I loved working with custom sweets by Sarah for a baby shower so much that I also asked her to bake our wedding cake! She’s an excellent communicator, punctual, and detailed! I would recommend her again and again! Delicious!!
Jun 25 · Alaina KaganovichCustom Sweets by Sarah
2556 Nemitz Ave E, Maplewood, MN 55119, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 2556 Nemitz Ave E, Maplewood, MN 55119, USA
- Phone
- (952) 201-6350
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 5.0 from 68 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Tuesday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Wednesday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Thursday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Friday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Saturday9:00 AM – 12:00 AM
- SundayClosed
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For Minnesota residents seeking a truly personalized and meticulously crafted dessert experience, Custom Sweets by Sarah stands out as a premier destination in the Maplewood area. This locally-owned business operates as a specialized Bakery, Caterer, and Dessert shop, focusing intensely on creating custom-designed treats that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Sarah's passion is evident in every order, ensuring your celebration, whether large or small, is marked by a memorable, high-quality centerpiece.
The core mission of Custom Sweets by Sarah is to transform clients' visions into edible art. This isn't your average grab-and-go bakery; it is a custom-order business that excels in detailed, handcrafted work. From elegant wedding cakes—a popular service attested to by local couples—to fun, themed cupcakes for children’s birthdays, every item is made from scratch using high-quality ingredients. Furthermore, the bakery has earned a reputation in the Twin Cities East Metro for its commitment to accommodating various dietary needs, including excellent dairy-free options, a valuable service for those with sensitivities or allergies in the community.
Customer feedback highlights Sarah's exceptional communication, punctuality, and, most importantly, the delicious flavor of her creations. As one delighted customer noted about their dairy-free raspberry lemon cake, the taste was so perfect "you would never guess this cake was dairy free!" This dedication to taste and detail solidifies Custom Sweets by Sarah as a go-to local expert for custom baked goods in the 55119 zip code and beyond.
Location and Accessibility
Custom Sweets by Sarah is situated conveniently for the Maplewood and surrounding Twin Cities East Metro communities. Operating from its location on Nemitz Ave E, the focus is on a streamlined ordering and collection process, tailored to the custom nature of the business.
The full address is: 2556 Nemitz Ave E, Maplewood, MN 55119, USA.
As a business centered on custom orders and catering, accessibility is prioritized through its convenient service options and on-site facilities designed for easy interaction:
- Parking: The facility is equipped with a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, providing convenience for customers arriving to pick up their orders.
- Collection: The nature of custom sweets often means carefully transporting delicate items. The location and service structure are set up to make curbside pickup and delivery smooth and stress-free for the local customer base.
Services Offered
Custom Sweets by Sarah is a full-service custom baker and caterer, providing comprehensive solutions for any special event need. The primary services revolve around made-to-order creations, ensuring every client receives a unique product:
- Custom Cakes: Specializing in multi-tiered wedding cakes, baby reveal cakes, birthday cakes, and other special occasion cakes, all customized in flavor, size, and intricate design.
- Cupcakes and Dessert Bars: Custom cupcakes and a full range of desserts perfect for creating a memorable dessert bar for catered events, including specialized corporate or large family gatherings.
- Cookies and Small Sweets: Handcrafted sweets like cheesecakes, chunky cookies, Snickerdoodle Doozies, and custom-decorated cloud cookies (soft, cakey sugar cookies with buttercream), often featuring intricate, personalized designs.
- Specialty Diet Accommodation: Proven expertise in creating delicious cakes and desserts that meet special dietary needs, including popular dairy-free and gluten-friendly options, ensuring everyone can enjoy the celebration.
- Customer Convenience Options: Offering flexible ways to receive your order, which are vital for busy Minnesota residents:
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery (for local catering and dessert orders)
- Full Catering Services: Providing catering for large-scale events, which often includes coordinating a selection of cakes, cookies, and other desserts.
Features / Highlights
What truly sets Custom Sweets by Sarah apart for the Twin Cities community are these key features:
- Dairy-Free Expertise: The ability to produce exceptional-tasting dairy-free cakes, proven to satisfy even those without dietary restrictions, ensuring inclusivity for all guests at your event.
- Wedding and Event Specialization: A highly recommended choice for wedding cakes and large event desserts, noted for high-quality production, excellent communication, and reliable punctuality—essential for event coordination.
- Artisan Design and Detail: Every cake, cupcake, and cookie is treated as a unique project, featuring meticulous decoration, from elegant buttercream florals to themed designs, showcasing a true commitment to edible artistry.
- High-Quality Ingredients: Commitment to using real butter in frostings and real fruit in fillings, guaranteeing a superior scratch-made taste that elevates the finished product above mass-produced alternatives.
- Flexible Payment Methods: Acceptance of Checks, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments (e.g., Apple Pay, Google Pay) for easy, modern transactions.
Contact Information
To begin the custom-order process, inquire about catering services, or discuss specific dietary needs, Minnesota residents can reach out using the contact information below:
Address: 2556 Nemitz Ave E, Maplewood, MN 55119, USA
Phone: (952) 201-6350
Mobile Phone: +1 952-201-6350
What is Worth Choosing Custom Sweets by Sarah
Choosing Custom Sweets by Sarah is worth it for any Minnesota user who values personalization, premium flavor, and a hassle-free, professional ordering process for a significant event. If your celebration—be it a wedding, baby shower, or major birthday—demands a show-stopping cake or a full dessert spread that caters to all guests, including those with dietary restrictions, this Maplewood bakery is an unparalleled choice. The fact that customers repeatedly return to Sarah for their most important life events, moving from baby showers to wedding cakes, is the strongest possible endorsement of the quality and trust she has established within the local community.
The rave reviews, particularly the success stories with accommodating dairy intolerance while delivering a "DELICIOUS" result, confirm that you are not sacrificing taste for customization or dietary requirements. By offering essential modern conveniences like curbside pickup and delivery, Custom Sweets by Sarah ensures that ordering and receiving your unique, artisan desserts is as smooth as the buttercream on your cake. For a truly memorable and stress-free custom sweet experience in the Twin Cities, local users need look no further than this trusted Maplewood baker.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Payments
- Checks
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Sarah made our baby reveal cake an amazing experience! She accommodated my husbands dairy intolerance & worked with me to create my dream cake. Most importantly, it was DELICIOUS - raspberry lemon!!! You would never guess this cake was dairy free! It turned out perfectly & Sarah was so easy to work with! Can’t wait to work with her again.
Apr 9 · Michelle NadrchalWe hired Sarah to make cookies (300+!) for our wedding & she knocked it out of the park! We had multiple people tell us they were some of the best cookies they’ve ever had, especially the chocolate chip.
Aug 7 · Maddy WogSarah has created beautifully designed and absolutely delicious goodies for three different events for me over the past year (a baby shower, first birthday and and a 75th birthday). Her custom cookies were amazing and a huge hit, her carrot cake was gorgeous and loved by all, but my favorite was the layered almond raspberry cake for my daughters first birthday. All so wonderful! As an added bonus, Sarah is a delight to work with - quick to reply, kind, flexible, patient and always meets me with a big smile at pick up. Would most definitely recommend Sarah for any celebration!
Nov 4 · Melissa Smith BullerSarah did such an amazing job creating cookies for my mom’s 60th birthday! I was asked by almost everyone where I got the cookies and how awesome they looked. People didn’t even want to eat them because they were so perfect. Not only did they look great, they tasted amazing too. So worth it!
Mar 16 · Danielle BrezinskyCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.












This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
