Batter Up did my wedding & bridal shower cake! A m a z i n g. My guests were raving about my cake for days!! I wasn’t 100% sure what I wanted for my wedding cake at first and felt extremely nervous about it, I worked with Candice and she reassured me that we had sometime to think about it. I finally had an idea in my head but couldn’t find an inspo pic to show them. I explained exactly what I envisioned and Batter Up brought it to life. My wedding cake was everything I wanted & more! Before my venue allowed me to use Batter Up, I did a tasting at the original bakery they recommended and was so disappointed. I went there and picked up a box to take home to taste, it was messy and honestly just gross. Batter Up really gives you the whole experience! You set up your date for your tasting, go to the bakery, they have a cute little table you can sit at and take your time deciding, they offer you coffee (my husband LOVED their coffee) & then they bring out the options you picked to taste! The cake is cut into little heart shapes and they give you cute little spoons. My point is… Batter Up puts that EXTRA LOVE & care in what they are doing. 10 Stars for Batter Up!!! Looking forward to ordering more cakes & goodies for future events!
Apr 17 · Francesca ABatter Up Bakery
697 N Newbridge Rd, Levittown, NY 11756, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 697 N Newbridge Rd, Levittown, NY 11756, USA
- Phone
- (516) 681-4743
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 150 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Tuesday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Wednesday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Thursday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Friday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Saturday7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
About and visit notes
For those with a sweet tooth or in search of that perfect celebratory confection, Levittown, New York, is home to a delightful destination: Batter Up Bakery. This local establishment has garnered a reputation for crafting beautiful and delicious cakes and pastries, serving the Long Island community with an array of treats that cater to both everyday cravings and special occasions. If you’re a New Yorker looking for a bakery that understands the importance of flavor, presentation, and personalized service, Batter Up Bakery aims to be your go-to spot. From intricate wedding cakes that become the centerpiece of your big day to a simple yet satisfying donut, they strive to deliver quality and care in every bite. This article will provide a comprehensive look at Batter Up Bakery, detailing its location, the services it offers, its unique features, and why it holds a special place in the hearts of many local patrons.
Stepping into a local bakery is often more than just a transaction; it's an experience. Batter Up Bakery endeavors to create just that, whether you're meticulously planning a wedding cake tasting or simply stopping by for a morning treat. While every business has its nuances and areas for growth, Batter Up Bakery consistently aims to put that "extra love and care" into what they do, as highlighted by loyal customers. Their commitment to turning visions into edible realities, particularly for significant life events, sets them apart. This makes them not just a bakery, but a partner in celebrating life's sweetest moments. For those of us living in and around Levittown, having such a dedicated local bakery is a true convenience and a pleasure.
Batter Up Bakery is conveniently located at 697 N Newbridge Rd, Levittown, NY 11756, USA. This accessible address places it squarely within the heart of Levittown, making it a familiar and easy-to-reach destination for residents throughout Nassau County and beyond. Situated on North Newbridge Road, the bakery is positioned along a well-trafficked route, ensuring visibility and ease of access for both local commuters and those making a special trip. For New Yorkers, convenience is key, and Batter Up Bakery’s location aims to provide just that, whether you’re driving over for a quick pick-up or arranging a more detailed consultation. Ample parking is typically a consideration for any local business in a busy area, and the bakery's placement strives to offer a smooth experience for customers arriving by car. Its central spot in Levittown means it's a known entity for many, a place often recommended by word-of-mouth, and a reliable stop for those needing a sweet fix or planning an event. The ease of finding the bakery contributes significantly to its appeal as a local favorite.
Batter Up Bakery offers a wide range of services and products designed to satisfy various dessert cravings and event needs.
Custom Cakes for Special Events: Specializing in bespoke cakes for occasions such as weddings, bridal showers, birthdays, anniversaries, and other significant celebrations. They work closely with clients to bring their unique design visions to life, often involving detailed consultations and tastings.
Wedding Cake Consultations and Tastings: A standout service where couples can schedule a dedicated tasting session at the bakery, often in a comfortable setting with personalized attention. This includes sampling various cake flavors and fillings while discussing design elements, often accompanied by coffee or other beverages.
Assorted Pastries and Baked Goods: A daily selection of freshly baked pastries, including muffins, croissants, cookies, brownies, and other individual treats for walk-in customers.
Donuts: A variety of classic and filled donuts, often generously sized and packed with fillings. While availability can vary, they are a popular item for quick grabs.
Pies and Tarts: Seasonal or regularly available pies and tarts, perfect for family desserts or holiday gatherings.
Cupcakes: Individual cupcakes in various flavors, often decorated for everyday enjoyment or special orders.
Dessert Platters: Custom dessert platters for catering events, offering an assortment of miniature pastries, cookies, and other bite-sized treats.
Coffee Service: Often provides coffee to complement their baked goods, particularly during morning hours or tasting sessions.
Batter Up Bakery distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that resonate with its loyal customer base.
Exceptional Custom Cake Design and Execution: A primary highlight is their ability to translate a client's specific vision for custom cakes into a stunning reality. This bespoke service, particularly for wedding and bridal shower cakes, is frequently lauded for its creativity and precision, often exceeding expectations.
Personalized Tasting Experience: Unlike some bakeries that offer pre-packaged tastings, Batter Up Bakery provides a dedicated, in-person tasting experience. This often involves a comfortable seating area, a selection of heart-shaped cake samples, and complimentary coffee, creating a relaxed and enjoyable decision-making process for clients.
Generous Fillings in Donuts: For donut enthusiasts, a notable feature is the generous amount of filling in their donuts, which is often cited as a key characteristic, appealing to those who prefer a rich, oozing center.
Commitment to Customer Service for Events: Customers planning major events, particularly weddings, often praise the staff, like Candice, for their reassurance, patience, and collaborative approach in helping design the perfect cake, demonstrating a strong customer-centric focus for significant orders.
Local Recognition: Having been recognized as "Long Island’s best" by some, this accolade, while subjective to individual taste, highlights a level of local acclaim and community recognition for their products.
Focus on "Extra Love & Care": Many patrons describe the bakery's approach as putting "extra love & care" into their products and services, fostering a perception of dedicated craftsmanship and genuine passion for baking.
For all your baking needs, Batter Up Bakery can be contacted at the following:
Address: 697 N Newbridge Rd, Levittown, NY 11756, USA
Phone: (516) 681-4743
In essence, Batter Up Bakery in Levittown is more than just a place to buy desserts; it's a vital part of the local fabric for those in search of quality baked goods, especially for life's significant moments. For New Yorkers, particularly those on Long Island, having a reliable and creatively driven local bakery is incredibly valuable. While individual experiences with everyday items like donuts might vary based on personal preference—as is common with any culinary establishment—the consistent praise for their custom cakes, particularly wedding and bridal shower creations, speaks volumes about their expertise and dedication in that specialized area.
What makes Batter Up Bakery particularly suitable for locals is its commitment to personalized service, exemplified by their detailed cake consultations and the evident care they put into their bespoke orders. For residents of Levittown and surrounding areas, this bakery offers the convenience of a nearby establishment that can handle everything from a spontaneous sweet craving to the most important cake of your life. It serves as a community asset, providing not just delicious treats but also a sense of local charm and a personalized touch that larger, more impersonal chains often lack. When you’re looking to support a local business that genuinely invests in its craft and its customers' satisfaction, especially for those unforgettable celebrations, Batter Up Bakery remains a compelling and worthy choice for the discerning palates of New York locals.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- On-site services
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
I’d heard that this bakery was voted Long Island’s best, so I was excited to give it a try. Before heading over, I called to ask if they had Boston cream and jelly donuts available, and was told they did. However, when we arrived just a few minutes later, we were informed that they were baking a batch. It took about 10 minutes.The bakery itself is quite small with no seating, aside from a table for DoorDash pickups. I also noticed a tiny printout of the menu, which I missed at first, as I was expecting something more visible like a wall menu. Another thing that stood out was the lack of labels on the desserts, so it was a bit hard to know what everything was. There were also some pies (possibly meringue) on a shelf without any covers, which made me a little uncomfortable.On the plus side, the donuts are generously sized and packed with filling. If you like your donuts oozing with filling, this is the place for you!However, I was a bit disappointed with the taste. The filling in both the Boston cream and the jelly donut didn’t quite hit the mark. The Boston cream filling had an odd flavor that I couldn’t quite place—maybe it was too "eggy," or something else, but it didn’t taste as expected. The jelly filling was similarly off, so much so that I couldn’t finish it and ended up scraping out the excess.While they’ve earned the title of Long Island’s best, I’d say your experience may vary!
Apr 25 · Mimmoon CWe worked with Candace for our 2 wedding events and we could not be any more impressed or happy. Candace is very well organized, very easy to talk to and work with. Her and her team did an absolutely phenomenal job on our 2 wedding cakes, both were such beautiful works of art, and they were probably THE best cakes we ever had. Everyone in our families still talk about how delicious the cakes were and how amazing they looked. We will most certainly be repeat customers for any future events that we have!
Jun 15 · Sonia DiMartinoI ordered a cake for my mom's birthday this weekend. Ordering the cake was super easy through the website. The cake was BEAUTIFUL! I expected the old school thick buttercream flowers around the border of it, but the designs were soooo cute. The cake was very light, fluffy, and fresh. I ordered the lemon mousse filling and it was delicious; very light and not overly sweet.I will definitely be ordering from here again 🥰
Jun 23 · Kimberly SciortinoWow! I’m blown away by the service here.I called the shop today looking for a custom cake — last minute — and they had it ready for me in just a few hours! The cake came out absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing (cannoli cake, by the way — a huge hit at the office!). Huge thanks to Amber for pulling this off on such short notice. I’ll definitely be recommending you to all my friends and family.
Jul 17 · Mark BlinkCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.


Lisau2019s bagel-n-brew delicatessen
164 Gardiners Ave, Levittown, NY 11756, USA










This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
