I'm glad I took a picture of the cookie label when we visited Bentley last fall. I wanted to thank Tiff, who worked on our cookie. It came out amazing. Of course, we already know they will taste delicious. We will order cookies from Wicked Good Cookies again.Thank youColleen Savage
Jun 20 · Colleen SavageWicked Good Cookies
61 Shrewsbury St, Boylston, MA 01505, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
Essential details
- Address
- 61 Shrewsbury St, Boylston, MA 01505, USA
- Phone
- (508) 869-6577
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 113 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday8:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Tuesday8:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Wednesday8:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Thursday8:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Friday8:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- SaturdayClosed
- SundayClosed
About and visit notes
Welcome to a local's guide to a Boylston gem, Wicked Good Cookies. For residents of Massachusetts, the phrase "wicked good" is the highest praise you can give, and this bakery has certainly earned it. Specializing in custom-made cookies, this is a place where creativity meets delicious flavor, making it a go-to spot for everything from a simple treat to a show-stopping party favor. This article is crafted for our fellow Massachusetts locals who are looking for a unique and high-quality bakery experience. We'll provide a detailed overview of what makes Wicked Good Cookies a standout business, from its exceptional products to its convenient location and personalized service.
For those in the Boylston area and beyond, Wicked Good Cookies is more than just a bakery; it's a partner in celebrating life's special moments. The business has built a reputation for delivering not only amazing-tasting cookies but also beautifully crafted, custom-designed treats that are a hit at any event. We’ll delve into the specific services and features that have garnered rave reviews from a loyal customer base. We understand that when you're planning a party, a corporate event, or a special gift, you want a product that looks great and tastes even better. Our goal is to provide all the information you need to make Wicked Good Cookies your first and only stop for your next custom cookie order.
Wicked Good Cookies is conveniently located at 61 Shrewsbury St, Boylston, MA 01505, USA. This location places it on a well-known street in a central part of Boylston, making it easily accessible for anyone in the surrounding communities. Shrewsbury Street is a key thoroughfare, so finding the shop is straightforward whether you're coming from Worcester, Shrewsbury, or another nearby town. The shop’s location is a significant advantage for customers who are picking up large custom orders for parties or events, as it's a simple, no-fuss drive.
Accessibility is key for a business that handles custom orders, and Wicked Good Cookies’ location is designed for just that. There is typically ample parking available, which is a major convenience when you're loading up dozens of cookies for a big celebration. The storefront is easy to spot, and the process of picking up your order is seamless. For Massachusetts residents who appreciate businesses that prioritize convenience and efficiency, this location is a major plus. It ensures that the excitement of receiving your custom cookies isn’t dampened by a difficult-to-navigate location.
Wicked Good Cookies offers a specialized but impressive range of services centered around their delicious cookies. The bakery’s strength lies in its ability to combine a high-quality product with a highly personalized service. The menu is designed to cater to various needs, from individual treats to large-scale custom orders. Here is a detailed look at the services and products offered:
- Custom Photo Cookies: This is a major highlight of the business. Customers can order cookies with custom photos or designs printed on them, making them perfect for birthdays, graduations, corporate events, and more. A reviewer noted they ordered "6 dozen custom photo cookies" for a milestone birthday party, and they were a "big hit."
- Delicious Flavors: Beyond the custom designs, the cookies themselves are known for their taste. A customer review states, "Of course, we already know they will taste delicious." The focus is on creating a product that is not only visually appealing but also genuinely enjoyable to eat.
- Collaborative Ordering Process: The bakery works closely with customers to ensure their custom orders are perfect. One reviewer praised the "creative staff" who "worked with me on several iterations, positioning the photos and adding numbers to the design until I was satisfied with the appearance." This collaborative process ensures customer satisfaction.
- Bulk Orders: The bakery is well-equipped to handle large orders, as evidenced by a customer who ordered "6 dozen custom photo cookies." This service makes them an ideal choice for large events and corporate gifts.
- Personalized Gifts: The custom cookies are perfect for personalized gifts, as a customer mentioned ordering them to thank a specific person. The ability to add a personal touch makes them a thoughtful and memorable present.
Several key features and highlights distinguish Wicked Good Cookies and make it a beloved destination for locals. These are the elements that contribute to its strong reputation and loyal customer base.
- Exceptional Product Quality: The cookies are consistently praised for both their taste and appearance. The fact that a custom photo cookie "came out amazing" and was "delicious" shows the bakery’s commitment to a high-quality final product.
- Outstanding Customization and Service: The ability to create custom designs, particularly photo cookies, sets this bakery apart. The staff is described as "creative" and easy to work with, making the ordering process "seamless" and enjoyable.
- Perfect for Special Occasions: Wicked Good Cookies is a go-to for milestone events like birthday parties, as the cookies "looked great and importantly, tasted great!" The personalized nature of the cookies makes them an ideal choice for making an event feel truly special.
- Positive Customer-Centric Attitude: A customer was so happy with their experience that they specifically wanted to thank a staff member by name, which highlights the personal and positive interactions that are a hallmark of this business.
To connect with Wicked Good Cookies and place your next custom order, you can use the following information:
Address: 61 Shrewsbury St, Boylston, MA 01505, USA
Phone: (508) 869-6577
You can call them directly to discuss your custom cookie needs, whether for a small thank you gift or a large event.
In conclusion, Wicked Good Cookies is an exceptional local business that perfectly serves the needs and desires of Massachusetts residents. It combines a unique and highly customizable product with a commitment to both quality and customer satisfaction. For locals in Boylston and the surrounding communities, this bakery is the ideal choice for creating memorable party favors, thoughtful gifts, or simply a delicious treat. Its central location on Shrewsbury Street makes it easily accessible, while the seamless ordering process and the friendly, creative staff make the entire experience a pleasure. The rave reviews from customers, who praise the taste, appearance, and collaborative spirit of the team, demonstrate that Wicked Good Cookies is more than just a bakery—it's a trusted partner in celebrating life's special moments. For anyone looking for a unique, delicious, and personalized baked good, Wicked Good Cookies is undoubtedly a top recommendation.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
See the bakery
No visitor photos are available in this record.
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
We ordered 6 dozen custom photo cookies,, three different designs, for a milestone birthday party. They looked great and importantly, tasted great! The ordering process was seamless, and the creative staff worked with me on several iterations, positioning the photos and adding numbers to the design until I was satisfied with the appearance. They were a big hit. I hope someday the company adds a vegan and gluten-free option, so that all attendees would have been able to try them.
Jan 7 · Kathleen GI ordered the 3” sugar cookies with 2 different pictures for my son’s Wedding Welcome party. Mark sent me a mock-up to review before they made the cookies. I didn’t like how one of the pictures looked (picture was too light) so I sent him another picture and asked if they could use it instead. Mark sent me a final rendition that I approved before they began. Mark was great to work with….Everyone loved how the cookies looked and tasted. I’d definitely order from Wicked cookies again!
Jul 3 · Beth MillerI ordered these cookies for a client appreciation event and they are even more adorable than I expected!!! I love how they turned out and they included some for free so I can taste test away guilt free!! Every part was super easy from online ordering to quick delivery and now to see the finished product...so CUTE! Love it and highly recommend!!! they are Wicked Awesome!special thanks to Tiff who packaged our cookies!!!
Nov 27 · Amy O'ConnellThe Wicked Good Cookies “Graduate Gift Box” was the highlight of my brother’s graduation party! Being able to customize each of the 3 cookies was awesome, plus they sent a proof of what the cookies would look like. Service was fast, the website was easy to use. Plus the cookies are delicious! Mark went above and beyond in resolving a UPS mishap by hand delivering a set of cookies the day of the graduation party (I live a couple of towns from their bakery). I can’t tell you how much this meant, especially since graduation celebrations were different this year due to the pandemic. Thank you, Mark, and everyone at Wicked Good Cookies!
May 27 · Lauren BaileyCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.


Gerardo's Italian Bakery
339 W Boylston St, West Boylston, MA 01583, USA







Mozelle's Sweet Shoppe
Food Hub on line only, 25 Francis St, Worcester, MA 01606, USA



This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
