Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville

Introduction / Overview

For residents of South Carolina looking for a genuine taste of Southern tradition, the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Greenville offers a dessert experience steeped in family heritage and high-quality, scratch-made ingredients. More than just a dessert shop, this location serves as a modern revival of grandmother-approved, time-honored recipes, specializing in a wide variety of sweet pies that capture the comforting essence of the region. The very concept of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is rooted in the kitchens of the founders' maternal grandmothers, Ruth and Edith, who imparted a love for baking and a standard of quality that guides every item on the menu. This strong foundation ensures that every pie, cookie, and parfait is made daily from scratch, upholding a tradition of making every day a "Buttermilk Sky day."

Located on Augusta Street, this Greenville pie shop has become a beloved fixture for local users, offering everything from full 9-inch pies perfect for holiday dinners and celebrations, to the popular 4-inch mini pies, often referred to as 'Cutie Pies,' ideal for individual treats or sampling multiple flavors. The menu is a delightful blend of classic Southern staples, like the Voted “Best Pecan Pie” Nanny's Pecan, and creative, best-selling originals such as the renowned I-40 Pie—a flavorful twist on pecan pie that incorporates shredded coconut and chocolate chips. Customers often praise not only the amazing taste and rich, creamy fillings but also the high level of hospitality, confirming that the experience truly goes above and beyond a typical sweet shop visit. Whether seeking a quick, delicious dessert or a show-stopping finish for a special occasion, the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is committed to connecting people through the simple, comforting joy of pie.

The shop’s dedication to quality is apparent in its ingredients and baking methods. They make the dough for their signature shortbread crusts in-house, press each individual crust, and prepare all fillings and toppings fresh daily. This focus on "Made From Scratch" excellence is why South Carolina locals return repeatedly for their dessert needs. They are also active in the community, often participating in the "Pie It Forward" program, which helps support local organizations by donating a portion of sales from a designated pie flavor each month—a wonderful example of Southern hospitality extending beyond the front door.

Location and Accessibility

The Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville is conveniently situated at 2222 Augusta St #9, Greenville, SC 29605, USA. This central location places the dessert shop in a highly accessible area of Greenville, making it a convenient stop for residents traveling within the city and from surrounding Upstate communities. Located on Augusta Street, the shop is easy to find, often drawing customers who are intrigued by the welcoming atmosphere and the aroma of fresh-baked goods.

For the convenience of all South Carolina patrons, the shop provides excellent accessibility features. These include a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that all customers, regardless of mobility requirements, can enjoy a visit. The service options are highly flexible, catering to a busy, modern clientele with choices that include Delivery, In-store pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout, allowing for quick visits or a more leisurely experience. For those who choose to linger, the shop also offers Wi-Fi connectivity. When it comes to payment, the shop makes it simple, accepting Checks, Credit cards, and Debit cards.

Services Offered

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville offers a focused menu of high-quality, scratch-made Southern desserts and related services.

• Full 9-Inch Pies: A core offering featuring classic and signature flavors like the famous I-40 Pie (pecan pie with coconut and chocolate chips), Nanny's Pecan, Key Lime, Chewy Chocolate Chip, Southern Custard, Coconut Cream, plus Seasonal options like Caramel Turtle, and Pie It Forward (PIF) flavors like Peach. All full pies are currently priced at $32.00.
• 4-Inch Mini Pies: Perfect for single servings, personal sampling, or assembling variety boxes. Flavors mirror the 9-inch pies, including I-40, Chewy Chocolate Chip, Nanny's Pecan, Key Lime, Southern Custard, Coconut Cream, and Seasonal/PIF options, priced at $6.25 each.
• Pie Packs and Mini Dozens: Discounted assortments for party planning, including a 4" Pie Pack (4 mini pies for $24.00) and a Dozen Minis (12 mini pies for $64.00).
• Pie Parfaits: Layered, creamy desserts served in cups, offering a rich and easy-to-eat alternative to pie slices. Current featured flavors are Peanut Butter Parfait ($7.25) and Chocolate Cream Parfait ($7.25).
• Thumbprint Cookies: Melt-in-your-mouth, soft-baked shortbread cookies available by the piece ($1.25) or by the dozen ($14.00). Varieties include Vanilla, Vanilla With Ganache, and Key Lime.
• Cloud Cookies: Their homemade shortbread recipe cookies with pecans and almond extract, offered in a quantity of 24 cookies for $15.00.
• Beverages: Offering fresh, quality Coffee to perfectly complement any dessert selection.
• Convenient Ordering Options: Providing Delivery, In-store pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout for maximum customer flexibility.

Features / Highlights

Several distinctive features make Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville a must-visit dessert shop for South Carolina users.

• Southern, Grandmother-Approved Recipes: The entire menu is based on time-honored, proprietary recipes from the founders’ two Southern grandmothers, Ruth (fruit pies) and Edith (cream and pecan pies), ensuring an authentic, nostalgic taste.
• The Best-Selling I-40 Pie: A signature, original creation named for Interstate 40, this best-seller is a unique twist on pecan pie, enhanced with shredded coconut and chocolate chips, making it a regional favorite.
• Focus on Scratch-Made Quality: Every element, from the buttery shortbread crust dough to the fillings and toppings, is made from scratch daily in-house, prioritizing quality and fresh flavor over mass-produced convenience.
• Flexible Sizing for All Needs: The availability of both full 9-inch pies for major gatherings and 4-inch 'Cutie Pies' allows customers to easily cater events or simply enjoy an individual treat, or try multiple flavors.
• Creative Dessert Alternatives: Beyond pies, the shop offers unique items like the indulgent Pie Parfaits and various thumbprint and Cloud Cookies, providing delicious options for all preferences.
• Community Engagement: The "Pie It Forward" initiative highlights the shop’s commitment to giving back to the local community, making a purchase at the shop a way to support local charities.
• Exceptional Hospitality: Customer reviews consistently highlight the warm, friendly, and above-and-beyond hospitality, creating a welcoming and pleasant shopping experience.

Contact Information

South Carolina customers interested in ordering a pie or visiting the shop can find Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville at the following location and contact details:

Address: 2222 Augusta St #9, Greenville, SC 29605, USA

Phone: (864) 203-3370

What is worth choosing

Choosing Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville is highly recommended for South Carolina residents for several compelling reasons that center on quality, heritage, and convenience. The most significant factor is the commitment to a traditional, scratch-made process. In an era of quick, often-processed desserts, the shop stands out by upholding the high standards of Southern grandmothers. This means every bite—from the rich, gooey Nanny's Pecan pie, voted "Best Pecan Pie" by

Taste of the South

, to the bright and balanced Key Lime pie—delivers a superior flavor and texture that mass-produced options simply cannot replicate.

For Greenville locals and those in the Upstate area, the flexible menu is a game-changer. Whether you are hosting a small dinner and want to try a variety of flavors with a 4" Pie Pack, or you need a decadent 9" I-40 Pie for a major holiday, the shop offers the perfect size and a wide range of flavor profiles. The addition of portable, rich Pie Parfaits addresses the need for a quick, luxurious grab-and-go sweet that can be enjoyed instantly, as customer reviews attest to their rich and creamy nature.

Beyond the exceptional food, the shop embodies genuine Southern hospitality. The staff's willingness to go "above and beyond" and the shop’s charitable "Pie It Forward" program reflect a business model that values community as much as confections. This combination of deep-rooted Southern tradition, unparalleled scratch-made quality, and modern convenience—including delivery and multiple payment options—makes Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop the premier destination for pies and authentic Southern desserts in the South Carolina Upstate region.