BAKERY PROFILE

Bagelry

★ 3.0204 recorded reviews$

1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address: 1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA
Phone: (516) 766-9207
Rating signal: 3.0 from 204 recorded reviews

HOURS

Listed operating hours

Monday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Tuesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Wednesday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Thursday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Friday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Saturday5:00 AM – 3:30 PM
Sunday5:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Open turn-by-turn directions →

About and visit notes

In the charming Long Island community of Rockville Centre, New York, finding a local spot that feels like a second home is a true treasure. For many residents, that place is Bagelry. A bagel shop in New York is more than just a place to get food; it's a daily ritual, a source of comfort, and a cornerstone of the neighborhood. Bagelry has established itself as a go-to destination, known for its commitment to quality bagels, delicious coffee, and a welcoming atmosphere that has earned it a loyal following. This article will provide an in-depth look at what makes Bagelry a significant part of the Rockville Centre community, from its accessible location and popular menu items to the key features that define the customer experience. We will explore why, despite occasional inconsistencies, this shop is seen as a reliable and beloved local spot for New Yorkers.

Bagelry’s reputation is built on a foundation of solid, consistent quality and a friendly, efficient staff. For locals, a bagel shop is a place where you know what to expect and where you can count on a positive experience. The business has earned a reputation for being a place where "it’s always going to be good," a testament to its consistent product quality. The staff, in particular, are frequently praised for their friendliness and efficiency, a combination that is highly valued by New Yorkers who are often in a hurry but appreciate a personal touch. While one isolated negative experience has been noted, the overwhelming sentiment from long-time customers paints a picture of a business that prides itself on creating a warm and inviting environment. This dedication to customer service is a crucial part of what makes a local business successful and why Bagelry continues to be a favorite among many.

Bagelry is located at 1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA. This address places it in a highly accessible and central part of the community. North Park Avenue is a significant street in Rockville Centre, making the bagel shop easy to find and convenient for residents and visitors alike. Its location near the heart of the village means it is well-integrated into the daily routines of many locals, whether they are on their way to work, running errands, or enjoying a day out. For New Yorkers, especially those in Long Island, a business's accessibility is a key factor in its popularity. Bagelry’s position on North Park Avenue ensures that it is easily reached by car, on foot, or by public transportation, making a visit to the shop a straightforward and convenient experience.

The accessibility of Bagelry is a major advantage that contributes to its status as a community hub. The surrounding area is a mix of commercial and residential properties, allowing the bagel shop to serve a diverse clientele. Its location is likely well-connected to local bus routes and is a short distance from the Rockville Centre Long Island Rail Road station, making it a perfect stop for commuters. For those driving, the central location on North Park Avenue provides a clear landmark and easy navigation. The convenience of its address means that customers can seamlessly incorporate a trip to Bagelry into their daily schedules, whether for a quick morning coffee or to pick up a dozen bagels for the family. This prime location solidifies the shop's role as a reliable and essential part of the Rockville Centre neighborhood.

Bagelry provides a menu that focuses on classic bagel shop fare, with a reputation for both quality and variety. The services are designed to meet the needs of a busy morning crowd while also providing great options for a more leisurely visit.

Fresh Bagels and Spreads: The core of the business is its fresh bagels. While specific flavors aren't listed, the general quality is highly regarded by customers. They are served with a variety of spreads, including different cream cheese options.
Breakfast Sandwiches: A major highlight for many customers is the breakfast sandwich selection. The "egg and cheese on a bagel" is specifically mentioned as a favorite, indicating a commitment to crafting a classic and delicious morning meal.
High-Quality Coffee: The coffee at Bagelry is frequently praised as "so good," which is a significant factor for New Yorkers who are particular about their morning brew. This makes the shop a destination not just for food, but for a great cup of coffee as well.
Efficient and Friendly Service: The staff is described as "the most efficient of any bagel place," which is a huge plus for customers in a hurry. The friendly service also adds a welcoming touch that makes the experience more enjoyable.

These services combine to create a comprehensive and appealing menu that caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences.

Bagelry has several key features and highlights that have earned it a loyal and dedicated customer base. These are the elements that consistently stand out in customer feedback.

Exceptional Staff and Service: The most significant highlight is the staff. Customers feel a personal connection, describing the experience as "like coming home." The staff are consistently praised for being "friendly" and "efficient," which is a powerful combination for a local business.
Delicious and Consistent Food: The quality of the food, from the egg and cheese bagel to the coffee, is a major draw. The phrase "it’s always going to be good" speaks to the shop's reliability and consistency, a key factor in building trust with customers.
Community Feel: Bagelry has successfully created a strong community feel. The long-term customers and the personal connection they have with the staff and the establishment are a testament to this. It's a place where people feel known and appreciated.
Popular Menu Items: Specific menu items, like the egg and cheese bagel and the coffee, have a reputation for being excellent. Highlighting these popular items helps new customers know what to try and reinforces the bakery's strengths.

These features collectively make Bagelry a cherished local spot in Rockville Centre.

For those looking to visit or get in touch with Bagelry, here is the essential contact information.

Address: 1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Phone: (516) 766-9207

Mobile Phone: +1 516-766-9207

This information ensures that potential and existing customers can easily find the shop, call ahead with questions, or place an order, reinforcing its role as an accessible local resource.

In conclusion, Bagelry is a highly suitable choice for locals in the Rockville Centre area of New York. Despite a single reported negative experience, the overwhelming feedback highlights a business built on quality, consistency, and a deeply personal, friendly service. The description of the shop as "my favorite bagel shop on Long Island" and "like coming home" speaks volumes about its success in creating a welcoming environment. Its convenient location on North Park Avenue makes it a practical option for daily routines. For New Yorkers who value a local establishment with a great product and a staff that makes them feel like a part of the family, Bagelry is a perfect fit. It is a true community staple that provides more than just food; it provides a positive and reliable start to the day.

MENU SNAPSHOT

Vibe

Menu items and prices may change. Confirm availability with the bakery.

By the 1/2 Pound 21 items

1/2 Pound Curry Mango Chicken Salad
New!!.
US$9.00
1/2 Pound Of Swiss Cheese
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Egg Salad
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Sliced Turkey
US$10.00
1/2 Pound Of Craisins Chicken Salad
US$9.50
1/2 Pound Of Tuna Salad
*Popular item* Flavorful half-pound serving of fresh daily albacore white tuna salad prepared with mayonnaise, and celery.
US$9.00
1/2 Pound Of Vegetable Cream Cheese
*Popular item* A half-pound serving of cream cheese, enriched with a variety of vegetables for added taste and texture.
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Scallion Cream Cheese
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Lox Spread Cream Cheese
US$9.50
1/2 Pound Of Baked Salmon Salad
US$12.00
1/2 Pound Of Soft Butter *Easy To Serve
A half-pound of soft creamy easy to serve whipped butter for your bagels
US$7.00
1/2 Pound Of Whitefish Salad
US$12.00
1/2 Pound Of American Cheese
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Olive Cream Cheese
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Chicken Salad
*Popular item* Flavorful half-pound of freshly baked shredded chicken breast salad mixed with mayonnaise and celery,
US$9.00
1/2 Pound Of Walnuts & Raisins Cream Cheese
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Low Fat Vegetable Tuna
A half-pound serving of low-fat vegetable albacore white tuna salad, includes light low fat dressing with a variety of chopped vegetables
US$9.50
1/2 Pound Jalapeño Cream Cheese
US$8.00
1/2 Pound Of Sliced Ham
US$10.00
1/2 Pound Of Cream Cheese
US$7.50
1/2 Pound Of Muenster Cheese
US$8.00

Salads 13 items

Turkey Mish
Served with a bagel: Plain Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Raisin Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Sunflower Seeds Bagel, Honey Oat Bagel, Onion Bagel, Garlic Bagel, Salt Bagel, Caraway Bagel, Everything Bagel, Whole Wheat Bagel, Pumpernickel Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Onion Bagel, Bialys Bagel, French Toast Bagel or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$12.00
Tri Color Quinoa Spinach Salad
Healthy food!.
US$6.00
Fruit Salad
US$6.50
Tuna Mish
Served with a bagel: Plain Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Raisin Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Sunflower Seeds Bagel, Honey Oat Bagel, Onion Bagel, Garlic Bagel, Salt Bagel, Caraway Bagel, Everything Bagel, Whole Wheat Bagel, Pumpernickel Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Onion Bagel, Bialys Bagel, French Toast Bagel or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$15.00
Garden Salad
US$12.00
Bagelry Summer Salad
Lettuce, mango, blueberry, almond, strawberry & coconut. Great summer salad.
US$7.00
Bagelry Combo Salad
Salad with tuna and egg salad. Served with a bagel: Plain Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Raisin Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Sunflower Seeds Bagel, Honey Oat Bagel, Onion Bagel, Garlic Bagel, Salt Bagel, Caraway Bagel, Everything Bagel, Whole Wheat Bagel, Pumpernickel Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Onion Bagel, Bialys Bagel, French Toast Bagel
US$14.00
Asian Chopped Salad
US$7.00
Low Fat Yogurt Parfait With Granola
Low Fat Yogurt Parfait with Granola and Fresh Fruits
US$6.00
Hummus Spread & Vegetables
US$10.00
Chicken Mish
Served with a bagel: Plain Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Raisin Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Sunflower Seeds Bagel, Honey Oat Bagel, Onion Bagel, Garlic Bagel, Salt Bagel, Caraway Bagel, Everything Bagel, Whole Wheat Bagel, Pumpernickel Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Onion Bagel, Bialys Bagel, French Toast Bagel or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$15.00
Chopped Salad
US$12.00
Master Slicer
The best vegetable ever. Get your meal/vegetables prepared in no time with the Original Master Slicer
US$39.00

Drinks and Smoothies 22 items

Naked Juice
Served with your Choice of flavor: Blue Machine, Green Machine, Protein Zone, Orange Carrot or Orange Mango flavor.
US$4.50
Nesquick
Choice of chocolate or strawberry.
US$3.25
24 Oz Flavored Iced Coffee
Served with your Choice of flavor: Hazelnut, French Vanilla, Caramel or Sweet Chocolate flavor and with Milk: Skim, Half and Half or Whole Milk. Served with your Choice of Sugar: Regular, Sweet and Low, Splenda or Equal Milk. Choice of 24 oz. or 32 oz..
US$3.50
11 Oz Tropicana Juice
Served with your Choice of flavor: No Pulp, Calcium, Some Pulp, Orange Pineapple or Orange Tangerine flavor.
US$3.25
32 Oz Iced Coffee
US$4.00
Iced Green Tea
Choice of 24 oz. or 32 oz..
US$3.75
Box Of Coffee
Served 12 to 15 coffee cups. Comes with milk, sweetness, and cups.
US$29.00
Snapple
Served with your Choice of flavor: Ice Tea Lemon, Ice Tea Peach, Ice Tea Raspberry, Fruit Punch, Grapeade, Green Tea, Half and Half, Go Bananas, Diet Peach, Lemon, Raspberry Ice Tea or Lemonade flavor.
US$3.25
Vitamin Water
Served with your Choice of flavor: Power C Vitamin Water, Focus Vitamin Water, Energy Vitamin Water, Revive Vitamin Water, XXX Vitamin Water or Essential Vitamin Water flavor.
US$3.25
Flavored Hot Tea
Orange Spice Chamomile Green Tea Earl Grey English Breakfast
US$2.50
Hot Chocolate
Choice of 12 oz., 16 oz., 20 oz., or 24 oz..
US$2.50
Chia Seeds With Low Fat Yogurt
Low fat vanilla/ strawberry/ blueberry mixed with chia seeds granola and fruits
US$6.00
Iced 1/2 Tea 1/2 Lemonade
Choice of 24 oz. or 32 oz..
US$4.00
20 Oz Soda Bottle
Choice of coke, diet coke, seltzer, or nestea.
US$3.25
Vitamin Water Zero
Served with your Choice of flavor: Vitamin Water, XXX Vitamin Water, Glow Vitamin Water or Squeeze Vitamin Water flavor.
US$3.25
Flavored Hot Coffee
Served with your Choice of Flavor: Hazelnut, French Vanilla, French Vanilla or Sweet Chocolate flavor and with Milk: Skim Milk, Half and Half or Whole Milk. Served with your Choice of Sugar: Regular, Sweet and Low, Splenda or Equal sugar. Choice of 12 oz., 16 oz., 20 oz., or 24 oz..
US$2.50
Hot Tea
US$2.50
Hot Coffee
Served with your Choice of Milk: Skim, Half & Half or Whole Milk and with Sugar: Regular, Sweet and Low, Splenda or Equal Sugar. Choice of 12 oz., 16 oz., 20 oz., or 24 oz..
US$2.25
Canned Drink
Served with your Choice of Drink: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Sunkist Orange, Ginger Ale, Nestea Ice Tea or Welch's Grape Drink.
US$1.75
16.9 Oz Poland Spring Water Bottle
US$1.50
24 Oz Iced Coffee
Served with your Choice of Milk: Skim, Half & Half or Whole Milk and with Choice of Sugar: Regular, Sweet & Low, Splenda or Equal Sugar.
US$3.00
Iced Lemonade
Choice of 24 oz. or 32 oz..
US$3.75

Fresh Fish 1 items

1/4 Freshly Hand Sliced Nova
US$15.00

Wraps 5 items

Egg & Cheese On A Wrap
US$9.00
Chicken Salad Wrap
US$12.00
Tuna Salad Wrap
US$12.00
Turkey Wrap
US$10.00
Ham Wrap
US$10.00

Oatmeal 2 items

16 Oz Oatmeal
Daily Fresh Home Made Oatmeal
US$7.75
12 Oz Oatmeal
Daily Fresh Made Oatmeal *Please choose toppings below
US$6.75

Mini Bagels 12 items

Mini Bagel With Butter
US$2.25
Mini Bagel With Ham, Egg & Cheese
Served with your choice of Cheese: American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$7.00
Mini Bagel With Bacon
Bacon on a Mini Bagel
US$4.00
Mini Bagel With Sausage, Egg & Cheese
US$6.00
Mini Lox
US$5.75
Mini Lox And Flavored Cream Cheese
Please specify flavor cream cheese
US$7.50
Mini Bagel With Egg White
US$5.25
Mini Bagel With Egg
US$4.25
Mini Bagel With Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Served with your choice of Cheese: American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$6.00
Mini Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Bagel
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato on a Bagel
US$5.50
Mini Lox And Cream Cheese
US$6.75
Mini Bagel With Egg & Cheese
Served with your choice of Cheese: American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$5.50

Bagels *Only 6 items

Bagel Chips
12 oz mixed bagels chips.
US$2.50
1 Dz Flat Bagels
US$30.00
Flat Bagel *Only
Served with your choice of bagel: everything, sunflower, poppie, plain, whole wheat, rye or onion bagel.
US$2.25
Baker’s Dozen Bagels
A dozen bagels please choose flavor, in the special instructions.
US$24.00
Bagels *Only
Your choice of bagel: plain bagel, sesame bagel, poppy bagel, poppy raisin bagel, cinnamon raisin bagel, sunflower seeds bagel, honey oat bagel, onion bagel, garlic bagel, salt bagel, caraway bagel, everything bagel, whole wheat bagel, pumpernickel bagel, egg bagel, egg onion bagel, bialys bagel, French toast bagel or bacon baja bagel.
US$1.75
Mini Bagel *Only
Served with your choice of bagel: plain, poppie, sesame or everything bagel.
US$1.50

Egg Sandwiches 33 items

Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Croissant
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$11.50
Bacon, Egg & Cheese On A Roll
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$9.00
Eggs On A Bagel
US$5.50
Bacon On A Flat Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$6.00
Bacon, Egg & Cheese On A Bagel
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$8.75
Bacon & Egg On A Roll
US$7.75
Bacon On A Roll
US$6.50
Egg & Cheese On A Croissant
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$8.00
Egg & Cheese On A Bagel
Served with your choice of bagel: plain, sesame, poppy, poppy raisin, cinnamon raisin, sunflower seeds, honey oat, onion, garlic, salt, caraway, everything, whole wheat, pumpernickel, egg, egg onion, bialys, French toast or bacon baja bagel and with choice of American, Swiss or muenster cheese.
US$6.75
Egg & Cheese On A Roll
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$7.25
Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Roll
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$10.75
Bacon, Egg & Cheese On A Flat Bagel
Served with Choice of Bagel: Everything, Sunflower, Poppie, Plain, Whole Wheat, Rye or Onion Bagel and with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$9.00
2 Eggs *Plate
US$5.50
Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel and with Choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$10.00
Ham & Egg On A Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$8.00
Eggs On A Roll
US$5.75
Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Flat Bagel
Served with Choice of Bagel: Everything, Sunflower, Poppie, Plain, Whole Wheat, Rye or Onion Bagel and with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$10.50
Bacon & Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$6.25
Brown Hard Boiled Eggs
US$2.00
Ham & Egg On A Croissant
US$9.50
Ham & Egg On A Roll
US$9.00
Bacon On A Croissant
US$6.50
Bacon, Egg & Cheese On A Croissant
Served with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$9.50
Bacon & Egg On A Flat Bagel
Served with Choice of Bagel: Everything, Sunflower, Poppie, Plain, Whole Wheat, Rye or Onion Bagel.
US$7.75
Egg & Cheese On A Flat Bagel
Served with Choice of Bagel: Everything, Sunflower, Poppie, Plain, Whole Wheat, Rye or Onion Bagel and with choice of American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$7.25
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato On A Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$8.00
Bacon & Egg On A Croissant
US$9.00
Eggs On A Croissant
US$6.50
Egg Whites *Plate
US$6.50
Eggs On A Flat Bagel
Served with choice of bagel: everything, sunflower, poppie, plain, whole wheat, rye or onion bagel.
US$5.75
Ham & Egg On A Flat Bagel
Served with Choice of Bagel: Everything, Sunflower, Poppie, Plain, Whole Wheat, Rye or Onion Bagel.
US$8.75
Bacon On A Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$5.50
Bacon & Egg On A Bagel
Served with your Choice of Bagel: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Poppy Raisin, Cinnamon Raisin, Sunflower Seeds, Honey Oat, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Caraway, Everything, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, Egg Onion, Bialys, French Toast or Bacon Baja Bagel.
US$7.25

Bakery 13 items

Chocolate Croissant
US$3.75
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
US$3.50
Mini Raisin Scone
US$2.00
Cinnamon Bun
US$3.75
Scones- Raisin Or Chocolate Chip Or Blueberry
US$3.75
Plain Croissant
US$3.75
Cheese Danish
US$3.75
Muffin
Choose from a variety of muffins including Banana Nut, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Coffee Cake, Corn, Cranberry Nut, Glorious Morning, Pistachio, and Raisin Bran.
US$3.75
Black & White Cookies
US$3.75
Strawberry Cheese Croissant
US$3.75
Small Chocolate Chip Cookie
US$1.25
Apple Turnover
US$3.75
Raspberry Crumb Cake
US$3.75

Sandwiches 28 items

Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50
Lox Spread Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$7.00
Peanut Butter Sandwich
US$5.00
Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.00
Butter & Jelly
Served with your choice of Jelly: Grape or Strawberry Jelly.
US$5.50
Cheese Sandwich
Served with your choice of Cheese: American, Swiss or Muenster Cheese.
US$5.00
Butter & Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50
Egg Salad Sandwich
US$8.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich
US$10.00
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
US$12.00
Cream Cheese And Nova Lox Sandwich
US$12.00
Cream Cheese & Jelly Sandwich
US$5.50
Low Fat Vegetable Tuna Sandwich
US$11.00
Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich
Served with your choice of Jelly: Grape or Strawberry Jelly.
US$5.50
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
US$12.00
Mini Bagel With Butter
US$3.00
Egg White Salad With Spinach Sandwich
US$9.00
Mini Bagel With Cream Cheese
US$4.00
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50
Butter Bagel
US$4.00
Tuna Salad Sandwich
US$10.00
Ham Sandwich
US$9.50
Pepper & Garlic Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50
Jalapeño Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50
Jelly Bagel
Served with your choice of Jelly: Grape or Strawberry Jelly.
US$4.00
Turkey Breast Sandwich
Tender turkey breast paired with your choice of bagel, including options like bialys, caraway, whole wheat, and more.
US$9.50
Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50
Vegetables Cream Cheese Sandwich
US$5.50

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

From the business

Identifies as women-owned
Small Business

Service options

Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

Coffee

Dining options

Breakfast

Amenities

Gender-neutral toilets
Toilet

Crowd

LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safe space

Planning

Quick visit

Payments

Cash only
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Parking

Paid parking lot
Paid street parking

PHOTOS

See the bakery

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

cream cheese 15egg 10bacon 6lox 5delivery 4phone 3sesame 3chicken salad 2saturday 2tuna salad 2

★ 1.0

One star – Extremely disappointed this time.I’ve been a regular customer here for a long time — we always get our bagels from this place. But today was a whole different story. The guy in the red shirt (staff) was rude, clearly in a bad mood, and made the whole experience super uncomfortable. No smile, no basic courtesy, just attitude. Honestly, I don’t come here to deal with someone else’s bad day. Totally unprofessional. I won’t be coming back after this.

Jul 16 · Mesut Yilmaz

★ 5.0

My favorite bagel shop on Long Island. I am addicted to their egg and cheese on a bagel. And their coffee is so good too. The staff are very friendly and are the most efficient of any bagel place. I love coming here because I know it’s always going to be good, and the staff is always going to be friendly. It’s like coming home.

Aug 17 · Scuba Divemaster

★ 2.0

Interesting way to rate this place but the food is great. Service is horrible. Still order breakfast from here but if they get the order right it is a bonus. Order bacon and eggs every weekend. Usually get it wrong. Today was egg whites and cheese on a croissant.

Jun 7 · Joseph

★ 4.0

Their everything bagel has caraway seeds and sunflower seeds. Interesting choice and gives the everything bagels a distinct and unique flavor. They should promote some kind of sanwhich that takes advantage of the unique caraway flavor.

Apr 8 · J C

★ 5.0

Excellent crunch (everything bagel with bacon and scrambled hard egg). Very pleased and friendly, quick experience. $6.40 total

Jun 17 · Kiana

NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

★ 4.0 · 1,107 reviews · 0.1 mi

Sugarberry Bakery Cafe

312 Sunrise Hwy, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 44 reviews · 0.1 mi

Cookies N Cream

17 S Village Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Details

★ 0.0 · 0 reviews · 0.6 mi

A Little Bit of Sunshine Cookies

40 Harrison Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 141 reviews · 0.7 mi

Bagel House

2664 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 212 reviews · 0.9 mi

Rockville Bagels

191 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre, NY 11530, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 63 reviews · 0.9 mi

Polka Dot Pound Cake

Polka Dot Pound Cake, 217 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Details

★ 0.0 · 0 reviews · 1 mi

KwaPaBa Bakery

2859 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 182 reviews · 1 mi

Bagel Boss Cafe

405 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 719 reviews · 1 mi

Mario's Bakery

409 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 137 reviews · 1.2 mi

Bagelville

2816 Brower Ave, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 354 reviews · 1.2 mi

Cino's Hot Bagels

2941 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Details

★ 4.0 · 73 reviews · 1.3 mi

Bagel Cafe Maru

438 Atlantic Ave, East Rockaway, NY 11518, USA

Details

About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.