals for a multitude of reasons, all of which contribute to its growing reputation as a community staple. Its convenient location makes it a simple trip, and the welcoming environment ensures every visit is a pleasant one. The bakery’s commitment to producing high-quality, delicious, and visually stunning custom baked goods means that it can cater to all your special occasion needs, from birthday parties to corporate events. The team’s ability to create beautiful, personalized cookies and cakes takes the stress out of party planning and adds a truly unique touch that your guests will remember. The fact that the new ownership is actively working to expand offerings and host community events is a testament to their dedication to building a lasting relationship with the people they serve. It’s more than just a place to buy a dessert; it’s a place to celebrate life's moments, big and small, with something sweet and special. For all these reasons, Treat Me Sweet Cookies is not just a business to support—it’s a valuable part of the fabric of our local community. We highly recommend you stop by and see for yourself why so many of your neighbors are raving about this sweet spot.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Small Business
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- On-site services
- Takeaway
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Dessert
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Pets
- Dogs allowed inside
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
The shop is really cute and has a fun vibe! I’ve noticed they’ve been offering some adorable events lately, which is a great addition to the space. I also like that the new owner seems to be working on expanding the cookie selection. Excited to see how things continue to grow!
May 31 · Casey O'HernNEW OWNERS – BE AWARE!The quality is not the same under the new ownership. I placed my order in January — this was not a last-minute request — and not once did anyone reach out to inform me that the business had changed hands. I had to follow up myself just two weeks before my bridal shower because I hadn’t heard a word. That’s when I was told by Stephanie (the new owner) that there had been an ownership change.She did mention that they don’t have an airbrush, so the colors wouldn’t be exact. I responded that was totally fine — I just wanted a shimmer of the color, a soft dusting.What I received, however, was completely unacceptable. The piping was sloppy, the designs looked rushed, and overall the cookies were nowhere near the quality I expected — especially after paying $162 ($9 per cookie). These were for my bridal shower, and it was incredibly upsetting to receive something so poorly done the day before the event.When I brought up my concerns, she did apologize — but offered no refund, partial, or otherwise. Instead, the only “solution” was asking me to pay even more if I wanted the cookies redone with a new printed design. No accountability, no real attempt to make it right.Please be mindful that the new bakers and designers do not have the same level of skill or professionalism as the previous owner. I truly wish someone had warned me.
May 15 · Aleasa MolinariI heard the store was under new ownership and since my daughter and I always liked visiting after dance, thought we’d go in over the weekend and grab something sweet and check it out. To say I was shocked would be an understatement. The store looked abandoned, I don’t even think all the lights were on, the cookie signs weren’t on and the menu board was still promoting Mother’s Day. There was nothing on the shelves to buy other than old Mother’s Day cookies and even Easter treats. Which I’m pretty sure by the looks of the Easter stuff they were spoiled. Otherwise it was pretty bare of cookies to buy. We decided to go look at the gourmet cookies and there were quite a few to choose from but when I looked behind the counter and into the kitchen it was dirty and disgusting, we just left without buying anything. The whole place seemed just dirty feeling. It was disappointing to see such a cute cookie shop go from what it was to what I experienced the other day. I even went back to my pictures to see if I was crazy and I wasn’t. It used to be so cute. I hope the new owners are able to turn it around fast. Attaching a photo on the left when I first came in to now, just for reference.
May 29 · Felicia BermanAbsolutely delicious cookies. The snickerdoodle was so tasty, moist and chewy/soft. Best snickerdoodle I’ve ever tasted. The lavender heart cookies were phenomenal too; just the right amount of lavender! 🙌
May 6 · Jenny BachCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.




Pierre & Michel Authentic French Bakery
38 E Ridgewood Ave, Ridgewood, NJ 07450, USA








This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
