Colonial pie company

When Virginia residents talk about where to find truly exceptional, comforting, and inventive baked goods, the conversation often leads directly to Colonial Pie Company in the heart of Williamsburg. More than just a traditional bakery, this establishment has expertly carved out a niche as a specialized pie shop that elevates the concept of "round food" to an art form. It is a local culinary gem, cherished for its dedication to crafting everything from deeply flavorful savory pot pies that are perfect for a family dinner, to bright, mouthwatering sweet pies ideal for dessert or a special occasion.

The appeal of Colonial Pie Company lies in its dual mastery: serving up both main course dishes and delectable desserts, all unified by a commitment to quality ingredients and scratch-made crusts. Customers consistently praise the quality, noting that the products are clear examples of top-quality ingredients used with care. This Williamsburg favorite is not only a place to buy a slice of pie but a destination for a complete meal, with a menu that boldly steps outside the usual bakery bounds to include popular items like gourmet pizza.

This unique combination of offerings—encompassing savory comfort food and classic dessert mastery—makes Colonial Pie Company a standout in the Williamsburg bakery scene. For locals seeking a reliable, high-quality option that covers lunch, dinner, and dessert, this pie shop delivers a delightful dining experience with the cozy, welcoming atmosphere of a neighborhood bakery. The commitment to providing dine-in service, alongside convenient takeout and delivery, further solidifies its position as a go-to food spot for the Virginia community.

It is important for prospective Virginia customers to note that while the quality is consistently rated as excellent (a "10/10" according to one reviewer), the popularity of the freshly prepared food can lead to longer wait times, with one customer mentioning a wait of approximately 45 minutes during busy periods. However, the resounding consensus is that the food is always well worth the wait.

Location and Accessibility

Colonial Pie Company is conveniently located at 5203 Center St, Williamsburg, VA 23188, USA. This address places it in a well-trafficked, easily accessible area of Williamsburg, making it a simple stop for both local errands and dedicated meal outings. The location is situated near popular local routes, providing easy entry and exit for customers traveling from various parts of the Virginia Peninsula.

Accessibility is a clear priority at this Williamsburg pie shop, ensuring that every patron can visit comfortably:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The premises provide easy entry for all guests.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated, accessible parking spaces are available in the adjacent lot.
• Free Parking Lot: Abundant, complimentary parking is provided, removing one potential hassle for visitors arriving by car.

The physical location supports all three main service options—Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery—allowing customers maximum flexibility in how they choose to enjoy their food.

Services and Products Offered

Colonial Pie Company specializes in a core selection of round food items, primarily functioning as both a Pie Shop and a Bakery, but with a surprising and much-loved diversification into gourmet savory dishes.

• Savory Pies / Pot Pies:

  • Delicious savory pot pies are a signature item, often highlighted for surpassing frozen store-bought alternatives and providing hearty comfort meals.
  • Specific customer favorites include the Chicken Pot Pie and other savory pot pies perfect for dinner.
  • Savory items can be purchased in individual sizes for a quick meal or family sizes for shared dining.

• Sweet Dessert Pies:

  • A wide range of classic and unique sweet pies is offered for dessert or celebration.
  • Customer-raved specialties include Bumble Pie, Pecan Pie, and Key Lime Pie.
  • Other popular sweet options noted in reviews and mentions are apple crumb, black peach, and strawberry peach pies.
  • The dessert selection extends to items like Baklava, praised by one reviewer as "fantastic."

• Gourmet Pizza Pies:

  • Colonial Pie Company also serves gourmet pizza, which customers consider a standout offering, often with unique and fresh toppings.
  • Highly recommended is the Shrimp Pizza, with one review highlighting the great flavors and "absolute perfection" of the crust.
  • The menu also features Sicilian pizza, noted for its delicious cheese and toppings, showcasing the bakery's use of top-quality ingredients.

• Service Options for Customers:

  • Dine-in service is available for those who wish to enjoy their food fresh on site.
  • Takeout is offered for convenient pick-up.
  • Delivery options are provided, bringing the delicious pies directly to homes and businesses across the Virginia community.

Features and Highlights

The Colonial Pie Company distinguishes itself from other Williamsburg eateries through several key features that draw consistent praise from local Virginia customers.

• Unparalleled Product Variety: The simultaneous mastery of savory pot pies, sweet dessert pies, and gourmet pizza pies under one roof is a remarkable feature, offering a complete, high-quality meal solution. This eliminates the need to visit separate shops for dinner and dessert.

• Exceptional Crust Quality: Multiple customer reviews specifically call out the "absolute perfection" of the crust, whether on the pizza or the savory pies. The attention to detail in the pastry forms the foundation of their superior baked products.

• High-Quality Ingredients: A core strength of the business is its commitment to using top-quality, fresh ingredients, as reported by customers who can taste the difference in the cheese, toppings, and fillings of their products.

• Friendly and Professional Service: Despite potential wait times, the business is noted for its "fast and friendly service," suggesting that the staff is attentive and professional, creating a positive customer experience.

• Modern Payment Methods: The ability to pay using Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments (such as Apple Pay or Google Pay) ensures a quick and modern transaction process for all Virginia patrons.

Contact Information

For placing orders, inquiring about daily specials, or arranging delivery, local customers can reach Colonial Pie Company using the following details:

Address: 5203 Center St, Williamsburg, VA 23188, USA

Phone Number: (757) 229-7775 (Also accessible via mobile at +1 757-229-7775)

What is Worth Choosing

Colonial Pie Company is worth choosing for any Virginia local who appreciates scratch-made quality over mass production and values a menu that is both unique and comprehensive. What truly sets this Williamsburg bakery apart is its distinctive offering of both savory main-course pies and classic dessert pies, all prepared with the same dedication to high standards. For busy individuals or families, the ability to order a fantastic, hearty Chicken Pot Pie or a specialty Shrimp Pizza for dinner, alongside a slice of highly-rated Bumble Pie or Pecan Pie for dessert, all from one location, is an unparalleled convenience.

The strong positive feedback on specific items—particularly the savory pot pies and the unexpected excellence of the pizza, combined with traditional sweet pies—indicates a consistency of flavor and quality that is difficult to find elsewhere. While customers should be aware that their popularity can lead to a longer wait for food, the consensus from the local community is that the superb taste and high quality of the food make the wait a minor consideration. For a bakery and pie shop that genuinely delivers on the promise of delicious, round comfort food made with care, Colonial Pie Company on Center Street is an essential stop in Williamsburg, VA.