Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

For North Carolinians with a discerning sweet tooth, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Huntersville is a cherished local gem that specializes in what it does best: crafting authentic, scratch-made Southern pies. Functioning as a specialized Pie Shop and Bakery, this spot in Birkdale Village offers a charming, cozy, and nostalgic experience reminiscent of simpler times and Grandma’s kitchen. The entire business is proudly women-owned, adding a personal and dedicated touch to every flaky crust and rich filling.

The core of the offering is simple yet profound: exceptional pies made with real, simple ingredients. They are famous for their Southern-inspired flavors, which range from the tart and refreshing Key Lime Pie—often called "phenomenal" and a "top 3" by critical customers—to decadent chocolate and nutty variations. Their signature piece is the I-40 Pie, a unique twist on the classic pecan pie that incorporates toasted coconut and chocolate chips for an unforgettable flavor combination. Whether you need a full 9" Pie ($27.00) for a family gathering or a convenient 4" Pie ($5.50) for a personal indulgence, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop ensures quality and comfort in every bite.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is strategically located within the popular Birkdale Commons Parkway area in Huntersville, NC. This placement in a major retail and dining center makes it highly convenient for residents across the Lake Norman region, including those in Cornelius and Davidson.

The address is 16836 D Birkdale Commons Pkwy, Huntersville, NC 28078, USA.

The shop is designed for easy access, prioritizing the needs of all local patrons. Accessibility features include a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a designated Wheelchair accessible parking lot. Given the nature of a quick dessert stop or a pie pickup for an event, the shop is set up for a Quick visit, ensuring you can get your freshly baked goods without unnecessary delay.

The bakery understands the busy schedules of North Carolina families and has tailored its services to provide maximum convenience for picking up sweet treats.

• Flexible Pickup Options: Customers can utilize multiple convenient services, including Curbside pickup, In-store pickup, and traditional In-store shopping to browse the day's fresh selections.
• Takeout Focus: The business model centers around Takeout to accommodate patrons who are planning a meal at home or stopping by for a dessert to bring to an event.
• Variety in Size: Pies are available in two main sizes: the 9" Pies for sharing and the individually-sized 4" Pies, which can also be purchased in discounted 4 Pie Packs ($20.00) for sampling different flavors.
• Modern Payments: The shop accepts all popular methods of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and seamless.
• Sweet Accompaniments: Beyond pies, the shop often features other sweet treats like Thumbprint cookies and Cloud 9s (pie à la mode) for a complete dessert experience.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop distinguishes itself through its dedication to quality, tradition, and a welcoming atmosphere.

• Signature I-40 Pie: This best-seller is a unique twist on the Southern favorite, pecan pie, made with pecans, chocolate chips, and shredded coconut in a buttery shortbread crust. It is a highly recommended must-try.
• Award-Winning Classics: The bakery maintains a high standard for its traditional recipes, with classics like the Key Lime Pie consistently receiving high praise for its phenomenal, perfectly balanced flavor. Other celebrated pies include Nanny's Pecan and Coconut Cream.
• Women-Owned Business: The shop proudly identifies as women-owned, fostering a supportive and warm environment that often reflects in its charming decor and service.
• Focus on Southern Custard Pies: Their namesake Southern Custard Pie (often called Buttermilk Pie) is a specialty, described as smooth, mild, and sweet—a perfect blend between a chess pie and a sugar cookie.
• Ideal for Sampling: The availability of the individual 4" Pies and the 4 Pie Pack allows customers to easily sample multiple rich flavors like Chocolate Cream, Peanut Butter Cream, and Granny's Apple without committing to a full-sized pie.

To place an order for your next gathering, inquire about seasonal pie flavors, or simply find the charming shop in Huntersville, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 16836 D Birkdale Commons Pkwy, Huntersville, NC 28078, USA

Phone Number: (704) 997-8441

For North Carolina residents who appreciate quality over volume, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is worth choosing for its commitment to scratch-made, gourmet Southern pie.

The value here is in the high-quality ingredients and meticulous recipes, many of which are passed down from grandmothers. While customers note the pies are "pricey" compared to mass-produced alternatives, the consensus is universal: "you pay for what you get," and what you get is a "great pie." This is the place you go when you need a dessert that is guaranteed to impress guests, not just fill a plate. The Key Lime Pie and the complex, rich I-40 Pie are clear standouts and reliable crowd-pleasers.

Furthermore, the shop’s setup, offering both large 9" Pies and convenient 4" Mini Pies, provides perfect flexibility. You can quickly grab a 4 Pie Pack for a weekend treat without committing to a family-sized pie, or easily pre-order a full pie for a holiday. For locals in the Huntersville area and beyond, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop offers an authentic, high-quality, and charmingly nostalgic Southern baking experience that truly is worth going out of your way for.